|
|
||||||||



*
The Hospital For Sick Children, Research Institute, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada;
Departments of Pediatrics and Immunology, Sunnybrook and Womens College Health Sciences Center, and
University of Western Ontario, Department of Immunology, John P. Robarts Research Institute, London, Ontario, Canada
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
cells and brain. Its function is
unknown, but knockout of its Caenorhabditis elegans
homologue, ric-19, compromised neurotransmission. We
disrupted the murine gene, ica-1, in 129-strain mice.
These animals aged normally, but speed-congenic ICA69null
nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice developed mid-life lethality, reminiscent
of NOD-specific, late lethal seizures in glutamic acid decarboxylase
65-deficient mice. In contrast to wild-type and heterozygous animals,
ICA69null NOD congenics fail to generate, even after
immunization, cross-reactive T cells that recognize the dominant Tep69
epitope in ICA69, and its environmental mimicry Ag, the ABBOS epitope
in BSA. This antigenic mimicry is thus driven by the endogenous self
Ag, and not initiated by the environmental mimic. Insulitis,
spontaneous, and adoptively transferred diabetes develop normally in
ICA69null NOD congenics. Like glutamic acid decarboxylase
65, ICA69 is not an obligate autoantigen in diabetes. Unexpectedly,
ICA69null NOD mice were resistant to cyclophosphamide
(CY)-accelerated diabetes. Transplantation experiments with hemopoietic
and islet tissue linked CY resistance to ICA69 deficiency in islets.
CY-accelerated diabetes involves not only ablation of lymphoid cells,
but ICA69-dependent drug toxicity in
cells that boosts
autoreactivity in the regenerating lymphoid
system. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
cells. Causes that underlie the development of
diabetic autoimmunity remain obscure. Products of some
20+ predisposing genes interact with critical
environmental accelerators and decelerators to generate the autoimmune
phenotype (1).
Clinical insulin deficiency and its attendant metabolic abnormalities
are the end result of a drawn-out prediabetes phase, in which
autoreactive T cell pools accumulate in the islet. Prediabetes proceeds
in a stepwise fashion (2, 3), from benign periinsulitis to
islet invasion and progressively rising rates of
cell death, as
signaled by the generation of autoantibodies (4, 5).
Because of the difficulty of tissue access in humans, much of the
current view of autoimmune diabetes derives from the excellent rodent
models for the disease, BB rats and nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice
(6, 7). However, many years of prediabetes are a reality
of the human disease, in which B and T cell autoimmunity arise many
years before and can persist for decades after onset of overt disease
(see Refs. 8, 9, 10).
A similar set of autoantigens is targeted by self-reactive T cells in
human and murine diabetes, including insulin/proinsulin, glutamic acid
decarboxylase 65 (GAD65), GAD67, ICA69 (islet cell Ag 69 kDa), and
IA-2/phogrin (1, 7). Of these, only insulin is (nearly)
cell specific, while others follow generally neuroendocrine gene
expression profiles. In NOD mice, immunotherapies with any one of these
autoantigens can halt, and in some circumstances accelerate development
of overt diabetes, depending on the choice of epitopes and the timing
of interventions early or later in prediabetes
(11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17).
While there may be a hierarchy among autoimmune targets, in particular early on (18), established prediabetes involves multiple T cell pools that home to the islet, targeting more self epitopes with increasing effectiveness (19, 20, 21). The progression of prediabetes is complex and passes through checkpoints that halt progression for some periods of time (2). A single dose of cyclophosphamide (CY), an alkylating cancer pro-drug (22), overcomes these checkpoints and allows rapid diabetes development in a process that is dominated by the local activation of myeloid APCs and their cytokine products (3). In this commonly used diabetes model, CY was suggested to remove regulatory hemopoietic cells (23, 24), in a host whose lymphoid cell lineages are relatively resistant to the drug and able to mount a dramatic recovery of lymphoid mass quickly after drug exposure (25). Data presented in this work suggest that the drugs role in diabetes development is more complex and critically depends on direct islet cell toxicity in a process that appears to require the function of ICA69.
To explore the role of self Ag in prediabetes and its progression to
overt disease, we disrupted the genomic locus of the autoantigen, ICA69
(14, 26, 27), and backcrossed the defect onto NOD, using a
speed-congenic strategy (28). The conserved ICA69 gene,
ica-1, maps to human chromosome 7p22 and a synthenic
location on mouse chromosome 6A1, 2, neither location mapping near
known diabetes risk loci (27, 29). The molecule has a
neuroendocrine expression pattern with peak levels in brain and
cell lines (30). Its function is unknown, but we found
that Caenorhabditis elegans deficient for the well-conserved
ICA69 homologue, ric-19, develops a neurotransmission defect
(31).
The protein includes a single, dominant T cell epitope, Tep69 (major T cell epitope in ICA69), targeted by autoreactive T cells in both human and NOD mouse T1D (26). There is well-established antigenic mimicry between this epitope and the ABBOS epitope in the commonly encountered, dietary Ag, BSA (14). BecauseABBOS is a highly dominant BSA epitope in NOD mice, it appeared possible that ICA69 autoimmunity might be triggered through mimicry with BSA/ABBOS (10, 14, 32), encountered through exposure to dietary cow milk protein, a risk factor for diabetes development (33, 34, 35, 36). Observations in ICA69null NOD congenics now indicate that the routinely generated Tep69/ABBOS mimicry T cell pools require and are driven by the endogenous self Ag, which also dictates the apparent dominance for ABBOS in BSA immune responses of wild-type NOD mice.
The 129SvJ mice with ICA69 deficiency had no obvious phenotype and aged normally. However, speed-congenic ICA69null NOD mice develop sudden lethality beginning in early middle age, reminiscent of GAD65 deficiency that produces mid-life lethal seizures only on the NOD background (37). ICA69null NOD female congenics develop diabetes at essentially wild-type NOD incidence. Like GAD65 (38), ICA69 emerges as a facultative, but not obligate element in diabetes progression. Surprisingly, and challenging current views, ICA69null mice were highly resistant to CY-accelerated diabetes due to a previously unrecognized drug effect on islets, which appears to require the function of ICA69.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
NOD/Lt (H-2g7) mice were bred in our rodent facility according to approved facility guidelines and protocols. Experiments were performed in our conventional unit, which presently has an 8386% diabetes incidence in 36-wk-old female mice.
Adoptive transfer
Spleen cells from three to five recently diabetic NOD females were pooled, and 107 cells were transferred i.v. to 6- to 8-wk-old, irradiated NOD male (650 rad) or NOD.scid (200 rad) recipients. In all experiments, glucosuria (TesTape, Lilly, Toronto) was used for daily diabetes screens. Diabetes was confirmed through blood glucose measurements on 2 consecutive days (13.8 mM/L, SureStep; Life Technologies, Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada).
CY-accelerated diabetes
To induce accelerated diabetes development, 8- to 10-wk-old wild-type, heterozygous or homozygous ICA69 knockout females received one i.p. injection of 250 mg/kg CY (Sigma, St. Louis, MO). In some experiments, 14-wk-old animals were used, or a second injection was given 3 wk later.
Pancreatic islet transplantation
Islets were isolated from pancreata of 4- to 5-wk-old wild-type NODs by standard digestion and manual picking procedures (39). The grafts were placed under the kidney capsule of anesthetized, 8-wk-old ICA69null NOD females. Sixteen days later, the recipients were treated with 250 mg/kg CY, and diabetes development was monitored for at least 4 wk. Sham-operated and nontransplanted wild-type NOD and ICA69null mice provided controls.
Generation of ICA69null mice
The ICA69 locus occupies approximately 100 kb on mouse
chromosome 6 (27, 29). A murine 129SvJ genomic library
(gift of T. Mak, Toronto, Canada) was screened with a full-length
ICA69-
cDNA probe (26). A 2.7-kb clone containing exon
2 was excised with BglII and subcloned into
pBluescript II-SK upstream of a herpes simplex thymidine
kinase expression cassette. The aminoglycoside phosphotransferase
(neo) gene was excised from the pPNT vector and
ligated into a StuI site at position 107 of exon 2, thus
disrupting the coding region of the Tep69 epitope in ICA69
(27).
The tetracycline transactivator (tTA) coding region (40, 41) (gift of H. Bujard, Heidelberg, Germany) was moved
in-frame into an AgeI restriction site at position 38
of exon 2 in ICA69 (see below, Fig. 1
). This was thought to allow
future experiments, such as possible rescue of knockout phenotypes
through doxycycline-regulatable expression of a tet07-ICA69
transgene (42). The function of the targeting vector,
including the tTA knock-in, was confirmed in NIT-1
cells
(43) with one allele replaced by the vector. Transient
transfection of these cells with low copy numbers of a
tet07-luciferase expression plasmid (40) (gift of
H. Bujard) resulted in excellent luciferase expression that was over
98% suppressed in the presence of 1 µM doxycycline (Hammond-McKibben
et al., manuscript in preparation).
|
Subcellular fractionation of mouse brain
Mouse brain tissue was fractionated as described (31). Briefly, brains were homogenized in ice-cold, supplemented HBSS buffer. Nuclei and cell debris were removed, and supernatant (S1) was centrifuged at 13,000 x g for 13 min. Supernatant was collected and spun at 100,000 x g for 30 min to yield S3 (the cytosol) and P3 (the microsomal pellet). The synaptosome fraction was washed with HBSS buffer and centrifuged at 13,000 x g for 13 min. The pellet was lysed, buffered (10 mM HBSS, pH 7.4), and centrifuged at 45,000 x g for 20 min. The pellet (LP1) was resuspended in HKA buffer (10 mM HEPES-KOH, pH 7.4, 140 mM KoAC, 1 mM MgCl2, 0.1 mM EGTA, 0.3 mM PMSF), while the crude synaptic vesicles were pelleted by further centrifugation of the supernatant at 150,000 x g for 1 h, then resuspended in HKA buffer. All procedures were performed on ice.
Western blots
Rabbit anti-ICA69 (gift from M. Pietropaolo, Pittsburgh, PA) was used at a final dilution of 1/7500 (30). Each subcellular fraction (40 µg) was separated on SDS polyacrylamide gels and transferred to nitrocellulose. Peroxidase-conjugated goat anti-rabbit Ab (The Jackson Laboratory, Bangor, ME; 1/15,000) was used to detect bound primary Ab. Rabbit anti-VAMP-2 provided a marker of synaptic vesicles (gift from W. Trimble, The Hospital For Sick Children).
Histology
Tissues for histological sections were fixed in 10% neutral buffered Formalin and stained with H&E. The degree of insulitis was scored blindly by two observers, using the following scale: 0, normal islet; 1, periinsulitis; 2, invasive infiltration of 25%50% of islet surface area; 3, invasive infiltration of greater than 50% of islet surface area or a small retracted islet. Immunohistochemistry for insulin was performed on Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections using guinea pig anti-insulin Ab and rabbit HRP-conjugated secondary Ab (Dako Diagnostics, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada). Reactions were visualized using diaminobenzidine peroxidase substrate, and sections were counterstained with hematoxylin.
Proliferative T cell responses
In vitro T cell proliferation was measured as described recently
for immunized and nonimmunized NOD mice (16).
Immunizations employed s.c. injection of a given Ag, 100 µg
emulsified in CFA. Regional lymph nodes were removed 910 days after
immunization, and 4 x 105 cells/well were
cultured in serum-free AIM V medium (Life Technologies) to measure
recall responses to 0.01100 µM Ag. After 60 h, cultures were
pulsed overnight with 1 µCi [3H]thymidine and
subjected to scintillation counting. Spontaneous T cell proliferation
in spleen cells from unimmunized naive or adoptively transferred mice
was similarly measured, except for the addition of 10 U human rIL-2
(45). Synthetic peptides were highly purified and
confirmed by mass spectroscopy: Tep69, AFIKATGKKEDE, ABBOS,
FKADEKKFWGKYLYE. Grade V BSA and OVA were purchased from Sigma.
Purified, mouse rICA69-
was prepared as described (26);
rGAD65 was purchased (Diamyd Diagnostics, Stockholm,
Sweden).
Statistics
Numeric values were compared by Mann-Whitney or Welsh tests; significance was set at 5%; and all tests were two tailed. Tables were used to compare diabetes incidence in different groups of animals (Fishers exact test); odds ratios were calculated with Woolfs approximation.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The targeting construct (Fig. 1
A) introduces a neomycin
resistance cassette to disrupt the Tep69 epitope in exon 2 of ICA69,
and inserts the tTA coding region in-frame after the leading 9 ICA69 aa
residues, followed by poly(A) and stop sites. Homologous recombination
of this vector in its genomic target locale introduces an additional
XbaI site that produces a 3.2-kb XbaI restriction
fragment, while the corresponding wild-type fragment is 3.6 kb in
length (Fig. 1
A). Homologous recombination of the targeting
construct was confirmed in genomic DNA of progeny from several chimeric
founders, using a 5'-end probe and XbaI restriction (Fig. 1
B) and a neo probe and HindIII restriction (not
shown). Several litters of this generation of 129SvJ x NOD
offspring were monitored for up to 26 mo, including 17
ICA69null animals derived from brother-sister
matings. No spontaneous deaths or obvious abnormalities were
observed.
ICA69 is expressed at low to very low levels in a variety of tissues,
with its major expression locale in the brain, and highest levels found
in
cell lines (30). Almost certainly reflecting
posttranslational modifications, Western blots resolve ICA69 as a
doublet band of approximately 69 kDa, despite its calculated mass of 55
kDa (30, 46). There was no detectable ICA69 in Western
blots of brain and salivary gland extracts from backcross 7 (not shown)
or backcross 11 mice (Fig. 1
C, left panel), but
there were occasional ghost bands in brain subcellular fractions
(right panel). These bands were not consistent, and could be
detected only with one rabbit Ab raised against a C-terminal peptide
(46) (Fig. 1
C), but not with another rabbit Ab
raised against a large, truncated ICA69 fragment (not shown). We were
unable to obtain sufficient material for mass spectrography and
sequencing studies of these ghost bands. As described below, the
distinct phenotypes of these mice, results of extensive RT-PCR,
Southern blot, and genomic PCR studies of the disrupted gene locus, and
in particular the silencing of the natural ICA69 promoter (see below)
make a hypomorphic phenotype with remnant gene expression of gene
fragments from this locus unlikely.
Heterozygous (ICA69+/-) progeny from backcross 2
were mated with the L7 transgenic mouse that carries a tet07-luciferase
transgene (40). Offspring carrying the L7 transgene as
well as one ICA69null/tTA+
allele demonstrated high luciferase activity in brain (note the
logarithmic scale), low levels in stomach and testes, and borderline
levels in pancreas, in which
cells contribute 0.1% of total
pancreas tissue (Fig. 1
D). The latter observation is
consistent with the fact that ICA69 expression in exocrine pancreas is
at best minuscule (47). In mice receiving doxycycline ad
libitum in drinking water (0.1 mg/ml), luciferase activity was
suppressed to background levels (not shown). These observations
provided an excellent readout of ICA69 promoter activity.
However, similar experiments with mice from backcross 3 showed a >10-fold reduction in luciferase activity, and no activity at all could be detected in offspring from L7 matings with knockout animals from backcross 5 and 7. While Southern blots and genomic PCR gave expected results, transcripts of tTA could be demonstrated by RT-PCR of brain RNA in backcross 2-derived, but not in animals from these latter experiments, indicating loss of ICA69 promoter activity. Transcriptional silencing is not rare among neuronal genes (48), and has been described for GAD65 (49).
Autoantigen skews the specificity of autoreactive T cells
Autoreactive T cells in wild-type NOD mice (like patients with
T1D) recognize the dominant ICA69 epitope Tep69 (10, 26).
These T cells show antigenic mimicry with the ABBOS epitope in BSA, and
T cell hybridoma as well as alanine replacement studies
indicated that these mimicry T cells represent the bulk of
ICA69-specific NOD repertoires (16).
ICA69null NOD congenics allowed us to determine
the role of endogenous self Ag in the development of these
self-reactive T cell pools. Immunization with BSA had divergent
consequences in heterozygous and homozygous ICA69 knockout mice (Fig. 2
A). Both lines of mice
generated good and similar proliferative recall responses after a
single BSA immunization in complete adjuvant. However, only
heterozygous (+/-) animals generated the coordinate ABBOS and Tep69
mimicry responses typical for wild-type NODs (14, 16). In
homozygous ICA69null NOD congenics, ABBOS was no
longer a prominent epitope, despite the fact that it binds to NOD
I-Ag7 with high affinity (16). Only
some low affinity ABBOS responses were observed at a very high peptide
dose. No mimicry responses to Tep69 were seen in BSA-immunized
ICA69null animals. Thus, the endogenous self Ag
is required for the recruitment of precursor T cell pools that
recognize both Tep69 and ABBOS, and the presence of these T cell pools
is responsible for the strong immunodominance (14) of the
ABBOS epitope in BSA.
|
ICA69null NOD mice develop diabetes
Autoimmunity to ICA69 is a routine element of prediabetes and of
diabetes in wild-type NOD mice and humans (10, 14, 16).
Spontaneously diabetic knockout females were observed beginning by wk
20,
4 wk later than in wild-type or heterozygous animals (Fig. 3
A). This difference was not
quite significant (p = 0.058). The consecutive
disease development in knockout mice paralleled that in heterozygous
and wild-type NOD females (p > 0.3). There was a
tendency for slightly less or slower development of invasive insulitis
(Fig. 3
B), but this again failed to reach significance.
Thus, ICA69 appears to be a facultative, but not obligate element in
NOD diabetes development.
|
Adoptive transfer of diabetes
Accelerated models of diabetes such as adoptive transfer of
diabetic spleen cells circumvent natural checkpoints in prediabetes
progression (50). We asked whether the slight delay in
spontaneous diabetes development would be amplified or eliminated
following adoptive transfer of wild-type diabetic spleen cells into
irradiated knockout recipients. The latter was observed: transferred
animals developed disease at the same rate and incidence as
heterozygous littermates or wild-type controls (Fig. 3
D),
unhindered by the fact that the knockout mice lost ICA69-specific T
cells during disease development (see above, Fig. 2
B), and
lacked this target autoantigen.
Acceleration of diabetes with CY
In striking contrast to wild-type and heterozygous animals,
injection of CY (250 mg/kg) failed to induce accelerated diabetes in
ICA69null mice (Fig. 4
). Heterozygous littermates began to
develop overt disease by 1011 days post-CY, reaching a high disease
incidence by 3 wk (p < 0.0001, odds ratio 27.4 vs
knockout (Fig. 4
A), p > 0.3 vs wild-type mice,
not shown). ICA69 protein is not expressed in hemopoietic cells
(30) (see Fig. 1
D for splenocytes).
Consistently, there was no detectable effect of ICA69 deficiency in
this tissue, with homozygous, heterozygous NOD as well as 129 mice
showing the same acute drug-induced fall in spleen weight and
cellularity. CY metabolism with generation of, and response to the
major toxic intermediates (22) was thus similar in these
animals (p > 0.3, data not shown).
|
cell death. This incompetence was not due to
a general delay of prediabetes, since ICA69null
NOD mice 14 wk of age, and thus close to the time of overt spontaneous
diabetes development, were still protected from CY-induced disease
(Fig. 4
CY-accelerated diabetes has been associated with the selective
elimination of regulatory T cells and/or with the induction of a
massive wave of T cell regeneration that would coexpand diabetogenic
pools (23, 24, 51). We more closely examined the CY
responses of knockout hemopoietic cells. NOD.scid mice were
pretreated with CY 2 days before adoptive transfer of spleen cells from
12-wk-old nondiabetic wild-type mice; diabetes did not develop within
the observation period (Fig. 4
E, CY
Tx).
This confirmed the critical role of acute, drug-induced toxicity in
lymphoid cells.
However, when NOD.scid mice were reconstituted with
107 spleen cells from 8-wk-old homozygous
knockout mice, from heterozygous littermates, or wild-type NOD
controls, 1 mo before CY treatment (Fig. 4
E,
Tx
CY), these transplanted NOD.scid
animals developed CY-accelerated diabetes at the same rates and
incidence (p > 0.5). This observation demonstrated
that hemopoietic cells were not involved in the CY resistance of
knockout mice. Collectively, these two observations delineated two drug
targets prerequisite for diabetes development, one in hemopoietic and
one in nonhemopoietic tissue.
Since the islet is one target tissue of CY toxicity (52),
we asked whether the nonhemopoietic tissue required for disease
acceleration by CY might be the islet itself. We therefore provided
ICA69null mice with a source of wild-type islets
in small, subrenal islet grafts. Sixteen days later, the engrafted mice
were injected with CY as before (Fig. 5
A). The presence of wild-type
islets reversed the resistance to CY-accelerated diabetes in
ICA69null mice, and allowed diabetes development
in engrafted knockout animals (p > 0.3,
knockout-operated vs sham-operated wild-type NOD; p =
0.016, islet-engrafted vs sham-operated or nontransplanted
ICA69null mice). These observations confirm and
extend previous, indirect evidence for a duality of CY effects that
accelerate diabetes development (53).
|
cells (Fig. 5
cells (Fig. 5
cell
destruction.
These observations suggest that the resistance of
ICA69null mice to CY-accelerated diabetes
reflects a relative resistance to CY toxicity in
cells, which
require ICA69 for an apoptotic drug response (52).
Consistently, CY resistance can be bypassed if a source of
drug-sensitive islets is present somewhere in the body, suggesting a
systemic effect that boosts T cell pools with pathogenic potential
during the rapid recovery and expansion of lymphoid cells after CY
treatment.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
cells (52). We
have only begun mechanistic studies of how ICA69 might be involved in
this process.
The function of ICA69 remains unclear. The neurotransmission defect
generated by knockout of its neuron-specific C. elegans
homologue, ric-19 (31), requires further study,
as does the mid-life lethality of ICA69null NOD
mice. Current experiments suggest that possible abnormalities in
neurotransmission of ICA69null mice will be
subtle. However, we recently observed that NOD mice undergoing the
spontaneous NOD autoimmune encephalitis develop seizures with
considerable incidence (45), and Kash et al.
(37) provided evidence for a rather strong modifier gene
that predisposes NOD to seizures. Neurological similarities in GAD65
and ICA69 knockout mice may place ICA69 into the GABAergic
pathway of neurotransmission, consistent with its pre- and postsynaptic
localization (e.g., see Fig. 1
C).
We were fortunate to identify a crossover event early in the backcrossing process, which replaced about two-thirds of the 129-derived chromosome 6 with NOD DNA. Nevertheless, a substantial stretch of 129-derived chromosome 6 remains. We had planned rescue experiments with a tet07-controlled ICA69 transgene, driven by the knock-in tTA transactivator. The silencing of the ICA69 promoter and consequent lack of tTA expression precluded this experiment, meant to rule out specific contributions of 129 genes to the knockout phenotype. However, comparing the CY toxicity in 129 and NOD mice failed to delineate differences in acute drug toxicity in spleen as well as testes, a tissue targeted by the drug (54). Although theoretically possible, it is therefore unlikely that the observed CY resistance of knockout mice reflects an unidentified 129 gene near the ica-1 locus. Nevertheless, whether CY resistance maps to ICA69 (likely) or a 129 gene (unlikely) is immaterial for the major conclusion of these experiments, i.e., that CY-accelerated diabetes involves direct drug toxicity to the islet.
Several and similar T cell autoreactivities appear to participate in murine and human diabetogenesis (7, 10). Immunotherapy of NOD prediabetes with single autoantigens such as GAD65, GAD67, insulin, ICA69, IA-2, and others can each dramatically modify the disease course, provided that they are applied early in life, generally before the islet is breached (7). The exact mechanisms of effective immunotherapy are still elusive (for a discussion, see Ref. 16), but these consistent observations assign important potential, but not necessarily obligate roles to each target Ag. Removal of one player through gene targeting, e.g., ICA69 or GAD65 (37, 38), is the most accurate way to measure the role of an individual autoantigen, and the data available support a model of many facultative, but not obligate autoantigens in the progression to diabetes.
An unresolved question in autoimmunity is whether autoantigens drive autoimmunity, or whether they are more passive elements, perhaps victims of mimicry with exogenous proteins (55, 56). At least in the case of ICA69, the former appears to be correct. There is well-established mimicry between the major T cell epitopes in ICA69 (Tep69) and the commonly encountered BSA (ABBOS) (10, 14, 16, 26, 32). T cell responses of wild-type NOD mice to BSA are extremely biased toward ABBOS reactivity. The same cells recognize Tep69 in NOD mice (16), and the same appears to apply to diabetes-prone humans (10). We expected that this polarization solely reflected properties of MHC alleles, with a very high ABBOS-binding affinity for diabetes risk-associated human and NOD MHC class II (16). This turned out to be incorrect: ICA69null mice have entirely different BSA responses, in which ABBOS is at best a minor epitope, recognized by low affinity T cells that do not show mimicry with Tep69. Demonstrating antigenic mimicry, therefore, does not per se imply a primary mechanism for loss of tolerance. However, wild-type NOD mice reared on a diet free of BSA also fail to generate mimicry T cell pools (57). The functional outcome of mimicry is thus affected by both endogenous and exogenous Ag.
The resistance of ICA69null mice to CY-induced
diabetes was unexpected and has since been reproduced in backcross 11
mice with ICA69 deficiency. This resistance did not reflect a
generalized resistance to
cell death or autoimmune attack, since
ICA69null mice develop diabetes spontaneously
with wild-type incidence, and since alloxan treatment eliminates
cells just as in wild-type mice (unpublished observation). These
observations, and the normal, accelerated diabetes development in
NOD.scid mice reconstituted with spleen cells from either
heterozygous or homozygous knockout donors suggested: 1) that
CY-induced diabetes had to require effects in a second target tissue,
and 2) that the resistance to diabetes acceleration in
ICA69null animals could not be attributed solely
to the hemopoietic cell compartment. Islet transplant experiments
strongly suggest that the second drug target is islet
cells
themselves.
If this is substantially correct, then the islet toxicity of CY is
dependent on the presence of ICA69. We propose that direct islet
toxicity provides a boost to pathogenic T cell pools, providing islet
Ags during the rapid, post-CY regeneration. Injury to
cells has
also been implicated as a requirement for virus-accelerated diabetes
(58, 59). The earliest, CY-induced change previously
reported is the rapid accumulation of monokines IL-12, TNF-
, and
IL-18 in the pancreas
2 days after drug treatment (3),
1 day after the peak of drug-induced
cell death (52).
While it may ultimately not be trivial to separate cause and effect,
the most obvious scenario would be that CY-induced
cell death
attracts and activates professional APCs, which then engender
pathogenic competence in preexisting T cell pools with islet
autoreactivity. Our data demonstrate that without this event, T cells
still home to the islet, but are incompetent to mediate
cell
death.
Overall, this process would then be analogous to the induction of NOD
autoimmune thyroiditis following induction of thyroid cell death by
high dose iodide treatment (60). It would differ from the
effects of drugs such as streptozotocin, which kill
cells and cause
diabetes in any strain, while CY-accelerated diabetes requires the NOD
host with established autoimmune T cell repertoires. Consistently, the
provision of wild-type islet grafts under the kidney capsule was
sufficient to reverse CY resistance in knockout mice, with rapid
elimination of endogenous
cells in the pancreas and consequent
diabetes. This outcome confirms that islets drive pathogenic, diabetic
autoimmunity, as has been suggested for natural disease development
(61).
The exact function of ICA69 remains unclear, but knockout mice will
provide excellent tools for further study. Collectively, ICA69 knockout
mice generated new insights into the role of a typical autoantigen
targeted in autoimmune diabetes. The observations make it unlikely that
the exogenous ICA69 mimicry Ag, BSA, has a primary triggering role in
the loss of tolerance to ICA69. Instead, the highly biased T cell
repertoire of NOD mice immunized with BSA now emerges as a function of
autoreactive mimicry T cells driven by the endogenous self Ag. The
combination of several autoantigen knockout mice should eventually
allow a more complete dissection of diabetic autoimmunity. The long,
drawn-out character of prediabetes remains a puzzle. The CY resistance
in ICA69null mice sheds new light on this
process, with a critical role for drug-induced
cell death, probably
coupled to autoimmunity through the activation of local APCs. The heavy
islet infiltration in CY-treated ICA69null mice
vividly illustrates that the endowment of pathogenicity in infiltrating
T cells is a critical progression event, which normally does not occur
until very late in prediabetes. These observations favor the view that
prediabetes progression is not a linear process of gradual
cell
destruction (62), but rather a process that culminates
late with massive
cell destruction near disease onset
(63). If correct and applicable to the human disease,
immunotherapy of prediabetes may be effective even late in prediabetes
if it avoids precipitation of diabetes in an immune system precariously
balanced between pathogenicity and nonpathogenicity.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 S.W., I.A., and R.G. contributed equally. ![]()
3 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. H.-Michael Dosch, IIIR Program, The Hospital For Sick Children, 555 University Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, M5G 1X8. E-mail address: hmdosch{at}sickkids.ca ![]()
4 Abbreviations used in this paper: T1D, type 1 diabetes; CY, cyclophosphamide; GAD, glutamic acid decarboxylase; ICA69, islet cell Ag 69 kDa; NOD, nonobese diabetic; Tep69, major NOD mouse T cell epitope in ICA69; tet07, artificial promoter tetoperon (x7) + TATA box; tTA, tetracycline transactivator. ![]()
Received for publication August 16, 2001. Accepted for publication October 25, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-cell line established from a transgenic NOD/Lt mouse. Diabetes 40:842.[Abstract]
-cell apoptosis. J. Pathol. 191:86.[Medline]
-cell damage and immune infiltration. J. Autoimmun. 16:211.[Medline]
cells drive T cell-immune responses in the nonobese diabetic mouse model. J. Exp. Med. 181:1635.
-cell destruction in pancreatic islets of NOD mice with spontaneous and cyclophosphamide-accelerated diabetes. Diabetologia 41:1381.[Medline]
-Cell destruction may be a late consequence of the autoimmune process in nonobese diabetic mice. Diabetes 45:1063.[Abstract]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Cao, J. Xu, C. Shen, C. Kam, R. L. Huganir, and J. Xia PICK1 ICA69 Heteromeric BAR Domain Complex Regulates Synaptic Targeting and Surface Expression of AMPA Receptors J. Neurosci., November 21, 2007; 27(47): 12945 - 12956. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Yagil, R. Barkalifa, M. Sapojnikov, A. Wechsler, D. Ben-Dor, S. Weksler-Zangen, N. Kaiser, I. Raz, and Y. Yagil Metabolic and genomic dissection of diabetes in the Cohen rat Physiol Genomics, April 24, 2007; 29(2): 181 - 192. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Vital, E. Larrieta, and M. Hiriart Sexual dimorphism in insulin sensitivity and susceptibility to develop diabetes in rats. J. Endocrinol., August 1, 2006; 190(2): 425 - 432. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Kubosaki, S. Gross, J. Miura, K. Saeki, M. Zhu, S. Nakamura, W. Hendriks, and A. L. Notkins Targeted Disruption of the IA-2{beta} Gene Causes Glucose Intolerance and Impairs Insulin Secretion but Does Not Prevent the Development of Diabetes in NOD Mice Diabetes, July 1, 2004; 53(7): 1684 - 1691. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Spitzenberger, S. Pietropaolo, P. Verkade, B. Habermann, S. Lacas-Gervais, H. Mziaut, M. Pietropaolo, and M. Solimena Islet Cell Autoantigen of 69 kDa Is an Arfaptin-related Protein Associated with the Golgi Complex of Insulinoma INS-1 Cells J. Biol. Chem., July 3, 2003; 278(28): 26166 - 26173. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||