|
|
||||||||

,
* Research Institute, Program in Infection, Immunity, Injury and Repair, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada; and
Department of Immunology and
Institute of Medical Science, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-microglobulin) and as hybrid human/mouse
(HLAhyb) molecules on the H2b background. To
eliminate the influence of H2b class I, each HLA Tg strain
was bred with a H2-Kb/H2-Db-double knockout
(DKO) strain to generate mice in which the only classical class I
expression was the human molecule. Expression of each
HLAhyb molecule and HLA-B27nat/human
2-microglobulin led to peripheral CD8+ T
cell levels comparable with that for mice expressing a single
H2-Kb or H2-Db gene. Influenza A infection of
Tg HLA-B27hyb/DKO generated a strong CD8+ T
cell response directed at the same peptide (flu nucleoprotein
NP383391) recognized by CTLs from flu-infected B27+
humans. As HLA-B7/flu epitopes were not known from human studies, we
used flu-infected Tg HLA-B7hyb/DKO mice to examine the CTL
response to candidate peptides identified based on the B7 binding
motif. We have identified flu NP418426 as a major HLA-B7-restricted
flu CTL epitope. In summary, the HLA class I Tg/H2-K/H2-D DKO mouse
model described in this study provides a sensitive and specific
approach for identifying and characterizing HLA-restricted CTL epitopes
for a variety of human disease-associated Ags. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|

-TCR CTLs of
viral Ags in the form of peptides presented by self MHC class I
molecules at the cell surface (1). In general, Ags present
in the cytosol of infected cells are processed to peptides by the
proteasome and transported into the endoplasmic reticulum by TAP, where
they interact with MHC class I molecules (HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-C in
humans; H2-K, H2-D, and H2-L in mouse) (2, 3). Effective
binding leads to transport and expression of the MHC/peptide complex at
the cell surface for survey by CTLs. A number of studies have shown
that class I-associated peptides range from 8 to 11 aa in length, and
that those able to bind a particular allele share the same or related
amino acid residues at conserved positions (4, 5, 6). The
existence of these allelic binding motifs demonstrates the importance
of complementarity between the sequence of the presented peptide and
the unique structure of the cleft of distinct alleles
(4, 5, 6). Furthermore, given that only a limited number of
viral peptide T cell epitopes restricted by specific human
or mouse MHC alleles have been identified to date, the uncovering
of such conserved motifs provides a reverse-genetics approach for
initial identification of candidate MHC-binding peptides by scanning of
amino acid sequences of Ags of interest (4, 5, 6, 7). In addition to the multiplicity of MHC molecules encoded by distinct gene loci in both mice and humans, these proteins are also the most polymorphic molecules in both species, with many alleles identified for most loci (8). Despite this, the T cell response to infection is often observed to become focused in two ways. First, for a given infection, there tends to be a hierarchy or dominance within the responding CTL population with respect to usage of the available MHC class I alleles as restricting elements. Second, despite potential generation of up to hundreds of different peptides for a typical virus for recognition by T cells, a substantial proportion of the antiviral response comes to be directed at a limited number. This phenomenon is called immunodominance, with the preferred MHC/peptide complex(es) called the immunodominant epitope(s) and less favored ones referred to as subdominant epitopes (9, 10).
A detailed understanding of immunodominance is criticial for delineating the determinants of effective antiviral immunity and developing vaccines for infections such as HIV-1. Although the inbred mouse is experimentally suited to studies of immunodominance as well as epitope identification and characterization, the results have little direct bearing on Ag recognition in the context of the human MHC molecules. However, performing such investigations for the human directly is complicated for several reasons. Aside from practical issues, MHC polymorphism results in most individuals being heterozygous and expressing up to six different class I alleles and an even greater number of class II alleles. This multiplicity of MHC allele expression, together with additional genetic influences on immune responsiveness, complicate analyses of the functional activities of individual HLA products in the outbred human population.
To attempt to reduce this complexity with respect to HLA function and recognition, we and others have explored the possiblity that HLA class I molecules expressed in transgenic (Tg)3 mice might provide a useful model for studying HLA-specific T cell recognition in vivo (11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16). In particular, if human MHC class I alleles bind and present the same Ag-derived peptides to Tg T cells as they do in allele-matched humans, then a panel of Tg mice expressing different HLA alleles should facilitate studies in the context of the human Ag-presenting molecules of immunodominance. Furthermore, this will also have direct application in the identification of new viral and tumor Ag T cell epitopes, as well as developing vaccine immunization strategies. However, despite some efforts along these lines, the extent to which human MHC molecules function efficiently and with the identical specificity as in humans is not clear. Although some studies have suggested that fully native Tg HLA class I molecules are recognized poorly as restriction elements by Tg mouse T cells (11, 12), other reports using apparently similar strains or additional engineered versions of this model suggest that Tg HLA molecules can be recognized by the mouse immune system essentially as alternate mouse H2 class I alleles (13, 14, 15, 16). It is possible that at least some of these discrepant results are due to allele-specific differences in the function of human MHC molecules in the mouse background. Furthermore, competition between Tg HLA and endogenous H2 could also limit HLA-dependent thymic selection and T cell recognition in a background coexpressing the normal array of H2 class I molecules.
We previously described a panel of HLA Tg mice on a wild-type (WT)
C57BL/6 background that express the class I alleles HLA-A2, HLA-B7, or
HLA-B27 as fully native molecules in association with human
2-microglobulin (h
2m)
or as human/mouse hybrid molecules consisting of the HLA
1
2
Ag-binding domains linked to the mouse
3, transmembrane, and
cytoplasmic domains (16). Although such mice are useful
for certain applications, coexpression of endogenous H2 class I may
reduce the efficiency of detection of HLA-restricted Ag-specific
responses. The possibility of a TCR repertoire bias inherently favoring
mouse over human MHC recognition could also influence detection of
HLA-restricted responses. Finally, related peptide-binding
specificities of certain human and mouse alleles (i.e., HLA-B7 and
H2-Ld) would also complicate analyses in HLA Tg
mice coexpressing these mouse class I molecules. With these concerns in
mind, we have transferred each of the above HLA class I Tgs onto a
background naturally deficient for H2-L and double knockout (DKO) for
H2-Kb and H2-Db expression
(17). The absence of H2 class I expression eliminates
possible competition with Tg HLA, and thus the majority of
CD8+ T cells in the periphery of these Tg HLA/H2
DKO mice are specific for the human allele. In this study, we compare
each of the HLAhybrid (hyb)/DKO and
HLAnative (nat)/DKO strains with respect to the
level of peripheral CD8+ T cells as well as
antiviral CTL responses. Based on recognition of the same influenza A
peptide in allele-matched HLA Tg mice and humans, we go on to show that
this model provides a powerful approach for identifying new viral CTL
epitopes recognized in the context of human MHC class I alleles.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The HLAnat and HLAhyb class I Tg mouse strains, originally generated in (B6/SJL)F2, were backcrossed a minimum of 10 generations onto C57BL/6J (referred to as Tg HLAnat/B6 and HLAhyb/B6) and described in detail previously (15, 16). C57BL/6J mice for breeding or experiments were from The Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME). HLA Tg offspring were identified by tail DNA hybridization or by flow cytometry of PBLs (15, 16). Although all Tg HLA class I molecules reacted with mAb B9.12.1, Tg HLA-B27hyb, HLA-B27nat, HLA-B7hyb, and HLA-B7nat could also be detected with mAb ME1, and Tg HLA-A2hyb and A2nat with mAb MA2.1 (15, 16).
Each Tg HLAnat line carries the cloned genomic
gene encoding the fully native HLA class I allele (15, 16). The HLA-B27nat (B*27052) and
A2nat (A*02011) Tg mice were generated by
coinjection of the HLA and h
2m genes and are
referred to as Tg
HLA-B27nat/h
2m and Tg
HLA-A2nat/h
2m,
respectively (16). The
HLA-B7nat(B*07021)/h
2m
Tg mice were derived by breeding HLA-B7nat singly
Tg mice with mice Tg for the h
2m gene, as
described (15, 16). Each HLAhyb Tg
line carries a cloned hybrid genomic gene containing the human exons
for the B*27052, A*02011, or B*07021
1 and
2 domains linked to
the mouse exons for the
3, transmembrane, and cytoplasmic domains of
H2-Kb (16). Although efficient
surface expression of Tg HLAnat class I molecules
requires coexpression of h
2m, Tg
HLAhyb class I molecules are expressed
efficiently at the cell surface in the absence of
h
2m due to association with endogenous murine
2m (m
2m) (15, 16). For each HLAnat and
HLAhyb Tg construct, multiple lines were
originally established and characterized with respect to Tg expression
by tissue RNA blot hybridization and flow cytometry (15, 16). Individual Tg lines for each allelic construct were
selected for further detailed study on the basis of a normal breeding
and Tg transmission rate, an appropriate tissue distribution of Tg RNA,
and cell surface expression at a level similar to each other and to
endogenous H2 class I (16). These Tg HLA class I lines on
the B6 (H2b) background are formally referred to
as follows:
Tg(B*27052nat/h
2m)
H2b chamber; Tg(B*27052hyb)
H2b chamber;
Tg(A*02011nat/h
2m)
H2b chamber; Tg(A*02011hyb)
H2b chamber;
Tg(B*07021nat/h
2m)
H2b chamber, and
Tg(B*07021hyb) H2b
chamber.
The HLAhyb and HLAnat
Tg mice on the B6 background described above were subsequently
established on a background deficient for expression of endogenous H2
class I (i.e., H2-Kb and
H2-Db) by backcrossing each HLA Tg at least six
times with
H2-K-/-/H2-D-/- DKO
mice previously backcrossed onto B6 (17). These
HLAnat/DKO and HLAhyb/DKO
strains are formally referred to as follows:
Tg(B*27052nat/h
2m) DKO
chamber; Tg(B*27052hyb) DKO chamber;
Tg(A*02011nat/h
2m) DKO
chamber; Tg(A*02011hyb) DKO chamber;
Tg(B*07021nat/h
2m) DKO
chamber; and Tg(B*07021hyb) DKO chamber.
Mice deficient for H2-K (i.e., H2-K-/-D+/+ (H2-K single knockout (KO))) or H2-D (i.e., H2-K+/+D-/- (H2-D single KO)) expression only (18) were also used for specific experiments as well as for breeding with DKO mice to generate offspring having only one H2-D gene (H2-K-/-D+/-) or one H2-K gene (H2-K+/-D-/-). Single KO and DKO parental strains were kindly provided by F. Lemonnier (Institut Pasteur, Paris, France). All mice were housed in a pathogen-free animal facility at The Hospital For Sick Children according to the guidlines of the Canadian Council of Animal Care.
Influenza A virus, peptides, and cytotoxicity assays
Mice were infected by i.p. injection of 300 hemagglutinating units of influenza A virus X31 (SPAFAS, North Franklin, CT) in PBS. In H2b mice, the anti-flu CTL response has been shown to recognize nucleoprotein (NP) peptide aa 366374 (NP366374; ASNENMETM) in association with H2-Db (19). In HLA-B27+ humans, B27-restricted CTLs have been shown to recognize flu peptide NP383391 (SRYWAIRTR) (20). These and all other peptides used in this study were from Research Genetics (Huntsville, AL).
Spleen cells from mice infected 3 wk earlier were restimulated in vitro
for two 6- to 7-day periods with the indicated peptide in
-MEM (Life
Technologies, Grand Island, NY) containing 10% FCS
(Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO), 10 mM HEPES, 5 x
10-5 M 2-ME, penicillin/streptomycin (Life
Technologies), and 0.5 U/ml of mouse IL-2 (21). Autologous
peptide-pulsed spleen cells were the source of APCs and T cells for the
first period. For the second period, viable cells were harvested and
restimulated with peptide-pulsed irradiated (2000 rad) strain-matched
spleen cells that served as APCs. Cell aliquots were stained on the
indicated day with anti-CD8 and anti-CD4 mAbs to monitor the
CD8+ and CD4+ populations.
On the day of 51Cr release assay, target cells
were labeled with
Na251CrO4
(16) and then pulsed with the indicated peptide. Targets
were Con A-stimulated (2 days with 2 µg/ml) strain-matched spleen
cells. After 4 h of incubation of effectors with targets at
various E:T ratios, supernatants were harvested and counted. Specific
lysis was calculated as ((experimental - spontaneous
release)/(maximal - spontaneous release)) x 100%
(16, 21).
Flow cytometry
The mAbs and detection reagents used for flow cytometry and
their specificities and sources are as follows: CD3 PerCP, CD4 PE,
CD8
FITC, CD8
PerCP, TCR V
8.3 FITC,
H2-Kb biotin, and SA-PE were from BD PharMingen
(San Diego, CA); ME1 (specific for HLA-B7, HLA-B27, and HLA-Bw22),
MA2.1 (specific for HLA-A2), and 28-14-8S (specific for
H2-Db, H2-Ld, and
H2-Dq) were from American Type Culture Collection
(Manassas, VA). FITC-conjugated F(ab')2 goat
anti-mouse IgG (Fc specific) and FITC-conjugated
F(ab')2 goat anti-rat IgG (Fc specific) were
from Accurate Chemical and Scientific (Westbury, NY). The anti-TCR
V
mAbs were obtained from J. Penninger (Amgen Institute, Toronto,
Canada), and were specific for V
2 (B20.6), V
6 (44.22.1),
V
7 (TR310), V
8.2 (F23.2), V
8.1/8.2 (KJ16), V
11 (KT11),
V
12 (MR11-1), and V
14 (14.2) (22). Following two- or
three-color staining, cells were washed, fixed in 1% paraformaldehyde
in PBS, and then analyzed on a BD Biosciences FACScan flow cytometer
(Mountain View, CA) (16, 21). Data analysis was performed
using CellQuest software (BD Immunocytometry Systems, San Jose,
CA).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To facilitate studies of allele-specific human MHC
class I function in vivo, a series of HLA class I transgenic (HLA class
I Tg) mice that express the HLA-B27, HLA-B7, or HLA-A2 alleles as
either fully human native (HLAnat) molecules
or as human (
1
2)/mouse (
3, transmembrane,
cytoplasmic domains) hybrid (HLAhyb) molecules
were established on the C57BL/6 (B6; H2b)
background and described previously (16). Individual
representative lines for each Tg were selected for further studies
based on expression of the human molecules at close to physiological
levels that were similar to each other and to endogenous H2 class I
(16, 23). Tg B27nat and
A2nat were coexpressed with
h
2m
(B27nat/h
2m,
A2nat/h
2m), while
B7nat was expressed in the presence
(B7nat/h
2m) or absence
(B7nat) of human
2m
(15, 16, 23). Compared with the Tg
HLAnat molecules, the
B27hyb, B7hyb, and
A2hyb molecules associated with
m
2m and were efficiently expressed at the
surface of Tg cells in the absence of human
2m
(15, 16).
As H2-Kb and H2-Db were
both expressed in these original Tg mice on the
H2b B6 background, the proportion of the
peripheral T cell repertoire that was specific for Tg HLA vs endogenous
H2 class I was unknown. Furthermore, given some apparently inconsistent
results from different groups using various HLA Tg lines
(11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16), it seemed possible that competition at some
level with endogenous H2 class I may influence recognition of Tg HLA by
developing or mature CD8+ T lymphocytes. To be
able to investigate Tg HLA function in the absence of endogenous H2
class I, each Tg HLA line was backcrossed onto a DKO background
deficient for both H2-Kb and
H2-Db expression (17, 24). Flow
cytometric analyses of lymphoid cells from spleen (Fig. 1
) and lymph node (LN) (not shown) showed
that there was about a 2- to 3-fold increase in the level of
expression at the cell surface of each
HLAhyballele
(HLA-B7hyb, HLA-B27hyb, and
HLA-A2hyb) on the DKO vs WT (C57BL/6) background
(Fig. 1
). This increase may be due to elimination of competition with
H2 class I on the DKO background for association with
m
2m. In contrast, the expression level of each
of the Tg HLAnat/h
2m
molecules
(HLA-B7nat/h
2m,
HLA-B27nat/h
2m,
HLA-A2nat/h
2m) on these
two backgrounds was similar (not shown), presumably because the
HLAnat molecules preferentially associate with
h
2m and therefore are unaffected by the
availability of m
2m.
|
2m (Fig. 2
2m (not shown) and
HLA-A2nat/h
2m/DKO (Fig. 2
|
3, transmembrane,
and/or cytoplasmic domains of the hybrid vs native molecules in the
mouse background (14, 16). Interestingly, unlike
HLA-A2nat and HLA-B7nat
mice whose peripheral CD8+ T cell level was only
slightly above that in non-Tg DKO mice,
HLA-B27nat lymphoid tissues contained a
significantly higher proportion of CD8+ T cells
(p < 0.002). Allelic differences in the level
of CD8+ T cells also exist for the
HLAhyb molecules because expression of
HLA-A2hyb consistently gave rise to the highest
level of peripheral CD8+ T cells, followed by
HLA-B7hyb and HLA-B27hyb.
Quantitation of Tg HLA expression at the cell surface for each native
and hybrid molecule indicates that these allelic differences in
peripheral CD8+ T cell levels are not simply due
to differences in expression level of Tg HLA in the various Tg lines
(16, 23) (Fig. 1
Although the level of peripheral CD8+ T cells for
several of the Tg HLA lines was significantly greater than in the DKO
strain, it was still less than that for WT non-Tg
H2b mice (Fig. 2
). This lower level could be due
to quantitative effects of MHC expression level because there are four
expressed H2b gene loci in C57BL/6 mice, while
there is only one HLA gene locus in the HLA Tg DKO mice. To investigate
this possibility, we first examined the influence of the number of
expressed H2 class I genes on the size of the peripheral
CD8+ T cell population. For this purpose, mice
having only one H2-D
(K-/-/D+/-) or one H2-K
(K+/-/D-/-) gene were
generated by appropriate breedings (see Materials and
Methods). LN and spleen cells from each strain were analyzed by
flow cytometry to determine the level of CD8 and CD4 cells (Fig. 3
A). Compared with the WT
(K+/+D+/+), mice with a
single expressed H2-D or H2-K gene have a reduced level of
CD8+ T cells in the periphery (Fig. 3
Ai, WT, 24.2%; iii,
K-/-/D+/-, 8.6%;
iv,
K+/-/D-/-, 16.3%).
Thus, mice with a greater number of H2b class I
genes (e.g., four H2b genes in WT C57BL/6) have a
higher percentage of peripheral CD8+ T cells than
mice having a lower number of H2b genes. This
relationship is particularly evident when the results are displayed
graphically, as in Fig. 3
B. Interestingly, these studies
also reveal a locus-specific effect, as mice with only one H2-K
gene have a higher percentage of CD8+ cells than
H2-D counterparts (Fig. 3
).
|
Peripheral CD8+ T cells in Tg
HLA/H2-K-/-D-/- DKO mice display a similar
spectrum of TCR V
chain usage compared with non-Tg WT
Although expression of all Tg HLAhyb, and to
a lesser degree HLAnat, molecules leads to the
appearance of CD8+ T cells in the periphery, it
was unknown whether the naive TCR repertoire was similar or deviated
compared with the non-Tg H2b WT mouse. To examine
this, three-color flow cytometry was used to identify
CD3+CD8+ LN T cells for
subsequent analysis of the relative abundance of cells expressing
various TCR V
-chains (V
2, 6, 7, 8.1, 8.2, 8.3, 11, 12, and 14)
that are useful for distinguishing subfamilies of a portion of the T
cell repertoire (22). Fig. 4
shows the percentage of
CD3+CD8+ T cells that
express each indicated TCR V
for the various mice (i,
non-Tg WT (K+/+/D+/+);
ii, DKO
(K-/-/D-/-);
iii, B27hyb/DKO; iv,
B27nat/h
2m/DKO;
v, B7hyb/DKO; and vi,
A2hyb/DKO). Although there was some variation for
mice of a given non-Tg or HLA Tg genotype, the trend is readily
apparent. Each TCR V
subpopulation that is present at a higher level
in CD8+ cells of H2b WT
mice is also more abundant in CD8+ cells of each
of the HLAhyb and HLAnat Tg
strains examined. Similarly, those that are less abundant in WT mice
are also less abundant in each HLA Tg strain. Thus, not only does
expression of Tg HLA class I lead to a significant level of peripheral
CD8+ T cells in the absence of
H2-Kb and H2-Db expression,
these cells display an overall similar distribution of TCR V
-chains,
signifying a grossly similar TCR repertoire compared with the
non-Tg WT.
|
To determine whether the CD8+ T cells in the
periphery of the Tg HLA/H2-K, H2-D DKO mice are functionally restricted
by the human class I allele, the CD8+ CTL
response to influenza A infection was examined. In
B27+ humans, a major portion of the
B27-restricted flu-specific CTL response is directed at flu NP peptide
383391 (NP383391), with most of these T cells expressing the TCR
V
7 chain (20, 25). In H2b mice,
the anti-flu CTL response is directed mainly at NP366374, with
the TCR V
8.3 chain dominating this response (19, 26).
To test for these responses, splenic T cells from influenza A-infected
Tg HLA-B27hyb/DKO, Tg
HLA-B27nat/h
2m/DKO,
non-Tg/DKO, and non-Tg/WT mice were restimulated in vitro for two 6- to
7-day periods, as described in Materials and Methods, with
NP383391 (B27-restricted), NP366374
(H2-Db-restricted), control peptide, or no
peptide. Fig. 5
shows the results of flow
cytometric analyses performed at 0, 6, and 13 days of stimulation to
monitor changes in the CD8+ and
CD4+ populations. Incubation of splenic cells
from infected Tg B27hyb/DKO mice with NP383391
resulted in a strong induction of CD8+ cells from
6.7% on day 0 to 66.0% on day 6 to 97.5% on day 13 (Fig. 5
c,
ii and iii). This expansion was similar to that for
cells from infected non-Tg WT H2b mice stimulated
with H2-Db-restricted NP366374 (Fig. 5
a,
iiii; 12.5% on day 0 to 63.3% on day 6 to 96.7% on day 13).
There was no significant expansion of CD8+ cells
for infected DKO mice incubated with either NP366374 (Fig. 5
b,
iiii) or NP383391 (not shown), or for cells from infected
non-Tg WT H2b mice incubated with NP383391 (not
shown). There was also a significant CD8+ cell
expansion for the Tg
B27nat/h
2m/DKO culture
incubated with NP383391 peptide, although the increase was slightly
less than that for B27hyb/DKO (i.e., 4.6% on day
0 to 30.8% on day 6 to 80.0% on day 13; Fig. 5
d, iiii).
Thus, peripheral CD8+ T cells in
HLA-B27hyb/DKO and
HLA-B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice
are responsive to the same flu peptide recognized in the context of
HLA-B27 in humans.
|
2m/DKO (Fig. 6
2m/DKO Con A-stimulated
target cells (lines E and G in Fig. 6
2m/DKO or
B27nat/h
2m/DKO targets pulsed with
NP366374 (lines F and H in Fig. 6
2m/DKO
responders and comparable with that forresponders from
infected non-Tg H2b mice stimulated and tested on
H2b cells pulsed with NP366374 (Fig. 6
2m/DKO mice are
B27 restricted and respond to the same viral peptide seen in natural
influenza A infection of B27+ humans as
immunodominant.
|
repertoire of infected Tg
HLA-B27/DKO mice following in vitro stimulation with NP383391
peptide, 13-day cultures established as above were stained for
expression of CD4 and CD8 in conjunction with the same panel of TCR
V
-chains tested previously. Consistent with a previous report
(26), CD8+ T cells expressing TCR
V
8.3 dominated the CD8+ CTL response of
flu-infected non-Tg H2b WT mice following 13 days
of stimulation with NP366374 (Fig. 6
8.1+ cells at day 13 (Fig. 6
2m/DKO cells
(Figs. 5
-chains
tested, including V
8.1, was found to consistently dominate this
population (not shown). This lack of expansion of
V
8.1+ cells for the
B27nat h
2m/DKO group is
not because this population is absent from the naive repertoire of
these mice (Fig. 4
2m/DKO mice are
able to respond to a specific flu peptide known to be restricted by B27
in humans, different TCR V
chains are used. Identification of candidate flu epitopes restricted by HLA-B7
The above findings showing that the same peptide is recognized in response to flu infection of B27/DKO Tg mice as in B27+ humans suggest that this model should be useful for identifying new HLA class I-restricted viral T cell epitopes in vivo. Although flu peptides recognized in association with HLA-B27 and HLA-A2 are known (20, 27), flu peptides restricted by HLA-B7 have not been reported. To identify such B7-restricted flu peptides, splenocytes from flu-infected HLA-B7hyb/DKO mice were stimulated as above with individual candidate peptides (see below) and then analyzed by flow cytometry to test for an increased relative abundance of CD8+ cells and by cytotoxicity for B7-restricted killing. Candidate peptides were first identified by using the SYFPEITHI program from Rammensee et al. (Ref. 28 ; www.syfpeithi.de/) to screen influenza A X31 protein sequences for the HLA-B7 binding motif (29, 30). Based on this analysis, two high ranking peptides were identified (NP418426 and hemagglutinin (HA)339347) and synthesized for the studies in this work. HA339374 ranked highest of all HA peptides and was assigned a score of 22 of 30 by the program (28). NP418426 ranked second of all X31 NP peptides, receiving a program score of 19 of 30. When this type of analysis was applied to HLA-A2, the program successfuly identifies a flu peptide known to be functional as a CTL epitope (M5866) at the top of the list of candidates. Interestingly, this was not the case for B27, as the program identified and ranked a number of candidate peptides in multiple flu X31 proteins above NP383391, the only functional B27 CTL epitope known to date.
In the case of the HLA-B7 peptides, while NP418426 from influenza A
PR8 strain has been shown to bind HLA-B7 in vitro, HA339347 PR8 did
not perform as well in this assay (31). Although
NP418426 is conserved between both X31 and PR8 strains (LPFDRTTVM),
HA339347 is not (VPEKQTRGL in X31; IPSIQSRGL in PR8)
(32). Fig. 7
A
shows that incubation of splenocytes from flu X31-infected Tg
HLA-B7hyb/DKO mice with NP418426 leads to
strong induction of a CD8+ population by day 14
(96.6% CD8+ on day 14 (ii) vs 11.6%
on day 0 (i). The cytotoxicity assays performed with day 14
cultures (Fig. 7
Bi) showed that this population is able to
lyse B7hyb/DKO targets pulsed with NP418426,
but not pulsed with an irrelevant peptide (NP383391) or no peptide.
These responders also did not kill non-Tg DKO cells or
B27hyb/DKO cells pulsed with or without
NP418426 (not shown). Analysis of the TCR V
repertoire of the
14-day NP418426-stimulated Tg HLA-B7hyb/DKO
CD8+ culture showed that cells expressing the
V
6 chain were a dominant population (Fig. 7
Bii). In
contrast to the results of Fig. 7
for peptide NP418426, similar
analyses conducted for peptide candidate HA339347 failed to detect
any significant induction of CD8+ CTLs from
flu-infected Tg HLA-B7hyb/DKO mice (results not
shown).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2m to overcome inefficient association of
fully native HLA class I H chains with m
2m
(15), replacement of the human class I
3 domain with
mouse
3 to overcome inefficient interactions with
m
2m and mouse CD8 (14, 16),
breeding of the HLA Tg onto apparently more favorable mouse H2
backgrounds (33), introduction of a Tg construct encoding
linked
2m and HLA onto a
m
2m-deficient background to reduce surface
expression of H2 class I (34), and coexpression of a human
CD8 Tg along with Tg HLA to facilitate species-specific CD8
interactions (35). Although these efforts have been
instructive, questions still remain about what form this type of model
should take to optimize efficient and specific function of the human
MHC molecules.
We previously described a panel of HLA class I Tg mice on the WT
H2b background that express the HLA-B27, HLA-B7,
or HLA-A2 alleles as fully human (HLAnat)
molecules or as hybrid human/mouse (HLAhyb)
molecules (16). To eliminate the influence of
H2b class I expression on Tg HLA function, each
strain was bred with a
H2-Kb/H2-Db-doubly
deficient (DKO) strain (17) to generate mice in which the
only classical class I expression is the human molecule. A similar
approach has been taken by another group for a HLA-A2 Tg analogous to
the A2hyb Tg studied in this work
(24). Relative to the greatly reduced number of
CD8+ T cells in lymphoid tissues of the parental
DKO strain, expression of each of the three Tg
HLAhyb alleles, as well as Tg
HLA-B27nat/h
2m, led to
development of a significant peripheral CD8+ T
cell population (Fig. 2
). As the only classical class I expression in
these mice is the human allele, these cells are assumed to be
restricted and tolerant to the Tg HLA molecule.
Compared with previous studies of HLA Tg mice on a WT background
(11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16), the absence of endogenous H2 class I-specific
CD8+ T cells in the mice described in this work
allows a more direct comparison of the ability of each Tg HLA class I
allele to mediate thymic development and peripheral function. Our
finding on the DKO background of a higher level of peripheral
CD8+ T cells for all three
HLAhyb class I Tg strains compared with the
corresponding HLAnat strains implicates the mouse
class I
3, transmembrane, and/or cytoplasmic domains in the
HLAhyb molecules as mediating this effect.
Although intermolecular species-specific interactions involving any of
these three domains may be improved, it is likely that a major effect
is on interactions of mouse CD8 on developing and mature T cells with
the Tg HLAhyb molecule. These increased
interactions would be expected to facilitate improved positive
selection in the thymus, with the result being a greater number of
CD8+ T cells exiting the thymus and populating
the periphery. Such improved interactions may also facilitate the
response of peripheral CTLs to Ag, as suggested by previous results
from ourselves and others (14, 16).
For HLA-B7nat/h
2m/DKO
and A2nat/h
2m/DKO Tg
mice, the level of peripheral CD8+ T cells is
only slightly above the background level in the parental DKO mice.
These results suggest that positive selection on Tg HLA-A2 and HLA-B7
class I molecules in this model is strongly dependent on interactions
with CD8 during T cell development. A possible explanation for the
cells that do appear in the periphery is that the
B7nat and A2nat molecules
may be able to weakly interact with mouse CD8, thus possibly allowing
positive selection of T cells with TCRs with increased affinity able to
compensate for the reduced contribution from CD8 (14).
Alternatively, if these two HLAnat molecules are
unable to functionally interact with mouse CD8 at all during selection,
then this peripheral population may express even higher affinity TCRs
and be completely CD8 independent. Despite the low level of these cells
in the A2nat/h
2m/and
B7nat/h
2m/DKO mice, it is interesting that
the level of CD8 expression appears to be in the normal range (Fig. 2
).
It will be important to distinguish between the above
possibilities.
In contrast to the Tg
A2nat/h
2m/DKO or
B7nat/h
2m/DKO mice, there was a
significant peripheral CD8+ population in the Tg
HLA-B27nat h
2m/DKO mice.
This was not due simply to differing levels of Tg HLA expression, as
the level of B7nat and
B27nat at the cell surface was similar to each
other and only slightly greater than A2nat
(16, 23 , and not shown). Therefore, some aspect of the
structure of the HLA-B27nat molecule permits
development of CD8+ T cells in the DKO background
more efficiently than the other two HLAnat
alleles. Presumably, this is due to one of the following reasons:
either 1) B27nat interacts suboptimally with
mouse CD8 to the same extent as A2nat and
B7nat, but due to some feature of the
1/
2
cleft structure, is inherently capable of interacting with and
selecting a broader array of TCRs; or 2) B27nat
interacts more effectively with mouse CD8 than the other two
HLAnat alleles, and as a result, selects a
greater number of developing T cells to the CD8+
lineage. Whichever is correct, the CD8+ T cells
in the Tg B27nat/h
2m/DKO
mice do not appear to be an unusual subpopulation, as the TCR V
repertoire was broad and grossly similar to both WT
H2b and Tg HLAhyb/DKO mice
(Fig. 4
). In addition, at least a portion of this population is
restricted to B27 and responsive to infection and stimulation with the
same flu NP peptide (383391) restricted by this allele in Tg
HLA-B27hyb mice and B27+
humans (Figs. 5
d and 6Aiii).
Although the level of CD8+ T cells for all three
HLAhyb alleles was greater than for the
corresponding HLAnat alleles, it appeared
initially that this was still less than for WT
H2b mice. However, more detailed analyses showed
that the level of CD8+ T cells for each Tg
HLAhyb class I molecule was in the same range as
for non-Tg mice carrying a single expressed H2-Kb
or H2-Db gene (Fig. 3
). Interestingly, these
studies also revealed that expression of a single
H2-Kb gene led to a higher level of
CD8+ T cells than for a single
H2-Db gene. Based on these differences in
efficiency in positive selection for H2 class I molecules, the
differences in the CD8+ T cell levels for the
three HLAhyb strains may result from similar
locus- or allele-specific effects. Taken together, these analyses lead
us to conclude that development of the CD8+
lineage in Tg HLAhyb/DKO mice occurs efficiently
and that there are no major limitations compared with H2 class
I-dependent CD8+ T cell development.
An important application for the HLA Tg model is in identifying and
characterizing T cell epitopes recognized in the context of particular
HLA alleles for specific disease- or infection-associated Ags. To
become useful in this way, it is essential that the Tg HLA alleles act
as restriction elements in the mice with an Ag-presentation specificity
similar to that in allele-matched humans. To date, only few studies
have been conducted to address this issue, and these have been mainly
for HLA-A2 (14, 24, 36). Our results demonstrate that
CD8+ T cells in both the Tg
HLA-B27hyb/DKO and
HLA-B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice
are functional and B27-restricted for recognition of influenza A Ags
following infection. Furthermore, both B27hyb and
B27nat mediate strong CTL responses against flu
NP383391 known to be immunodominant in the B27-restricted response
against flu in B27+ humans (Figs. 5
and 6
)
(20). Although we have not shown this peptide to be
immunodominant in the B27 Tg mice studied in this work, it is clear
that this is a major response against flu infection in these animals.
Additional experiments are in progress to address this point
directly.
Although the in vitro stimulated
B27hyb-restricted anti-NP383391
CD8+ T cell response occurred with a similar
kinetics and reached a similar level compared with the
H2-Db-restricted anti-NP366374 response of
non-Tg WT mice (Fig. 5
, c and a), the
B27nat/NP383391-specific response appeared to
reach a lower maximal level of CD8+ cells (i.e.,
80% for B27nat/DKO vs 97.5% for
B27hyb/DKO and 96.7% for
H2b WT by day 13; see Fig. 5
). We are uncertain
whether this reflects a lower Ag-specific frequency in the naive
repertoire or reduced proliferative expansion of Ag-specific cells in
the B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice, but are
examining this issue. If the latter, then it will suggest a role for
optimal CD8/class I interactions in mediating this effect.
Another feature of the Ag-specific response in Tg
B27hyb/DKO mice that was similar to the
H2-Db-restricted response was that the induced
CD8+ populations were dominated by expression of
a single TCR V
chain (V
8.1 for
B27hyb/NP383391 and V
8.3 for
Db/NP366374; Fig. 6
). This finding further
demonstrates that HLA-restricted Ag recognition in these mice occurs in
an overall similar fashion to that restricted by endogenous H2 class I.
However, despite recognition of the same flu peptide (NP383391) in
the context of B27, the response in
B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice is
not mediated by cells expressing TCR V
8.1 or any other dominant
V
-chain tested. This was not because V
8.1+
cells were absent from the naive repertoire of
B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice (Fig. 4
), and
therefore is most likely due to one of two main reasons. First, it is
possible that this induced population is dominated by cells expressing
a specific TCR V
chain different from any tested for with available
anti-TCR Abs. Alternatively, it may be that no single TCR V
chain comes to dominate this Ag-stimulated population. If the naive
repertoire in B27nat/h
2m/DKO mice is in fact
less CD8 dependent, then this latter possibility would suggest that one
effect of optimal CD8 interactions is to facilitate efficient
stimulation and expansion of specific CD8+ T cell
subpopulations following exposure to Ag, with the outcome being oligo-
or monoclonal dominance recognizable by a limited distribution of TCR
V
chain expression.
Despite the above, CD8+ cells from
B27nat mice stimulated with NP383391 lyse both
peptide-pulsed B27nat and
B27hyb target cells (Fig. 6
Aiii).
Similarly, CD8+ cells from
B27hyb mice stimulated with this peptide kill
both NP383391-pulsed B27hyb and
B27nat targets. Together, these findings indicate
that although B27hyb appears to function more
effectively than B27nat in mediating development
of the CD8+ T cell sublineage in Tg mice, both
molecules are able to stimulate strong responses for autologous T cells
and can be recognized at the effector stage by induced T cells both
from self as well as the alternate strain. It will be of interest to
determine the extent to which the naive T cell repertoires of these two
strains differ.
An important aspect of the above studies is that by removing the
background of H2-Kb- and
H2-Db-restricted CD8+ T
cells, any changes detected in the size or repertoire of the
CD8+ T cell population following Ag exposure in
vivo or in vitro must be due to recognition events in the context of Tg
HLA. This was not the case in prior versions of this model in which the
Tg HLA was expressed on the WT H2 class I+
background. This complicated previous attempts to use this model to
identify new HLA class I-restricted T cell epitopes for a given Ag or
to characterize the responding CD8+ population
because one had to contend with and control for a background of H2
class I-restricted Ag-specific responses. Our ability to identify a new
HLA-B7-restricted CTL epitope for influenza A by making use of the Tg
HLA-B7hyb/DKO mice (Fig. 7
) demonstrates that
this model and the approach taken provide an effective strategy and
solution to this problem. Although we do not know that the identified
peptide (NP418426) is immunodominant in this anti-flu
A/B7hyb-restricted CTL response, the high level
of killing observed implies that this is a major epitope recognized in
the context of this allele. We are attempting to confirm this finding
by testing for recognition of this peptide by CTLs from
HLA-B7+ humans previously exposed to
influenza A.
Although the Tg B27hyb-restricted anti-flu
NP383391 response was dominated by CD8+ T cells
that expressed the TCR V
8.1 chain, the Tg
HLA-B7hyb/flu NP418426 response was found to be
dominated by V
6+ CD8+ T
cells (Fig. 7
). In humans, the HLA-B27-restricted response against flu
NP383391 has been reported to be dominated by human CTLs that express
V
7 with V
12.1, 14.1, or 22 (20, 25), while the
HLA-A2-restricted response against flu matrix M5866 is dominated by
V
17+ CTLs (27, 37). To further
characterize the degree to which HLA-dependent recognition is conserved
in HLA allele-matched Tg HLA/DKO mice and humans, it will be important
to examine the specific TCR V
/V
-chain combinations that are
preferentially used in both species.
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. John W. Chamberlain, Research Institute, Programs in Infection, Immunity, Injury and Repair, and Genetics, The Hospital For Sick Children, 555 University Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, M5G 1X8. E-mail address: jchamber{at}sickkids.on.ca ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: Tg, transgenic;
2m,
2-microglobulin; DKO, double knockout; h
2m, human
2m; HA, hemagglutinin; hyb, hybrid; KO, knockout; LN, lymph node; m
2m, murine
2m; nat, native; NP, nucleoprotein; WT, wild type. ![]()
Received for publication April 29, 2002. Accepted for publication September 6, 2002.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
3 domain into HLA-B27. Nature 348:642.[Medline]
2-microglobulin) chain genes in transgenic mice. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85:7690.
8.3 T cells in the H2-Db-restricted response to an influenza A virus nucleoprotein epitope. J. Immunol. 151:2658.[Abstract]
2 microglobulin HLA-A2.1 monochain transgenic H2-Db
2m double knockout mice. J. Exp. Med. 185:2043.
and
chains of the human T-cell antigen receptor recognizing HLA-A2 and influenza A matrix peptide. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88:8987.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. Felio, H. Nguyen, C. C. Dascher, H.-J. Choi, S. Li, M. I. Zimmer, A. Colmone, D. B. Moody, M. B. Brenner, and C.-R. Wang CD1-restricted adaptive immune responses to Mycobacteria in human group 1 CD1 transgenic mice J. Exp. Med., October 26, 2009; 206(11): 2497 - 2509. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. C. M. Boon, G. de Mutsert, R. A. M. Fouchier, A. D. M. E. Osterhaus, and G. F. Rimmelzwaan The Hypervariable Immunodominant NP418-426 Epitope from the Influenza A Virus Nucleoprotein Is Recognized by Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes with High Functional Avidity. J. Virol., June 1, 2006; 80(12): 6024 - 6032. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. Wang, H. Chen, X. Jiang, M. Zhang, T. Wan, N. Li, X. Zhou, Y. Wu, F. Yang, Y. Yu, et al. Identification of an HLA-A*0201-restricted CD8+ T-cell epitope SSp-1 of SARS-CoV spike protein Blood, July 1, 2004; 104(1): 200 - 206. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Sesma, I. Alvarez, M. Marcilla, A. Paradela, and J. A. L. de Castro Species-specific Differences in Proteasomal Processing and Tapasin-mediated Loading Influence Peptide Presentation by HLA-B27 in Murine Cells J. Biol. Chem., November 21, 2003; 278(47): 46461 - 46472. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |