|
|
||||||||


* Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Department of Pediatric Oncology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115; and
Skirball Institute of Biomolecular Medicine and Department of Pathology, New York University Cancer Institute, New York University School of Medicine, New York 10016
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-associated Lck in driving CD8 single positive (SP) thymocyte development. We used a chimeric molecule encoding the extracellular and transmembrane domains of CD8
fused to full-length Lck. In mice deficient for CD8
and transgenic for 2C, a MHC class I-restricted TCR, robust reconstitution of CD8 SP thymocytes occurred both centrally and peripherally. The reconstituted CD8 SP population was phenotypically and functionally comparable to 2C wild-type counterparts expressing endogenous CD8
. A CD8
/Lck kinase-dead chimera also resulted in reconstitution of CD8 SP thymocytes. Our results suggest that CD8
-associated Lck is sufficient to drive CD8 SP thymocyte development. Furthermore, this CD8 SP development may not necessarily depend on Lck kinase activity. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|

-TCR with either a CD4 coreceptor or a CD8
heterodimeric coreceptor. These T cells, despite being mutually exclusive for one coreceptor, are positively selected in the thymus from a common double positive (CD4+CD8+) precursor population. Positive selection results in the maturation of single positive (SP)4 T cells with an optimal TCR:MHC affinity. Double positive (DP) thymocytes with too high or no affinity undergo apoptosis (negative selection and death by neglect, respectively). Absence of CD4 or CD8 results in inefficient development of helper T cells and CTLs, respectively (1, 2).
Although critical molecules involved in development have been identified, the nature of signals leading to lineage commitment is not well understood and several models have been proposed (reviewed in Refs. 3, 4). Lck, a member of the Src kinase family, is an important player throughout thymocyte development (reviewed in Ref. 5), and both the CD4 coreceptor and the CD8 coreceptor are known to bind Lck (6, 7, 8, 9). A pair of dicysteines, one on Lck and the other on the coreceptor cytoplasmic tail, mediate the coreceptor-Lck association. Zn2+ ions have been shown to promote this association (10). Also, substantially more Lck is known to associate with CD4 than with CD8. This difference is hypothesized to result in differences in signal intensities that can be discerned by the developing thymocyte and lead to lineage commitment, known as the strength of signaling model (3). Mice expressing either CD8
or CD4 cytoplasmic tailless coreceptors have inefficient development of their respective lineage (11, 12). Presumably, this is due to the inability to involve Lck in the CD3 complex during positive selection. Increasing the expression of wild-type CD4 but not tailless CD4 diminished the CD8 SP thymocyte population in H-Y TCR transgenic mice. It is proposed that as wild-type CD4 expression increases there is less Lck available to bind CD8 (13). The CD8
-chain has been shown to impart a 5-fold increase in CD8 SP thymocytes when present (14, 15, 16) and compromise their development when absent (17, 18, 19). It is suggested that the cytoplasmic domain of the CD8
-chain is integral in enhancing Lck association with CD8
. Mice expressing a mutant Lck that cannot associate with coreceptors have defects in development of both types of SP thymocytes (20). However, it has also been shown that a mutant CD8
coreceptor chain incapable of binding Lck can still mediate development of CD8 SP thymocytes (21). It has also been shown that both coreceptors bind the adapter protein called the linker for activation of T cells (LAT) (22). However, LAT preferentially associates more with CD8 relative to CD4. It was shown for CD8 that the coreceptor dicysteine motif accounts for about two-thirds of LAT binding, whereas some other aspect of the CD8
tail accounts for the remainder.
In this study we addressed the role of CD8-associated Lck by generating a chimeric coreceptor, CD8
-Lck, where the CD8
cytoplasmic domain was replaced by full-length Lck. This allowed us to focus on the Lck signaling requirements of CD8 at the expense of other CD8
cytoplasmic domain binding proteins. The construct also allowed us to differentiate between cytoplasmic Lck and CD8-associated Lck. Furthermore, the chimeric transgene is substantially underexpressed, thereby avoiding aberrant effects due to coreceptor and Lck overexpression, which can bias both development and lineage commitment (23). The CD8
-Lck transgene was analyzed in mice deficient for endogenous CD8
and transgenic for the MHC class I-restricted 2C TCR. The CD8
-Lck transgene reconstituted a CD8 SP population comparable to that found in 2C mice. Interestingly, expression of a kinase-inactive CD8
-Lck coreceptor also led to the reconstitution of the CD8 SP population, suggesting that CD8-associated Lck may rely on some function other than its kinase activity for thymocyte development.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The CD8
-Lck construct was generated by using the CD8
extracellular and transmembrane domains ligated to full-length Lck. The construct preparation strategy introduced three extra amino acids at the junction of CD8
and Lck ligation as follows: 5' CD8
- - -YHRS-ARA-GCVC- - -Lck 3'. The generated construct was placed under the human CD2 regulatory 5' and 3' elements using the CD2 minigene vector elements (a gift from Dr. D. Kioussis, National Institute for Medical Research, London, U.K.). The mutant kinase construct was generated from the wild-type chimeric construct. A PCR fragment introducing the appropriate mutation was generated and substituted into the wild-type chimeric construct. The mutation was the equivalent of a lysine to arginine mutation at position 273 of wild-type Lck. DNA constructs were verified by sequencing.
Mice
Microinjection of the wild-type chimeric construct into the sv129 background for generating transgenic founder lines was performed with help from Dr. D. Littman (Skirball Institute of Biomolecular Medicine, New York, NY). Selected mice with germline transmission and protein expression were crossed onto a 2C CD8
/ background. 2C CD8
/ mice were generated by crossing C57BL/6 CD8
/ mice (obtained from Dr. T. Mak, Ontario Cancer Institute, Toronto, Canada) with mice transgenic for the MHC class I-restricted TCR, 2C (obtained from Dr. D. Loh, Hoffmann-La Roche). Mice described as 2C CD8
/ Tg59 had been backcrossed onto the C57BL/6 background eight or nine times. Mice described as 2C CD8
/ Tg39 had been backcrossed onto a C57BL/6 background at least three times. Microinjection of the mutant chimeric construct into the C57BL/6 background was performed at the Brigham and Womens Hospital Transgenic Facility (Boston, MA). As before, the resulting founder mouse was crossed onto a 2C CD8/ background. C57BL/6 mice used in parallel for these experiments were siblings of 2C mice not expressing the 2C TCR transgene. All mice were housed in the Animal Resource Facility at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (Boston, MA).
Thymocyte and lymph node cell isolation
Thymocytes were harvested from mice 56 wk of age and lymph nodes were harvested from mice that were at least 12 wk of age. Lymph node harvest included axillary, cervical, mesenteric, inguinal, and iliac lymph nodes. In all cases, single cell suspensions were generated by grinding the tissues with frosted slides and then filtering through a sterile nylon mesh. Single cell suspensions were briefly treated with red blood cell lysing buffer (Sigma-Aldrich) for 1 min on ice. Prepared single cell suspensions were then counted and used for the various experiments.
Abs and FACS analyses
Anti-Lck Ab (clone 3A5) used for Western blotting was obtained from Upstate Biotechnology. All directly conjugated Abs used for FACS analyses were obtained from BD Pharmingen and included the following: anti-CD8
PE (clone 53-6.7), anti-CD8
PE (clone 52-5.8), anti-CD4 Cy (clone H129.19), anti-CD3
FITC (clone 145-2C11), anti-CD2 FITC (clone RM2-5), anti-CD5 FITC (clone 53-7.3), anti-CD24 FITC (clone M1/67), and anti-CD69 FITC (clone H1.2F3). The 1B2 Ab, specific for the 2C TCR, was a generous gift from Dr. H. Eisen (Massachussetts Institute of Technology, Boston, MA). 1B2 was subsequently biotinylated and used in conjunction with streptavidin-FITC (BD Pharmingen). FACS staining of isolated thymocytes or lymph node cells was conducted according to standard procedures and included pretreatment with Fc block (BD Pharmingen). Samples were acquired on a BD Biosciences FACScan driven by the CellQuest software. Fifty thousand forward scatter vs side scatter gated events were collected and the data were analyzed using the CellQuest software.
Proliferation assays
Harvested lymph node cells were analyzed by FACS (BD Biosciences) using anti-CD8
PE, anti-CD4 Cy, and 1B2:streptavidin-FITC. The proliferation capacity was then assessed by incubating 100 x 103 1B2+ lymph node cells in with 200 x 103 irradiated stimulator T2-Ld cells in 200 µl of cell culture medium and in the presence of the p2Ca peptide at its indicated concentration. Proliferation assays were performed in triplicate in 96-well, round-bottom plates (Corning) using RPMI 1640 medium (Mediatech) supplemented with heat-inactivated FBS (10% final; Sigma-Aldrich), penicillin-streptomycin (100 IU/ml to 100 µg/ml final; Mediatech), L-glutamine (2 mM final; Mediatech), HEPES (pH 7.4) (10 mM final), and 2-ME. T2-Ld is a TAP-deficient cell line expressing the murine Ld molecule. The p2Ca peptide (LSPFPFDL) is known to be presented by the Ld molecule and forms a ligand for the 2C TCR (24). Cell culture was performed at 37°C under a humidified 5% CO2 atmosphere. At the 42-h time point 0.8 µCi of [3H]thymidine was added, and at the 48-h time point the plates were harvested.
Cytokine production assays
Lymph node cell preparation for cytokine production capacity was performed in the same fashion as the proliferation assays. After the 48-h incubation, 100 µl of supernatant was assayed by ELISA to determine the cytokine produced. The following Abs obtained from BD Pharmingen were used: IL-2 capture and IL-2 detection (JES-1A12 and JES6-5H4, respectively) and IFN-
capture and IFN-
detection (R4-6A2 and XMG1.2, respectively).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-Lck reconstitutes a CD8 SP thymocyte population
To study the role of Lck directly associated with the CD8 coreceptor in thymocyte development, transgenic murine lines were generated that express the extracellular and transmembrane domains of CD8
fused to the full-length Lck. The CD8
-Lck chimeric construct was driven by a murine CD2 promoter. The two murine lines generated are referred to as Tg59 and Tg39. We first analyzed the expression levels of the transgenic thymocytes by Western blotting. Blotting of whole thymocyte lysates with anti-Lck Ab revealed that only the transgenic animals show a 90-kDa band of the size expected for the CD8
-Lck transgene (Fig. 1A). We then analyzed by FACS the surface expression of CD8 on thymocytes. Because we used the CD2 promoter to drive the transgene, the expression pattern of the transgene would follow the CD2 gene expression. We reasoned that surface expression of the transgene CD8
-Lck at the DP thymocyte stage just as thymocytes undergo negative selection would be most vital for survival of these thymocytes. Comparison of C57BL/6 (wild type) and the CD8
-Lck transgenic thymocytes revealed an
100-fold difference in expression levels of CD8
(Fig. 1B). FACS analysis also showed very similar expression levels of CD8
and CD8
at the critical DP stage as shown in Fig. 1C. To differentiate between the bona fide CD8 cells from other thymocytes that would express the transgene, we used CD8
expression to follow the various CD8+ subpopulations in the thymus and periphery.
|
/ and 2C mice have distinct phenotypic profiles with respect to CD3 expression in the thymus (Fig. 2). Most 2C wild-type thymocytes are CD3
high. In 2C CD8
/ mice the majority are CD3
low and those that are CD3
high correspond to CD4 SP and double negative (DN; CD4CD8) thymocytes, a population known to arise independently of MHC interactions in TCR transgenic animals (25). The CD3
profiles are consistent with the reported 1B2 profiles (26) and highlight the need for CD8 in driving development toward the relatively more mature CD3
high thymocytes. Additionally, compared with C57BL/6 mice, the CD3
low peak in 2C CD8
/ mice is narrower and at the "high end" of CD3
low expression (Fig. 2, histograms). Although this finding could result from CD3 being limiting when associating with the transgenic expression of 2C TCR in those thymocytes, a similar result was found for CD2 and CD5 and cannot be similarly explained. Collectively, the expression pattern of these markers suggests that 2C CD8
/ thymocytes are receiving signals via their TCRs but are too inefficient to drive them through development.
|
low peak to the CD3
high peak, no shift was readily apparent for Tg39 (Fig. 2, histograms). However, the corresponding CD3
-gated CD8
by CD4 profiles demonstrate that in both lines there are CD8
SP populations that are CD3
high. The expression of CD8
, expected only on thymocytes entering the CD8 SP lineage, identifies reconstituted thymocytes. Tg59 robustly demonstrates two such populations, a CD8
SP population and another having lower CD8
expression with natural boundaries extending from CD4+ to CD4. These populations are labeled A' and B', respectively (Fig. 2, CD3
high dot plots). Analogous population in 2C mice are labeled A and B. The remaining CD3
low populations for Tg59 and Tg39 are similar to their 2C CD8
/ counterparts. Phenotypically, Tg59 and Tg39 appear to be intermediates of 2C wild-type and 2C CD8
/ mice, with Tg59 more like 2C wild type and Tg39 more like 2C CD8
/.
The 2C TCR (1B2) and CD3
histograms (Fig. 2) were similar in each of the 2C TCR-expressing mice. Additionally, the CD8
by CD4 distributions for 1B2low (not shown) and 1B2high were essentially the same as their CD3
counterparts. One difference, however, is that most CD3
highCD4+ thymocytes are not 1B2highCD4+. Rather, this population tends to be 1B2/lowCD4+. This has been demonstrated previously for CD4 SP T cells from 2C mice (27) and holds true for 2C CD8
/ and both of the transgenic lines. Unlike the CD4 SP thymocytes, reconstituted CD8
-expressing populations are largely 1B2high. This finding suggests that the CD8
-Lck is specifically promoting the reconstitution of CD8
SP thymocytes bearing the 2C TCR.
In 2C mice, the CD3
low dot plot shows a small population that resembles C57BL/6 DP thymocytes as indicated by an arrow in Fig. 2. The remaining large fraction of DP thymocytes is CD3
high and CD8
low when compared with the CD8
SP population within the same dot plot or with that in C57BL/6 mice. The natural boundaries for this CD3
highCD8
low population appear to be contiguous from CD4+ to CD4 levels. This phenotype is consistent with thymocytes undergoing selection and is probably an intermediate population. An analogous population is also reconstituted in Tg59.
Comparable numbers of total and CD8 SP thymocytes reconstituted
Adolescent 2C mice possess a rather small thymus on the order of 20 x 106 thymocytes (25), in contrast to C57BL/6 mice that have more than five times as many thymocytes. 2C CD8
/ mice, however, have an intermediate number of thymocytes. Tg59 mice showed the same thymic cellularity as 2C mice (Table I) in the range of 20 x 106 thymocytes. FACS analysis demonstrated that the proportion of thymocytes that are CD8
SP is comparable to that found in 2C mice (Table I). The range for Tg59 mice was 3.212.0% and for 2C mice it was 6.611.4%. This indicates that Tg59 expression levels are sufficient to recapitulate not only thymic cellularity but also the absolute number of CD8 SP thymocytes seen in 2C wild-type mice.
|
Tg59 mice shows the reconstitution of two CD3
highCD8
+ thymic populations that have analogous populations in 2C mice as discussed for Fig. 2, indicating that CD8
-Lck has an impact on positive selection and development. However, CD8
-Lck is different from endogenous CD8 in that each coreceptor interaction necessarily involves Lck at the expense of other CD8
binding proteins. With this in mind, we analyzed surface markers in Tg59 and Tg39 mice to see whether development occurred in a phenotypically comparable manner to 2C wild-type thymocytes described previously (28). The results for Tg59 are detailed here, but comparable results were obtained for Tg39 also.
First we analyzed the surface expression of CD2 and CD5, the levels of which are increased on those DP thymocytes that undergo selection and maturation (29, 30, 31). For both of these markers, C57BL/6 mice showed a biphasic curve (Fig. 3). As was expected for both surface markers in C57BL/6 mice, "high" expression correlated largely with a SP phenotype. Interestingly, CD2 and CD5 histogram plots for 2C CD8
/ thymocytes were uniformly monophasic curves with an expression level at the intermediate high-low phenotype for both CD2 and CD5. This suggests that these thymocytes are largely a homogeneous population receiving signals via their 2C TCR but lack the necessary coreceptor signal to efficiently drive development, as suggested previously when discussing CD3
expression.
|
histograms in Fig. 2, where there was a comparably large CD3
low population. This indicates that in Tg59 a sizable proportion of the thymocytes are DP and phenotypically similar to 2C CD8
/ DP thymocytes. That may explain why Tg59 profiles tend to be intermediate to 2C wild type and 2C CD8
/. A similar analysis revealed that unlike CD2, a smaller proportion of the reconstituted A' and B' populations fall into the CD5high expression gate but still parallel their counterpart A and B populations in 2C wild type. A possible explanation may involve the higher level of CD5 expression on CD4 SP thymocytes relative to CD8 SP thymocytes (32, 33). Clearly, the Tg59 reconstituted thymocytes demonstrate the same phenotype for the markers CD2 and CD5 as their 2C wild-type counterparts.
Expression of CD24 (heat-stable Ag) and CD69 were also consistent between Tg59 and 2C wild-type thymocytes (Fig. 4). CD24low is associated with a mature phenotype (34, 35) corresponding to that of SP thymocytes in C57BL/6 mice (Fig. 4). In the case of Tg59, the CD24low gate includes nearly the entire A' population, which is lacking in the CD24high gate. The B' population, however, was mainly CD24high with a small proportion being CD24low. Again, these populations parallel their 2C wild-type thymocyte counterparts. The early activation Ag CD69 also helps to phenotypically categorize these thymocytes (36, 37) and helps identify thymocytes that have recently engaged their TCR. Again, the analogous Tg59 and 2C wild-type populations showed similar profiles. The histogram (Fig. 4) is monophasic for 2C transgenic mice. With respect to the 2C CD8
/ curve, both Tg59 and 2C wild-type curves are slightly shifted to the right, indicating that a greater number of thymocytes have been robustly activated and that the CD8
-Lck transgene and endogenous CD8 have comparable signaling capacity during TCR:MHC engagement. For Tg59, a considerable proportion of CD69high thymocytes corresponds to population A' and to a lesser extent to population B'.
|
expression. The first population, A', is largely characterized as CD8
+CD4CD3
highCD2highCD5highCD24low, with a substantial proportion being CD69+. Population B' is largely characterized as CD8
lowCD4+/CD3
highCD2highCD5highCD24high. These phenotypes are consistent for a mature SP and an intermediate thymocyte phenotype, respectively. These phenotypes are comparable to the analogous A and B populations in 2C mice.
Peripheral reconstitution for CD8
-Lck transgenic T cells is equivalent to 2C mice
The peripheral lymph node compartment of CD8 SP T cells for Tg59 and 2C mice were similar for phenotype and total number. In 2C mice there was a large CD8 SP population and a modest CD4 SP population. Phenotypically, the CD8
-Lck reconstituted CD8 SP population had a similar profile of expression of CD3
high and 1B2high as in 2C wild-type mice (Fig. 5) and of CD24low expression (data not shown). Lymph node cell numbers were similar between Tg59, 2C CD8
/, and 2C mice (Table II). However, for 2C CD8
/ mice the proportion of 1B2high cells was less but there was a large 1B2/lowCD3
high CD4 SP population (Fig. 5). The total numbers of CD8 SP T cells were comparable between Tg59 and 2C. Overall, lymph node profiles for Tg59 mice were similar to those of 2C mice.
|
|
+/1B2+CD24lowCD62L+CD44, as is the case for 2C CD8 SP T cells. Reconstituted CD8 SP T cells are functionally competent
Because the chimeric coreceptor is qualitatively and quantitatively different from the endogenous CD8 coreceptor, it is possible that the reconstituted cells did not undergo the appropriate program to include functional activity despite expressing the appropriate phenotypic surface markers. To determine whether there were any gross functional abnormalities, lymph node cells from Tg59, 2C, and 2C CD8
/ mice were stimulated and assessed for proliferation and cytokine production (Figs. 6 and 7, respectively). Tg59 lymph node cells had essentially the same response to ligand as 2C lymph node cells for proliferation and for IL-2 and IFN-
production. The level of response to ligand concentration was greater than that of 2C CD8
/ lymph node cells, where the 1B2+ cells are predominantly DN. In a previous study, DN 1B2+ T cells (Kb background) have been shown to possess functional capacities like CD8+1B2+ T cells. However, they required
10-fold more ligand to achieve comparable proliferation and were severely compromised in IL-2 production but efficient for IFN-
production (25). Our results suggest that a CD8
-Lck chimera can provide appropriate signals for functional development of mature CD8 SP T cells.
|
|
With the CD8
-Lck coreceptor we focused on the direct association between Lck and CD8 in thymocyte development. Lck has multiple domains that include protein adapter domains (i.e., Src homology (SH) 2 and SH3) and a kinase domain. To further delineate the Lck function and define the specific activity that might be required in thymocyte development, we generated a murine line expressing an Lck kinase-inactive CD8
-Lck mutant coreceptor, Tg(K273R). Side by side comparison of C57BL/6 wild type, 2C CD8
/, Tg39, and Tg(K273R) revealed that CD8 SP thymocytes are reconstituted in the Tg(K273R) animal to the same extent as the Tg39 animal (Fig. 8A). We decided to determine whether there was any correlation between the extent of CD8 SP reconstitution in these different transgenic animals and their surface CD8 coreceptor expression. We analyzed the expression levels of the different transgenic coreceptors on the surface of thymocytes and mature T cells by FACS. Although we did not observe any CD8
population in the 2C CD8
/ mice, an analogous population of cells had surface expression of CD8
and CD8
in all of the transgenic mice analyzed. Because a CD2 promoter drives our CD8
-Lck transgene, most types of thymocytes would be expressing the transgene following the CD2 expression profile. Therefore, to estimate the level of expression of the transgene in CD8 SP cells, we calculated the median fluorescence intensity (MFI) values of CD8
on DP thymocytes and mature T cells in the different mouse lines studied. As shown in Fig. 8B, the MFI values of cells expressing CD8
on the surface were significantly lower on the cells from 2C CD8
/ and the transgenic mice expressing the CD8
-Lck chimera when compared with the wild-type C57BL/6 animals. Among the different transgenic mice, Tg59 had the highest expression level of CD8
when compared with Tg39 and Tg(K273R), a CD8
-Lck kinase inactive chimera.
|
SP population was reconstituted that represented
16% of CD3 positive thymocytes (Fig. 8C). The shift from CD3
low to CD3
high (Fig. 8C; histograms) was similar to the shift observed in Tg39 and not as apparent as in Tg59. Also, in these mice most of the CD8
-expressing population are largely IB2high, indicating that the 2C CD8 SP cells are being specifically reconstituted despite the lack of kinase activity by CD8 coreceptor-associated Lck. Analysis of the phenotypic profile for thymocyte population from Tg(K273R) mice (Fig. 8C) showed that it was the same as that of the Tg39 population already described, characterized as CD8
+CD4CD3
highCD2highCD5highCD24low with a proportion being CD69+. Reconstitution of the CD8 SP cells could be detected in the thymus as well as in the peripheral T cell populations of the spleen, blood, and lymph nodes (Fig. 8 and data not shown). | Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
tail with full-length Lck. The chimeric protein was assessed in mice deficient for endogenous CD8
and transgenic for the MHC class I-restricted TCR, 2C. This provided a homogeneous CD8
-Lck:CD8
coreceptor on DP thymocytes that allowed us to determine whether Lck binding to the CD8
tail alone is sufficient for reconstituting CD8 SP T cells in both a phenotypically and functionally competent manner. Interestingly, robust reconstitution of two thymocyte populations was observed (A and A' in Fig. 2). Thymocytes and lymph node cells were assayed and found to be comparable to their counterparts in mice with wild-type endogenous CD8 expression. These results suggest that CD8 association with Lck is sufficient to mediate development of CD8 SP T cells.
The impact of the CD8
-Lck coreceptor on thymocyte development is most apparent in Tg59 and most notable by the shift of thymocytes from the less mature CD3
low peak to the more mature CD3
high peak (Fig. 2). The CD8
by CD4 dot plots clearly show that the CD3
high population consists of two distinct populations, both of which express CD8
, consistent with thymocytes auditioning for selection and developing into the CD8 SP thymocyte lineage. Further, each population has essentially the same phenotype as its 2C wild-type counterparts developing with endogenous CD8; i.e., the level of CD3
and 2C expression is equivalent and both populations are largely CD2high and CD5high. This phenotype is expected on DP thymocytes undergoing selection or on SP thymocytes that are completing or have just completed development. However, both of these populations show a clear difference in CD24 expression. The population that is clearly CD8
SP is CD24low, but the second population is largely CD24high. The reconstituted CD24lowCD8
SP population represents mature thymocytes, whereas the reconstituted CD24highCD8
SP population likely represents intermediate thymocytes auditioning for selection. If this population is indeed an intermediate population, then the CD8
-Lck chimeric coreceptor is driving development along the same intermediates as endogenous CD8 and as such, is able to recapitulate phenotypic intermediates of normal development. The counterpart population in 2C mice has previously been shown to possess a phenotype consistent with an intermediate phenotype, similar to our results presented here, including the CD8
low expression level (28).
We also detect a small population (noted in Fig. 2) that is phenotypically consistent with DP thymocytes in that the CD8 expression is higher (comparable to C57BL/6 DP thymocytes) and CD3
lowCD24high, with some members being CD2low and CD5low. If this population represents DP thymocytes not auditioning for selection, it is curious to note that the population is very small. One possibility is suggested by our 2C CD8
/ thymocyte data. In these mice the majority of CD3
low thymocytes appear to be a homogeneous population poised to undergo selection but lacking the coreceptor signal to do so. In 2C mice the CD8 coreceptor may be efficiently driving DP thymocytes into selection, and the cells accumulate as intermediate phenotypes. These intermediate cells, or at least a significant portion, are likely undergoing positive selection because CD8 SP T cells are generated. As such, a significant portion of this population could also be undergoing negative selection, which may in part explain why these mice have such small thymi. It has been shown in 2C mice that a two-fold increase in CD8 coreceptor expression can alter selection from positive to negative in the otherwise positively selecting Kb background (38). A similar mechanism may be occurring in Tg59 mice. In this case, the expression level of CD8
-Lck appears to provide the requisite activity to promote the efficient and robust development of the intermediate thymocyte population. Again, the reconstituted intermediate population may be undergoing positive selection, leading to the formation of a CD8 SP population and negative selection, partly explaining the small thymi in these animals as well.
The reconstitution of both CD8 SP and intermediate thymocyte populations is likely the result of Lck rather than just the presence of the CD8 extracellular domain. In an earlier study where a CD8
tailless coreceptor chain was expressed in CD8
/ mice at levels comparable to those in endogenous CD8, development was severely impaired (11). Further, when these transgenic mice expressed the 2C TCR, reconstitution did not occur at significant levels. The expression levels for both Tg59 and Tg39 are significantly less than that for mice expressing endogenous levels of CD8, and yet reconstitution occurs to significant levels in both the thymus and the periphery. Because tailless CD8
has been shown to be inefficient and low expression levels of transgene Tg59 and Tg39 are sufficient, it can be concluded that Lck is important in efficient development of CD8 SP thymocytes.
An interesting aspect of the CD8
-Lck coreceptor is that, because Lck has replaced the CD8
tail, it might be expected to be more "CD4 like." Engagement of the chimeric coreceptor would involve Lck in the TCR:MHC interaction but not LAT, similar to what might be expected for CD4 but not CD8. Various reports aimed at altering Lck association with coreceptors show alteration of thymocyte development in the direction hypothesized by the strength of signaling model (39, 40, 41). It has been shown that expression of a constitutively activated Lck promotes SP development and preferential development of CD4 SP over CD8 SP thymocytes with increasing levels of expression (23). This occurs at the expense of DP thymocytes and is independent of MHC class I or class II expression. It is clear in our studies that CD8
-Lck is promoting the development of CD8 SP thymocytes bearing the 2C TCR and not CD4 SP thymocytes bearing the 2C TCR. In fact, the CD4 SP T cells represent a small percentage and are largely 1B2/low in 2C mice. This finding indicates that CD8
-Lck is providing specific signals leading to the development of CD8 SP thymocytes. An explanation of this paradox might be that the absolute levels of coreceptor-associated Lck during TCR:MHC interaction might be the lineage-determining factor. Low expression levels of Tg59 and Tg39 by virtue of being ligated to CD8 might involve the same amount of Lck as wild-type CD8 during coreceptor engagement.
To better understand how CD8-associated Lck might be involved in the DP to CD8 SP developmental transition, we generated a murine line expressing a kinase-inactive CD8
-Lck coreceptor. The expression level of this transgene was similar to that of Tg39. Interestingly, it was also able to reconstitute those thymocyte populations observed in Tg59 and Tg39 in a phenotypically equivalent manner. This result was surprising, because the accepted model for coreceptor-associated Lck in TCR signaling involves its kinase activity in phosphorylating CD3 ITAMs. Here, Lck may be effecting development via an adapter function that can occur through the Lck SH2 and/or SH3 domains or by having phosphotyrosine residues that can be bound by other proteins.
The notion that Lck adapter domains (i.e., SH2 and SH3) can contribute to thymocyte development has been explored previously. A chimeric protein consisting of Lck adapter domains ligated to the Fyn catalytic domain in Lck/ mice and driven by the Lck proximal promoter could reconstitute both thymocyte numbers and a robust DP population (42). However, a SP population was not fully reconstituted. Interestingly, the CD8 SP population did not appear to be as affected as the CD4 SP population. The converse chimeric protein of Fyn N-terminal domains ligated to a catalytically active Lck domain could not reconstitute thymocyte numbers but was capable of reconstituting some DN to DP transitions and some DP to SP transitions. These results suggest that the adapter domains of Lck may be more critical than its kinase domain in efficiently promoting a thymocyte developmental transition. It may be that CD8 SP thymocytes rely on Lck-associated adapter function for more efficient development from the DP pool. In our studies, the adapter function of CD8
-Lck is promoting the efficient development of CD8 SP thymocytes where at low levels of expression the adapter domains may be much more efficient than the kinase domain in exerting their biological effects. In any case, because we did not generate mice with varying levels of the CD8
-Lck kinase-dead transgene we must remain cautious in our statement regarding the role of Lck adaptor function.
The exact of role of Lck in CD8 development has been less clear than that for CD4. Initial experiments with Lck/ mice showed a marked reduction in total thymocyte numbers but nonetheless were leaky, with CD8 SP being much less affected than CD4 SP (43, 44). This has raised the question as to whether the CD8 delineation is strictly dependent on Lck expression or whether there could be other molecules or mechanisms involved.
Although we cannot formally exclude the possibility that endogenous Lck binding to CD8
-Lck may recruit Lck kinase activity, we were unable to detect any coimmunoprecipitation of endogenous Lck with a CD8
-Lck immunoprecipitation (data not shown). Another interesting example of a role for kinase dead Lck is provided by the studies of Hernandez-Hoyos et al. (39), where Lck with kinase-active and kinase-dead domains were expressed under the control of the distal Lck promoter. In these studies active Lck promoted thymocytes with MHC class I-restricted TCRs to the CD4 lineage, and dead Lck promoted thymocytes with MHC class II restricted-TCRs to the CD8 lineage. These results support the strength of signaling model. However, one could speculate that providing kinase-dead Lck was decreasing the Lck activity associated with CD4 coreceptors and in essence increasing the adapter function associated with it, thereby promoting CD8 lineage development. Vice versa, introducing active Lck competes with LAT and endogenous Lck binding to CD8 such that a threshold of Lck kinase activity is achieved that predominates over its adapter function and promotes CD4 lineage development.
In summary, our data provide evidence that the association of Lck to CD8 is sufficient to mediate CD8 SP thymocyte development and, interestingly, that it can proceed independently of the associated Lck kinase activity. A possible mechanism for endogenous CD8 might involve an integral Lck adapter function that, at low coreceptor association levels, predominates over its kinase activity to efficiently promote CD8 SP thymocyte development. If indeed only low levels of Lck association to CD8 are required, LAT association may be critical in that it limits Lck association and enables the adapter function aspect of Lck to predominate. Because the exact role of LAT at this developmental point is not known, it would be interesting to see whether a chimeric CD8
-LAT molecule can reconstitute CD8 SP thymocyte development like CD8
-Lck does and at what expression levels. Along these lines, it would be interesting to see whether a CD4-Lck chimeric coreceptor with or without kinase activity expressed at levels comparable to Tg59 can drive development of CD4 SP thymocytes (or are higher levels required?).
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Disclosures |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grant AI 17258 (to S.J.B.). ![]()
2 R.C.F. and S.P. contributed equally to this work. ![]()
3 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Steven J. Burakoff, 540 First Avenue, Floor 5/Laboratory No. 1, Skirball Institute of Biomolecular Medicine, New York, NY 10016. E-mail address: burakoff{at}saturn.med.nyu.edu ![]()
4 Abbreviations used in this paper: SP, single positive; DN, double negative; DP, double positive; LAT, linker for activation of T cells; MFI, median fluorescence intensity; SH, Src homology. ![]()
Received for publication April 29, 2005. Accepted for publication August 9, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
cytoplasmic domain resulted in a dramatic decrease in efficiency in thymic maturation but only a moderate reduction in cytotoxic function of CD8+ T lymphocytes. Eur. J. Immunol. 23: 2834-2840. [Medline]
chain. Immunity 1: 277-285. [Medline]
gene-targeted mice. J. Exp. Med. 180: 959-967.
chain in positive selection of CD8-lineage T cells. Science 263: 1131-1133.
domains in CD8 coreceptor function: importance for MHC I binding, signaling, and positive selection of CD8+ T cells in the thymus. Immunity 12: 409-418. [Medline]
regulates Lck kinase activation and CD8 T cell development. J. Immunol. 161: 183-191.
chain influences CD8
chain-associated Lck kinase activity. J. Exp. Med. 181: 1267-1273.
-Lck association. Science 261: 1581-1584. 
T cells and positively selected CD8 T cells expressing the same TCR and the induction of anergy in CD4-CD8-
T cells in antigen-expressing mice. J. Immunol. 163: 1222-1229.
/
-regulated developmental transitions. J. Exp. Med. 191: 703-716. 
T cell development is abolished in mice lacking both Lck and Fyn protein tyrosine kinases. Immunity 5: 429-436. [Medline]
| ||||||||