|
|
||||||||




*
Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Genetics,
Center for Comparative Medicine, and Departments of
Microbiology and
Cell Biology, University of Virginia Health Sciences Center, Charlottesville, VA 22908
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We have previously reported on the use of cross-linked mAb complexes (heteropolymers (HP)) to promote the binding of bacteria and viruses to primate E in vitro (11, 12). The HP consists of a mAb specific for the target pathogen cross-linked with a mAb specific for primate E CR1 (13); therefore, substrates are bound to E without a requirement for complement activation. Studies in monkey models indicate that HP can be used to bind prototype pathogens to E, thereby confining the pathogens within the vasculature until they are removed from the circulation (8, 14, 15, 16). The E are not destroyed and thus the HP-mediated clearance reaction appears to follow the natural primate E-mediated immune complex clearance mechanism (7, 16).
The goal of the present work was to evaluate the potential of the HP-E system to target bacteria in the bloodstream. We used an acute bacterial infection model based upon challenge with large doses of bacteria infused i.v. continuously over several hours (17, 18, 19, 20). Under these conditions live bacteria can be demonstrated in the circulation and a variety of effector mechanisms can be analyzed, although the role of immune adherence in this model has not, to our knowledge, been previously evaluated. We studied handling of Pseudomonas aeruginosa (strain PAO1) in the bloodstream of complement-depleted and complement-replete animals, with and without HP treatment. We found that although a variable fraction of bacteria infused into the circulation of complement-replete monkeys binds to E in the absence of HP, infusion of HP leads to >99% binding of bacteria to E. In addition, experiments conducted with paired monkeys challenged with or without HP demonstrate that several parameters associated with resistance to the bacterial challenge are enhanced by HP treatment.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Anti-CR1 mAbs 7G9 and 9H3, specific for human and monkey E CR1, have been described previously (21, 22). mAbs specific for P. aeruginosa PAO1 (23) and Escherichia coli (strain O type 2, cytotoxic necrotizing factor type 1 isolated from the clinical microbiology laboratory, University of Virginia Hospital) were generated from hybridomas after immunization of A/J mice with heat-killed bacteria. Cell culture supernatants (CCS) produced by hybridomas were screened for specific mAbs by measuring binding to microtiter plates coated with bacteria. Selection for high-avidity mAbs (15) employed flow cytometry, RIA, and magnetic separation. Bacteria were incubated with CCS, washed, and probed with FITC-labeled anti-mouse IgG or 125I-labeled anti-mouse IgG. Washed samples were analyzed by flow cytometry or monitored for bound 125I, respectively. Alternatively, BioMag anti-mouse IgG-coated iron particles (Polysciences, Warrington, PA) were added to bacteria incubated in CCS. Free bacteria were separated from particle-bound bacteria in a Polysciences Magnetic Separation unit and counted in a Coulter MultiSizer II (Coulter, Luton, U.K.). mAbs which bound the bacteria in these assays were selected as high-avidity mAbs. The anti-PAO1 mAb 2H4, isotype IgG2a, recognizes the LPS of PAO1 on Western blots (data not shown) and the anti-E. coli mAb 3E1 is isotype IgG1.
Preparation of HP
mAbs were purified from ascites fluid or CCS by affinity chromatography (24) and dialyzed exhaustively against borate saline (0.15 M NaCl and 0.03 M boric acid, pH 7.8). The cross-linking procedure was based on the method of Segal and Bast (25). The anti-CR1 mAb was reacted with N-succinimidyl S-acetylthioacetate (SATA, Pierce, Rockford, IL) at a ratio of 14 µg SATA/mg mAb for 2 h at room temperature (RT). The mixture was dialyzed with one change against HP buffer (50 mM sodium phosphate and 5 mM EDTA, pH 7.5) and then the SATA-mAb was deprotected to produce SH-mAb by treatment with 0.5 M hydroxylamine, 50 mM sodium phosphate, and 25 mM EDTA (pH 7.5), under argon, for 2 h at RT. During this time, the anti-pathogen mAb was reacted with sulfosuccinimidyl 4-(N-maleimidomethyl)cyclohexane-1-carboxylate (sSMCC; Pierce) at a ratio of 14 µg sSMCC/mg mAb for 2 h at RT. At the end of these incubations, both the SH-mAb and the sSMCC-mAb were subjected separately to gel filtration in HP buffer on gravity flow 10DG columns (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA). Gel filtration of the SH-mAb was performed under a stream of argon, and the SH-mAb-containing fractions were stored under argon for a minimum period of time until coupling. The SH-mAb and sSMCC-mAb were combined at a 1020% (by weight) excess of SH-mAb, mixed gently by inversion, flushed with argon, and reacted for 16 h at RT with gentle shaking. The coupling reaction was stopped by incubation with 1 mg iodoacetamide/10 mg mAb for 1 h at RT and then stored at 4°C. The coupling reaction mixture was subjected to gel filtration in borate saline buffer on Superose 6 (Pharmacia, Peapack, NJ) which was calibrated with monomeric IgG mAb and human IgM. Cross-linked product eluting between, but fully excluding the positions of these two markers, was pooled and used for experiments. Pooled product was stored at 4°C .
Construction of GFP-PA01 and GFP-E. coli
Plasmid pSMC2 coding for GFP (26) and
-lactam
resistance was kindly provided by Dr. G. OToole (Dartmouth Medical
School, Hanover, NH). The plasmid was transferred to P.
aeruginosa PAO1 and the clinical isolate of E. coli by
electroporation using standard procedures (27, 28).
Cultures were maintained on standard agar supplemented with 350 µg/ml
carbenicillin and 100 µg/ml ampicillin, respectively.
Monkey antibacterial Abs
The titers were determined by incubating GFP-PAO1 with varying dilutions of monkey plasma for 15 min at 37°C. Opsonized bacteria were washed three times and probed with PE-labeled anti-monkey IgG or a PE-labeled mAb specific for human IgM which cross-reacts with monkey IgM. The IgG titers are reported as the reciprocal dilutions of plasma that caused 50% of the bacteria to register as FL2 positive by flow cytometric analysis. IgM titers (data not shown) gave similar trends.
In vitro binding of GFP-PAO1 and GFP-E. coli to primate E
Measurement of HP- and/or serum-mediated binding of bacteria to
E followed methods reported by Kuhn et al. (11). In brief,
10 µl (70 ng) of specific or irrelevant HP was added to 50 µl of a
50% E dispersion in either 1% BSA in PBS (BSA-PBS) or in a blood
group-matched serum. After 5 min at 37°C, 5 x
106 GFP-transformed bacteria were added, giving
an E:bacterium ratio of
50:1 (Fig. 1
A). Mixtures were
incubated for 560 min at 37°C, and an aliquot was diluted into iced
BSA-PBS. Samples were analyzed by flow cytometry (FACSCalibur; BD
Biosciences, Mountain View, CA ) by gating for FL1-positive events.
Percent of bacteria either bound to E or free was determined by
examination of the forward and side scattering profiles of FL1 events
for the two populations. In some assays, HP were added to mixtures of
whole blood and bacteria at much higher E:bacterium ratios (>500:1),
and after incubation and centrifugation (100 x g, 5
min), the number of bacteria free in the supernatant (SN) was
determined by flow cytometry and compared with matched samples in which
either an irrelevant HP or no HP was added (Fig. 1
B). Equal
volumes of the samples were examined in each case. We found no evidence
for serum-mediated killing of GFP-PAO1 for an incubation period of
1 h at 37°C based on CFU assays (data not shown).
|
All animal experiments were supervised by a qualified
veterinarian in accordance with approved protocols of the University of
Virginia Animal Care and Use Committee and the Institutional Biosafety
Committee. Cynomolgus and rhesus monkeys weighed between 2.3 and 8.5
kg. RIA (21, 22) conducted with anti-CR1 mAbs
demonstrated 10003000 CR1 epitopes per E, with the exception of one
monkey (see Fig. 2
C). Some monkeys were pretreated i.v. with
cobra venom factor (CVF, 70 U/kg; Quidel, San Diego, CA) 24 h
before GFP-PAO1 infusion to consume complement (29).
Hemolytic complement activity (CH50) determinations revealed little to
no residual complement activity 24 h later. Before the bacterial
infusion, the monkey was anesthetized (ketamine, 10 mg/kg i.m.;
atropine, 0.04 mg/kg s.c.), intubated, and maintained under anesthesia
with isoflurane and 100% oxygen. Blood pressure was monitored through
a catheterized femoral artery (MicroMed, Louisville, KY).
|
An overnight agar culture of GFP-PAO1 was suspended in PBS, washed
three times, suspended in sterile saline (at
1 x
109 CFU/ml), and infused into the cephalic vein
over a period of 14 h (see
Figs. 24![]()
![]()
) at infusion rates
corresponding to
109 CFU/kg per h. Blood
samples were drawn through an arterial catheter, and HP preparations or
mAbs were infused as a bolus, 35 ml over 60 s, through the
opposite cephalic vein. At the end of the experiment all animals were
humanely euthanized under anesthesia. Samples of liver, lungs, and
spleen were fixed in 10% Formalin and submitted, blinded, for
examination by a pathologist. In addition, in selected experiments,
samples of organs were homogenized as 20% dispersions in
sterile-filtered 0.1% Triton X-100 in PBS, and diluted aliquots of
these dispersions were analyzed for CFU.
|
|
Blood samples were anticoagulated with EDTA, held on ice, and
processed within 15 min. Plasma SNs were taken after centrifugation
(100 x g, 5 min). The pellet was washed once at
200 x g and twice at 1800 x g, and
the buffy coat was removed during washing. A 10-µl aliquot of this
washed E pellet was lysed by dilution into 0.5 ml distilled water
followed by vigorous vortexing and 0.5 ml of 2x PBS was added. Both
the plasma and lysed E pellet were analyzed for GFP-PAO1 by flow
cytometry based on a series of in vitro calibrations. The method for
analysis of the E pellet is based on the controlled acquisition of an
identical volume (500 µl of 1 ml) of each sample at constant flow. An
FL1 threshold was set to record fluorescent events and then a
forward/side scattering window of sufficient size was selected to
include all bacteria in the cell lysate, including those that may have
been associated with E membrane fragments. In all experiments, the E
were in far excess over bacteria, and therefore the likelihood of
undercounting of bacteria due to their coincident binding to the same E
was minimized. The number of E in the lysed preparation was determined
by measurement of the absorbance at 541 nm of the residual uncounted
sample. A hematocrit (HCT) of 0.4% corresponds to an absorbance of
0.81 after lysis. Based on these determinations and the HCT, we
calculated the concentration of GFP-PAO1 bound to E (designated
Particles, Pellet in
Figs. 24![]()
![]()
) and free in the plasma (designated
Particles, SN). The plasma SNs were diluted into sterile-filtered
BSA-PBS and measured volumes of 0.5 ml were counted for fluorescent
bacteria using the same FL1 cutoff and a similar light scattering gate.
Replicate samples of whole blood, plasma SN, and pelleted E were
analyzed for CFU (designated CFU, Whole Blood; CFU, SN; CFU, Pellet,
respectively, in
Figs. 24![]()
![]()
). When levels were so low that bacteria
could not be detected by CFU assay in the most concentrated samples,
the value is reported as 100 CFU/ml in
Figs. 24![]()
![]()
.
Separate aliquots of blood were washed three times, the buffy coat was removed, and isolated E were reconstituted in BSA-PBS and probed with either a 125I-labeled anti-CR1 mAb (the same as used to prepare the HP) or with 125I-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG. Approximately 108 E were incubated with 0.21 µg 125I-labeled probe for 30 min at 37°C, and after three washes or centrifugation through oil (21, 22) the amount of 125I bound to the E was determined. The E concentration in these samples was determined as described above. Additional aliquots of blood were centrifuged at 3000 x g to generate plasma SNs which were stored at -80°C for cytokine determinations. A total of 1015% of the blood volumes of the animals was taken, and as much as 150 ml lactated Ringers solution was infused; the HCT of both the control and HP-treated monkeys showed comparable decreases.
Cytokine assays
An ELISA sandwich assay was used to measure cytokines (TNF-
,
IL-1
, IL-6) in the plasma of monkeys. Plates were coated with the
appropriate anti-cytokine capture mAb (BD PharMingen, San Diego,
CA), incubated with diluted plasma, and then with a biotinylated mAb
which did not compete with the capture mAb. Development was
accomplished by addition of neutralite-avidin coupled to HRP (Southern
Biotechnology, Birmingham, AL). Standards included recombinant rhesus
monkey TNF-
(BioSource International, Camarillo, CA), human IL-1
,
and human IL-6 (BD PharMingen).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
HP specific for binding of GFP-PAO1 to CR1 on primate E were
tested in vitro with human and monkey E in preparation for in vivo
studies in monkey models. Fig. 1
A shows the degree of
GFP-PAO1 binding to human E under a variety of conditions at a ratio of
50 E:bacterium. In BSA-PBS, <15% of GFP-PAO1 bacteria were bound
to E. Addition of specific HP promoted >90% binding of GFP-PAO1 to E
in BSA-PBS, and this binding is rapidly attained and stable over 60
min. In the presence of serum (no HP added), where complement
activation should lead to deposition of C3b on GFP-PAO1, E binding
reaches 68% in 20 min, but then binding decreases, presumably as C3b
decays to C3bi and C3dg. It is likely that E binding is mediated by
activation of the classical pathway of complement because binding is
lower during the first 20 min in serum containing Mg-EGTA, which only
allows for alternative pathway activation and binding is abrogated if
serum is treated with EDTA (Fig. 1
A). Preadsorption of serum
with bacteria on ice greatly reduces the ability of serum to facilitate
GFP-PAO1-E binding, suggesting that the sera contain complement-fixing
Abs specific for the bacteria. mAb 1B4, which blocks the C3b binding
site on human E (31, 32), inhibits binding as does heat
inactivation of serum (data not shown). We find that in whole serum it
is difficult to demonstrate HP-mediated binding (Fig. 1
A),
because the natural process of complement-mediated immune adherence
leads to a high level of binding in the absence of HP. However, as
noted above, serum-mediated E binding decreases by 60 min, and at this
time point the differences between the HP-treated and control samples
in serum achieve modest statistical significance, 61 ± 11% vs
39 ± 19%, p = 0.042, unpaired t test
(Fig. 1
). If the bacteria are suspended in BSA-PBS, in serum EDTA, or
in adsorbed sera, then HP-mediated binding is demonstrable (Fig. 1
A). However, the level of binding in BSA-PBS (>90%) was
always higher than in samples that contained plasma, even if complement
was inhibited.
We next tested for HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E in whole blood
anticoagulated with EDTA, and to more closely simulate physiological
conditions expected in the bloodstream, where E would be in great
excess over bacteria (33, 34), we used a ratio of 500
E:bacterium. The results (Fig. 1
B) demonstrate HP-mediated
binding of GFP-PAO1 to both monkey and human E; at least two log units
of bacteria were bound to E in these experiments. Finally, under
similar experimental conditions, both serum and specific HP mediate
substantial binding of another Gram-negative bacterium, E.
coli, to primate E. In BSA-PBS HP-mediated binding of GFP-E.
coli to human and monkey E averaged >90%; binding in serum (no
HP added) averaged 80 and 95% for human and monkey E, respectively,
based on 36 independent determinations.
Complement-depleted monkeys: in vivo HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E
In view of the natural, physiologic effects of complement in
facilitating binding of bacteria to E in the primate system, we tested
HP in a monkey model in which animals were pretreated with CVF to
consume complement. After CVF treatment, we waited 24 h to infuse
bacteria, with the expectation that by this time most complement
activation products would be cleared from the bloodstream and
complement receptors, especially E CR1, would be available for
ligation. As shown in Fig. 2
A,
continuous infusion of GFP-PAO1 led to negligible binding of bacteria
to E over the first hour of the experiment. When a bolus of HP was
infused, the number of GFP-PAO1 that circulated freely in the plasma
decreased by
100-fold, the number of bacteria bound to E increased
by a factor of
500, and the total number of bacteria in the
bloodstream increased. The initial effect of the HP was observed within
a few minutes of infusion and persisted for the remainder of the
experiment. After the bacterial infusion was stopped at 160 min, the
levels of both E-bound and free bacteria decreased. GFP-PAO1 bound to E
and free in plasma was analyzed by flow cytometry and by determination
of CFU (see Materials and Methods). In this experiment and
those described below (Figs. 3
and 4
; Table I
), there was generally good agreement
between the flow cytometry measurements (Particles) and the CFU assays
with respect to the number of bacteria determined as either bound to E
or as free in the plasma.
|
Finally, we found that pretreatment of a complement-depleted monkey
with HP before infusion of bacteria led to a very high level of
E-associated binding when bacteria were infused (Fig. 2
D).
Fluorescence microscopy confirmed that in the presence of HP the
bacteria were bound to E; however, the vast majority of the E had no
bound bacteria (data not shown), as expected for
107 bacteria/ml vs 4 x
109 E/ml.
Complement-replete monkeys: in vivo HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E
We next investigated whether HP could be used to unambiguously
bind GFP-PAO1 in complement-replete monkeys (Fig. 3
, A and
B) which represent a more physiologically relevant
condition. We found that continuous infusion of bacteria into either
cynomolgus or rhesus monkeys leads to a steady state in which a
variable fraction of the bacteria in the circulation is bound to E.
This observation, coupled with the absence of immune adherence in
CVF-treated animals, argues that complement activation must play a role
in binding GFP-PAO1 to E. When HP was infused, the substantial changes
in the distribution of E-bound and free bacteria observed in the
CVF-treated monkeys were again demonstrable (Fig. 3
, A
monkeys and B). The number of bacteria free in the
circulation decreased precipitously while the number bound to E
increased and the total number of bacteria in the bloodstream increased
2- to 4-fold. After HP infusion, >99.9% of bacteria in the
bloodstream were associated with E. These rapid changes in the
distribution of E-bound and free bacteria were not observed in a
control monkey in which HP was not infused (Fig. 3
C).
Both the in vitro and in vivo results (Figs. 1
and 3
) suggest that, in
the absence of HP, the binding of the bacteria to primate E is
facilitated to a great extent by anti-PAO1 Abs which promote
complement activation (3, 5, 16). The isotype of
anti-PAO1 mouse mAb 2H4 is Ig2a, which is capable of fixing
complement, and therefore it could be argued that the enhanced
HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E in the bloodstream of the monkeys
might be due to complement activation after mAb 2H4 binds to the
bacteria. To examine this possibility, mAb 2H4 was infused into the
circulation of a cynomolgus monkey during a continuous infusion of
GFP-PAO1 (Fig. 3
D). Before mAb treatment, E binding was
50%. Infusion of the mAb alone led to an increase in E-bound PAO1
and to a decrease in PAO1 in plasma, consistent with enhanced immune
adherence (Fig. 3
D and Table I
). However, when an equimolar
amount of HP was later infused, the number of bacteria free in the
plasma decreased substantially, the total number of bacteria in the
bloodstream increased 2-fold, and >99% of the bacteria in the
bloodstream were bound to E (Fig. 3
D and Table I
). This
result is in agreement with our previous findings which indicate that
at equivalent doses, mAbs alone are not as effective at promoting in
vivo binding of the target pathogens to primate E compared with the
same mAbs when they are formulated into the HP (15).
There was no evidence that HP infusion caused E destruction. Total bilirubin levels remained low (<0.3 mg/dl; data not shown) before and after HP infusion for all monkeys. The decreased HCT at the end of some experiments (see figure legends) are expected after withdrawal of 1015% of the total blood volume and infusion of fluids. We have previously demonstrated negligible loss of autologous E when 51Cr-labeled E were opsonized with 125I-labeled substrates (both proteins and E. coli) via HP and infused into a monkey (16).
Complement-replete monkeys: treatment with HP before infusion of bacteria
We next investigated how pretreatment of monkeys with HP would
affect the short-term responses of the animals to bacterial challenge.
The experiment was designed to examine several clinical parameters, in
particular lung damage, over a 24-h time period after GFP-PAO1 infusion
in the presence of HP but in the absence of antibiotics. A naive animal
was compared with a HP-treated monkey for three different infusion
doses of bacteria. The results indicate that for each GFP-PAO1 dose,
more bacteria were free in the plasma in the naive animals compared
with the HP-treated animals (Table II
and Fig. 4
). However, binding
of PAO1 to E was clearly evident in the untreated monkeys. The
levels of immune adherence roughly correlated with the titers of monkey
IgG Abs for PAO1. For example, monkey 4A (Fig. 4
) had only moderate
binding (32%, Table II
) and had a reciprocal titer of 5. More than
60% of the infused bacteria bound to the E of monkeys 3B (before HP
infusion), 5A, and 5C (Fig. 3
and Table II
), and these monkeys had
reciprocal titers of IgG for PAO1 of 40, 50, and >100, respectively.
|
|
Septic shock, one of the most severe consequences of
infection by Gram-negative bacteria, is mediated by LPS
(35, 36, 37). HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E reduced
substantially the level of free bacteria in the bloodstream, and it
seemed reasonable that redirection to a clearance pathway which
includes E binding might also affect the inflammatory potential of
bacterial LPS. The mechanisms by which LPS interacts with plasma
proteins and cell surface receptors to initiate inflammation are
complex. However, it is well established that one of the earliest
events in the inflammatory pathway is the appearance in the bloodstream
of inflammatory cytokines such as TNF-
, IL-1
, and IL-6 (19, 37, 38, 39). Several groups have used primate models to delineate
the kinetic profile of cytokine appearance in the circulation upon
challenge with E. coli (18, 19, 38, 39). We
find that the cytokine release pattern after challenge with GFP-PAO1 is
quite similar (Table IV
and Fig. 5
). TNF-
levels increase in the
circulation
1 h after the bacterial infusion is initiated, peak
after 90120 min, and decrease thereafter. The
increase in TNF-
is followed by an increase in the levels of IL-1
and IL-6. Our results indicate that use of HP dampens significantly the
increase in cytokines promoted by the bacterial infusion. This finding
strongly suggests that HP facilitate redirection and clearance of the
bacteria by a pathway that may substantially reduce inflammation (see
Discussion).
|
|
-adrenergic agonist
and does not block TNF-
production (40, 41, 42). Moreover,
in the animals not treated with phenylephrine the same trends are
evident. E-HP and E CR1 levels
Isolated and washed E were examined by RIA for bound HP and
relative CR1 levels. The results indicate that the HP rapidly binds to
E, because infusion of HP led to a substantial increase in the amount
of E-bound 125I-labeled anti-mouse IgG (Table V
). As the experiment progressed, the
amount of this probe which could bind to the E decreased, suggesting
that HP were being removed from the E, as we have previously
demonstrated in similar systems (14, 21). E probed with
anti-CR1 mAb 7G9 used to prepare the HP evidenced only small
decreases in mAb binding immediately after HP infusion, which would be
expected since the HP infused into the monkeys was sufficient to occupy
30% of total CR1, and some re-equilibration between free mAb and
E-bound HP might have occurred during the in vitro incubations. It is
noteworthy, however, that at later time points the amount of
anti-CR1 probe that bound to the E further decreased, and these
results follow the same patterns we have reported previously, in which
clearance of E-bound HP occurs concomitantly with loss of E CR1
(14, 16, 21).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our goal in this study was to determine the ability of the HP
system to target GFP-PAO1 in the bloodstream and bind the bacteria to E
during an i.v. challenge. HP were able to facilitate a very high level
of binding of GFP-PAO1 to human and monkey E in BSA-PBS (Fig. 1
A) and in anticoagulated whole blood at higher E:PAO1
ratios (Fig. 1
B). At lower E:PAO1 ratios (Fig. 1
A), in the presence of normal human serum (NHS), there was
a variable level of immune adherence, and HP-mediated binding to E
could not easily be distinguished from natural complement-mediated
binding. When complement activation was blocked, HP clearly promoted E
binding, but the presence of the plasma proteins may have reduced
HP-mediated binding in vitro. However, experiments in both
complement-depleted and complement-replete monkeys (
Figs. 24![]()
![]()
) clearly
demonstrate the very high level of efficiency by which HP promotes
binding of the bacteria to E in vivo.
When the anti-PAO1 mAb 2H4 was used alone, an increase in
complement-mediated immune adherence of bacteria to E was observed
(Fig. 3
D; 91 min, Table I
). However, subsequent use of the
HP containing this mAb at equal concentrations was far more effective
in promoting E binding (Fig. 3
D; 151 min, Table I
). It is
likely that this enhanced E binding mediated by the HP occurs because
the anti-CR1 mAb in the HP, which acts as a surrogate for C3b
(16), binds to CR1 with a higher avidity than C3b, and
therefore substantially increases ligation to CR1. We have found that a
concentration of 0.13 µg/ml anti-CR1 mAb 7G9 is sufficient to
achieve 50% saturation of E CR1, which corresponds to an association
constant in excess of 109
M-1 (43), whereas the avidity of
monomeric C3b for CR1 is >100-fold less (44, 45).
Therefore, successful immune adherence requires that multiple C3b
molecules deposit on a substrate and engage clusters of CR1 on the E to
assure multivalent binding (32). The present work,
including the findings in both the CVF-treated and complement-replete
monkeys, confirms earlier studies which indicate that the HP construct
functions quite effectively in promoting in vivo binding of substrates
to E CR1 (12, 14, 15).
We used mAb 2H4 alone in the in vivo immune adherence test (Fig. 3
D) rather than an irrelevant HP (i.e., 2H4 x IgG)
because the HP themselves do not activate complement when bound to a
variety of substrates. For example, of relevance to the present work,
flow cytometry experiments indicated that incubation of the 7G9 X 2H4
HP with E and NHS in solution, or incubation of preformed E-HP
complexes with NHS, gave negligible deposition of C3b on the E (data
not shown). These observations are in agreement with the work of Meri
and colleagues (46, 47). Synthesis of the HP makes use of
N-hydroxysuccinimide chemistry to derivatize lysines on the
mAbs (see Materials and Methods), and Jokiranta and Meri
(46) have reported that such chemical modification of mAbs
blocks classical complement activation by blocking binding of
C1q.
Immune adherence
Most animals appear to develop Abs against common bacteria
(5, 48, 49) and therefore it is not surprising that our in
vitro and in vivo experiments demonstrate binding of GFP-PAO1 and
E. coli to both monkey and human E under conditions allowing
for activation of complement (Figs. 1
, 3
, and 4
; Table I
). Although the
acute bacterial infusion model has been extensively tested and
described in a variety of nonhuman primates (17, 18, 19, 20, 38, 39), to our knowledge there have been no attempts to determine
whether bacteria were bound to E or free in the plasma. In addition,
although there is an extensive literature describing human clinical
conditions associated with bacteremias, these reports have not revealed
whether the bacteria in the bloodstream were free in the plasma or
bound to E (33, 34, 50). Our results demonstrate immune
adherence of bacteria to E in the nonhuman primate infusion model.
Because the degree of immune adherence of bacteria to E in the
circulation is undoubtedly related to several factors, including the
levels of complement and anti-bacterial Abs, it is possible that
quantitative measurements of immune adherence may provide important
prognostic information for patients with bacteremia. Similarly, it
would seem important to determine whether bacteria infused into the
bloodstream of mice or rabbits are bound to platelets which contain the
nonprimate immune adherence receptor (51, 52).
Effects of HP on bacterial clearance
Experiments which compared HP-treated and naive monkeys indicate
that HP-mediated binding of GFP-PAO1 to E tends to maintain the
bacteria in the circulation for longer periods (compare monkey 2B vs
monkey 2C, Fig. 2
, and monkey 4B vs monkey 4A, Fig. 4
). That is,
the rate of removal of GFP-PAO1 from the vasculature was faster in the
untreated monkeys, since both the steady-state levels of bacteria in
the circulation were lower and the bacteria left the bloodstream more
rapidly after the bacterial infusion was stopped. In contrast, after a
monkey was treated with HP, the new steady-state level of bacteria in
the circulation increased and, when the infusion ended, bacteria bound
to E were removed from the circulation at a slower rate. An important
question focuses on the fate and organ distribution of the bacteria
after they exit the bloodstream in the untreated vs the HP-treated
monkeys. The slower rate of clearance of GFP-PAO1 bound to E via HP may
reflect a different clearance mechanism due to a rate-determining step
which requires scission of CR1 (14, 16, 53) by proteases
associated with fixed tissue macrophages in the liver and spleen,
followed by uptake of the bacteria in these organs. Clearance through
this mechanism should decrease the rate at which otherwise free (not
E-bound) bacteria can invade other organs and tissues, including the
lungs, which are particularly susceptible to PAO1 (54, 55). The decreased pathology associated with the lungs in the
HP-treated monkeys (see above) is consistent with this hypothesis.
Therefore it is reasonable to anticipate that upon HP treatment a
larger fraction of the bacteria will be redirected to the liver and
spleen where the bacteria will be phagocytosed and destroyed. We
measured live bacteria associated with these organs (Table II
); if the
bacteria were indeed killed they would not register in the CFU assay.
There was no evidence for increased liver pathology as a result of HP
treatment, and in fact the levels of liver enzymes in the circulation
tended to be lower in HP-treated animals (Table II
). Finally,
comparison of monkey A and monkey B of Fig. 4
suggests that in the control monkey the bacteria that bound to E by
immune adherence are cleared faster than bacteria bound to E via HP in
the treated monkey. It is likely that, with respect to binding of PAO1
to E, more HP (compared with C3b) engage a greater number of CR1 with
higher avidity. It is therefore reasonable to expect that clearance of
HP-bound bacteria would be slower, presumably because more CR1
molecules would have to be cleaved to allow transfer of the HP-bacteria
complex to acceptor macrophages.
Effect of HP on cytokine release
Recognition of bacterial-associated structures such as LPS by
plasma proteins and cellular receptors such as CD14/Tlr4 constitutes an
important element in defense against bacterial invasion. High levels of
LPS which are processed via the CD14 pathway can, however, provoke an
exaggerated inflammatory response, generally signaled by an increase in
cytokines in the circulation, which is ultimately damaging to the host
(35, 36, 56, 57). In monkeys treated with HP, >99% of
bacteria in the bloodstream were bound to E, and the reduced cytokine
levels in these animals suggests that processing of bacteria in these
animals may have been different from processing of bacteria in the
untreated animals. It is likely that bacteria bound to E via HP are
more efficiently phagocytosed and destroyed by fixed tissue macrophages
via a pathway that presumably utilizes Fc receptors on the macrophages
(53, 58, 59, 60). Under these conditions, the bacteria and LPS
in particular could therefore be redirected away from pathways which
engage the CD14 receptor and might otherwise provoke an inflammatory
response mediated by cytokines such as TNF-
. We hope to examine this
possibility directly in future in vitro studies. We recognize that the
number of monkeys used in the present study is limited and that
statistically significant comparisons cannot be made based on such a
small sample size.
In summary, we have examined how treatment with HP affects handling of GFP-PAO1 in the bloodstream of monkeys. A fraction of infused bacteria bind to E via immune adherence, a complement-mediated reaction. However, infusion of a HP specific for GFP-PAO1 and E CR1 leads to a much higher level of binding of the bacteria to E (>99%), and to a substantially reduced level of bacteria free in the plasma. Based on the results presented, we propose that E-bound bacteria have less opportunity to colonize susceptible organs and in addition are cleared from the circulation by a mechanism which bypasses to a great extent the CD14/LPS inflammatory pathway. Several clinical parameters, including the degree of lung damage, cytokine levels, and liver enzymes in the circulation, indicate that the HP, besides facilitating robust and rapid binding of bacteria to E, can provide a degree of protection against the bacterial challenge.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 M.A.L. and A.N. contributed equally to this work. ![]()
3 Current address: Immuno-Designed Molecules, 72 rue de Charonne, 75011 Paris, France. ![]()
4 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Ronald P. Taylor, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Genetics, Box 800733, University of Virginia Health Science Center, Charlottesville, VA 22908-0733. E-mail address: rpt{at}virginia.edu ![]()
5 Abbreviations used in this paper: CR1, primate E complement receptor; HCT, hematocrit; NHS, normal human serum; CH50, hemolytic complement activity; HP, heteropolymer; CVF, cobra venom factor; CCS, cell culture supernatant; GFP, green fluorescent protein; RT, room temperature; SATA, N-succinimidyl S-acetylthioacetate; sSMCC, sulfosuccinimidyl 4-(N-maleimidomethyl)cyclohexane-1-carboxylate; SN supernatant. ![]()
Received for publication April 3, 2001. Accepted for publication June 19, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-galactose antibody production in baboons. Transplantation 62:678.[Medline]
and potentiates IL-10 production during human endotoxemia. J. Clin. Invest. 97:713.[Medline]