|
|
||||||||
-Chain Gene Assembly by Intrinsic Features of the TEA Promoter1Department of Pathology and Immunology, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO 63110
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
- and
-chain genes lie in a single complex locus, the TCR
/
locus. TCR
-chain genes are assembled in CD4CD8 (double negative (DN)) thymocytes and TCR
-chain genes are assembled in CD4+CD8+ (double positive) thymocytes due, in part, to the developmental stage-specific activities of the TCR
and TCR
enhancers (E
and E
), respectively. E
functions with TCR
promoters to mediate TCR
-chain gene assembly in DN thymocytes. However, E
is unable to function with TCR
promoters such as the TEA promoter to drive TCR
-chain gene assembly in these cells. This is important, because the premature assembly of TCR
-chain genes in DN thymocytes would disrupt 
and 
T cell development. The basis for TEA inactivity in DN thymocytes is unclear, because E
can activate the V
5 gene segment promoter that lies only 4 kb upstream of TEA promoter. In this study, we use gene targeting to construct a modified TCR
/
locus (TCR
/
5
T) in which the TEA promoter lies in the same location as the V
5 gene segment on the wild-type TCR
/
allele. Remarkably, the TEA promoter on this allele exhibits normal developmental stage-specific regulation, being active in double positive thymocytes but not in DN thymocytes as is the case with the V
5 promoter. Thus, the inactivity of the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes is due primarily to intrinsic developmental stage-specific features of the promoter itself and not to its location relative to other cis-acting elements in the locus, such as E
. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|

or 
T cells (1). Assembly of the TCR
-,
-, and
-chain genes is initiated in double negative (DN)3 thymocytes (2, 3, 4). Expression of a 
TCR leads to progression along the 
T cell lineage pathway. Generation of a productive TCR
-chain gene and expression of a TCR
-chain, as a pre-TCR, promote commitment to the 
T cell lineage, cellular expansion, and transition to the double positive (DP) stage of thymocyte development (5). Pre-TCR signals also lead to the initiation of TCR
-chain gene assembly, which occurs primarily in DP thymocytes, as well as the cessation of further TCR
-chain gene rearrangements through the process of allelic exclusion (2, 3, 5, 6, 7).
The assembly of different TCR genes is precisely regulated within the context of thymocyte development. This regulation is mediated, in part, by modulation of the accessibility of gene segments to the RAG-1 and -2 proteins through the activity of cis-acting elements, such as promoters and enhancers, that regulate transcription (8). The regulation of the TCR
- and
-chain genes poses perhaps the greatest regulatory challenge, as these genes lie in a single complex locus, the TCR
/
locus (2, 9). The TCR
/
locus spans
1.6 Mb with the V
and V
gene segments clustered over 1.5 Mb in the 5' region of the locus (Fig. 1) (9, 10). Some V gene segments are used primarily in TCR
-chain gene assembly (V
gene segments), and others primarily in TCR
-chain gene assembly (V
gene segments). However, most V gene segments are used in both TCR
- and TCR
-chain gene assembly (V
/
gene segments) (10). The V gene segment cluster is followed by two D
(D
1 and D
2) gene segments, two J
(J
1 and J
2) gene segments, and the TCR
constant region gene (C
) (Fig. 1). A single V
gene segment, V
5, lies 3' of C
and rearranges by inversion (Fig. 1). A cluster of 61 J
gene segments and the TCR
constant region gene (C
) lie in the most 3' region of the locus (Fig. 1).
|
-chain genes are assembled in DN thymocytes, whereas TCR
-chain genes are assembled in DP thymocytes. The developmental stage-specific assembly of TCR
- and
-chain genes is thought to be regulated primarily by the TCR
and the TCR
enhancers E
and E
(2). E
lies in the intron between J
2 and C
and is active in DN thymocytes to promote germline transcription and accessibility of TCR
-chain gene segments (Fig. 1) (2). E
, which lies 3' of C
, is not active in DN thymocytes (Fig. 1) (2). Rather E
becomes active only after DN thymocytes commit to either the 
T cell lineage or the 
T cell lineage (DP thymocytes) (2, 11). In 
T cells E
augments transcription from TCR
promoters (12). In DP thymocytes E
activates transcription from germline J
gene segment promoters, such as the TEA promoter, that are required for TCR
-chain gene assembly (2, 11, 12). E
is also required for TCR
-chain gene expression in mature 
T cells (2, 12).
TCR
gene assembly does not occur in DN thymocytes due, at a minimum, to the inactivity of the TEA promoter and other J
gene segment promoters in these cells (13). This may result from the inactivity of E
in DN thymocytes (11, 14). However, E
is active in DN thymocytes and promotes the accessibility of TCR
gene segments, including V
5 (see Results), that lie immediately upstream of the TEA promoter (2, 15). How is it that E
is capable of activating the V
5 promoter, which lies 10 kb downstream, but not the TEA promoter, which lies 14 kb downstream (Fig. 1)? Deletion of a 2-kb region between V
5 and the TEA promoter known as BEAD-1, which exhibits insulator activity in vitro, did not lead to TEA promoter activation in DN thymocytes (16). It is thus possible that other sequences between V
5 and the TEA promoter, such as the V
5 promoter, prevent E
from functioning with the TEA promoter. In addition, because E
may function over a shorter distance than E
it is possible that E
may function over the 10-kb distance to V
5 but not the 14-kb distance to TEA (17). Lastly, it is possible that intrinsic features of the TEA promoter prohibit its activation in DN thymocytes.
To distinguish between these possibilities, we used a gene-targeting approach to generate mice with a modified TCR
/
locus (TCR
/
5
T), in which a 4-kb region encompassing the V
5 gene segment and the immediate downstream region to the 5' border of the TEA promoter has been deleted. Thus, the TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele lies in the same location as the V
5 gene segment on the wild-type TCR
/
allele. The TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele exhibits normal activity in DP thymocytes. However, analyses of TCR
/
5
T/5
T DN thymocytes failed to reveal a significant increase in TEA-driven J
gene segment transcription or accessibility. These findings demonstrate that the inactivity of the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes is not due to its relative position in the locus with respect to other cis-acting elements such as E
. Rather, our findings suggest that intrinsic features of the TEA promoter limit its activity in DN thymocytes and, as such, have important implications for the developmental stage-specific regulation of TCR gene assembly.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All mice were bred and maintained under specific pathogen-free conditions at the Washington University School of Medicine (St. Louis, MO) and were handled in accordance to the guidelines set forth by the Division of Comparative Medicine of Washington University.
Generation of embryonic stem cells with the TCR
/
5
T allele
The 5' homology arm of the pV
5TC targeting vector was generated as PCR fragment corresponding to nt 857414306 of the GenBank accession no. M64239 sequence. The 5' end of this fragment is in exon 1 of the C
gene segment and the 3' end is in the spacer of V
5 gene segment recombination signal sequences (RSS). The 3' homology arm is a BglII-NsiI DNA fragment corresponding to nt 1829225232 of the GenBank accession no. M64239 sequence. The 5' end of this fragment is immediately upstream of the 5' border of the TEA promoter. The homology arms were cloned into the pLNTK vector (12). Embryonic stem cell targeting and Cre-loxP mediated deletion was conducted as previously described (12).
Southern and Northern blot analyses
Southern and Northern analyses were performed as described (12). The 5' (probe 5), V
5 (probe 7), C
(probe 6), TEA (probe 8), C
, and GAPDH probes have been described (12, 18). The 3' probe is a PCR fragment corresponding to nt 2655427388 of the GenBank accession no. M64239 sequence.
PCR, RT-PCR, J
utilization index calculation, and ligation-mediated PCR (LMPCR)
V
D
J
rearrangements were assayed by PCR using the oligonucleotides 5'-TTTTGGTATCGCAAAAGGCC-3' and 5'-CCCTGCTCCTATGGAGGAGC-3'. Standard PCR buffer conditions with 1 mM MgCl2 were used. Cycling conditions were 94°C for 5 min followed by 30 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 60°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 30 s. This was followed by a final 7 min of incubation at 72°C. PCR products were hybridized to the oligonucleotide probe 5'-TGTGAAGCACAGCAAGGCCA-3' as described previously (19). The IL-2 gene PCR was described previously (20).
RT-PCR for analysis of J
gene segment utilization has been described previously (21). The J
gene segment utilization index was calculated as index = (J
5
T/C
5
T)/(J
+/C
+), where J
5
T and J
+ are the intensities of the Southern blot bands from the hybridization of J
-specific oligonucleotides to V
-C
RT-PCR products from TCR
/
5
T/5
T and wild-type splenocyte cDNA, respectively. C
5
T and C
+ are the intensities of the Southern blot bands from the hybridization of a C
-specific oligonucleotide to the same RT-PCR products and serve as the loading control. LMPCR and Southern analyses were conducted with primer A (5'-CCAAGATTCCTGGGACAACC-3'), primer B (5'-GCGATGGGACTGTGACTGAC-3'), primer BW1H, and the oligonucleotide probe P (5'-TCCAAAAGAGGAAAGGAAGGCAGTC-3') as previously described (19).
Flow cytometric analyses and cell sorting
To obtain DN CD25+ cells, total thymocytes were enriched for DN cells by complement-mediated lysis of CD4+ and CD8+ cells as described (19). The resulting cells were stained with FITC-conjugated anti-mouse CD25 (BD Pharmingen) followed by sorting for CD25+ cells with FACSDiva (Becton Dickinson) to >95% purity.
Generation of 
T cell hybridomas
Two independent panels of 
T cell hybridomas were generated from TCR
/
+B6/5
T mice as described previously (12).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5 transcription and accessibility in DN thymocytes requires E
To determine whether E
is required for V
5 gene segment transcription and accessibility in DN thymocytes, we conducted Northern blot analyses on RNA from RAG-2-deficient DN thymocytes that were homozygous for the wild-type TCR
/
locus (R2/:E
+/+) or a TCR
/
locus in which E
had been deleted (R2/:E
/
) (Fig. 2A). R2/:E
+/+ DN thymocytes have a robust level of V
5-hybridizing germline transcripts (Fig. 2A). In contrast, the level of V
5 germline transcripts were dramatically reduced in R2/:E
/
DN thymocytes, demonstrating that E
activity is required for the optimal level of V
5 gene segment transcription in these cells (Fig. 2A). That E
is required for V
5 rearrangement is evidenced by the
10-fold reduction in complete V
5DJ
1 rearrangements in E
/
thymocytes as compared with wild-type thymocytes (Fig. 2B). In agreement with previous reports, TEA-hybridizing transcripts were not observed in DN thymocytes (Fig. 2C) (13). Together, these findings demonstrate that in DN thymocytes E
functions to promote V
5 gene segment transcription and accessibility but it is unable to activate the TEA promoter, which lies just 4 kb downstream of V
5.
|
/
5
T/5
T mice
To determine why E
is unable to activate the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes, we generated the TCR
/
5
T allele through gene targeting of embryonic stem cells (Fig. 3). Initially the TCR
/
5NT allele was generated by replacing the 4-kb region upstream of the TEA promoter that includes the V
5 gene segment with the neomycin resistance gene flanked by loxP sites (Fig. 3, A and B). The TCR
/
5
T allele was then generated from the TCR
/
5NT allele through Cre-loxP mediated deletion of the neomycin resistance gene (Fig. 3). On the TCR
/
5
T allele the TEA promoter lies at the same distance from E
as the V
5 gene segment on the wild-type TCR
/
allele (Fig. 3A). Furthermore, any sequences between V
5 and the TEA promoter that could inhibit E
interactions with the TEA promoter, including the V
5 promoter, have been deleted on the TCR
/
5
T allele.
|
/
5
T/5
T mice revealed no significant differences in the number of DN, DP, and CD4+ or CD8+ single positive thymocytes or in the number of mature peripheral 
or 
T cells as compared with wild-type mice (data not shown).
The TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele is active in DP thymocytes
To determine whether the TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele is regulated normally in DP thymocytes, we generated RAG-2-deficient mice expressing the DO11 TCR
transgene that were homozygous for the wild-type TCR
/
allele (R2/:
:TCR
/
+/+) or the TCR
/
5
T allele (R2/:
:TCR
/
5
T/5
T) (Fig. 4A). Northern blot analysis revealed similar levels of germline TEA-hybridizing transcripts in R2/:
:TCR
/
+/+ and R2/:
:TCR
/
5
T/5
T DP thymocytes (Fig. 4A). Analysis of TCR
mRNA from TCR
/
5
T/5
T and TCR
/
+/+ 
T cells revealed that similar fractions of VJ
rearrangements use the J
58 and J
57 gene segments, which are located 5' in the J
gene segment cluster and are dependent on TEA promoter activity for accessibility (Fig. 4B) (22). Together, these data demonstrate that the TEA promoter is intact and regulates transcription and accessibility normally on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DP thymocytes.
|
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes
Transcription from the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes was assayed by the Northern blotting of RNA isolated from RAG-2/:TCR
/
+/+ (R2/:TCR
/
+/+) and RAG-2/:TCR
/
5
T/5
T (R2/:TCR
/
5
T/5
T) thymocytes (Fig. 5). As shown previously, no TEA- or C
-hybridizing transcripts were detectable in R2/:TCR
/
+/+ (Fig. 5). Although there were slightly more TEA-hybridizing transcripts in DN thymocyte RNA from R2/:TCR
/
5
T/5
T as compared with R2/:TCR
/
+/+ mice, the level was significantly lower than what was observed in R2/:
:TCR
/
5
T/5
T DP thymocytes where the TEA promoter is active (Fig. 5). Furthermore, although TEA transcripts are frequently spliced to C
, C
hybridizing transcripts were not detected in R2/:TCR
/
5
T/5
T DN thymocytes (Fig. 5). Germline TCR
transcripts from the TCR
/
+ and TCR
/
5
T alleles were found at similar levels in DN thymocytes (Fig. 5). Together, these data demonstrate that although E
is functional and promotes normal level of germline TCR
transcripts on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes (Fig. 5), it is unable to promote a significant level of TEA transcripts in these cells.
|
gene segment accessibility on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes
To determine whether J
gene segments are accessible for RAG-mediated cleavage, we assayed for J
61 signal ends (SEs) in thymocytes at different stages of development by LMPCR. To this end, thymocytes from mice heterozygous for the wild-type B6 and 129 TCR
/
alleles (TCR
/
+B6/+129) or those hemizygous for the wild-type B6 TCR
/
allele and the TCR
/
5
T allele (TCR
/
+B6/5
T) were assayed. The TCR
/
5
T allele was generated through targeting of the 129 TCR
/
allele. LMPCR products generated by TCR
/
+129 or TCR
/
5
T J
61 SEs can thus be distinguished from TCR
/
+B6 J
61 SEs by a DdeI restriction site polymorphism (Fig. 6A).
|
61 SEs in total TCR
/
+B6/+129 thymocytes, which are composed predominantly of DP thymocytes with ongoing TCR
-chain gene assembly (Fig. 6B). Digestion of LMPCR products with DdeI revealed similar levels of J
61 SEs from the TCR
/
+B6 and TCR
/
+129 alleles, indicating that there are no intrinsic differences in RAG-mediated cleavage at the wild-type TCR
/
locus in these two alleles (Fig. 6C). TCR
/
+B6/5
T thymocytes had level of J
61 SEs similar to that observed in TCR
/
+B6/+129 thymocytes (Fig. 6B). Furthermore, digestion of these products with DdeI demonstrated that a similar fraction originated from cleavage at the TCR
/
+B6 and TCR
/
5
T alleles (Fig. 6C). Thus, in total thymocytes the level of J
61 cleavage on the TCR
/
5
T allele is similar to that observed on the wild-type TCR
/
+ allele.
To determine whether the TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele can promote J
gene segment accessibility in DN thymocytes, CD25+ DN thymocytes were purified from TCR
/
+B6/5
T and TCR
/
+B6/+129 mice by flow cytometric cell sorting. CD25+ DN thymocytes from TCR
/
+B6/5
T and TCR
/
+B6/+129 mice had similar levels of J
61 SEs, which were considerably lower than the levels observed in DP thymocytes (Fig. 6B). Furthermore, digestion of the LMPCR products with DdeI revealed that there were similar levels of J
61 SEs from the TCR
/
+B6 allele and TCR
/
5
T allele in TCR
/
+B6/5
T DN thymocytes (Fig. 6D). Together, these findings demonstrate that there is a significantly lower level of RAG-mediated cleavage at the J
61 gene segment on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes as compared with DP thymocytes. Furthermore, the level of J
61 gene segment cleavage on the TCR
/
5
T allele is similar to that observed for the wild-type TCR
/
allele in DN thymocytes. Thus, the TEA promoter does not promote increased J
gene segment accessibility on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes.
V to J
rearrangement is not initiated on the TCR
/
5
T allele in 
T cells
E
may only function with the TEA promoter on the TCR
/
5
T allele in DN thymocytes that have committed to the 
T cell lineage and promote V-J
rearrangements in these cells. To investigate this possibility, we generated a panel of 81 
T cell hybridomas from splenic TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cells. That these T cell hybridomas were all derived from 
T cells was evidenced by flow cytometric analyses demonstrating cell surface expression of TCR
- but not TCR
-chains (data not shown).
All V
to J
rearrangements occur by deletion and result in deletion of the TEA exon from the TCR
/
+B6 or TCR
/
5
T allele in TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cells. Genomic DNA isolated from the TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cell hybridomas was digested with BglII and subjected to Southern blot analyses using the TEA exon probe (Fig. 7). A BglII polymorphism, generated by the targeting, permits the distinction of TEA hybridization on the TCR
/
+B6 or TCR
/
5
T alleles in TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cells (Fig. 3A). These analyses revealed the retention of TEA hybridization on both the TCR
/
+B6 and TCR
/
5
T alleles in all 81 of the TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cell hybridomas (Fig. 7 and data not shown). That these hybridomas represented a diverse population of 
T cells was evidenced by hybridization with a probe 3' of the J
1 gene segment, which revealed many different size-hybridizing fragments that represent heterogeneous TCR
-chain gene rearrangements in the TCR
/
+B6/5
T 
T cell hybridomas (Fig. 7). Thus, E
is not capable of promoting V to J
gene segment rearrangement on the TCR
/
5
T allele in 
T cell precursors.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5 gene segment promoter, which is normally active in these cells. Thus, TEA promoter inactivity in DN thymocytes is not due to its physical distance from enhancer elements, such as E
, that promote TCR
gene rearrangement and expression in DN thymocytes. Furthermore, the absence of TEA transcripts in these DN thymocyte also suggests that there are no cis-acting elements, including the V
5 promoter, between V
5 and TEA that are necessary to prevent E
from activating the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes. Rather, our findings suggest that TEA promoter activity in DN thymocytes may be limited by intrinsic properties of the promoter itself. The TEA promoter is factor-loaded in DN thymocytes but is unable to function in these cells (23). It is possible that transcription factors bound to the TEA promoter in DN thymocytes are repressive in nature. However, it is also possible that some additional trans-acting factors are required for TEA activity but are only expressed in DP thymocytes. In this regard, it is notable that the expression of Ets family transcription factors, which are predicted to bind to the TEA promoter, are up-regulated as cells transit from the DN to the DP stage of thymocyte development (24). It is also possible that the TEA promoter has a 5' region with insulator activity.
Because many V gene segments in the TCR
/
locus are accessible and participate in TCR
gene assembly in DN thymocytes, it is likely that V to J
rearrangements are prevented in these cells primarily due to the inaccessibility of the J
gene segments. Our findings suggest that this inaccessibility is due, in part, to intrinsic features of the TEA promoter that prohibit it from being activated by cis-acting elements, such as E
, that function to promote TCR
-chain gene rearrangements in DN thymocytes.
Activation of V to J
rearrangements in DN thymocytes could have a detrimental effect on both 
and 
T cell development and lineage commitment. All V to J
rearrangements occur by deletion, leading to the excision of the TCR
-chain genes from the chromosome and, thus, limit the ability of DN thymocytes to generate a 
TCR (25). Expression of an 
TCR or a pre-TCR by DN thymocytes leads to signals that induce transition to the DP stage of thymocyte development (5). However, the pre-TCR is more efficient at mediating this transition than the 
TCR (26, 27). The TCR
-chain can compete successfully with the pre-T
protein for dimerization with the TCR
-chain (28). Thus, a productive VJ
rearrangement and the expression of a TCR
-chain in DN thymocytes would favor formation of an 
TCR instead of pre-TCR and, as a result, promote a less efficient transition to the DP stage of thymocyte development.
| Disclosures |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 B.P.S. is supported by National Institutes of Health Grants AI47829 and AI49934 and American Cancer Society Grant RSG-05-070-01-LIB. ![]()
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Barry P. Sleckman, Department of Pathology and Immunology, 660 South Euclid Avenue, Campus Box 8118, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO 63110. E-mail address: Sleckman{at}immunology.wustl.edu ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: DN, double negative; DP, double positive; LMPCR, ligation-mediated PCR; RSS, recombination signal sequence; SE, signal end. ![]()
Received for publication March 20, 2007. Accepted for publication April 29, 2007.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
/
locus. Immunol. Rev. 165: 131-147. [Medline]
gene rearrangement and role of TCR-
expression during CD3CD4CD8 thymocyte differentiation. J. Immunol. 152: 4783-4792. [Abstract]
locus. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 14: 230-234. [Medline]
locus. Immunity 7: 601-607. [Medline]
/
gene rearrangement by T cell receptor
and
enhancers. J. Exp. Med. 179: 1913-1921.
enhancer in 
and 
T cells. Immunity 7: 505-515. [Medline]
gene rearrangement and T early
(TEA) expression in immature 
lineage thymocytes: implications for 
/
lineage commitment. Immunity 4: 37-45. [Medline]
and TCR
gene enhancers confer tissue- and stage-specificity on V(D)J recombination events. EMBO J. 12: 4335-4346. [Medline]
locus accessibility and expression by the TCR
enhancer. Immunity 10: 503-513. [Medline]
/
locus. Immunology 104: 11-18. [Medline]
/
locus enhancer identity and position are critical for the assembly of TCR
and
variable region genes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100: 2598-2603.
gene rearrangements play a critical role in the 
/
T cell lineage decision. Immunity 2: 617-627. [Medline]
locus: role of secondary rearrangement in thymic selection. J. Immunol. 166: 2597-2601.
gene assembly by a complex hierarchy of germline J
promoters. Nat. Immunol. 6: 481-489. [Medline]
following targeted deletion of T early
(TEA): implications for TCR
locus accessibility. Immunity 5: 331-342. [Medline]
enhancer to TCR
a enhancer function during thymocyte maturation. Immunity 10: 723-733. [Medline]
-chain genes is dispensable for
T cell lineage commitment. Int. Immunol. 17: 225-232.
-chain on thymocyte development. Eur. J. Immunol. 34: 1532-1541. [Medline]
by TCR-
during TCR assembly prevents surface coexpression of pre-TCR and 
TCR. J. Immunol. 165: 5566-5572.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |