|
|
||||||||





* Department of Neuroimmunology, Max Planck Institute of Neurobiology, Martinsried, Germany;
Department of Animal and Avian Sciences, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742;
Department of Medicine, Neuroimmunology Unit, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden; and
Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, United Kingdom
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The route of sensitization will in part determine the outcome of molecular mimicry, a factor that becomes important if sensitization occurs across the gastrointestinal tract. This will normally lead to oral tolerance, a physiological response that suppresses potentially inflammatory T cell responses to Ag derived from the diet or the gut microbial flora (13). However, oral tolerance can be disrupted by concurrent gastrointestinal infections (14, 15) and is also poorly developed in suckling neonates (13, 16, 17), situations in which mimicry between dietary Ags and self could result in autoaggression. The potential importance of mimicry involving dietary Ags for MS was first recognized following the demonstration of immunological cross-reactivity between bovine milk proteins and CNS myelin autoantigens in an animal model of MS, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) (18, 19). These cross-reactive immune responses involved epitopes derived from myelin basic protein and BSA (18), and the milk protein butryophilin (BTN) and myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) (19).
MOG was identified as a candidate autoantigen in MS following the demonstration that MOG-induced EAE reproduced the immunopathology and complex clinical course of the human disease in rodents and primates (20, 21, 22). MOG is localized at the outer surface of the CNS myelin sheath where it can be targeted by demyelinating autoantibody responses directed against its extracellular N-terminal Ig-like domain (MOGIgd) (23, 24). In MOG-induced EAE, this demyelinating Ab response acts synergistically with an encephalitogenic MOG-specific T cell response to reproduce the inflammatory demyelinating pathology of MS (21, 22). Reports of enhanced MOG-specific T cell (25, 26, 27, 28) and Ab (28, 29, 30, 31) responses in MS patients suggest that autoimmunity to MOG may play a similar role in the pathogenesis of human disease. This concept is supported by the demonstration of MOG-reactive Abs associated with disintegrating vesicular myelin debris in acute demyelinating MS lesions (22, 32) and a recent report that MOG-specific Ab can be used as a prognostic marker early in the course of disease (33).
In contrast to MOG, BTN is expressed only in the lactating mammary gland where it forms a major component of the milk fat globule membrane (34). The two proteins are members of an extended family of B7-like proteins encoded by single genes located telomeric to the HLA complex (35) that are related by the structure and amino acid sequence of their N-terminal Ig V-like domains, which have an amino acid sequence identity of
50% (36). The ease with which self-tolerance to MOG is disrupted in both EAE and MS is attributed to the inability of the protein to induce self-tolerance. The expression of MOG protein outside the immunologically privileged environment of the CNS is controversial (37, 38). However, if MOG is expressed in immune organs, recent studies using genetically manipulated MOG-deficient mice demonstrate that MOG itself is unable to induce immunological self-tolerance (39). As a consequence, potentially pathogenic MOG-reactive lymphocytes are retained within the healthy immune repertoire and may be activated due to mimicry with epitopes derived from environmental agents (8, 19, 40). In the case of BTN, immunization in CFA activates a cross-reactive Th1 CD4+ T cell response to MOG that initiates a subclinical encephalomyelitis (19). However, if sensitization is transmucosal, molecular mimicry between the two proteins can be exploited to induce a protective immune response that suppresses MOGIgd-induced EAE (19).
Epidemiological studies repeatedly associate the prevalence of MS with dietary factors including the consumption of milk and dairy produce (41, 42, 43), and this has lead to speculation that molecular mimicry involving BTN may modulate MOG-specific autoimmune responses in humans (19, 44). To examine this possible link in more detail, we investigated the Ab response to MOGIgd in patients with MS for evidence of molecular mimicry with BTN. We report that MOGIgd-specific autoantibodies immunopurified from MS sera cross-react with multiple epitopes present within the N-terminal Ig domain of the protein (BTNIgI). Furthermore Ab responses to certain BTN peptides are preferentially sequestered in the CNS, suggesting they may be involved in disease pathogenesis. These results provide the first formal demonstration of molecular mimicry involving this common dietary Ag in MS and suggest that the composition and function of the MOG-specific immune repertoire may be influenced during the course of disease by BTN present in milk and dairy products.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Recombinant human MOGIgd (aa 1125) corresponding to the N-terminal Ig-like domain of the protein and rat S100
were expressed with a C-terminal hexahistidine tag in Escherichia coli and purified as described previously (31). The entire mature exoplasmic domain of bovine BTN (aa 1216; BTNexo; Ref. 34) was expressed as a baculo virus product in High5 cells according to the manufacturers instructions (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) and purified by chromatography on Ni-NTA agarose to a purity of >98% as assessed by gel electrophoresis. Protein concentration was determined using Petersons modification of the micro-Lowry method (Sigma-Aldrich, Deisenhofen, Germany). Panels of overlapping synthetic peptides spanning both MOGIgd and BTNIgI were purchased from Genosys (Cambridge, U.K.) (Table I).
|
Blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sampling techniques were approved by the Karolinska Institute Ethical Committee and samples were taken after obtaining the donors informed consent. A total of 35 paired samples of serum and CSF was obtained from patients with clinically definite MS as defined using the Poser criteria and who were undergoing no immunotherapy at the time (males, n = 13; mean age, 43.8 years; range, 2560 years; females, n = 22; mean age, 40.6 years; range, 2459 years). Control sera were obtained from a group of 25 healthy donors (males, n = 9; mean age, 35.3 years; range, 2841 years; females, n = 16; mean age, 35 years; range, 2456 years).
MOGIgd-reactive Abs were isolated from peripheral blood (200300 ml) taken with informed consent from 12 MS patients (males, n = 4; mean age, 40 years; range, 17- 54 years; females, n = 8; mean age, 46 years; range, 2158 years) and 9 MOG Ab-seropositive healthy donors (males, n = 6; mean age, 35.5 years; range, 2946 years; females, n = 3; mean age, 27 years; range, 2430 years). In addition, samples were also obtained from a patient with an acute steroid-unresponsive, intractable relapse who required plasmapheresis (female, age 28) and from one patient with a chronic progressive course who regularly undergoes lipid (low-density lipoprotein) pheresis for hyperlipidemia (female, age 43).
MOGIgd-specific autoantibodies were isolated as described previously (31). Briefly, serum and plasma samples (
150 ml) were diluted 1/1 with PBS and passed through a matrix consisting of human MOGIgd coupled to cyanogen bromide-activated agarose (Sigma-Aldrich) at 4°C. The matrix was then washed extensively with PBS until the absorbance of the wash buffer flow-through had returned to its baseline A280 value. Bound Abs were eluted with 0.1 M glycine (pH 2.5) immediately neutralized by the addition of concentrated (10x) PBS (pH 7.4) and analyzed without any further manipulations.
ELISA
ELISA was performed using polystyrene 96-well PVC plates (Costar, Cambridge, MA) coated overnight with 10 µg/ml Ag in PBS containing 0.02% NaN3. The plates were then washed with PBS containing 0.05% Tween 20/0.02% NaN3 and blocked with 1% (w/v) BSA in PBS for a minimum of 1 h at 37°C. The plates were again washed with PBS-Tween 20 and incubated with 100 µl of diluted serum/Ab either overnight at 4°C or alternatively for 1 h at 37°C. Bound Ab was detected using 100 µl of either peroxidase or alkaline phosphatase-conjugated, human IgG-specific Abs diluted in PBS (Dianova, Hamburg, Germany). Plates were developed with either o-phenyldiamine or p-nitrophenyl phosphate (Sigma-Aldrich) as appropriate and OD was determined either at 490 or 405 nm, respectively. The background OD varied between samples and the Ag-specific response was only considered positive when it exceeded a threshold defined as the background plus 2 SDs in wells coated with BSA and incubated with both sample and secondary Ab. Statistical evaluation was performed using the Students t test, the Fishers exact test, or the McNemar test, as indicated in the text.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Previous studies reported that MS is associated with increased levels of serum Ab to several milk proteins (18), including BTN (44), but in this study we found that this was not the case for the Ab response to epitopes within BTNIgI, the N-terminal region of BTN (aa 1120) homologous to MOGIgd. Analysis of the serum Ab response to the entire exoplasmic domain of BTN (aa 1216; BTNexo) revealed no significant differences between MS patients and healthy control donors (HD)(Fig. 1). In both groups, the frequency of responses to BTNexo was >85% (MS, n = 35, frequency = 89%; HD, n = 25, frequency = 88%), and there was no significant difference in the mean Ab response (MS, mean A405 = 0.43; HD, mean A405 = 0.54; t test, p > 0.05). However, the frequency of responses to individual BTNIgI peptides was consistently lower in MS patients than HD (Fig. 1b). One or more peptides were recognized by 75% of HD, but by only 54% of the MS patients (Fig. 1b). This disease-associated effect was observed for all BTNIgI peptides but appears more pronounced for responses directed toward epitopes within the C-terminal half of this domain. This decrease in Ab responses to individual BTNIgI peptides is apparently masked by increased reactivity to other regions of the protein when the BTN-specific Ab response is assayed using either BTNexo (see above) or the full-length protein (44).
|
To investigate whether the decreased serum Ab response to BTNIgI peptides in MS was due to sequestration within the CNS, we analyzed the patients CSF. Comparison of Ab responses in paired sera and CSF samples (n = 35) identified a subset of 15 patients with a CSF Ab response to one or more BTNIgI peptides (Table II). In many cases, this CSF response was not accompanied by a corresponding peptide-specific serum Ab response (Table II), resulting in a strikingly different specificity profile in the serum and CSF (Fig. 2a). In the sera the response to BTNIgI epitopes was dominated by Ab recognizing BTN126. This specificity was present in 43% of sera (15 of 35), but in only 9% of CSF samples (3 of 35; p = 0.0033, McNemer test). In contrast, the frequency of Ab responses to all other BTNIgI peptides was higher in CSF, where the response was dominated by Ab recognizing peptide BTN76100 (Fig. 2a). This specificity was detected at a high level in 34% of CSF (12 of 35; A405, range, 0.202.16; mean, 0.54), but in only one serum sample (p = 0.0026, McNemer test). Concordance of CSF Ab responses to the BTNIgI peptide(s) and recombinant protein was 66% and in six cases the response to recombinant BTN was higher in the CSF than in sera suggestive of local intratheccal Ab synthesis (Table II). These observations reveal that Ab responses to certain BTNIgI peptides are differentially distributed between the periphery and CNS, in particular Abs binding to BTN76100 are selectively sequestered in the CNS, while Ab responses to BTN126 are skewed in favor of serum
|
|
The sequestration of Ab responses recognizing a bovine milk protein in the CNS was surprising and led us to speculate that this may reflect intratheccal Ab synthesis stimulated by molecular mimicry with the homologous region of MOGIgd. The patients Q Albumin (QAlb) values support the concept that Ab synthesis is occurring within the CNS compartment (Table II), but it was not possible to test for molecular mimicry directly, since insufficient CSF was available to either immunopurify BTN76100 Ab for direct analysis or establish competition assays with MOG and MOG-derived peptides. However, comparison of the specificity profiles of the BTNIgI and MOGIgd peptide-specific response in sera and CSF provides circumstantial evidence that this may indeed be the case. Anti-MOGIgd Ab responses were detected at similar high frequencies in both MS sera (72%) and CSF (77%). The epitope specificity of this Ab response was heterogeneous and did not exhibit such an obvious pattern of sequestration within the CNS as observed for BTN (Fig. 2b). Nevertheless, we still observed a selective and statistically significant skewing of the response to MOG76100 in favor of CSF that mimics the response to the homologous BTN peptide. Abs binding to MOG76100 were present in 60% of CSF but in only 9% of sera (p = 0.001, McNemer test). A similar skewing of the Ab response in favor of the CSF was also seen for the peptides MOG89113 and MOG101125, but in this case the differences were not statistically significant. All patients with a CSF Ab response to BTN76100 had a corresponding response to MOG76100 and regression analysis of the data obtained from all 35 patients supports the proposal that these responses selectively cosegregate in the CNS compartment (Fig. 2c; n = 35, R2 = 0.681).
MOGIgd-specific autoantibodies cross-react with BTN peptide epitopes
To confirm that molecular mimicry can occur between the two proteins, in particular within the amino acid sequence 76100, we investigated the ability of immunopurified MOGIgd-specific Igs to bind to BTNIgI peptides. MOGIgd-specific Igs were isolated from sera/plasma of 14 MS patients and 9 seropositive coworkers (31). The specificity of the Igs eluted from the MOGIgd matrix was confirmed by ELISA and Western blotting, the latter also being used to control for potential contamination by anti-bacterial Abs (data not presented).
Epitope mapping revealed that immunopurified MOGIgd-specific Abs could bind several BTNIgI peptides (Table III). This cross-reactive response was heterogeneous, but dominated by two distinct clusters of epitopes defined by the overlapping peptides BTN126 and BTN1439 and BTN5074 and BTN6387. Cross-reactive Ab responses involving these two regions of BTN were present at similar frequencies in MS patients and HD: BTN139, 64% of MS (9 of 14) and 78% of the controls (7 of 9); BTN5487, 50% of donors in both groups (Table III). In contrast, Ab cross-reacting with BTN76100 was detected more often in MS patients (43%, 6 of 14) than in control donors (11%, 1 of 9; Table III). This difference does not however reach statistical significance (Fishers exact test, p > 0.05). This cross-reactive response between the MOG-specific Ab repertoire and BTN is biased in favor of cryptic peptide epitopes, as demonstrated when the assay was repeated using recombinant BTN as the target Ag), which revealed that only 6 of the 21 samples analyzed exhibited a cross-reactive response to recombinant BTN (Table IV).
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It has been suggested that increased Ab reactivity to dietary Ags in MS may reflect a generalized regulatory defect in mucosal immunity (18); a hypothesis supported by the concordance of inflammatory bowel disorders with MS (46) and the identification of susceptibility loci common to both MS and inflammatory autoimmune diseases affecting the gastrointestinal tract (47). Previous studies describe a disease-associated increase in the serum Ab response to several milk proteins, including BTN (18, 44). However, our data indicate that this is not the case for the Ab response to individual BTNIgI peptides that occur at a lower frequency in MS than in healthy controls. This may be due to the sequestration or absorption of Ab with these specificities in the CNS and we surmise that any decrease in the serum Ab response to BTNIgI peptides was masked in previous studies by enhanced responses to other regions of the protein (44). This would also account for the similar level of Ab reactivity to the entire exoplasmic domain of BTN in MS and control donors seen in this study.
Our evidence for molecular mimicry between MOG and BTN is currently restricted to the humoral arm of the immune system and is based on the analysis of immunopurified MOGIgd-specific Ab isolated from sera obtained from both MS patients and healthy seropositive controls. The epitope specificity of the response is complex and also involves cryptic BTN peptide epitopes. Surprisingly, we were unable to detect an equivalent response in Ab isolated from a large pool of healthy naive donors. This observation along with the high frequency of BTNIgI-specific Ab responses in the general population suggest that the expansion and selection of cross-reactive B cell clones is not driven by exposure to BTN per se, but rather the homologous MOG peptide epitope. In the majority of the population, MOG will remain sequestered behind the blood-brain barrier, but becomes accessible to the immune system in MS as a consequence of CNS inflammation, demyelination, and blood-brain barrier dysfunction, while the inhalation of MOG-containing aerosols apparently has a similar effect in laboratory workers (28). We are currently investigating whether cross-reactive MOG/BTN Ab responses are also enhanced in other CNS diseases in which loss of tolerance to MOG is reported to occur.
The pathophysiological consequences of Ab cross-reactivity between MOG and BTN are uncertain and its effects may well be epitope specific, as suggested by the differential distribution of responses to BTN126 and BTN76100 between the periphery and CNS. The peptide specificity of the cross-reactive Ab response is probably influenced by the donors HLA haplotype, although we could not identify any specific association between haplotype and specificity in our limited sample set. In view of data suggesting that the immunodominant demyelinating Ab response to MOG is conformation dependent (31, 48, 49, 50), cross-reactive BTN/MOG Ab recognizing linear peptide epitopes may not mediate primary demyelination. Nevertheless, several residues within the N-terminal region of MOGIgd (aa 12, 30 and 3334) contribute to the binding of the demyelinating mAb 8-18C5 to MOG (50) and are therefore accessible to Ab in vivo. This raises the possibility that cross-reactive components of the Ab repertoire directed against the N-terminal sequence of MOG are selectively absorbed in the CNS by binding to MOG, a mechanism that may explain the low frequency of BTN126-reactive Ab in the CSF compartment in MS. Similarly, some demyelinating MOG-specific mouse mAbs bind to peptides containing aa 6387 (48), suggesting that BTN/MOG cross-reactive Ab recognizing this region of the molecule may also be pathogenic.
In contrast, the enhanced CSF Ab response to other BTN peptides, in particular BTN76100, indicates that these specificities are not rapidly cleared from the CNS, presumably because the cross-reactive epitopes are not accessible on the surface of the intact extracellular domain of MOG. The sequestration within the CNS of Ab specific for determinants of a milk protein is in itself surprising and we suggest that this may reflect intratheccal Ab synthesis maintained by molecular mimicry with the corresponding MOG epitope(s). This hypothesis is supported for Ab response to BTN76100 by the absence of detectable Ab in the majority of sera, the patients Qalb, and the observation that Abs binding to BTN76100 and MOG76100 cosequester in the CNS. Moreover, molecular mimicry involving this region of the two proteins appears to be enhanced in the peripheral MOGIgd-specific Ab repertoire of MS patients. A full understanding of the pathophysiological significance of Ab cross-reactivity involving these different regions of MOG/BTN will require a detailed mapping of the responses in serum and CSF combined with in vitro studies to investigate their effects on myelination and presentation of Ag to T cells.
The demonstration of molecular mimicry between these two proteins has broader implications with respect to MS that extends to the T cell repertoire. The consumption of milk and milk products provides a source of BTN-derived peptides that can cross the gut mucosa to stimulate Ag-specific immune responses both locally in gut-associated lymphoid tissue as well as in peripheral immune organs (51). This is a normal physiological event that induces oral tolerance, the systemic suppression of proinflammatory T cell responses to soluble dietary Ags (13). Mimicry involving BTN may therefore not only induce a cross-reactive B cell response but also a T cell response that is counterinflammatory and that may suppress cross-reactive and potentially encephalitogenic MOG-specific Th1 T cell responses, as indicated by the suppression of MOG-EAE by transmucosal treatment with BTN peptide (19). It should however be noted that oral tolerance can be abrogated by gastrointestinal infections (14, 15) that may allow a transient expansion of cross-reactive and encephalitogenic Th1 T cell responses to MOG that might exacerbate CNS inflammation. Similarly, oral tolerance is also poorly developed in suckling neonates (13, 16, 17) so that in the context of a susceptible genotype early exposure to bovine BTN could prime the MOG-reactive repertoire to potentiate disease activity later in life.
In summary, we demonstrate that the milk protein BTN acts as a molecular mimic of MOG and that immunological cross-reactivity occurs between these two proteins in a subset of MS patients. Because milk and milk products are a staple component of the Western diet, BTN should be considered a ubiquitous environmental factor that can influence the autoimmune response to this specific myelin autoantigen. The pathophysiological consequences of molecular mimicry involving BTN are difficult to predict, as they will be influenced by multiple factors, including an individuals genotype, the timing and level of exposure to BTN, and the health of the gastrointestinal tract. In fact, chance may play a major role in determining whether or not molecular mimicry between MOG and BTN leads to a detrimental or protective immune response in any particular individual. Intriguingly, epidemiological studies associate the prevalence of MS with the consumption of milk and dairy produce (41, 42, 43), but whether this is related to molecular mimicry involving MOG and BTN remains a matter of speculation.
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 This publication contains data obtained during the course of a dissertation (J.G.) submitted to the Faculty of Medicine, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität (Munich, Germany). ![]()
3 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Christopher Linington, Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, Institute of Medical Sciences, University of Aberdeen, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB25 2ZD, U.K. E-mail address: c.linington{at}abdn.ac.uk ![]()
4 Abbreviations used in this paper: MS, multiple sclerosis; MOG, myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein; MOGIgd, MOG Ig domain; EAE, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis; BTN, butyrophilin; BTNexo, BTN exoplasmic domain; BTNIgI, BTN N-terminal Ig domain; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; HD, healthy control donor. ![]()
Received for publication June 4, 2003. Accepted for publication October 22, 2003.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. A. McLaughlin, T. Chitnis, J. Newcombe, B. Franz, J. Kennedy, S. McArdel, J. Kuhle, L. Kappos, K. Rostasy, D. Pohl, et al. Age-Dependent B Cell Autoimmunity to a Myelin Surface Antigen in Pediatric Multiple Sclerosis J. Immunol., September 15, 2009; 183(6): 4067 - 4076. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Jeong, A. U. Rao, J. Xu, S. L. Ogg, Y. Hathout, C. Fenselau, and I. H. Mather The PRY/SPRY/B30.2 Domain of Butyrophilin 1A1 (BTN1A1) Binds to Xanthine Oxidoreductase: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUNCTION OF BTN1A1 IN THE MAMMARY GLAND AND OTHER TISSUES J. Biol. Chem., August 14, 2009; 284(33): 22444 - 22456. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Bar-Or and J. Antel Cross-reactivity between epidemiology and immunology in multiple sclerosis Neurology, October 7, 2008; 71(15): 1132 - 1133. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Otaegui, S. Mostafavi, C. C. A. Bernard, A. L. de Munain, P. Mousavi, J. R. Oksenberg, and S. E. Baranzini Increased Transcriptional Activity of Milk-Related Genes following the Active Phase of Experimental Autoimmune Encephalomyelitis and Multiple Sclerosis J. Immunol., September 15, 2007; 179(6): 4074 - 4082. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Gold, C. Linington, and H. Lassmann Understanding pathogenesis and therapy of multiple sclerosis via animal models: 70 years of merits and culprits in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis research Brain, August 1, 2006; 129(8): 1953 - 1971. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R P Lisak, J A Benjamins, B Bealmear, B Yao, S Land, L Nedelkoska, and D Skundric Differential effects of Th1, monocyte/macrophage and Th2 cytokine mixtures on early gene expression for immune-related molecules by central nervous system mixed glial cell cultures Multiple Sclerosis, April 1, 2006; 12(2): 149 - 168. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. L. Spitsberg Invited Review: Bovine Milk Fat Globule Membrane as a Potential Nutraceutical J Dairy Sci, July 1, 2005; 88(7): 2289 - 2294. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. L. Ogg, A. K. Weldon, L. Dobbie, A. J. H. Smith, and I. H. Mather Expression of butyrophilin (Btn1a1) in lactating mammary gland is essential for the regulated secretion of milk-lipid droplets PNAS, July 6, 2004; 101(27): 10084 - 10089. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |