The JI
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     
 


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Request Permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Lucas, B.
Right arrow Articles by Germain, R. N.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Lucas, B.
Right arrow Articles by Germain, R. N.
The Journal of Immunology, 2000, 165: 1889-1895.
Copyright © 00 by The American Association of Immunologists

Opening a Window on Thymic Positive Selection: Developmental Changes in the Influence of Cosignaling by Integrins and CD28 on Selection Events Induced by TCR Engagement

Bruno Lucas* and Ronald N. Germain1,{dagger}

* Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale, Unité 345, Institut Necker, Paris, France; and {dagger} Lymphocyte Biology Section, Laboratory of Immunology, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892


    Abstract
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
How TCR and non-TCR signals are integrated by thymocytes to generate a decision to undergo either positive or negative selection remains incompletely understood. Recent evidence suggests that TCR signal transduction changes its quality during thymocyte maturation, but whether the contributions of various cosignaling or costimulatory pathways to thymocyte selection also are modified during development is unclear. Questions also remain about the possible selective roles of specific costimulatory pathways in induction of differentiation vs death among thymocytes at any given stage of maturity. To address these issues, a quantitative in vitro analysis of initiation of CD4+CD8+ thymocyte differentiation as measured by CD69 up-regulation/coreceptor down-modulation was conducted in parallel with an analysis of induction of death. Using transfected cells varying in their surface display of ICAM-1 or B7.1 along with antibody blocking experiments, we demonstrate here that ICAM-1 provides a selective boost to signaling for differentiation without substantially affecting induction of death among CD4+CD8+ cells, a property that is lost as thymocytes mature further. In contrast, B7 engagement enhances both cell activation and death in parallel. Based on these data, we propose that the high level of ICAM-1 on cortical epithelial cells plays a special role in opening a window between TCR signaling for differentiation vs death, permitting efficient initiation of positive selection on epithelial ligands. In contrast, late CD28-dependent cosignaling on hemopoietic cells in the medulla would help enforce negative selection by augmenting the effects of TCR engagement by low levels of high affinity ligands.


    Introduction
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Following successful rearrangement of the gene segments encoding the component {alpha}- and ß-chains, precursor T lymphocytes each express a unique receptor (TCR) that regulates mature Ag-induced effector function. Because of the unpredictable diversity in their binding specificity, the differentiation and survival of precursor T cells include a test of the recognition properties of these somatically generated receptors against the internal antigenic environment (1, 2, 3, 4). A key aspect of this process involves the death of developing thymocytes with TCR whose interactions with self Ags (short peptides bound to MHC molecules) might result in full activation of the mature T cell bearing that TCR (5, 6). This creates an apparent paradox: how the same set of self peptide-associated MHC molecules can deliver both death-inducing signals that yield a repertoire depleted of potentially harmful self-reactive T cells and positive signals ensuring survival but not overt activation of other T cells also recognizing these ligands (7).

One hypothesis proposed to explain how this distinction between cell fates arises comes from the demonstration that full activation of mature T cells requires cosignals delivered by a variety of receptor/counter-receptor interactions, especially those involving CD28 on the T cell and CD80/86 (B7.1, B7.2) on the APC. This model postulates that thymocytes simultaneously signaled through the TCR and by this costimulatory pathway are induced to undergo apoptosis and that epithelial thymic stromal cells differ from the hemopoietic cells typically involved in activation of mature T cells in lacking expression of these key costimulatory molecules (8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15). Thus, only thymocytes with TCR recognizing peptide:MHC complexes uniquely expressed on the costimulatory-deficient stromal cells (16) would survive the selection process, preventing maturation of cells recognizing self ligands on activated, costimulatory hemopoietic presenting cells in the peripheral immune system.

The experiments examining this model have involved single ligand concentrations, one stage of T cell maturation, or failed to compare thymocyte differentiation vs death in the same experiments (8, 11). Differences in these parameters among experimental models may account for the discrepant results and also obscure the real role of these interactions in thymocyte development. In addition, this proposal implies that no peptides shared between epithelial cells and hemopoietic cells can be involved in positive selection, a conclusion for which no support currently exists and that is at odds with recent data from this laboratory on the ability of dendritic cells to support late stages of positive selection in reaggregate organ cultures (17).2

To re-examine the role of cosignaling during thymocyte development in a quantitative manner, we have used an in vitro model system in which thymocytes and mature T cells can be exposed to self-peptide:MHC molecule ligands or to graded concentrations of foreign Ag:MHC molecule ligands, each in the presence or the absence of various cosignaling molecules on MHC class II-expressing transfected L cells. While it has its own limitations, this in vitro approach allows direct analysis of the response of pure populations of thymocytes at discrete developmental stages to a homogenous accessory cell population. In vivo or organ culture models cannot provide such quantitative information, enforce such a limitation of the cell types involved in signal delivery or receipt, or restrict the surface molecule display as completely. The latter is an important point, as many studies using mice, whole organs, or isolated stromal cells are confounded by the operation of redundant pathways that obscure the capacity of the deleted or blocked molecule to perform a given function, while not being absolutely required for that function.

Our results using this model system suggest a key role for ICAM-1 in allowing immature double-positive (DP)3 thymocytes interacting with cortical epithelial cells to achieve a level of intracellular signaling suitable for initiation of positive selection without activation of a death program. This window of opportunity provided by ICAM-1 is lost as the thymocytes mature. B7:CD28 interactions, in contrast, work especially efficiently with maturing thymocytes to augment signaling that can lead to cell death, helping to enforce negative selection upon TCR engagement of even a low density of high affinity/high quality ligands on hemopoietic cells in the thymic medulla. Together with prior evidence for maturation-related changes in the nature of signal generation by the TCR complex itself (18, 19, 20), the present findings of differential, developmentally controlled modification of the outcome of this TCR signaling by integrin and CD28 cosignaling pathways provide additional insight into how the decision to mature or die is made by thymocytes.


    Materials and Methods
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Mice

The H-2b AND TCR transgenic (21) RAG-2-/- (22) mice were generated by breeding and were maintained in a National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Research Animal Facility. They were provided by Dr. B. J. Fowlkes.

Cells

DAP.3 (23) is an MHC class II-negative fibroblast cell line derived from H-2k mice. DCEKhi7 and P13.9 L cells are daughter cell lines of DAP.3 stably transfected with cDNA expression constructs encoding I-Ek or I-Ek, B7.1, and ICAM-1, respectively (24) (Table IGo). FT7.1C6 and P12 are daughter cell lines of DAP.3 transfected with cDNA expression constructs encoding I-Ab or I-Ab, B7.1, and ICAM-1 respectively. EKAM1.5 is a cell line derived from DCEKhi7 L cells by transfection with pßA-ICAM (25), a cDNA construct encoding the costimulatory molecule ICAM.1. EKAM2.5 L cells were obtained from the same transfection but do not express ICAM.1 and therefore are phenotypically identical with their parental cell line DCEKhi7 (18).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table I. Cell surface phenotypes of L cells used as APC

 
Monoclonal Abs

Abs were purchased from PharMingen (San Diego, CA). For inhibition of cell surface molecule function during cell culture, purified anti-B7.1 (16-10A1), anti-B7.2 (GL1), and/or purified anti-ICAM.1 (3E2) were used. These Abs were stored in a no azide/low endotoxin buffer. For flow cytometry, the following Ab combination was used: PE-anti-CD4 (RM4-5), FITC-anti-CD8 (53-6-7), and biotinylated anti-CD69 (H1-2F3) revealed by Tricolor-streptavidin (Caltag, South San Francisco, CA). Surface staining was performed as previously described (26).

In vitro culture assay

Thymi or pooled mesenteric lymph nodes and spleens were homogenized on a nylon cell strainer (Falcon, Franklin Lakes, NJ) in complete RPMI 1640 medium with 10% heat-inactivated FCS. Thymocytes (1 x 106) or 0.5 x 106 peripheral T cells and 1 x 106 or 0.5 x 106 fibroblasts of the indicated cell line, respectively, were centrifuged and then incubated in 6-ml polypropylene, round-bottom tubes with caps (Falcon) at 37°C in an atmosphere containing 5% CO2. Where indicated, peptides were added at 5 x 10-5 µM to 50 µM. The following peptides were used for these experiments. PCC88–104 is KAERADLIYLKQATAK; P99 and Q99 peptides are synthetic peptides in which the lysine in position 99 is changed to proline or glutamine, respectively. All peptides were synthesized and purified by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Peptide Synthesis Facility, National Institutes of Health (Bethesda, MD). For Ab-mediated inhibition studies, fibroblasts were preincubated for 4 h at 4°C with the indicated Ab. After 18–21 h of culture, thymocyte cell death, IL-2 production by peripheral T cells, and CD69 expression on thymic DP cells or on thymic and peripheral CD4+ cells were determined.

IL-2 production

Pooled peripheral mesenteric lymph node and spleen cells were cultured with peptide and APCs overnight in 2.5 ml of complete medium. Supernatants were assayed in triplicate for the presence of IL-2 by ELISA, using jES6-1A12 mAb (PharMingen, San Diego, CA) as a capture reagent. Bound cytokine was detected with biotinylated jES6-5H4 mAb. To detect the binding of biotinylated Abs, alkaline phosphatase-conjugated avidin (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) was followed by p-nitrophenyl phosphate (Sigma). The reaction product was measured at 405 nm.

In vitro cell death assay

After overnight culture, thymocytes were harvested, and cell death was measured as previously described (27, 28, 29). These previous studies have shown that this method accurately assesses cell loss resulting from T cell apoptosis. Briefly, all recovered cells were stained for CD4, CD8, and CD69; washed; then resuspended in identical volumes. Data were acquired for 60 s at a constant flow rate using a FACScan equipped with CellQuest software (Becton Dickinson, Mountain View, CA). Total viable cells were enumerated using a restricted gate defined by forward/side scatter parameters and verified by the absence of propidium iodide incorporation. The numbers of viable DP thymocytes were quantified by setting a gate on the basis of CD4/CD8 fluorescence intensity (as shown in Fig. 1GoA). The results were converted to percentage of maximal cell death as explained below. No increase in cell death was observed among peripheral CD4+ cells during culture at any peptide concentration.



View larger version (35K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 1. B7.1/ICAM-1 dependent self peptide:MHC class II molecule stimulation of immature DP and mature CD4+ SP thymocytes or mature CD4+ SP T cells. A, Thymocytes or peripheral lymph node cells from H-2b AND TCR transgenic RAG-2-/- mice were incubated overnight with the indicated L cells. Recovered cells were stained for CD69, CD4, and CD8 expression. B, Illustration of the gates used to define the mature CD4+ SP thymocytes (R1) and immature (DP) thymocytes (R2) whose CD69 expression is shown in A. Similar analysis was used with peripheral lymph node cells to define CD4+ T cells (not shown). The number in the upper right of each panel represents the mean fluorescence values for the cells in R2 and demonstrates the down-modulation of both coreceptors that accompanies stimulation and CD69 expression.

 
Calculations

Because reactivity against some fibroblast cell lines was observed without adding any source of peptide, the various measured parameters were expressed as percentages of maximal response after subtraction of the response obtained with the same APCs not exposed to peptide: this protocol allowed us to measure specific reactivities against the added peptide (PCC 88–104) by subtracting the "natural" reactivity against the APCs. Because a significant percentage of DP thymocytes died during culture due to peptide exposure and because CD69 expression on DP thymocytes was routinely measured by flow cytometry only on viable cells, we have corrected for this by assuming that all DP cells induced to die by peptide exposure also expressed CD69. Specifically, the percentages of CD69+ DP thymocytes obtained by cytometry analysis were modified as follows: % of CD69 induced on DP cells = (% of viable DP cells x % of CD69 measured by cytometry) + (% of dead DP cells).


    Results
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Developmental stage-specific contributions of ICAM-1- and B7.1-dependent cosignaling to self-ligand-induced thymocyte differentiation

To achieve a quantitative understanding at discrete developmental stages of the contributions of Ag-specific and unspecific signaling to T cell differentiation or death, we employed an in vitro cell-cell interaction system in which cell death, the expression of relevant marker genes for differentiation, or other outcomes of TCR-dependent signaling can be measured and in which the TCR ligands and cosignaling molecules available to the thymocyte can be carefully controlled. CD69 expression, which occurs on all thymocytes undergoing Ag-induced positive as well as negative selection (26, 30, 31, 32), was analyzed as an indicator of TCR signaling for differentiation, in parallel with induction of cell death. The thymocytes were from RAG-2-/- AND TCR transgenic H-2b/b mice (21, 33), in which selection of mature CD4+ T cells bearing this TCR occurs, but which do not express the I-Ek MHC class II molecule able to present the cognate foreign Ag ligand for this TCR (pigeon cytochrome c, residues 88–104). All T-lineage cells from these mice express a single defined TCR.

Neither fibroblasts (DAP.3) lacking the I-Ek MHC class II molecule that is involved in foreign Ag recognition by this TCR nor I-Ek+ but ICAM-1-, B7.1low fibroblasts (EKAM2.5) induced CD69 expression upon overnight coculture with AND thymocytes (Fig. 1GoA). Strikingly, without any exogenous source of peptide, a significant number of thymic DP and CD4+ mature thymocytes expressed CD69 after overnight culture with I-Ek+, ICAM-1+ (EKAM1.5) or I-Ek+, ICAM-1+, B7.1+ (P13.9) fibroblasts. These responses were not due solely to interactions with ICAM-1 and/or B7.1, because ICAM-1+, B7.1+, I-Ab+ fibroblasts (P12) did not induce any CD69 up-regulation (data not shown). These results suggest that the I-Ek+ fibroblasts express a ligand capable of engaging the AND transgenic TCR, but that this TCR-ligand pair only produces a signal able to induce a visible functional response in the presence of ICAM-1 and/or B7.1. This ability of I-Ek+, ICAM-1+ fibroblasts to induce CD69 up-regulation is consistent with the capacity of I-Ek bound to self-peptides to negatively select many AND TCR transgenic thymocytes (34). Interestingly, the roles of ICAM-1 and B7.1 in this CD69 response appear to be different at distinct stages of T cell development. DP cells respond to coculture with ICAM-1-expressing I-Ek+ fibroblasts (EKAM1.5), and this response is not markedly affected by the coexpression of B7.1 (Fig. 1GoA). In contrast, B7.1 overexpression considerably increases thymic (as well as peripheral) SP CD4+ T cell responses, which are marginal using I-Ek+ cells with only ICAM-1 but not B7.1 expressed at high levels. These results help explain why various analyses that do not discriminate among the effects of blocking these cosignaling pathways at different stages on T cell development yield different interpretations.

Differing roles of ICAM-1 and B7.1 costimulation in DP vs mature thymocyte responses to foreign agonist ligand

ICAM-1 expression is high on both cortical epithelial cells and dendritic cells (35), whereas CD80/86 expression is largely confined to the latter in the thymus (36). Because these two cell populations have been proposed to function almost exclusively in positive and negative selection, respectively, it was clearly of interest to examine more quantitatively ICAM-1 and B7.1 contributions to DP cell activation and death. This was done using different fibroblast cell lines (Table IGo) in the presence of different concentrations of PCC88–104, the full agonist peptide recognized by the AND transgenic TCR. Some investigators have claimed that low concentrations of such agonists can be effective in positive selection (37, 38, 39), whereas others could not obtain such agonist-driven maturation, but observed only induction of apoptosis when using thymic organ cultures (40, 41, 42). CD4 and CD8 coreceptor down-regulation was examined (Fig. 1GoB). The results obtained by measuring coreceptor loss were identical with those obtained studying the induction of CD69 expression, in agreement with earlier findings (26, 43, 44, 45, 46). Thus, as a measure of TCR signaling potentially adequate for induction of differentiation, we examined CD69 levels, whose up-regulation is known to correlate with initiation of thymocyte selection (26, 30, 31, 32), and compared these to the extent of induced cell death under various stimulation conditions.

In the absence of ICAM-1 expression, all tested concentrations of ligand induced CD69 expression on and death of the same fraction of DP thymocytes, that is, no thymocyte was induced to differentiate without also being signaled to die (Fig. 2GoA). These data are superficially consistent with results indicating that potent agonists cannot induce positive selection without overriding induction of apoptotic cell death (42). Surprisingly, however, in the presence of ICAM-1 the induction of a given amount of cell death required the same or only slightly lower Ag concentrations, whereas the induction of a given number of high CD69-expressing cells occurred at significantly lower Ag concentrations, with a 5- to 10-fold concentration window opening up within which many cells could be induced to high CD69 expression without accompanying cell death (Fig. 2GoB). For example, at a concentration of 0.05 µM PCC88–104, 20.5, 27.6, and 24.3% of DP thymocytes were induced to die using EKAM 2.5-, EKAM 1.5-, and P13.9-presenting cells, respectively. However, 22.3, 75.1, and 74.2% of the remaining viable cells were induced to express CD69 under the same condi- tions. Because reactivity to some fibroblast lines was observed without adding any PCC peptide (Fig. 1GoA), the results shown in the figure have taken account of this and also of variations in the absolute levels of induced differentiation and death among different experiments by expressing the data as a percentage of the maximal response after subtraction of the values obtained with the same APCs not exposed to peptide (Fig. 2GoA). Results similar to those seen using APC with varying expression of ICAM-1 were obtained using Ab inhibition to interfere with ICAM-1 binding to its integrin receptor(s) (Fig. 3Go). Thus, ICAM-1 does not appear to substantially protect thymocytes against death induced by TCR signaling per se as previously concluded (11), but instead, it seems to selectively synergize with TCR signaling for thymocyte activation, permitting ligands in a specific concentration range to induce biologic responses associated with positive selection without apoptotic loss (37, 38).



View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 2. Contributions of ICAM-1 and B7.1 to stimulation of CD69 and death responses of thymocytes or CD69 and IL-2 responses of mature peripheral CD4+ T cells. Thymocytes or peripheral lymph node CD4+ T cells from H-2b AND TCR transgenic RAG-2-/- mice were incubated overnight with the indicated L cell APCs with or without the indicated concentrations of antigenic peptide. CD69 expression, cell death, and/or IL-2 production were measured, and the responses are presented as a percentage of the maximal response calculated as described in Materials and Methods. A, Data derived from the use of transfectants differing in B7.1 and/or ICAM-1 expression as APCs. B, Quantitation of thymic positive selection window.

 


View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 3. Differing roles of ICAM-1 and B7.1 costimulation in DP vs mature thymocyte responses to foreign agonist ligand. Thymocytes or peripheral lymph node CD4+ T cells from H-2b AND TCR transgenic RAG-2-/- mice were incubated overnight with I-Ek, B7.1, ICAM-1-expressing P13.9 cells as presenting cells with or without inhibiting B7.1, ICAM-1, or both using mAbs.

 
The effects of B7.1 were very different from those of ICAM-1. This cosignaling ligand has been claimed to specifically facilitate thymocyte cell death upon TCR ligation (8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15). However, when examined in a quantitative fashion in comparison to cell activation assessed by CD69 expression, it is clear that B7.1 acts to increase thymocyte sensitivity to agonist signaling by the TCR, without a selective change in either death or differentiation (CD69) responses (Figs. 2GoA and 3). Using assays for death only or analysis at only one ligand concentration, however, this effect would appear as a selective increase in cell loss, as these previous studies have reported.

It is also important to note that inhibition of B7.1 expression did not totally abrogate DP thymocyte CD69 responses or induction of death, whereas IL-2 production by peripheral CD4SP cells was reduced to nearly undetectable levels. These results suggest that B7/CD28 interaction is not required to induce immature thymocyte cell death (and therefore negative selection), and also that the signaling required for death in the thymus is not equivalent to the signaling cascade allowing IL-2 production at the peripheral level.

ICAM-1 and B7.1 show the same functionalities using variant ligands with partial agonist properties for mature AND T cells

The preceding data were obtained using a potent agonist ligand for the TCR. Although recent data (18, 47) indicate that variant peptides that create partial agonist or antagonist ligands for mature T cells act as weak agonists for DP, it was of interest to determine whether the roles of ICAM-1 and B7.1 revealed above were also true when these less potent ligands were employed as stimuli. Fig. 4Go shows that although using these weak ligands results in a striking shift in the overall dose response to a requirement for higher peptide concentrations for equivalent responses, the effects of ICAM-1 and B7.1 on the relationship between CD69 induction and cell death is similar for the P99 and Q99 variant peptides and the full agonist PCC peptide. Thus, ligands that may more closely simulate those involved in thymic positive selection do not reveal a different role for these counter-receptors from that seen using a strong ligand expected to mediate negative selection.



View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 4. ICAM-1 and B7.1 show the same functionalities using variant ligands with partial agonist properties for mature AND T cells. Thymocytes from H-2b AND TCR transgenic RAG-2-/- mice were incubated overnight with the indicated L cell APCs with the indicated peptide. CD69 expression and cell death were measured, and the responses are presented as a percentage of the maximal response calculated as described in Materials and Methods.

 

    Discussion
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Here we have used an in vitro model to perform a quantitative analysis of the differentiation and/or death responses of individual cells at distinct stages of T cell maturation in the presence of changing cosignaling environments. Our data do not support proposals that the CD28 pathway is linked uniquely to thymocyte death (8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15); rather, with strong agonist ligands this receptor/counter-receptor system appears to have the ability to synergize with multiple intracellular pathways, such as that involving Vav (48, 49, 50), and/or to augment TCR engagement of ligand, shifting the dose-response for many functional outcomes of TCR signaling. More interestingly, interaction with ICAM-1, which is very highly expressed by cortical epithelial cells contacting precursor CD4+CD8+ thymocytes (35), was shown to have the capacity to selectively amplify TCR signaling for differentiation in comparison to signaling for death. This opens a ligand concentration window within which the DP thymocyte can be signaled to differentiate without induction of apoptosis, even by strong agonist ligands, forming an initial pool of positively selected thymocytes capable of further maturation. These observations applied similarly to strong agonists and to weaker ligands with little or no capacity to trigger mature T cells with the AND TCR. The latter might be considered an approximation of the type of ligand involved in normal thymic selection, indicating that the effects of ICAM-1 and B7 that we observed are not peculiar to ligands that would only delete developing thymocytes.

Although many of these conclusions are based on analysis of CD69, CD4, and CD8 expression using an in vitro model and transfected cells for presentation, we have been able to show recently that the CD69+CD4lowCD8low thymocytes, generated either under the conditions described here with fibroblasts (unpublished observations) or using CD45-negative, nontransformed thymic stromal cells or dendritic cells (17) (see Footnote 2), show enhanced differentiation into functional CD4+ T cells in reaggregate thymic organ culture. Such findings clearly indicate that thymocytes induced in vitro under our conditions to acquire the CD69+CD4lowCD8low phenotype have initiated intracellular changes involved in positive selection, supporting the physiological relevance of the above conclusions concerning the roles of cosignals and TCR ligands in the selection process.

It is more difficult to provide such confirmatory data using either animals or organ cultures for our in vitro analysis of cell death, and questions have been raised about the validity of such in vitro models of negative selection. Thymic selection is not grossly disturbed in mice with targeted deletions in ICAM-1 (51, 52) (our unpublished observations). Only specific exons were targeted in these animals, however, and the resulting mice are thus not null (53). In addition, these animals still express alternative LFA-1 ligands such as ICAM-2. Thymic development has not been carefully studied in LFA-1 (54) or in CD43 (55) targeted mice. Functional redundancy in these pathways can complicate attempts to see the contribution of a single pathway when others are still active. Thus, the in vivo studies do not contradict our observations and might be considered less informative about what a molecule is capable of as opposed to what it is absolutely necessary for. Furthermore, our results are in agreement with the recent data reported by Dautigny et al. (56). Indeed, they found that although endogenous superantigen-driven thymic negative selection could occur at different steps during DP/SP cell transition, this event was never observed among CD69+CD4lowCD8low thymocytes, i.e., within the first subset to be generated upon TCR-mediated activation of immature DP cells. Numerous other reports have also reported that thymocytes can initiate selection and then be induced to undergo cell death at a later stage of development (57, 58, 59).

All these data suggest that strong agonist ligands can initiate thymic positive selection, and we have recently been able to directly demonstrate the generation of Ag-responsive mature T cells using TCR transgenic thymocytes and full agonist ligand to start the differentiation process (see Footnote 2). Thus, further mechanisms must exist that operate later in development to insure deletion of potentially autoreactive clones. Negative selection could result from dramatic changes in the thymic environment (a change possibly involving thymocyte migration from the thymic cortex to the thymic medulla) and/or changes in the perception of self ligands by thymocytes. We and others have recently shown that the signaling properties of TCR change during thymocyte maturation (18, 19, 20). Weak agonists for DP thymocytes lose potency during development, whereas sensitivity to strong agonists is maintained. These changes together with the lower expression of ICAM.1 on bone-marrow derived medullary stromal cells compared with epithelial cortical cells (35) are precisely those required for deletion of potentially autoreactive clones seeing potent self-ligands and for generation of a mature T cell pool possessing a wide margin of safety against activation by self ligands. This conclusion is consistent with and amplifies the findings of Page on the role of accessory molecules in thymocyte selection in fetal thymic organ culture (60), while agreeing with quantitative data on late negative selection by hemopoietic cells in the thymus (61). It also suggests that overt autoreactivity among peripheral T cells might be observed in animals with limited B7 expression on thymic presenting cells but intact cosignaling by presenting cells in lymphoid organs.

Some previous attempts to explain how mature T cells can receive an essential differentiation-promoting signal through the TCR upon self recognition without this leading to effector function, yet remain highly responsive to full activation upon recognition of a slight variant in ligand structure (foreign peptide:MHC molecule complexes), have treated the developmental process leading to this state in a largely one-dimensional way. Signaling by self-ligand recognition was presumed to occur at a specific stage of thymocyte development and to have a particular quantity or quality that defined its ability to promote differentiation vs death. Our results indicate that a one-time, one-place model for decision-making in the thymus is untenable, and that therefore a more multidimensional view is required to explain ligand-dependent thymic development and the properties of the mature T cell repertoire.


    Acknowledgments
 
We thank Dr. B. J. Fowlkes for mice and for discussion and Dr. Koji Yasutomo for sharing unpublished data.


    Footnotes
 
1 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Ronald N. Germain, Laboratory of Immunology, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Building 10, Room 11N-311, 10 Center Drive, MSC 1892, Bethesda, MD 20892-1892. Back

2 K. Yasutomo, B. Lucas, and R. N. Germain. Submitted for publication. Back

3 Abbreviations used in this paper: DP, double positive; RAG, recombinase-activating gene; PCC, pigeon cytochrome c; SP, single positive. Back

Received for publication March 24, 2000. Accepted for publication June 5, 2000.


    References
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 

  1. Robey, E., B. J. Fowlkes. 1994. Selective events in T cell development. Annu. Rev. Immunol. 12:675.[Medline]
  2. Fink, P. J., M. J. Bevan. 1995. Positive selection of thymocytes. Adv. Immunol. 59:99.[Medline]
  3. Von Boehmer, H., H. Teh, P. Kisielow. 1989. The thymus selects the useful, neglects the useless and destroys the harmful. Immunol. Today 10:57.[Medline]
  4. Von Boehmer, H.. 1994. Positive selection of lymphocytes. Cell 76:219.[Medline]
  5. Kisielow, P., H. Blüthmann, U. W. Staerz, M. Steimetz, H. Von Boehmer. 1988. Tolerance in T-cell-receptor transgenic mice involves deletion of nonmature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Nature 333:742.[Medline]
  6. Kappler, J. W., N. Roehm, P. Marrack. 1987. T cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymus. Cell 49:273.[Medline]
  7. Allen, P. M.. 1994. Peptides in positive and negative selection: a delicate balance. Cell 76:593.[Medline]
  8. Punt, J. A., B. A. Osborne, Y. Takahama, S. O. Sharrow, A. Singer. 1994. Negative selection of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes by T cell receptor-induced apoptosis requires a costimulatory signal that can be provided by CD28. J. Exp. Med. 179:709.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  9. Amsen, D., A. M. Kruisbeek. 1996. CD28–B7 interactions function to co-stimulate clonal deletion of double-positive thymocytes. Int. Immunol. 8:1927.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  10. Vukmanovic, S.. 1996. The molecular jury: deciding whether immature thymocytes should live or die. J. Exp. Med. 184:305.[Free Full Text]
  11. Kishimoto, H., Z. Cai, A. Brunmark, M. R. Jackson, P. A. Peterson, J. Sprent. 1996. Differing roles for B7 and intercellular adhesion molecule-1 in negative selection of thymocytes. J. Exp. Med. 184:531.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  12. Kishimoto, H., J. Sprent. 1997. Negative selection in the thymus includes semimature T cells. J. Exp. Med. 185:263.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  13. Kishimoto, H., C. D. Suhr, J. Sprent. 1998. A role for Fas in negative selection of thymocytes in vivo. J. Exp. Med. 187:1427.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  14. Kishimoto, H., J. Sprent. 1999. Several different cell surface molecules control negative selection of medullary thymocytes. J. Exp. Med. 190:65.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  15. Lesage, S., J. Charron, G. Winslow, P. Hugo. 1997. Induction of thymocyte deletion by purified single peptide/major histocompatibility complex ligands. J. Immunol. 159:2078.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  16. Nakagawa, T., W. Roth, P. Wong, A. Nelson, A. Farr, J. Deussing, J. A. Villadangos, H. Ploegh, C. Peters, A. Y. Rudensky. 1998. Cathepsin L: critical role in Ii degradation and CD4 T cell selection in the thymus. Science 280:450.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  17. Yasutomo, K., C. Doyle, L. Miele, R. N. Germain. 2000. The duration of antigen receptor signalling determines CD4+ versus CD8+ T-cell lineage fate. Nature 404:506.[Medline]
  18. Lucas, B., I. Stefanova, K. Yasutomo, N. Dautigny, R. N. Germain. 1999. Divergent changes in the sensitivity of maturing T cells to structurally related ligands underlies formation of a useful T cell repertoire. Immunity 10:367.[Medline]
  19. Davey, G. M., S. L. Schober, B. T. Endrizzi, A. K. Dutcher, S. C. Jameson, K. A. Hogquist. 1998. Preselection thymocytes are more sensitive to T cell receptor stimulation than mature T cells. J. Exp. Med. 188:1867.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  20. Peterson, D. A., R. J. DiPaolo, O. Kanagawa, E. R. Unanue. 1999. Negative selection of immature thymocytes by a few peptide-MHC complexes: differential sensitivity of immature and mature T cells. J. Immunol. 162:3117.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  21. Kaye, J., M. L. Hsu, M. E. Sauron, J. C. Jameson, R. J. Gascoigne, S. M. Hedrick. 1989. Selective development of CD4+ T cell in transgenic mice expressing a class II MHC-restricted antigen receptor. Nature 341:746.[Medline]
  22. Shinkai, Y., G. Rathbun, K. P. Lam, E. M. Oltz, V. Stewart, M. Mendelsohn, J. Charron, M. Datta, F. Young, A. M. Stall, et al 1992. RAG-2-deficient mice lack mature lymphocytes owing to inability to initiate V(D)J rearrangement. Cell 68:855.[Medline]
  23. Margulies, D. H., G. A. Evans, K. Ozato, O. R. Camerini, K. Tanaka, E. Appella, J. G. Seidman. 1983. Expression of H-2Dd and H-2Ld mouse major histocompatibility antigen genes in L cells after DNA-mediated gene transfer. J. Immunol. 130:463.[Abstract]
  24. Ding, L., P. S. Linsley, L.-Y. Huang, R. N. Germain, E. M. Shevach. 1993. IL-10 inhibits macrophage costimulatory activity by selectively inhibiting the up-regulation of B7 expression. J. Immunol. 151:1224.[Abstract]
  25. Siu, G., S. M. Hedrick, A. A. Brian. 1989. Isolation of the murine intercellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1) gene: ICAM. 1 enhances antigen-specific T cell activation. J. Immunol. 143:3813.[Abstract]
  26. Lucas, B., R. N. Germain. 1996. Unexpectedly complex regulation of CD4/CD8 coreceptor expression supports a revised model for CD4+CD8+ thymocyte differentiation. Immunity 5:461.[Medline]
  27. Boehme, S. A., M. J. Lenardo. 1993. Propriocidal apoptosis of mature T lymphocytes occurs at S phase of the cell cycle. Eur. J. Immunol. 23:1552.[Medline]
  28. Combadière, B., C. Reis e Sousa, R. N. Germain, M. J. Lenardo. 1998. Selective induction of apoptosis in mature T lymphocytes by variant T cell receptor ligands. J. Exp. Med. 187:349.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  29. Duke, R. C., J. J. Cohen, S. A. Boehme, M. J. Lenardo, C. D. Surh, H. Kishimoto, J. Sprent. 1995. Morphological, Biochemical and Flow Cytometry Assays of Apoptosis John Wiley & Sons, New York.
  30. Yamashita, I., T. Nagata, T. Tada, T. Nakayama. 1993. CD69 cell surface expression identifies developing thymocytes which audition for T cell antigen receptor-mediated positive selection. Int. Immunol 5:1139.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  31. Swat, W., M. Dessing, H. von Boehmer, P. Kisielow. 1993. CD69 expression during selection and maturation of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Eur. J. Immunol. 23:739.[Medline]
  32. Lucas, B., F. Vasseur, C. Pénit. 1994. Production, selection, and maturation of thymocytes with high surface density of TCR. J. Immunol. 153:53.[Abstract]
  33. Kaye, J., N. J. Vasquez, S. M. Hedrick. 1992. Involvement of the same region of the T cell antigen receptor in thymic selection and foreign peptide recognition. J. Immunol. 148:3342.[Abstract]
  34. Matechak, E. O., N. Killeen, S. M. Hedrick, B. J. Fowlkes. 1996. MHC class II-specific T cells can develop in the CD8 lineage when CD4 is absent. Immunity 4:337.[Medline]
  35. Volkmann, A., T. Zal, B. Stockinger. 1997. Antigen-presenting cells in the thymus that can negatively select MHC class II-restricted T cells recognizing a circulating self antigen. J. Immunol. 158:693.[Abstract]
  36. Degermann, S., C. D. Surh, L. H. Glimcher, J. Sprent, D. Lo. 1994. B7 expression on thymic medullary epithelium correlates with epithelium-mediated deletion of Vß5+ thymocytes. J. Immunol. 152:3254.[Abstract]
  37. Sebzda, E., V. A. Wallace, J. Mayer, R. S. M. Yeung, T. W. Mak, P. S. Ohashi. 1994. Positive and negative thymocyte selection induced by different concentrations of a single peptide. Science 263:1615.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  38. Ashton-Rickardt, P. G., A. Bandeira, J. R. Delaney, L. van Kaer, H.-P. Pircher, R. M. Zinkernagel, S. Tonegawa. 1994. Evidence for a differential avidity model of T cell selection in the thymus. Cell 76:651.[Medline]
  39. Ashton-Rickardt, P. G., L. van Kaer, T. N. M. Schumacher, H. L. Ploegh, S. Tonegawa. 1993. Peptide contributes to the specificity of positive selection of CD8+ T cells in the thymus. Cell 73:1041.[Medline]
  40. Hogquist, K. A., S. C. Jameson, W. R. Heath, J. L. Howard, M. J. Bevan, F. R. Carbone. 1994. T cell receptor antagonist peptides induce positive selection. Cell 76:17.[Medline]
  41. Hogquist, K. A., S. C. Jameson, M. J. Bevan. 1994. The ligand for positive selection of T lymphocytes in the thymus. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 6:273.[Medline]
  42. Hogquist, K. A., S. C. Jameson, M. J. Bevan. 1995. Strong agonist ligands for the T cell receptor do not mediate positive selection of functional CD8+ T cells. Immunity 3:79.[Medline]
  43. Lucas, B., G. Marodon, C. Pénit. 1996. CD4lowTCRint thymocytes do not belong to the CD8 lineage maturation pathway. J. Immunol. 156:1743.[Abstract]
  44. Hogquist, K. A., A. J. Tomlinson, W. C. Kieper, M. A. McGargill, S. Naylor, S. C. Jameson. 1997. Identification of a naturally occurring ligand for positive selection. Immunity 6:389.[Medline]
  45. Groves, T., M. Parsons, N. G. Miyamoto, C. J. Guidos. 1997. TCR engagement of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes in vitro induces early aspects of positive selection, but not apoptosis. J. Immunol. 158:65.[Abstract]
  46. Sant’Angelo, D. B., B. Lucas, P. G. Waterbury, B. Cohen, T. Brabb, J. Goverman, R. N. Germain, Jr C. A. Janeway. 1998. A molecular map of T cell development. Immunity 9:179.[Medline]
  47. Smyth, L. A., O. Williams, R. D. J. Norton, O. Acuto, S. C. Ley, D. Kioussis. 1998. Altered peptide ligands induce quantitatively but not qualitatively different intracellular signals in primary thymocytes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 95:8193.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  48. Sajolin, K. V., J. Zhang, T. L. Delovitch. 1999. TCR and CD28 are coupled via ZAP-70 to the activation of the vav/Rac-1-/PAK-1/p38 MAPK signaling pathway. J. Immunol. 163:844.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  49. Chiang, Y. J., H. K. Kole, K. Brown, M. Naramura, S. Fukuhara, R. J. Hu, I. K. Jang, J. S. Gutkind, E. Shevach, H. Gu. 2000. Cbl-b regulates the CD28 dependence of T-cell activation. Nature 403:216.[Medline]
  50. Villalba, M., N. Coudronniere, M. Deckert, E. Teixeiro, P. Mas, A. Altman. 2000. A novel functional interaction between vav and PKC{theta} is required for TCR-induced T cell activation. Immunity 12:151.[Medline]
  51. Sligh, J. E., C. M. Ballantyne, S. S. Rich, H. K. Hawkins, D. W. Smith, A. Bradley, A. L. Beaudet. 1993. Inflammatory and immune responses are impaired in mice deficient in intercellular adhesion molecule 1. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90:8529.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  52. Xu, H., J. A. Gonzalo, Y. St. Pierre, I. R. Williams, T. S. Kupper, R. S. Cotran, T. A. Springer, J. Gutierrez-Ramos. 1994. Leukocytosis and resistance to septic shock in intercellular adhesion molecule 1-deficient mice. J. Exp. Med. 180:95.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  53. King, P. D., E. T. Sandberg, A. Selvakumar, P. Fang, A. L. Beaudet, B. Dupont. 1995. Novel isoforms of murine intercellular adhesion molecule-1 generated by alternative RNA splicing. J. Immunol. 154:6080.[Abstract]
  54. Schmits, R., T. M. Kündig, D. M. Baker, G. Shumaker, J. J. L. Simard, G. Duncan, A. Wakeham, A. Shahinian, A. Van der Heiden, M. F. Bachmann, et al 1996. LFA-1-deficient mice show normal CTL responses to virus but fail to reject immunogenic tumor. J. Exp. Med. 183:1415.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  55. Manjunath, N., M. Correa, M. Ardman, B. Ardman. 1995. Negative regulation of T-cell adhesion and activation by CD43. Nature 377:535.[Medline]
  56. Dautigny, N., A. Le Campion, B. Lucas. 1999. Timing and casting for actors of thymic negative selection. J. Immunol. 162:1294.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  57. Guidos, C. J., J. S. Danska, C. G. Fathman, I. L. Weissman. 1990. T cell receptor-mediated negative selection of autoreactive T lymphocytes precursors occurs after commitment to the CD4 or CD8 lineages. J. Exp. Med. 172:835.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  58. Marodon, G., B. Rocha. 1994. Activation and "deletion" of self-reactive mature and immature T cells during ontogeny of Mls-1a mice: implications for neonatal tolerance induction. Int. Immunol. 6:1899.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  59. Huang, L.-Y., J. P. M. van Meerwijk, E. K. Bikoff, R. N. Germain. 1996. Comparison of thymocyte development in normal and invariant chain-deficient mice provides evidence that maturation-related changes in TCR and co-receptor levels play a critical role in cell fate. Int. Immunol. 8:1429.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  60. Page, D. M.. 1999. Thymic selection and autoreactivity are regulated by multiple coreceptors involved in T cell activation. J. Immunol. 163:3577.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  61. van Meerwijk, J. P. M., S. Marguerat, R. K. Lees, R. N. Germain, B. J. Fowlkes, H. R. MacDonald. 1997. Quantitative impact of thymic clonal deletion on the T cell repertoire. J. Exp. Med. 185:377.[Abstract/Free Full Text]



This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
BloodHome page
J. Kurtz, F. Raval, C. Vallot, J. Der, and M. Sykes
CTLA-4 on alloreactive CD4 T cells interacts with recipient CD80/86 to promote tolerance
Blood, April 9, 2009; 113(15): 3475 - 3484.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
FASEB J.Home page
Y. Gong, R. Zhang, J. Zhang, L. Xu, F. Zhang, W. Xu, Y. Wang, Y. Chu, and S. Xiong
{alpha}-Dystroglycan is involved in positive selection of thymocytes by participating in immunological synapse formation
FASEB J, May 1, 2008; 22(5): 1426 - 1439.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Mol. Cell. Biol.Home page
H. G. Kasler and E. Verdin
Histone Deacetylase 7 Functions as a Key Regulator of Genes Involved in both Positive and Negative Selection of Thymocytes
Mol. Cell. Biol., July 15, 2007; 27(14): 5184 - 5200.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
J. J. Engelhardt, T. J. Sullivan, and J. P. Allison
CTLA-4 Overexpression Inhibits T Cell Responses through a CD28-B7-Dependent Mechanism
J. Immunol., July 15, 2006; 177(2): 1052 - 1061.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
J. N. Wu, S. Gheith, N. A. Bezman, Q.-H. Liu, L. V. Fostel, A. M. Swanson, B. D. Freedman, G. A. Koretzky, and E. J. Peterson
Adhesion- and Degranulation-Promoting Adapter Protein Is Required for Efficient Thymocyte Development and Selection.
J. Immunol., June 1, 2006; 176(11): 6681 - 6689.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
E. Hailman and P. M. Allen
Inefficient Cell Spreading and Cytoskeletal Polarization by CD4+CD8+ Thymocytes: Regulation by the Thymic Environment
J. Immunol., October 15, 2005; 175(8): 4847 - 4857.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
T. K. Starr, M. A. Daniels, M. M. Lucido, S. C. Jameson, and K. A. Hogquist
Thymocyte Sensitivity and Supramolecular Activation Cluster Formation Are Developmentally Regulated: A Partial Role for Sialylation
J. Immunol., November 1, 2003; 171(9): 4512 - 4520.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
K. J. Hare, J. Pongracz, E. J. Jenkinson, and G. Anderson
Modeling TCR Signaling Complex Formation in Positive Selection
J. Immunol., September 15, 2003; 171(6): 2825 - 2831.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
J. E. Buhlmann, S. K. Elkin, and A. H. Sharpe
A Role for the B7-1/B7-2:CD28/CTLA-4 Pathway During Negative Selection
J. Immunol., June 1, 2003; 170(11): 5421 - 5428.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
L. Bertry-Coussot, B. Lucas, C. Danel, L. Halbwachs-Mecarelli, J.-F. Bach, L. Chatenoud, and P. Lemarchand
Long-Term Reversal of Established Autoimmunity upon Transient Blockade of the LFA-1/Intercellular Adhesion Molecule-1 Pathway
J. Immunol., April 1, 2002; 168(7): 3641 - 3648.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
A. Le Campion, B. Lucas, N. Dautigny, S. Leaument, F. Vasseur, and C. Penit
Quantitative and Qualitative Adjustment of Thymic T Cell Production by Clonal Expansion of Premigrant Thymocytes
J. Immunol., February 15, 2002; 168(4): 1664 - 1671.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
JEMHome page
I. Corre, M. Gomez, S. Vielkind, and D. A. Cantrell
Analysis of Thymocyte Development Reveals that the GTPase RhoA Is a Positive Regulator of T Cell Receptor Responses In Vivo
J. Exp. Med., September 24, 2001; 194(7): 903 - 914.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
K. Yasutomo, B. Lucas, and R. N. Germain
TCR Signaling for Initiation and Completion of Thymocyte Positive Selection Has Distinct Requirements for Ligand Quality and Presenting Cell Type
J. Immunol., September 15, 2000; 165(6): 3015 - 3022.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Request Permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Lucas, B.
Right arrow Articles by Germain, R. N.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Lucas, B.
Right arrow Articles by Germain, R. N.


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS