|
|
||||||||
Department of Pathology, Committee on Immunology and Cancer Biology, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Arg76 and
ßAsp57 at the periphery of the peptide binding groove.
Using mAbs we have identified alternative conformations of
I-Ag7 class II molecules. By using an invariant chain
construct with various peptides engineered into the class II-associated
invariant chain peptide (CLIP) region we have found that formation of
these conformations is dependent on the peptide occupying the binding
groove. Blocking studies with these Abs indicate that these
conformations are present at the cell surface and are capable of
interactions with TCRs that result in T cell
activation. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Susceptibility to IDDM in humans has been mapped to specific alleles in
HLA-DQ (6, 7, 8, 9, 10), while the spontaneous onset of diabetes in
the nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse is also linked to the MHC class II
molecule, I-Ag7 (11). Homozygosity
of the class II allele is required for high penetrance of diabetes
susceptibility. Heterozygosity of the class II locus in either humans
or mice or the expression of either an I-E
or an I-Aß transgene in
NOD mice (12, 13, 14) results in a dramatic decrease in
disease incidence, indicating that the effect of the class II molecule
is recessive, and loss of tolerance can be protected against by the
presence of an additional nondiabetogenic class II molecule.
The DQ allele associated with diabetes in humans shares a structural
variation with the I-Ag7 class II molecule
expressed in NOD mice. In both these molecules, but not in any other
class II molecule, position 57 of the ß-chain is mutated from an
aspartic acid to a serine or other noncharged amino acid. In NOD mice,
position 56 of the ß-chain is also mutated from a proline, expressed
in most other alleles, to a histidine (15). Crystal
structures of I-Ak and I-Ad
have indicated that Asp57 of the ß-chain forms
an interchain salt bridge with Arg76 in the class
II
-chain at the carboxyl end of the peptide binding groove of the
class II molecule (16, 17). The interchain salt bridge
between Aspß57 and
Arg
76 probably stabilizes the interaction
between the
- and ß-chains and may stabilize the integrity of the
peptide binding pocket of the class II molecule. The crystal structure
of I-Ag7 indicates that the loss of the salt
bridge results in a substantially wider peptide-binding groove around
ß57, which may account for differences in peptide preferences
(18).
Because MHC class II molecules function to present peptide to CD4+ T cells, a change in class II structure can affect systemic immunity by altering peptide binding, resulting in a change in either the repertoire of peptides bound or the affinity with which the peptide associates. Alternatively, changing the class II structure can alter the TCR-class II interaction. Recent evidence suggests that much of I-Ag7 class II expressed in APCs may not be associated with peptide (19). In vitro assays indicated that peptide binding to I-Ag7 is undetectable and that even immunogenic peptides rapidly dissociate from I-Ag7. Although another study reported success in eluting peptides from I-Ag7 and found that some peptides were able to stably associate with the I-Ag7 class II molecule, the authors conceded that much of the I-Ag7 class II appeared to be empty based on low yields of eluted peptides and on peptide binding studies (20). Large amounts of empty I-Ag7 would result in decreased cellular concentrations of I-Ag7 associated with specific peptide ligands. In the thymus, this decreased concentration of peptide:class II complexes would result in inefficient negative selection, thus allowing increased numbers of autoreactive T cells to emerge into the periphery (for review, see Refs. 21, 22, 23). Recent studies suggest that the peptide binding specificity of the class II I-Ag7 molecule is influenced dramatically by the presence or the absence of Asp57 in the ß-chain (18, 24). Thus, it is possible that changing the amino acid at ß57 may affect the selection of autoantigenic T cell epitopes. Finally, a variant class II structure induced by the unique sequence of I-Ag7 could affect class II interaction with the TCR. This altered structure could decrease the affinity of the class II-TCR interaction and thus could decrease the efficiency of negative selection, allowing autoreactive T cells to escape to the periphery.
Previously our group investigated the association of NOD MHC class II molecules with invariant chain and DM, both known cofactors of class II molecules. Invariant chain participates in a number of events in class II biosynthesis; most notably it facilitates MHC class II folding in the endoplasmic reticulum and localization to endosomes. In endosomes, invariant chain is proteolyzed, leaving a short fragment, called the class II-associated invariant chain peptide (CLIP), in the peptide binding pocket of the MHC class II molecule (25, 26). An MHC-encoded heterodimer termed DM associates with class II molecules in endosomes and facilitates the exchange of CLIP for antigenic peptide in the class II binding pocket (27, 28). To test whether class II molecules that had loaded with Ag in the presence of DM possessed any unique conformational features, cells coexpressing NOD class II, invariant chain, and DM were tested for reactivity with a panel of monoclonal anti-class II alloantibodies. These experiments revealed that a class II-specific mAb, 40M, preferentially stains I-Ag7 molecules biosynthesized in the presence of invariant chain and DM (29). Additional experiments demonstrated that 40M does not recognize I-Ag7 when CLIP is associated. Thus, DM expression apparently enhances the reactivity of I-Ag7 with 40M by facilitating the release of CLIP. These results indicate that 40M recognizes an epitope on I-Ag7 that is disrupted by CLIP association. Another Ab, 10.2-16, stained cells expressing I-Ag7 equally well in the presence or the absence of invariant chain (29). In the current paper we extend our analyses of this conformational flexibility in the NOD mouse. We show that I-Ag7 can adopt alternative conformational states that appear to be dictated by the sequence of the peptide within the class II binding pocket. These conformations can be present at the cell surface and can interact with TCRs, leading to T cell activation.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
NOD and CBA/J mice were obtained from The Jackson Laboratory
(Bar Harbor, ME) and maintained in a pathogen-free barrier facility. B
cell hybridomas secreting the mAb 10.2-16 (30), which
binds both I-Ag7 and I-Ak,
and 161-11N (31), which binds
H-2Kk class I molecules, were obtained from
American Type Culture Collection (Manassas, VA). Cells secreting 40M,
which binds both I-Ag7 and
I-Ak (32); the anti-invariant
chain Ab In-1 (33), and K24-199, which recognizes the
I-Ad
-chain (34), were provided
by Dr. Jim Miller (University of Chicago, Chicago, IL). 39E
supernatant, which recognizes I-Ak ß-chain, was
originally described by Pierres et al. (32). 20-8-4S
recognizes H-2 KbDb (35), and
cells secreting the Ab were purchased from American Type Culture
Collection. The anti-ß-chain antiserum was made by collecting
serum from rabbits originally immunized with a peptide corresponding to
the cytoplasmic region of the I-A ß-chain conjugated to keyhole
limpet hemocyanin in CFA, followed by subsequent immunizations in
IFA.
Generation and expression of invariant chain constructs
Invariant chain cDNA constructs in which the CLIP region was
either mutated at single amino acids or replaced with heterologous
peptides were generated by ligation of annealed oligonucleotides into a
mutated invariant chain construct engineered to contain a unique
restriction site on each side of the CLIP region (Fig. 1
). The mutated
invariant chain cDNA was constructed using PCR-mediated site-directed
mutagenesis. The plasmid containing the new restriction sites was
digested with KpnI and XbaI, gel isolated, and
treated with calf alkaline phosphatase, then ligated to
oligonucleotides (Life Technologies, Gaithersburg, MD) pretreated with
polynucleotide kinase in the presence of 1 mM ATP at 37°C for 1
h, and heated to 65°C to inactivate the kinase. The 5' and 3'
oligonucleotides were mixed, placed in a beaker of 65°C water, and
allowed to cool to room temperature to permit annealing. After
ligation, plasmid clones were sequenced to verify the insertion of the
modified CLIP segment. The constructs were then transiently transfected
in Ltk- cells stably expressing
I-Ag7. Briefly, Ltk- cells
expressing I-Ag7 were incubated with 5 µg of
cDNA in DMEM/10 mM HEPES/25.8 µg/ml chloroquine/0.25 mg/ml
DEAE-dextran at 37°C for 3 h. The DNA solution was aspirated and
replaced with DMEM and 10% DMSO (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) at room
temperature for 1 min. The DMEM/DMSO was replaced with complete medium,
and the cells were incubated for 72 h before harvesting from
culture and biochemical analysis.
|
Spleen cells were isolated from either NOD or CBA/J mice and prelabeled in leucine-free medium for 1 h at 37°C. Cells were then transferred to plates containing leucine-free medium plus 0.25 mCi of [3H]leucine (New England Nuclear, Boston, MA)/ml of medium and incubated at 37°C for 2 h, after which they were recovered by centrifugation and incubated in complete medium at 37°C for 5 h. Detergent lysates of the labeled cells were prepared by lysing cells on ice for 20 min in 0.5% Nonidet P-40, 150 mM NaCl, 50 mM Tris (pH 7.6), 5 mM EDTA, and 5 mM iodoacetimide plus protease inhibitors. The presence of iodoacetimide prevents disulfide bond formation between invariant chain molecules by air oxidation following cell lysis. Class II molecules were isolated from the postnuclear supernatant by immunoprecipitation using anti-class II Abs prebound to protein A-Sepharose (Pharmacia, Piscataway, NJ). Samples were dissociated in SDS-sample buffer containing 2% 2-ME, then electrophoresed on SDS-10% PAGE, and the gel was processed for autoradiography using Fluoro-Hance (Research Products International, Natick, MA) for 30 min. The treated gel was dried and exposed to film at -70°C.
Western blot analysis
Cells were lysed in a buffer containing 150 mM NaCl, 50 mM Tris (pH 7.6), 5 mM EDTA, 5 mM iodoacetimide, protease inhibitors, and either 6 mM 3-((3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio)-1-propane-sulfate (CHAPS) or 0.5% Nonidet P-40 on ice for 20 min (29). Postnuclear supernatants were incubated with mAbs prebound to protein A-Sepharose (Pharmacia). Immunoprecipitated proteins were eluted at room temperature with 2% SDS, 0.0625 M Tris (pH 6.8), and 10% glycerol, then boiled for 2 min. Samples were electrophoresed on a SDS-10% PAGE and transferred to nitrocellulose for Western blot analysis as described previously (29). The nitrocellulose membrane was blocked with 5% dry milk in TBST (10 mM Tris (pH 7.6), 0.15 M NaCl, and 0.1% Tween 20), then probed with the anti-invariant chain Ab In-1 in 5% milk/TBST overnight. Bound In-1 was detected with HRP-conjugated anti-rat Ab in 5% milk/TBST and developed by chemiluminescence using LumiGLO (Kirkegaard & Perry, Gaithersburg, MD).
Surface biotinylation
Spleen cells were washed in cold PBS three times before biotinylation to remove competing proteins. NHS-SS-biotin (Pierce, Rockford, IL) was dissolved in DMSO at 300 mg/ml, then diluted to 1.5 mg/ml in cold PBS immediately before use. Washed splenic cells were suspended in NHS-SS-biotin/PBS at a concentration of 2 x 107 cells/ml and incubated on ice for 30 min. The biotinylation reaction was stopped by washing cells three times with 50 mM glycine in cold PBS. The cells were then washed twice with excess amounts of iodoacetimide in cold PBS (5 mg/ml) to prevent biotinylation of internal material following cell lysis and solubilized, and the lysate was subjected to immunoprecipitation as described above.
Ag presentation assays
The OVA-specific and HEL-specific, I-Ag7-restricted T cell hybridomas were generated by fusing Ag-specific T cells to the TCR-negative variant of the T cell lymphoma BW5147. The T cells used in the fusions were obtained by in vivo priming with 50 µl of 1 mg/ml OVA or HEL in CFA (Sigma), followed by subsequent restimulations in vitro with Ag and syngeneic splenocytes for 10 days. Fusion was performed 3 days after a secondary Ag restimulation, and fused cells were cloned by limiting dilution. Ag-specific hybridomas were identified by coculture with Ag and NOD splenocytes as APCs. T cell hybridomas are specific to OVA (10.10, 30.5, and 97.4) or HEL (90.5, S17.10, and S70.4). S70.4 has a different fine specificity than 90.5 because it does not react with the HEL peptide 929. T cell Ag presentation assays were performed as previously described (29). Briefly, 25,000 T cells and 250,000 NOD spleen cell APCs were cocultured in 96-well dishes in the presence of submaximal doses of appropriate Ag. Ab supernatant, either 10.2-16 or 40M, was added to 25% of the final volume. The cells were cocultured for 20 h. The IL-2 content of each well was determined by MTT assay. Briefly, 50 µl of supernatant from each well was transferred to a new 96-well plate, which was then frozen to kill any transferred cells. The plate was thawed, and 10,000 CTLLs were added per well. After overnight culture 30 µl of a 2 mg/ml MTT solution was added to each well to detect viable cells. Following overnight incubation, 100 µl 10% SDS:0.01 N HCl was added to each well. Sixteen hours later the OD of each well was determined. Serial dilutions of recombinant human IL-2 (Amgen, Thousand Oaks, CA) were included as a standard.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We have previously shown that the presence of the CLIP peptide in
the peptide binding groove of I-Ag7 disrupts
recognition by the mAb 40M (29). Assaying whether the
presence of other peptides in the groove can also affect 40M reactivity
with I-Ag7 is hindered by the fact that
I-Ag7 binds peptides poorly (19).
Thus, attempts to selectively accumulate known soluble synthetic
peptides on I-Ag7 would probably fail. To
circumvent this problem, we used the natural chaperone of class II,
invariant chain, to hold a heterologous peptide in the groove of
I-Ag7 (36). As discussed above, the
CLIP region of invariant chain associates with the peptide binding
groove of the class II molecule. The regions of invariant chain
flanking CLIP also make contact with the associated class II molecule,
thus serving to tether CLIP within the binding pocket
(37, 38, 39). We capitalized on this natural association to
engineer different peptides into the class II binding pocket
(36). Invariant chain constructs were derived in which the
CLIP region was either mutated at single amino acids or completely
replaced with other heterologous peptides (Fig. 1
). These constructs were then
transiently transfected into L cell fibroblasts expressing
I-Ag7.
To determine whether the presence of these peptides in the binding
groove of I-Ag7 affects 40M recognition,
detergent lysates were prepared from cells expressing the alternate
invariant chain constructs described in Fig. 1
, and class II molecules
were assayed for reactivity with mAbs. Class II molecules were
immunoprecipitated from the lysates with either 10.2-16 or 40M. Class
II molecules associated with CLIP or the replacement peptide were
identified by Western blotting for intact invariant chain, which
tethers the peptide in the class II binding groove. We have not yet
assessed the relative binding affinity or stability of the CLIP
variants with I-Ag7, but it should be noted that
our assay only reads out class II molecules assembled with intact
invariant chain. The immunoprecipitation analyses revealed that the
presence of CLIP in the I-Ag7 binding groove
decreased the relative yield of class II-invariant chain complexes
isolated with 40M compared with the yield obtained with 10.2-16 (Fig. 2
, Expt. 1). However, when the entire
CLIP region was exchanged with aa 921 from HEL, 40M and 10.2-16
demonstrated equal reactivity (Fig. 2
, Expt. 1), indicating that
10.2-16 and 40M recognize I-Ag7 molecules
associated with this peptide equally well. These peptides, HEL 9-21
and CLIP, have multiple differences, making it difficult to deduce the
structural feature in the peptide responsible for the change in class
II conformation detected by the mAb. Because previous studies have
shown that peptides stably associated with I-Ag7
frequently possess a negatively charged amino acid at the carboxyl
terminal (40), we speculated that the presence of an
acidic amino acid at the carboxyl end of the peptide would interact
with the unpaired arginine available in the I-Ag7
-chain and might change the conformation of the ß-chain. Mutation
of Arg99 to Ala resulted in equal 10.2-16 and 40M
reactivity to the class II-peptide complex (Fig. 2
, Expt. 2),
confirming that recognition of I-Ag7 by these Abs
is dependent on the peptide present in the peptide binding groove and
can be influenced by single amino acid changes. Together these results
suggest that I-Ag7 is present in alternative
conformations, which are differentially recognized by 10.2-16 and 40M
and are dictated by the sequence of the peptide in the class II binding
pocket.
|
In the previous experiment the alternate conformations of
I-Ag7 were present in the biosynthetic pathway of
the cell in the presence of associated intact invariant chain. We next
sought to determine whether the alternative conformations of the class
II molecule could be induced by naturally occurring peptides. To
determine whether naturally occurring peptide:class II complexes can be
distinguished by their reactivity with 10.2-16 vs 40M, newly
synthesized proteins expressed by NOD spleen cells were radiolabeled
with [3H]leucine. The cells were then chased in
complete medium to allow the labeled protein to traffick through the
secretory system and into endosomes, where endosomally acquired peptide
would be loaded onto the class II molecules. To identify class II
molecules exclusively reactive with 10.2-16 or 40M, a sequential
immunoprecipitation strategy was employed. Following preparation of a
detergent lysate from the radiolabeled spleen cells, class II molecules
reactive with 10.2-16 were exhaustively removed from one-third of the
lysate by successive immunoprecipitations, while molecules reactive
with 40M were depleted from one third, and the last third of the lysate
was treated with a control Ab. Class II molecules remaining in the
lysate following depletion were assayed for Ab reactivity by
immunoprecipitation with either 10.2-16 or 40M, then MHC class I
molecules were immunoprecipitated to demonstrate that equivalent
amounts of cell lysate were used for each immunoprecipitation following
immunodepletion (Fig. 3
C).
Spleen cells from CBA mice expressing a different, but serologically
related, class II allele (I-Ak) were also
radiolabeled, chased, immunodepleted, and precipitated to determine
whether specific monoclonal reactivity, and thus adoption of specific
alternative conformations, is limited to the
I-Ag7 class II allele. The results of this
experiment are shown in Fig. 3
. Following immunodepletion of NOD spleen
lysate with 10.2-16, very little 10.2-16-precipitable
I-Ag7 persisted in the lysate, showing that
quantitative depletion was obtained. Examination of the 40M
immunoprecipitation revealed that there was a significant amount of
40M-reactive class II molecules remaining in this lysate (Fig. 3
A, compare lanes 3 and 4). Similarly,
40M immunodepletion was complete (Fig. 3
A, lane
6), yet there was a substantial amount of
I-Ag7 precipitated with 10.2-16 (Fig. 3
A, compare lanes 7 and 8). From these
data we can identify three distinct sets of class II-peptide complexes
in NOD APCs. The major set of complexes, comprising
80% of all
class II molecules, is reactive with both 10.2-16 and 40M. The
remaining class II molecules are in two equally represented sets, one
reactive with only 10.2-16 and one reactive with only 40M. By contrast,
there are no I-Ak molecules that are only
precipitable by 40M (Fig. 3
B, compare lanes 3 and
4), although 10.2-16 precipitates some
I-Ak proteins following 40M immunodepletion (Fig. 3
B, compare lanes 7 and 8). These data
indicate that I-Ag7, but not
I-Ak, is present in at least three
peptide-dependent alternate conformations that can be distinguished by
10.2-16 and 40M reactivity. These alternate conformations of
I-Ag7 are present in splenic APCs and can be
induced by naturally occurring peptide in association with mature class
II molecules.
|
- and ß-chain
precipitable by 10.2-16. If, following 40M depletion, 10.2-16 only
precipitates class II associated with invariant chain, then the 10.2-16
precipitation following the anti-invariant chain depletion should
contain no class II molecules. As seen previously, 10.2-16 precipitates
class II
- and ß-chains as well as some invariant chain following
quantitative immunodepletion with 40M. Following immunodepletion of
invariant chain, 10.2-16 still precipitates class II
- and
ß-chains, but no associated invariant chain molecules (Fig. 4
|
To determine whether the class II molecules in the alternate
conformations are present at the cell surface, and thus are able to
interact with T cells, surface proteins expressed on NOD spleen cells
were biotinylated. Sequential immunoprecipitation was again used to
isolate class II molecules reactive with only 10.2-16 or 40M. These
molecules were then detected by streptavidin in a Western blot. The
results (Fig. 5
) indicate that all three
conformations, 10.2-16+/40M+,
10.2-16+/40M-, and
10.2-16-/40M+, are present at the cell surface
and thus potentially able to interact with TCRs.
|
To determine whether T cells are able to interact with the
alternate conformations of I-Ag7, the abilities
of 10.2-16 and 40M to block T cell recognition of class II-peptide
complexes on APCs were assessed. A set of T cells specific for either
HEL or OVA in the context of NOD class II were generated, and
dose-response curves to Ag were determined (data not shown). These T
cells were then tested for their relative ability to be blocked by
10.2-16 vs 40M at a suboptimal dose of Ag (Fig. 6
). One set of T cells restricted to OVA
(10.10, 30.5, and 97.4) in the context of I-Ag7
was more efficiently blocked by 10.2-16 than 40M. Another set of T
cells restricted to HEL (S70.4, 90.5, and S17.10) in the context of
I-Ag7 was also generated. We know the fine
specificity of these T cells to be different, because 90.5 and S17.10,
but not S70.4, recognize HEL peptide 929 (data not shown). The mAb
blocking studies revealed that the T cells 90.5 and S17.10 were both
more efficiently blocked by 40M than by 10.2-16, consistent with the
data shown in Fig. 2
. The T cell S70.4, by contrast, is more
efficiently blocked by 10.2-16 than by 40M. Together these data
indicate that I-Ag7 associated with antigenic
peptides form different conformations that are differentially
recognized by 10.2-16 and 40M. Further, these class II-peptide
conformations are capable of interacting with T cells, resulting in T
cell activation, indicating that they are present on the cell surface
and may be functionally relevant in vivo.
|
The data shown above suggest that the I-Ag7
class II molecule can adopt multiple conformations that are dependent
upon the peptide present in the class II peptide binding groove.
However, the increased flexibility of the I-Ag7
molecule may be limited to a localized region of the class II molecule.
To determine whether the preceding data reflect a global flexibility of
the I-Ag7 molecule or merely increased
flexibility in a localized region, we screened additional
anti-class II mAbs for relative reactivity with
I-Ag7 bound to different peptides. In this
experiment we used an antiserum directed against the cytosolic tail of
the ß-chain of MHC class II molecules as a measure of total
I-Ag7 precipitable from lysates. In addition to
10.2-16 and 40M, reactivity of I-Ag7-peptide
complexes with K24-199, directed against the I-Ad
-chain, and 39E, directed against the ß-chain, was tested. Cells
stably expressing I-Ag7 were transiently
transfected with the constructs shown in Fig. 1
, and the cells were
harvested and lysed 3 days post-transfection. After dividing the lysate
into equal portions for precipitation, 12.5% of each portion was
analyzed by Western blot for invariant chain levels to verify that
equal amounts of lysate were used for each immunoprecipitation, and
that the relative levels of invariant expression for each transfection
were equivalent. Compared with the yield of class II-invariant chain
complexes isolated with the anti-ß tail antiserum,
I-Ag7 associated with CLIP was recognized well by
10.2-16, to an intermediate level by K24-199 and 40M, and not at all by
39E (Fig. 7
). I-Ag7
associated with invariant chain in which the CLIP peptide has been
exchanged for the HEL peptide was precipitated by 10.2-16, 40M, and 39E
in amounts similar to those precipitated by anti-ß tail
antiserum, but was recognized poorly by K24-199 (Fig. 7
). CLIP mutated
at position 99 from Arg to Ala associated with
I-Ag7 was recognized well by both 10.2-16 and 40M
compared with anti-ß tail antiserum, but was precipitated poorly
by both K24-199 and 39E (Fig. 7
). These data indicate that the peptide
in the binding groove can affect recognition by Abs directed against
both the
- and the ß-chain of the class II molecule, suggesting
that peptide-dependent alterations in conformation are not limited to
local regions, but result in more global changes in the structure of
the I-Ag7 class II molecule.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Ser polymorphism
shared by these alleles is thought to be important in disease
initiation or progression, but how this polymorphism affects class II
and thus diabetes susceptibility is not clear. Studies presented here
suggest that the murine class II molecule associated with diabetes
susceptibility, I-Ag7, exists in multiple
alternative conformational states. We used an Ab (40M) whose epitope
was previously found to be enhanced on I-Ag7 when
coexpressed with invariant chain and DM (29) along with
other anti-class II mAbs to identify alternate conformations of
I-Ag7. The formation of these conformations is
peptide dependent, as shown by the change in relative reactivities of
these Abs when different peptides are locked into the class II peptide
binding groove. T cell blocking assays show that these Abs
differentially block T cell clones, indicating that these conformations
are present at the cell surface and are capable of interacting with
TCRs resulting in T cell proliferation.
The I-Ag7 class II molecule is a unique hybrid
molecule, composed of the I-Ad
-chain and the
unique I-Ag7 ß-chain. The sequence at amino
acids 1214 in the ß-chain is identical with
I-Ad, allowing the ß-chain to dimerize with the
I-Ad
-chain (41). This sequence
is also shared with I-A u, f, and q class II ß-chains. The remainder
of the I-Ag7ß-chain most closely resembles
I-Au, although polymorphisms at positions 8, 9,
26, and 63 are shared with I-Ak. Amino acids at
positions 65 and 67 are deleted in I-Ag7 ß, as
they are in k, u, and f, allowing the I-Ag7
ß-chain to be recognized by the mAb 10.2-16. Finally,
I-Ag7 ß-chain contains polymorphisms at
positions 56 and 57, resulting in the lack of potential to form an
interchain salt bridge with the
-chain. These multiple substitutions
make it difficult to compare I-Ag7 with any other
class II molecule in terms of Ab reactivity and suggest that different
conformational states could be due not just to the lack of the salt
bridge, but possibly to the cumulative effect of multiple
polymorphisms.
The formation of alternate conformations by I-Ag7
suggests that this class II molecule is flexible, but the degree of
flexibility in molecular terms is difficult to directly assess. The Abs
used to identify the conformations recognize distinct regions in the
class II molecule. The mAb K24-199 recognizes the
I-Ad
-chain (34), which is the
partner chain for the I-Ag7 ß-chain. The
10.2-16 epitope is located around aa 64 in the ß-chain near the
carboxyl end of the bound peptide (34), whereas
recognition of class II by both 40M and 39E has previously been shown
to be dependent on amino acid Arg70 in the middle
of the groove (42). The region around ß70 contains a
kink in the
helix that may allow increased structural mobility and
has been implicated in conformational shifts in both class I (43, 44) and class II molecules (45). Comparison of
class II molecules with CLIP or other peptides in their binding grooves
indicates that the largest structural differences attributable to
peptide occur in this region around aa 70 in the ß-chain (46, 47). Because I-Ag7 lacks the potential to
form a salt bridge at the carboxyl end of the peptide binding groove,
more flexibility may be allowed at this end of the class II structure
compared with other allelic forms of class II. In fact, the recently
solved crystal structure of I-Ag7 indicates that
the peptide binding groove around ß57 is substantially wider than
that in other class II alleles (18). Previous studies have
identified Ab epitopes that are influenced by bound peptide or by the
absence of peptide, indicating that peptide can impart conformational
features on both class I and class II MHC molecules (43, 44, 45, 48, 49, 50). These findings are consistent with MHC crystallization
studies showing that structural features in the class II
helices
are influenced by the sequence of peptides in the class II peptide
binding pocket (46, 47). From these studies the concept
has emerged that MHC molecules have inherently flexible structures.
Either the lack of a stabilizing salt bridge or the presence of
other polymorphisms in the NOD class II molecule may result in
increased flexibility of the molecule, possibly accentuating the
impact of the peptide on the structure of the class II molecule.
Although the current studies demonstrate that the formation of the
alternate conformations is dependent on the sequence of the peptide
bound in the groove, we do not yet know the motif required to form each
conformation. Previous reports have identified sequence motifs for
peptides that interact well with I-Ag7. Using a
competitive peptide binding assay, one group identified the
I-Ag7 binding motif to include a large
hydrophobic amino acid at P6 and either an aromatic hydrophobic or
basic amino acid at P9 (51). Using a similar approach,
another group determined that peptides binding to
I-Ag7 are anchored at positions P4, P6, and P9.
Leucine is preferred at P4, although Tyr, Ala, and Thr are accepted. P6
must be occupied by small residues, such as Ala or Thr, while Glu is
preferred at P9, with any substitution resulting in decreased peptide
binding (20). Similarly, utilization of a peptide elution
sequencing strategy coupled with competitive binding assays by another
group suggested that a primary feature of I-Ag7
binding peptides is an acidic residue at P9 (40). This
acidic residue is postulated to neutralize the unpaired basic amino
acid at position 76 of the
-chain. A recent study found that
although CLIP does not bind well within the I-Ag7
binding pocket, modification of Met98 at P9 to an
acidic residue greatly increases binding affinity (52).
The recently solved crystal structure of I-Ag7
indicates that the peptide binding groove has an increased capacity for
promiscuous peptide binding. Interestingly, the P9 pocket can
accommodate two classes of amino acids in different orientations. Amino
acids with small side chains pointing down into the pocket are
accepted, but the positively charged environment favors acidic amino
acids with their side chains oriented sideways (18). This
difference in the orientation of the side chain would affect the
orientation of the peptide backbone, which could, in turn, affect
the conformation of the
helices of the class II molecule
through the hydrogen bonds and van der Waals interactions between the
class II molecule and the peptide. These different
I-Ag7 binding motifs may, in fact, reflect the
different subsets of peptides that lead to the alternate
peptide-dependent conformations that I-Ag7 can
adopt. We are currently employing the invariant chain cassetting
strategy to evaluate this possibility.
One possible interpretation of the data presented is that rather than
discriminating between different conformations of the
I-Ag7 class II molecule formed due to the peptide
in the binding groove, the Abs may, in fact, be partly recognizing
specific residues of the peptide itself. However, multiple mAbs
directed against both the
- and ß-chains of the class II
molecule differentially recognize the different peptide:class II
complexes. The likelihood that all Abs tested, against both the
-chain and the ß-chain, interact with specific residues of the
peptide in the peptide:class II complexes is very low. Also, arguing
against this possibility is that although both 40M and 39E recognize
epitopes in the same region of the class II molecule, specifically
around amino acid 70 (42), they display different
recognition patterns of I-Ag7 complexed with
different peptides. Specifically, although neither Ab recognizes
I-Ag7 associated with CLIP, recognition by 40M,
but not 39E, is regained when Arg99 is mutated to
Ala. Positions ß61 and ß57 have been modeled to interact with P9 of
peptides associated with I-Ag7 (20).
Arg99 would probably be P10 in CLIP
(52), suggesting that this amino acid would be far from
ß70 and thus unlikely to be recognized by 40M and 39E. Collectively
our data are more consistent with the possibility that mutation of the
peptide in the binding groove at P10 results in a conformational change
that is passed along the
helix of the ß-chain, which can be
distinguished by Abs binding to distal sites in the class II
molecule.
The relative levels of each conformation were assessed in the current
study. The metabolic labeling experiment followed by sequential
immunodepletion indicates that
80% of the molecules are reactive
with both 10.2-16 and 40M, whereas
10% of the molecules react with
only 10.2-16 or 40M. However, by biotinylation, the conformation
reactive with only 40M represents >25% of the total class II
molecules. This apparent discrepancy could be due to labeling
differences, with the
10.2-16-/40M+ conformation
exposing additional biotinylation sites, while the biotin-available
sites are masked on class II molecules reactive only with 10.2-16. The
disparity between biosynthetic labeling and surface biotinylation could
also be accounted for by differing half-lives of the class II molecules
expressing different conformations. Class II molecules that have
unstable interactions with peptide are thought to have more rapid
turnover rates within APCs. I-Ag7 has been shown
to both bind peptide poorly and to have an atypically short half-life
(19, 52, 53). Thus, the minor population of
I-Ag7 that interacts only with 40M may persist at
the cell surface, possibly due to its more stable interaction with
peptide. These molecules would thus accumulate over time. We are
currently examining these possibilities.
To be important in diabetogenesis, these alternate conformations must play a role in T cell selection and/or activation. The anti-class II mAb blocking data shown above suggest that the various conformations participate in T cell activation. If we consider what is known about the sites of interaction at the TCR:class II interface, we can speculate at least two events that could be affected by the alternative conformations of I-Ag7. First, the alternative conformations could interact with the TCR with different affinities. The TCR docks onto the MHC class I:peptide complex in a diagonal fashion, with the complementarity-determining region loops interacting both with the MHC molecule and the peptide (54, 55). Comparison of a solved crystal structure of a class I:peptide complex with that of a class I:peptide:TCR complex indicates that the side chains of the class I molecule shift slightly when the complex engages the TCR (55). Thus, an altered conformation could result in differential engagement of the TCR, potentially affecting both T cell education in the thymus and stimulation in the periphery. The recently published crystal structure of the D10 TCR complexed with I-Ak and peptide (56) indicates that TCRs bind to class II molecules in a more orthogonal manner, with multiple TCR-MHC contacts occurring in the region around ß67-ß77. In fact, ß70, which is present in the epitope recognized by both 40M and 39E, forms three hydrogen bonds and eight van der Waals contacts with various residues of the TCR. Thus, an alternative conformation in this area of the class II-peptide complex could reasonably be expected to result in differential interaction with TCRs.
Additionally, different conformations of I-Ag7
could result in differential engagement of the CD4 molecule on the
surface of the T cell. Mutagenesis studies suggest that the CD4
molecule interacts with two sites on the class II molecule, one on the
2 domain (57) and one on the ß2 domain (58, 59), each of which binds separate CD4 molecules. A mutation at
either site impairs CD4 function in T cell activation, indicating that
both sites must bind their receptor for full activation to occur
(57). Thus, one of the I-Ag7
conformations may interact with the TCR in an altered manner, such that
there is a change in the ability to recruit CD4, thus altering the
ability to stimulate the T cell in the thymus or the periphery.
Although the conformations recognized exclusively by a single Ab represent a minor population of the total class II molecules, it is possible that this small population of class II molecules may play a disproportionately large role in T cell selection in the thymus, since, as discussed above, it is not known whether all conformational states of MHC molecules equally recruit TCRs and coreceptors. Although we do not yet know how the various I-Ag7 conformations may alter TCR:class II interactions, there is evidence that the NOD class II molecule may have a general deficiency in effective interactions with the TCR. Data from Fathmans group (60, 61) have suggested that the addition of another class II allele to NOD mice results in the majority of the developing T cells being educated on the new allele, a finding that suggests that I-Ag7 is a poor class II molecule for T cell education (60, 61, 62). It is possible that the inability to stably bind peptide may be solely responsible for the poor recruitment of the TCR by I-Ag7. Our studies raise the alternative possibility that deficiencies in the ability of I-Ag7 to engage TCRs may be due to an unusually high degree of structural flexibility. Future experiments are being designed to evaluate this intriguing possibility.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Andrea J. Sant, Department of Pathology, Committees on Immunology and Cancer Biology, University of Chicago, 5841 South Maryland, MC 1089, Chicago, IL 60637. ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: IDDM, insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus; NOD, nonobese diabetic; CLIP, class II-associated invariant chain peptide; HEL, hen egg lysozyme. ![]()
Received for publication November 24, 1999. Accepted for publication June 5, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
chain. Nature 345:727.[Medline]
ß dimers and facilitates peptide loading. Cell 82:155.[Medline]
ß dimers and facilitates highly efficient peptide loading. Int. Immunol. 10:1159.
dimers: key influences of residues in the amino-terminal portion of the ß1 domain. J. Immunol. 144:329.[Abstract]
and ß chains in CD4 function indicates a role for ordered oligomerization in T cell activation. J. Exp. Med. 182:779.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Gardiner, K. A. Richards, A. J. Sant, and L. S. Arneson Conformation of MHC class II I-Ag7 is sensitive to the P9 anchor amino acid in bound peptide Int. Immunol., September 1, 2007; 19(9): 1103 - 1113. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. S. Arneson, J. F. Katz, M. Liu, and A. J. Sant Hydrogen Bond Integrity Between MHC Class II Molecules and Bound Peptide Determines the Intracellular Fate of MHC Class II Molecules J. Immunol., December 15, 2001; 167(12): 6939 - 6946. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Marrack, J. Bender, M. Jordan, W. Rees, J. Robertson, B. C. Schaefer, and J. Kappler Presidential Address to The American Association of Immunologists : Major Histocompatibility Complex Proteins and TCRs: Do They Really Go Together Like a Horse and Carriage? J. Immunol., July 15, 2001; 167(2): 617 - 621. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |