|
|
||||||||



* Laboratory of Immunology, Regina Elena Cancer Institute Centro della Ricerca Sperimentale, Rome, Italy;
Research Center Ospedale Bambino Gesù, Rome, Italy; and
Department of Chemistry, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA 22904
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-microglobulin (
2m) and are loaded with peptide Ags through multiple folding steps. When free of
2m, human H chains react with Abs to linear epitopes, such as L31. Immunodepletion and coimmunoprecipitation experiments, performed in this study, detected a preferential association of L31-reactive,
2m-free H chains with calnexin in
2m-defective cells, and with calreticulin and TAP in
2m-expressing cells. In
2m-defective cells, the accumulation of calnexin-bound H chains stoichiometrically exceeded their overall accumulation, a finding that supports both chaperoning preferences and distinct sorting abilities for different class I folds. No peptide species, in a mass range compatible with that of the classical class I ligands, could be detected by mass spectrometry of acidic eluates from L31-reactive HLA-Cw1 H chains. In vitro assembly experiments in TAP-defective T2 cells, and in cells expressing an intact Ag-processing machinery, demonstrated that L31 H chains are not only free of, but also unreceptive to, peptides. L31 and HC10, which bind nearly adjacent linear epitopes of the
1 domain
helix, reciprocally immunodepleted free HLA-C H chains, indicating the existence of a local un-/mis-folding involving the N-terminal end of the
1 domain
helix and peptide-anchoring residues of the class I H chain. Thus, unlike certain murine free H chains, L31-reactive H chains are not the immediate precursors of conformed class I molecules. A model inferring their precursor-product relationships with other known class I intermediates is presented. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-microglobulin (
2m),4 and a short (811 mer) peptide Ag derived from the degradation of intracellular proteins. They undergo a complex maturation process involving multiple biosynthetic intermediates and folding steps (1, 2).
In humans, class I H chains (still free of
2m) cotranslationally bind the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) transmembrane chaperone, calnexin. Subsequently, they bind
2m, and the H chain:
2m heterodimer associates with the so-called peptide-loading complex. This is a supramolecular structure comprising calreticulin (the soluble homologue of calnexin), the thiol oxidoreductase ERp57, the TAP, and the peptide editor/facilitator tapasin (1, 2). The peptide-loading complex tethers H chain:
2m intermediates until they acquire peptides, an event that results in yet another conformational change, and the release of fully assembled, thermally stable complexes ready for transport to the cell surface, where they can be recognized by CTL, and NK cells.
The biosynthesis of murine class I molecules is similar, but not identical. For instance, calnexin participates in the formation of the peptide-loading complex only in murine cells (3).
As shown by crystallographic studies (4, 5), the fully assembled, folded class I MHC H chains form a characteristic structure (a
-pleated floor topped by two
helices) that delimits the Ag-binding groove. In contrast, the three-dimensional structure of peptide-free H chain:
2m folding intermediates (6), and of class I MHC H chains that have not bound
2m (often referred to as free H chains), is not known, possibly due to their instability and/or a lack of defined conformations at early folding steps. Due to the lack of a direct method of analysis, the reactivity of murine (Ld, Db, and Kb) and human (HLA-A, -B, and -C) H chains with Abs to mapped linear epitopes, such as 64-3-7 (7), KU1, KU2, KU3 (8), HC10, HCA2 (9), LA45 (10), Q1/28 (11), and L31 (12), has become a widely used indicator of local unfolding at short amino acid stretches.
Extensive work has shown (7, 8, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19) (reviewed in Ref.1) that murine free H chains are a heterogeneous group of molecules that meet all or some criteria for overall unfolding (absence of exposed amphipathic residues, thermal instability, as well as a lack of association with
2m, peptides, promiscuous chaperones, members of the peptide-loading complex, etc.). Such a systematic characterization is lacking in the case of human free H chains. We are aware of one study (20) aimed at establishing whether human "free" and
2m-associated H chains have a precursor-product relationship similar to that between murine Ld alt and functional Ld (7). Limited information is also available about the precursor-product relationships between human free H chains and other early occurring (chaperone-bound) conformers. Thus, the evidence itself for multiple conformational changes during class I folding in human systems remains mostly indirect.
In this study, the L31 Ab has been selected as a valuable probe of human H chains, because of the location of its epitope. Binding of L31 is strictly dependent on the presence of aromatic amino acids (Y or F, present in HLA-C and certain HLA-B alleles) at position 67 of the
1 domain
helix (12). Residue 67 is buried deep in the binding groove and contributes to delimit the B pocket, a recess that secures bound peptides at their P2 anchor position (5).
Taking advantage of the reactivity of L31 and other selected Abs, we have tested the ability of free H chains to bind class I chaperones,
2m, and/or peptides, and have identified distinguishable subsets of L31-reactive free H chain conformers with an unfolded binding groove.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The TAP-defective 174 x CEM.T2 (T2 hereafter) cell line (21), the HLA-Cw1 transfectant (12) in the HLA-A-, HLA-B-, HLA-C-defective 721.221 (221 hereafter) cell line (22), the tapasin-defective 721.220 (220 hereafter) cell line (23), the HLA-homozygous B cell line LG2 (12), as well as the KJ29 and FO-1 cell lines and their
2m transfectants (24, 25) have been described.
Antibodies
The murine mAbs HC10 and L31 bind linear
1 domain epitopes, including residues 62 (9) and 67 (12), respectively. Q1/28 binds an
3 domain epitope (11). F4/326 (26) and W6/32 (27) bind class I MHC H chains associated with
2m. Namb-1 binds
2m (28). Rabbit polyclonal Abs to TAP1, tapasin, and ERp57 are described (29). Polyclonals to calnexin and calreticulin were from StressGen Biotechnologies.
Immunochemical methods
Cells were metabolically labeled with [35S]methionine (9.25 MBq/ml), as described in the figure legends, and solubilized with either 1.0% Nonidet P-40 or 0.5% CHAPS in PBS (0.01 M, pH 7.0, 0.15 M NaCl). For immunoprecipitation, purified Abs were covalently linked to Affigel (Bio-Rad). Human
2m was from Sigma-Aldrich. Isoelectric focusing (IEF) and Western blotting techniques (reducing conditions in all cases) are described (12, 24, 25, 29).
Isolation and synthesis of class I peptide ligands
Briefly, W6/32-reactive and L31-reactive class I molecules were isolated from CHAPS lysates of LG2 (Cw*0102) and 221.Cw*0102 transfectants by affinity chromatography, and submitted to acidic elution. Low molecular mass species were recovered by ultrafiltration, and resolved/sequenced by microbore HPLC/triple quadrupole mass spectrometry (30). The synthetic HLA-Cw*0102 ligand NCPERIITL, the HLA-A*0201 ligand GILGFVFTL from the influenza virus matrix glycoprotein, and the irrelevant nonamer QLLGIWGCS were from Sigma-Genosys.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Three distinct, nonoverlapping conformers of class I HLA H chains have been described (16, 31): 1) H chains that have not stably bound
2m, and are reactive with Abs (such as HC10) to free, unfolded H chains; 2) H chains that have already bound
2m, but, still free of peptides, remain temporarily associated with the peptide-loading complex, being coimmunoprecipitated by Abs to TAP; and 3)
2m-associated/TAP-free H chains, reactive with conformational (e.g., W6/32) Abs. W6/32-reactive H chains have also been described to associate with calnexin (16). To determine whether HLA-Cw1 H chains also exist in distinct conformations, immunodepletion experiments were performed in 221.Cw1 transfectants (Fig. 1). Neither the class I H chains directly immunoprecipitated by L31 nor those coimmunoprecipitated with TAP were significantly affected by immunodepletion with W6/32 (Fig. 1A, compare lanes 6 and 7 with lanes 2 and 3). However, L31-reactive H chains were affected, although slightly, by immunodepletion of TAP-associated H chains (Fig. 1B, lane 18 compared with lane 13). Interestingly, tapasin-associated H chains (lanes 16 and 11) were removed by TAP depletion, whereas ERp57-associated H chains (lanes 15 and 10) appeared to be unaffected.
|
L31-reactive conformers associate with calnexin, TAP, and calreticulin
To systematically test the ability of different H chain conformers to interact with all the known class I chaperones, coimmunoprecipitation experiments (Fig. 2A) were performed at steady state on soluble cell extracts from the 221.Cw1 transfectant (12), and two
2m-defective cell lines from different lineages (FO-1 melanoma and KJ-29 kidney carcinoma cells), together with their
2m transfectants (24, 25). Class I conformers were immunoprecipitated by L31 and an Ab to
2m, Namb-1 (28), because Abs to
2m have been shown to be optimal for the unbiased identification of
2m-associated/peptide-empty/W6/32-unreactive class I H chains bound to the peptide-loading complex (31).
|
2m-positive cells (compare lanes 2 and 3, 8 and 9, and 14 and 15), and
2m was undetectable, as expected, in L31 immunoprecipitates (lanes 20, 26, and 32).
Replicate L31 and Namb-1 immunoprecipitates were probed with Abs to class I chaperones (lanes 3751, 5569, 7387, 91105, and 109123). Two distinct coimmunoprecipitation patterns were observed, consistent with a hierarchical order of interactions. Calnexin was much more abundant in L31 immunoprecipitates from
2m-defective cells (lanes 41 and 47) than in L31 and Namb-1 immunoprecipitates from
2m-expressing cells (lanes 38 and 39, 44 and 45, and 50 and 51). In contrast, calreticulin, TAP, tapasin, and ERp57 were all present and most abundant in Namb-1 immunoprecipitates from
2m-expressing cells (lanes 57, 63, 69, 75, 81, 87, 93, 99, 105, 111, and 123). However, some of these latter chaperones were also present, at lower levels, in L31 immunoprecipitates from
2m-positive cells (lanes 56, 62, 68, 74, 80, 86, and 92). Interestingly, calreticulin and TAP were barely detectable even in some L31 immunoprecipitates from
2m-defective cells (lanes 65, 77, and 83). These results demonstrate the ability of H chains to interact with members of the peptide-loading complex independently of
2m.
Because different immunoprecipitates contain different amounts of H chains, a more accurate quantification of chaperoning interactions required densitometry and normalization (described in the legend to Fig. 2). Densitometric analysis demonstrated that L31 conformers were only 1.5 times more abundant in lane 5 than lane 8, but coprecipitated calnexin was 9 times more abundant in lane 41 than in lane 44. Following normalization (densitometric value in lane 41 divided by that in lane 5, and lane 44 divided by lane 8, Fig. 2B), this resulted in a
6-fold increase in H chain:calnexin association, suggesting that L31 conformers more tightly interact with calnexin when synthesized in the absence of
2m.
A similar normalization procedure, conducted on Namb-1 immunoprecipitates (Fig. 2B), was expected to be less accurate, because this Ab also reacts with L31-unreactive H chain alleles and, more importantly, a large fraction of
2m-associated H chains (unlike L31 conformers) is expressed on the cell surface, at which location they are not available for interaction with ER-resident chaperones. Consequently, normalization might underestimate the amounts of chaperones coimmunoprecipitated by Namb-1, as compared with those coprecipitated by L31.
Notwithstanding this limitation, we conclude that L31-reacting H chains preferentially interact with calnexin, particularly in
2m-defective cells, whereas H chains associated with
2m display a preference (the magnitude of which cannot be precisely assessed) for interaction with the known members of the peptide-loading complex. These data are consistent with a selective, although not exclusive, interaction of calnexin and the members of the peptide-loading complex with distinct populations of H chains with different degrees of
2m association and folding.
HLA-C H chains reacting with L31 are unfolded substrates of chaperoning
To obtain independent experimental evidence for a dominant interaction between L31 conformers and calnexin in FO-1 cells (Fig. 2B, highest histogram), the above coimmunoprecipitation/blotting experiments performed at steady state were complemented by a direct coimmunoprecipitation experiment from radiolabeled cell extracts.
Calnexin:H chain interactions were detected by a continuous (2-h) metabolic pulse using an Ab to calnexin (Fig. 3A, lanes 5 and 10), as well as two distinct Abs to free H chains (L31 and HC10; lanes 3, 4, 8, and 9), in both FO-1 and FO-1-
2m cells. The observed position of the calnexin band is compatible with its predicted isoelectric point (
http://au.expasy.org/uniprot/P27824
), and was confirmed in separate IEF blotting experiments, by staining filters with the same Ab to calnexin used for coimmunoprecipitation (data not shown). The low intensity of the calnexin band is consistent with the widely accepted notion that calnexin molecules actively involved in the chaperoning of newly synthesized proteins belong to a large, slowly renewing molecular pool (32). Accordingly, calnexin molecules immunoprecipitated in a radiolabeled form may represent a minor fraction in a large pool of molecules synthesized before metabolic pulse.
|
2m than FO-1 cells (compare, for instance, lanes 5 and 10). However, the calnexin band was much less abundant than the coprecipitated H chain bands in the absence of
2m (lane 5), and much more abundant in its presence (lane 10). Densitometric analysis and calculation of the H chain:calnexin ratios in the two lanes estimated an
8-fold difference in association (data not shown). The same conclusion can be drawn for lanes 3, 4, 8, and 9, although the differences in the ratios, calculated in the same way, were less striking (between 2- and 3-fold). In summary, two independent methods (Figs. 2 and 3A) detected strong and long-lived interactions between L31-reactive H chain substrates and calnexin, particularly in the absence of
2m.
In agreement with previous studies (16), a calnexin band was present in W6/32 immunoprecipitates from
2m-expressing cells (lane 7). Very surprisingly, a similar weak band appeared to be also present in
2m-defective cells (lane 2), in the absence of detectable H chains (lane 2). Possibly, this reflects coimmunoprecipitation with a very small (or poorly radiolabeled) pool of W6/32 H chains synthesized in the absence of
2m. H chains free of
2m have been described to carry the W6/32 epitope under certain conditions (27). Alternatively, calnexin may associate nonspecifically with the immunoadsorbent in this lane.
A component comigrating with
2m was visible within a smear of calnexin-bound proteins (lane 10). Because it was absent in the corresponding immunoprecipitate from
2m-defective parental cells (lane 5), it is likely to coincide with
2m. Its presence is not surprising, because significant levels of
2m-associated H chains were associated with calnexin in FO-1-
2m and other cell lines (see Fig. 2, lanes 39, 45, and 51). More surprisingly, a similar component may be present in L31 and HC10 immunoprecipitates (lanes 8 and 9). Assuming this extremely weak component coincides with
2m, its presence is easier to explain in HC10 than L31 immunoprecipitates, because only the former Ab was shown to immunoprecipitate low levels of
2m (16, 17, 33), whereas no
2m was detected in L31 immunoprecipitates by sensitive coimmunoprecipitation/blotting experiments (Fig. 2, lane 26, and data not shown). Therefore, we conclude that the presence of trace amounts of
2m in L31 immunoprecipitates cannot be excluded, although we have no direct confirmatory evidence.
Several additional bands were present in the basic area of the gel around and above
2m. One of these even exceeded the intensity of the calnexin band directly immunoprecipitated by the polyclonal Ab to calnexin (lanes 5 and 10, arrows), and was presumably identical with a weak band detectable in some L31 and HC10 immunoprecipitates (lanes 3 and 4). No such band was seen by probing IEF blot filters with the same polyclonal to calnexin (data not shown), suggesting that an unknown protein, primarily associated with calnexin, was detected as a result of coimmunoprecipitation rather than Ab cross-reactivity. This component was not further characterized.
Finally, from the results depicted in Fig. 3A, it is evident that, as expected, L31 only reacted with HLA-B8 and HLA-Cw7 H chains, whereas HC10 reacted more widely (lanes 3, 4, 8, and 9). Accordingly, immunodepletion experiments, performed to reveal a possible overlapping in the molecular pools of
2m-free H chains identified by the two Abs, resulted in the complete immunodepletion of all L31-reactive H chains (Fig. 3B, lane 16) by HC10, and in the partial depletion of HC10-reactive H chains by L31 (lane 18). The results of the immunodepletion experiment demonstrate that two nearly adjacent linear epitopes of the
1 domain
helix and binding groove become simultaneously accessible to, and hidden from, Ab binding on HLA-B8 and -Cw7 H chains, when these are
2m associated and
2m free, respectively.
In conclusion, the results shown in Figs. 2 and 3A are consistent with the existence of at least two class I intermediates in which the binding groove remains unfolded during successive chaperoning/quality control steps taking place on calnexin and on some members of the peptide-loading complex, respectively.
HLA-Cw1-free H chains do not bind naturally occurring peptides
To determine whether L31-reactive H chains naturally bind peptides in 221.Cw1 and LG2 cells (also expressing Cw1 as the only L31-reactive allele), low molecular mass peptides were eluted from W6/32-reactive and L31-reactive HLA class I molecules. Mass spectrometry identified several (2040) prominent and distinct peptide peaks with estimated molecular masses
1 kDa in the W6/32 eluates of 221.Cw1 transfectants. One dominant peptide peak was identified as NXPERIITL, in agreement with a previous report (34). Database searches identified heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein X (aa 5361) as the putative peptide donor, and NCPERIITL as the putative ligand. The corresponding synthetic peptide was shown to be a specific HLA-Cw1 ligand in in vitro assembly assays (see below). In contrast, no peptide species, in a mass range compatible with the classical class I (911 mer) ligands, were detected in the L31 eluates from the two cell lines, indicating that L31 conformers are not only free of
2m, but also free of peptides.
HLA-Cw1-free H chains do not bind exogenous peptides or
2m in in vitro assembly assays
The absence of natural class I ligands in L31 eluates raises the possibility that peptides with low affinity and high dissociation rates might be lost during the purification procedures. In this case, however, it should be possible to force HLA-C ligands to bind back to L31 conformers, by in vitro incubation with excess amounts of synthetic peptides. Therefore, we examined the binding of NCPERIITL to the L31 conformers present in cell lysates. To this aim, the TAP-deficient T2 cell line was initially selected, because it synthesizes H chain:
2m complexes largely devoid of high affinity, endogenous peptides, and naturally expresses HLA-Cw*0102 molecules. The in vitro assembly assay (13) was conducted at 4°C to enhance low affinity interactions, either in the absence or in the presence of exogenously added
2m, in the event that this might further stabilize transient H chain:peptide assemblies. As expected, the addition of
2m enhanced the recovery of W6/32-reactive HLA-A2, -B51, as well as -Cw1 H chains (Fig. 4A, compare lane 2 with lanes 5, 11, 14, and 17), while the addition of NCPERIITL selectively enhanced the W6/32 reactivity of the HLA-Cw1 allele only (lane 8). The addition of both
2m and peptide promoted W6/32 reactivity in a roughly additive fashion (compare Cw1 bands in lanes 2, 5, 8, and 17, and also see HLA-A2 in lanes 2, 5, and 14, the latter supplemented with an HLA-A2-specific ligand). In contrast,
2m had a marginal effect, and the NCPERIITL peptide had no effect, on the amounts of L31-reactive HLA-Cw1 conformers (lane 1 compared with lanes 4, 7, 10, 13, and 16). A densitometric analysis of these results, reported in the right panel of Fig. 4, confirmed that L31-reactive H chains do not appreciably assemble with peptide. Other HLA-Cw1-free H chain conformers, barely detectable in T2 soluble extracts, became more reactive with an Ab to the
3 domain (Q1/28) following addition of the Cw1 peptide (Fig. 4, A, lane 9, and B, histograms to the right end). Q1/28 conformers were not further investigated. Thus, L31 appears to identify a subset of free H chain conformers only marginally affected by the addition of exogenous
2m, and refractory to peptide-mediated stabilization, even at 4°C.
|
|
2m (naturally occurring in biosynthetically active cells or exogenously added) could detectably influence the fate of L31-reactive conformers. | Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2m, even provided in excess amounts, could not significantly stabilize L31 conformers in experiments of in vitro assembly performed in various experimental conditions. A spectrum of H chain intermediates with different degrees of folding
Among murine and human H chain intermediates with different degrees of folding, the peptide-free murine Ld alt molecules identified by the 64-3-7 Ab have been shown to be partially folded, because they: 1) are weakly associated with
2m (16, 18); 2) bind all members of the peptide-loading complex (19); and 3) can be readily converted into fully conformed H chains displaying stable association with
2m by peptide addition (7). This combination of features has not been described, to our knowledge, in any of the human H chain intermediates described to date, although HC10-reacting H chains were reported to weakly bind
2m (16, 17, 33), and to be coimmunoprecipitated with calnexin, calreticulin, and TAP (15, 16, 36). Likewise, another Ab (MARB-4) was shown to recognize H chains free of
2m and associated with peptides (37), but no information is available about its ability to coimmunoprecipitate class I chaperones.
In this study, L31-reactive H chains have been systematically characterized. An association with
2m could not be demonstrated conclusively, using a sensitive immunoprecipitation/blotting method in lysates prepared with the mild nonionic detergent CHAPS. Like HC10, L31-reactive H chains were found to interact with calnexin and at least two members of the peptide-loading complex (TAP and calreticulin). Unlike 64-3-7-reactive H chains, L31-reactive H chains were free of peptides, and unreceptive to a major peptide ligand, as shown by mass spectrometry and in vitro assembly (Figs. 4 and 5). These results complement the observation that HC10-reactive conformers were not spontaneously chased into assembled class I molecules (20). Thus, human class I molecules appear to be more sensitive to conformational melting in cell lysates as compared with mouse class I molecules. Possibly, this folding impediment of human
2m-free H chains reflects a more stringent quality control of class I assembly in humans than in mice (reviewed in Ref.17).
In this respect, it is of interest that the 64-3-7 epitope is on a protruding loop connecting the
-sheet floor of the binding groove with the beginning of the
1 domain
helix, just outside the peptide binding site, whereas the H chain epitopes recognized on human free H chains by several Abs such as HC10 (residues 5762), LA45 (residues 6263), L31 (epitope centered on residues 6769), and HCA2 (residues 7784) are clustered on the
1 domain
helix (9, 10, 38), i.e., they line up on one of the sidewalls of the peptide binding site. The availability of linear epitopes outside and inside the peptide-binding groove (in murine and human free H chains, respectively) may correlate with a different plasticity of the groove, and a distinct ability to achieve a peptide-receptive state.
Thus, our results are consistent with an unfolding of at least some of the H chains identified through the
1 domain
helix epitopes, with the L31 conformers most likely lying at the unfolded end of the H chain spectrum.
Clues to the structure of class I HLA intermediates
As noted above, the HC10 and L31 epitopes are adjacent. Both epitopes are accessible on free H chains, but hidden in H chain:
2m complexes, and spatially distant from
2m. This rules out direct epitope masking by the L chain subunit in assembled class I molecules, but remains compatible with masking by: 1) molecules other than the class I structural subunits, namely TAP or other members of the peptide-loading complex; 2) peptides in the binding groove; 3) H chain residues upon a conformational rearrangement; or 4) a combination of some or all of the above.
Mechanism 1 (see above paragraph) is not supported by the available experimental evidence, because association with TAP and calreticulin is compatible with L31 binding (Fig. 2) and, reciprocally, W6/32-reactive molecules are free of all members of the peptide-loading complex (39) (Fig. 1), and yet they do not react with L31. In contrast, mechanism 2 is plausible, because the HC10 epitope is located at the N-terminal end of the
1 domain
helix, right above the N terminus of bound peptides. These could mask the HC10 epitope without any significant contribution of a conformational rearrangement in H chain residues. Although this also applies to the L31 epitope, it may be noted that residue 67, i.e., the single most important residue for L31 binding (12), is buried deep in the B pocket of conformed H chains, in a region involved in anchoring antigenic peptides (5). This makes epitope unmasking unlikely, unless peptide loss is accompanied by an extensive loss of conformation in the peptide-binding groove (e.g., mechanism 3).
In support of this mechanism, we present three observations: 1) free H chains are simultaneously reactive with L31 and HC10 in the absence of
2m (Fig. 2), demonstrating linkage in the acquisition and loss of two linear epitopes on a long amino acid stretch (residues 5769) spanning the entire N-terminal end of the
1 domain
helix; 2) L31-reactive H chains are not only peptide free, but also peptide unreceptive (Figs. 3 and 4), indicating a degree of unfolding that precludes not only peptide binding, but also the formation of a potentially peptide-receptive interface; 3) conversely, thermally unstable HLA-Cw1:
2m complexes in both TAP-deficient and TAP-expressing cells are free of peptides, but receptive to class I ligands, and yet they are not reactive with L31 (Figs. 4 and 5), demonstrating that the absence of peptides per se is insufficient to elicit L31 reactivity.
Thus, in agreement with mechanism 3, L31 identifies an extensive local unfolding incompatible with peptide binding, possibly an extended conformation of an otherwise helical region surrounding the binding groove. The absence or presence of peptides either plays a marginal role, or has no effect, on epitope masking/unmasking.
Class I HLA intermediates
In this study, we have identified two
2m-free H chain intermediates, the former associated with calnexin, and the latter associated with at least two members of the peptide-loading complex (calreticulin and TAP). Both intermediates carry an unfolded binding groove. Their relative amounts depend on the availability of
2m (Figs. 2 and 3), suggesting an equilibrium between the two intermediates. In
2m-defective cells, the association of L31 conformers with calnexin stoichiometrically exceeds their overall accumulation. Two interpretations are possible to explain this feature: 1) with no
2m available, H chains have no alternative but passive calnexin association; 2) calnexin actively retains its substrates because it is capable of sensing an early qualitative impairment in the H chain fold consequent to the absence of
2m. In support of the latter possibility, previous phase partitioning studies with the nonionic detergent TX-114 demonstrated that
2m transfection of KJ-29 cells partially restores, in free HLA-C H chains, a detergent-accessible interface typical of folded proteins, somewhat similar to that of
2m-associated H chains (24).
The interpretation that calnexin-mediated sorting differs in the absence and presence of
2m, and the finding that L31-reacting H chains better associate with calreticulin and TAP in the presence of
2m, are in agreement with studies by Degen et al. (14), and the original view by Sugita and Brenner (15), further elaborated by Solheim et al. (36). These authors suggested that calnexin retains misfolded class I H chains in the ER exclusively in cells defective in peptide loading or
2m expression, while in physiological conditions H chains are released from calnexin, and additional quality control steps may take place on the peptide-loading complex.
In conclusion, we propose that at least two (and not mutually exclusive) pathways determine the accumulation of free H chains in human cells (see the diagram in Fig. 6). In one pathway, H chains might remain free of
2m even following their emergence from calnexin, and in this conformation they would gain limited access to some members of the peptide-loading complex, with no chance of productive assembly. This pathway might function in
2m-defective cells. In the other pathway, dominant in
2m-expressing cells, H chains might bind
2m, and be returned to the pool of unfolded H chains bound to TAP/calreticulin and calnexin, when they do not meet the requirements necessary for productive assembly. This may occur frequently in the case of HLA-C, a class I molecule characterized by restricted peptide binding, impaired assembly, and stable TAP association (39).
|
2m are the substrates of different class I chaperones, presumably to prevent their premature melting. Despite this, large amounts of these H chains are not the immediate precursors of folding and folded intermediates, but dead ends of unsuccessful folding, i.e., they are intermediates dismissed from the proper class I assembly pathway at the calnexin and/or peptide-loading checkpoints. | Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Disclosures |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 This work was supported by Associazione Italiana per la Ricerca sul Cancro (to P.G. and D.F.) and National Institutes of Health GM 37537 and AI33993 (to D.F.H.) Grants. ![]()
2 Current address: Department of Animal and Human Biology, University "La Sapienza," Rome, V. le dellUniversità 32, 00185 Rome, Italy. ![]()
3 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Patrizio Giacomini, Laboratory of Immunology, Regina Elena Cancer Institute Centro della Ricerca Sperimentale, Via delle Messi dOro 156, 00158 Rome, Italy. E-mail address: giacomini{at}ifo.it ![]()
4 Abbreviations used in this paper:
2m,
2-microglobulin; ER, endoplasmic reticulum; IEF, isoelectric focusing. ![]()
Received for publication December 29, 2004. Accepted for publication September 1, 2005.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 microglobulin and loading with peptide. Adv. Immunol. 64:105.-137. [Medline]
2m heterodimer. Nat. Struct. Biol. 5:377.-384. [Medline]
1 domain
helix of HLA-C heavy chains free of
2-microglobulin. Hum. Immunol. 46:69.-81. [Medline]
2-m and peptide. J. Exp. Med. 175:1653.-1661.
2m:major histocompatibility complex class I heavy chain intermediate dissociates from calnexin and then is stabilized by binding peptide. J. Exp. Med. 180:2163.-2171.
2m. Hum. Immunol. 53:23.-33. [Medline]
2-microglobulin, class I heavy chain conformation, and tapasin in the interactions of class I heavy chain with calreticulin and the transporter associated with antigen processing. J. Immunol. 158:2236.-2241. [Abstract]
2m-free heavy chains of HLA-B2705 on the cell surface. J. Immunol. 169:4379.-4387.
2-m-free HLA class I heavy chain epitope mimicry by monoclonal antibody HC-10-specific peptide. J. Immunol. 171:1918.-1926. This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Martayan, L. Sibilio, A. Setini, E. L. Monaco, E. Tremante, D. Fruci, M. Colonna, and P. Giacomini N-Linked Glycosylation Selectively Regulates the Generic Folding of HLA-Cw1 J. Biol. Chem., June 13, 2008; 283(24): 16469 - 16476. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Sibilio, A. Martayan, A. Setini, E. L. Monaco, E. Tremante, R. H. Butler, and P. Giacomini A Single Bottleneck in HLA-C Assembly J. Biol. Chem., January 18, 2008; 283(3): 1267 - 1274. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||