The JI
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     
 


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Request Permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Thornton, S.
Right arrow Articles by Hirsch, R.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Thornton, S.
Right arrow Articles by Hirsch, R.
The Journal of Immunology, 2000, 165: 1557-1563.
Copyright © 2000 by The American Association of Immunologists

Heterogeneous Effects of IL-2 on Collagen-Induced Arthritis1

Sherry Thornton*, Gregory P. Boivin{dagger}, Kwang N. Kim*, Fred D. Finkelman{ddagger} and Raphael Hirsch2,*

* William S. Rowe Division of Rheumatology, Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45229; {dagger} Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45267; {ddagger} University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, OH 45267; and § Cincinnati Veterans Administration Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45220


    Abstract
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
IL-2 is generally considered a pro-inflammatory cytokine that exacerbates Th1-mediated disease states, such as autoimmune arthritis. Consistent with this role for IL-2, recent studies from our laboratory demonstrate that IL-2 mRNA is markedly increased during the acute stage of collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), an animal model of rheumatoid arthritis. To further define the role of IL-2 in CIA, the levels of IL-2 protein and its receptor and the effects of IL-2 administration were analyzed during CIA. IL-2 protein and IL-2R were preferentially expressed at disease onset, compared with later stages of disease. Administration of recombinant human IL-2 (rhIL-2) at, or just before, disease onset exacerbated disease; surprisingly, rhIL-2 given before disease onset inhibited CIA, associated with reduced cellular and humoral responses to type II collagen. Determination of in vivo serum levels of Th1 and Th2 cytokines in response to rhIL-2 treatment demonstrated that IFN-{gamma}, but not IL-4, was markedly up-regulated in response to IL-2. In mice treated with anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab, both early and late IL-2 administration exacerbated CIA. Thus, IL-2 can have two opposite effects on autoimmune arthritis, a direct stimulatory effect and an indirect suppressive effect that is mediated by IFN-{gamma}.


    Introduction
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Cytokines are major mediators of inflammation in autoimmune arthritides such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA)3 (reviewed in Ref. 1). A myriad of cytokines are found within the rheumatoid joint. Some appear to exacerbate disease, whereas others may down-regulate inflammation. In many cases, their precise roles are, as yet, incompletely defined. A growing body of evidence from both animal models of arthritis and human RA suggests that Th2-type cytokines, such as IL-4 and IL-10, can protect against arthritis, whereas Th1-type cytokines, such as IL-2 and IFN-{gamma}, can be pro-inflammatory (2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12).

Support for this concept comes from a number of observations. The RA synovium is infiltrated with CD4+ T cells of the Th1 phenotype (13). In murine collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), a model of RA, administration of IFN-{gamma} can exacerbate disease (14, 15), and administration of anti-IL-2R Abs can inhibit disease onset (16). Thus, it is surprising that most studies of cytokines in RA have failed to detect IL-2 protein in RA synovial fluid (17). Recent studies from our laboratory suggest that the failure to detect IL-2 may relate to the timing of synovial sampling. Because of the difficulties in serially sampling the synovium of patients with RA, our laboratory has used the murine collagen-induced arthritis model to analyze mRNA cytokine patterns at various stages of autoimmune arthritis. These studies demonstrated that IL-2 mRNA levels are dramatically up-regulated in early CIA and that the expression of IL-2 mRNA declines during the chronic stage of disease (18). Further support for a possible role for IL-2 in early arthritis comes from the recent demonstration that IL-2 protein is significantly increased in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with early, but not late, RA (19).

IL-2 has been shown to regulate autoimmune processes in mice. IL-2-deficient mice develop autoimmune disorders, such as ulcerative colitis-like disease and generalized autoimmune hemolytic anemia (20, 21). Interestingly, these IL-2-deficient mice exhibit increased proliferation of both T and B cells, even though IL-2 has been characterized as a positive regulator of T cell proliferation. The development of autoimmune diseases in IL-2-deficient mice suggests a negative regulatory role for IL-2 in autoimmune diseases that may involve regulation of T and B cell proliferation.

These observations suggest that IL-2 might play a more important role in autoimmune arthritis than has previously been appreciated. To further define the role of IL-2 in CIA, the levels of IL-2 protein and its receptor, as well as the effects of IL-2 administration, were analyzed during the course of disease. These studies resulted in the unexpected observation that, although IL-2 is pro-inflammatory in established disease, it can play an anti-inflammatory role during early stages of disease induction. Furthermore, our studies revealed that IL-2-induced IFN-{gamma} mediates this early suppression of CIA, demonstrating the complex regulatory network of cytokine interactions involved in autoimmune arthritis.


    Materials and Methods
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
Animals

Male DBA/1 mice were purchased from The Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME). Mice were cared for according to American Association of Laboratory Animal Care guidelines. Mice were injected i.p. twice daily with 30,000 IU of recombinant human IL-2 (rhIL-2; Chiron, Emoryville, CA) in 0.5 ml of HBSS. All experimental procedures were approved by the Animal Care Committee of the Children’s Hospital Research Foundation of Cincinnati.

Type II collagen (CII) immunization

Bovine CII (Elastin Products, Owensville, MO) was dissolved in 0.1 M acetic acid at a concentration of 2 mg/ml and stored at -70°C until use. For immunization, 100 µg of CII was emulsified with an equal volume of CFA (2 mg/ml) and administered intradermally at the base of the tail of mice 6–8 wk of age. A booster, administered as above, was given 21 days after the primary injection. CII for footpad injections was prepared as above and consisted of one 100-µl injection into each footpad.

Clinical assessment of arthritis

Mouse paws were scored for arthritis, as previously described (22), using a macroscopic scoring system ranging from 0 to 4 (0, no swelling or redness; 1, swelling/redness of paw or one joint; 2, two joints involved; 3, more than two joints involved; and 4, severe arthritis of the entire paw and joints). The arthritic score for each mouse is the sum of the scores of all four paws.

RNase protection assay

Paws were quick frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -70°C. Frozen paws were homogenized with a polytron Tissue Tearor (Biospec Products, Bartlesville, OK) in appropriate volumes of RNA Stat 60 (Tel-Test, Friendswood, TX). RNA was extracted from the tissue homogenates according to the manufacturer’s instructions. RNA concentrations were determined by spectrophotometry.

Quantitation of IL-2 mRNA was performed on 5 µg of total RNA utilizing the Riboquant Multiprobe RNase Protection Assay System (PharMingen, San Diego, CA) following manufacturer’s instructions. [{alpha}-32P]UTP-labeled anti-sense RNA probes were synthesized by in vitro transcription of cDNA templates for IL-2 and GAPDH. DNA templates were degraded by DNase I digestion, and probes were purified by phenol/chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation, with subsequent hybridization to total RNA at 56°C overnight. Samples were treated with RNase A+T1, and double-stranded RNA was purified by phenol/chloroform extraction and precipitated with ethanol and salt. Samples were resuspended in loading dye and electrophoresed on a 5% denaturing polyacrylamide gel. The gel was dried and subjected to PhosphorImage analysis using a Storm 860 and ImageQuant software (Molecular Dynamics, Sunnyvale, CA). The mRNA level of IL-2 is expressed as the ratio of the PhosphorImager units of IL-2 to those of GAPDH from the same RNA sample.

Protein extraction from paws

Mice were sacrificed and paws minced in 1 ml of ice-cold PBS containing 2 mM PMSF and 1% Triton X-100. Tissues were placed on ice and homogenized. Homogenates were centrifuged at 2000 rpm and 4°C for 5 min to pellet cellular debris, and the supernatant was frozen in aliquots at -70°C until assayed. Protein concentrations were determined with bicinchoninic acid solution (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) using BSA as a standard.

IL-2 ELISA

IL-2 levels in paw homogenates were determined by ELISA as follows: a 96-well flat-bottom plate was coated with anti-IL-2 mAb (JES6-1A12; PharMingen) at a concentration of 5 µg/ml in PBS and incubated at 4°C overnight. Plates were washed with PBS-Tween 20 and blocked for 40 min with PBS containing 1% BSA. After washing, 40-µl aliquots of thawed paw homogenate were added to duplicate wells and incubated for 40 min. Plates were washed again, and biotin-labeled anti-IL-2 (JES6-5H4; PharMingen) at a concentration of 5 µg/ml in PBS was added and incubated for 40 min. After washing, streptavidin-peroxidase (Kirkegaard & Perry Laboratories, Gaithersburg, MD) was added. Plates were developed with Peroxidase Substrate System 2,2'-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) (Kirkegaard & Perry Laboratories). The plates were read at 405 nm in a microtiter plate reader (Dynex, Chantilly, VA). OD readings for the duplicate wells were averaged. Units of IL-2 in experimental samples were calculated by using a standard curve generated with dilutions of purified recombinant mouse IL-2 (PharMingen).

Immunohistochemistry

Staining for IL-2R{alpha} was performed on 8-micron frozen sections of paws using a Techmate 500 automatic immunostainer (Ventana, Tucson, AZ). All steps were performed at room temperature, and all rinses were with 1x PBS. Sections were blocked with CAS block (Zymed, San Francisco, CA) for 8 min. A biotin-conjugated rat anti-mouse CD25 mAb was used as the primary Ab at 2 µg/ml (PharMingen). The slides were exposed to the primary Ab for 1 h and then to streptavidin-peroxidase for 15 min. Aminoethyl carbazole (Zymed; four incubations at 5 min each) was used as the substrate. Sections were counterstained with Mayer’s hematoxylin.

Anti-CII Ab titers

Titers of anti-CII Abs in the serum samples were determined by ELISA, as previously described (22). All samples were measured in duplicate. Peroxidase-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG (Kirkegaard & Perry Laboratories) was used to measure CII-specific total IgG. IgG1 and IgG2a were measured using biotinylated rat anti-mouse IgG1 or IgG2a (PharMingen) and then streptavidin-peroxidase. Plates were developed with Peroxidase Substrate System 2,2'-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulfonic acid). The plates were read at 405 nm, as described above. OD readings for the duplicate wells were averaged. A serum sample consisting of pooled serum from control mice was tested at various dilutions and used as a standard to generate a curve from which relative titers of the other serum samples were calculated.

T cell IFN-{gamma} production

Draining lymph nodes were removed from mice and pooled to prepare single cell suspensions. Cells were plated in triplicate at a concentration of 5 x 105 cells/well in the presence of 300 µg/ml heat-denatured CII (10 min, 56°C) or 50 µl of 2C11 containing culture supernatant (anti-CD3). Supernatants were harvested at 48 h and analyzed by ELISA as described (22).

In vivo cytokine production

Serum levels of IL-4 and IFN-{gamma} were measured using the Cincinnati Cytokine Capture Assay (23). Mice were treated twice daily with rhIL-2 (30,000 U) for 2 days and once on the third day. Two hours after the last IL-2 administration, 10 µg of biotin-labeled anti-IL-4 (BVD4-1D11) or 50 µg of anti-IFN-{gamma} (R4-6A2) was administered i.v. via the lateral tail vein. Mice were bled 3 h later, and serum was collected and analyzed for IL-4 and IFN-{gamma} levels by ELISA as described (23).

Statistical analysis

Intergroup differences were assessed for statistical significance by the Mann-Whitney U test for qualitative data. The generalized Wilcoxon (Gehan) test was used to compare the two "survival curves." To test frequency data for statistical significance, {chi}2 was used. To compare baseline characteristics of the two groups, we used the independent two-tailed for parametric data t test. Comparisons of more than two means were done using the one-way ANOVA. Tukey’s honest significant difference multiple comparison test was used for pair-wise comparisons if significance was found by ANOVA. The p values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant, and all p values shown are unadjusted for multiple comparison. All calculations were performed by means of the software package SPSS-PC (version 8.0 for Windows, Chicago, IL).


    Results
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
IL-2 and IL-2R are preferentially expressed during the early stages of CIA

After immunization of DBA/1 mice with CII on days 0 and 21, arthritis is first observed between days 26 and 35. We have previously demonstrated that IL-2 mRNA levels are markedly increased in early CIA (18). The increase in IL-2 mRNA expression levels is first observed on day 28 and correlates with disease severity (Fig. 1GoA). To determine whether the presence of mRNA for IL-2 correlated with protein levels, paw homogenates from arthritic mice were analyzed for IL-2 at various times during disease evolution (Fig. 1GoB). IL-2 protein was detected during both acute disease (day 35) and chronic disease (day 49).



View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 1. IL-2 mRNA and protein expression during CIA. A, Mice were sacrificed on days indicated and IL-2 mRNA levels were examined by RNase protection assay. Symbols represent the mean ± the SEM of three or more paw RNAs (n = normal RNA from unimmunized mouse paws). B, Mice were sacrificed at days 35 and 49 of arthritis, and 40 µl of paw extract was analyzed for IL-2 activity by ELISA. Columns represent the mean values ± the SEM of four paw extracts.

 
Up-regulation of the {alpha} subunit of the IL-2R can be caused by IL-2 gene activation and the presence of IL-2 protein (24, 25). To determine whether IL-2R{alpha} is expressed in synovium of arthritic mice, joints from mice with acute (day 35) and chronic (day 49) CIA were analyzed by immunohistochemistry (Fig. 2Go). High levels of IL-2R{alpha} were detected on day 35 in paws with severe arthritis (score of 4; Fig. 2GoA). This IL-2R{alpha} expression required the presence of active synovitis because nonarthritic, day-35 paws (score of 0; Fig. 2GoB) and pre-arthritic, day-21 paws (data not shown) expressed little IL-2R{alpha}. In contrast to early CIA, little IL-2R{alpha} was observed in chronic disease (day 49), regardless of the severity of arthritis (Fig. 2Go, C and D). These observations suggest a functional role for IL-2 during the early stages of established CIA.



View larger version (137K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 2. IL-2R{alpha} expression at days 35 and 49 of CIA. Mice were sacrificed and paws were frozen. Sections were stained for IL-2R{alpha} with anti-CD25 Ab. A, Day 35, score = 0; B, day 35, score = 4; C, day 49, score = 0; D, day 49, score = 4.

 
IL-2 exacerbates established CIA

To further define the role of IL-2 in established CIA, rhIL-2 (30,000 U i.p. twice daily) was administered for 7 days to CII-immunized mice starting one day after the first clinical manifestation of CIA (average day of onset, day 28). Mice were scored for arthritis daily. IL-2 significantly exacerbated established disease (Fig. 3Go), demonstrating that IL-2 is pro-inflammatory in established CIA.



View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 3. Effects of administration of rhIL-2 on established CIA. HBSS (n = 15) or rhIL-2 (n = 14) was administered to CII-treated mice 1 day after onset of disease. Mice were scored as described. *, p <= 0.01.

 
To determine whether IL-2 had an effect when administered immediately before clinical disease onset, rhIL-2 was administered for 7 days, beginning at the time of the CII booster (day 21). Treatment with rhIL-2 from day 21 to 28 significantly hastened the onset of arthritis and increased the severity of disease (Fig. 4Go).



View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 4. Effects of administration of rhIL-2 with the CII booster on CIA. Mice were immunized with CII in CFA at days 0 and 21. rhIL-2 (60,000 U/mouse/day) or HBSS was administered i.p. from days 21 to 28. Mice were scored for arthritis daily as described. The median arthritic score (A) and the percentage of mice exhibiting arthritis (B) are shown. At least eight mice/group were analyzed. *, p <= 0.05. In B, comparison of survival experience was done using the Generalized Wilcoxon statistic p < 0.05.

 
IL-2 inhibits induction of CIA

The above studies demonstrate that IL-2 is pro-inflammatory when administered during established CIA or just before development of clinical disease. These findings are not unexpected, given that the onset of CIA is dependent on T cell and B cell responses to CII (26, 27, 28, 29, 30), which are well-established by the time of the booster administration on day 21 (31). Because IL-2 can enhance T cell responses to Ag (32), we hypothesized that a similar exacerbation of CIA would be observed if IL-2 was administered between the first and second CII immunization. Surprisingly, when rhIL-2 was administered from day 14 to 21, a significant decrease in both the incidence and severity of arthritis was observed (Fig. 5Go).



View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 5. Effects of administration of rhIL-2 before the CII booster on CIA. Mice were immunized with CII in CFA at days 0 and 21. rhIL-2 or HBSS was administered from day 14 to 21. Mice were scored for arthritis daily as described. The median arthritic index of 14 mice/group (A) and the percentage of mice affected (B) are shown. *, p <= 0.05.

 
IL-2 inhibits T and B cell responses to CII

To determine the mechanism by which early administration of IL-2 inhibited CIA, T and B cell responses to CII were measured in mice treated with IL-2. Mice were immunized with CII on day 0 in the footpad. IL-2 was administered from day 7 to 14, at which time mice were sacrificed, and draining popliteal and inguinal lymph nodes were harvested. Lymph node cells were stimulated in vitro with CII or anti-CD3 (2C11). Administration of IL-2 significantly suppressed secretion of IFN-{gamma} in response to CII and 2C11 in lymph node cell cultures (Fig. 6Go).



View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 6. Effects of administration of rhIL-2 on IFN-{gamma} secretion from T cells. Mice were immunized with CII on day 0 in the footpad. Six mice per group were given rhIL-2 or HBSS from day 7 to 14, after which they were sacrificed and lymph node cells were cultured in the presence of 300 µg/ml CII (A) or 50 µl of 2C11 culture supernatant (anti-CD3) (B). After 48 h, culture supernatants were assayed for IFN-{gamma} activity by ELISA. Columns represent the mean values ± the SEM of six animals. *, p <= 0.05.

 
Anti-CII Abs are a prominent characteristic of CIA. This Ab production is dependent on T cell help, in that T cell depletion before CII immunization prevents their development (28, 30). To determine whether the observed inhibitory effects of IL-2 administration on T cells had an impact on the B cell response to CII, sera from CII-immunized mice treated with rhIL-2 from day 14 to 21 were analyzed for anti-CII Abs. IL-2 decreased production of IgG Abs to CII (Fig. 7Go). The Th1-dependent IgG2a Ab response was also inhibited. This inhibition did not reflect a generalized B cell suppression, in that anti-CII IgG1 levels measured from day 28 sera were not inhibited.



View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 7. Effects of administration of rhIL-2 on the humoral response to CII. Mice were treated at days 0 and 21 with CII and were given rhIL-2 or HBSS from day 14 to 21 of CIA. Mice were bled on days 28 (A) and 48 (B), and samples were analyzed in duplicate for anti-CII Ab production by ELISA. Dilutions of a single serum sample from a CII-immunized mouse were used to generate a standard curve from which relative titers of the remaining samples were calculated. Columns represent the mean values ± the SEM of at least four animals. *, p <= 0.05.

 
rhIL-2 administration induces a Th1-type response

Because both inhibitory and pro-inflammatory effects of IL-2 on CIA were observed, we wanted to determine whether administration of rhIL-2 affected cytokine production, and, if so, whether it stimulated a predominantly IFN-{gamma} (type 1) or IL-4 (type 2) cytokine response. To address this issue, we compared in vivo serum levels of IFN-{gamma} and IL-4 in IL-2-treated or naive mice. Upon rhIL-2 treatment, a marked increase in the serum levels of IFN-{gamma}, but not IL-4, were observed (Fig. 8Go).



View larger version (10K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 8. In vivo production of cytokines in response to rhIL-2 administration. Mice were given 30,000 U of rhIL-2 or HBSS i.p. twice daily. On the second day, biotinylated Abs to either IL-4 or IFN-{gamma} were given i.v. 2 h after rhIL-2 injection. Mice were bled 3 h later and serum was collected. ELISAs quantitating the concentration of cytokine present in serum were performed as described. The columns represent the geometric mean values of three separate mice. Error bars representing the SE are present but are too small to be observed.

 
IFN-{gamma} mediates the inhibition of acute CIA, but not the exacerbation of chronic CIA, after rhIL-2 administration

To determine whether the observed effects of rhIL-2 administration on CIA were mediated by IFN-{gamma}, anti-IFN-{gamma} Abs were administered simultaneously with rhIL-2, both before and after disease onset. For treatment before disease onset, anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab (XMG.6) or a control isotype Ab (GL113) was administered on days 13 and 20. rhIL-2 was administered from day 14 to 21, as previously described. Administration of anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab blocked the inhibitory effect of IL-2 on acute disease (Fig. 9Go). Interestingly, administration of Abs to IFN-{gamma} alone results in exacerbation of CIA (p <= 0.05; days 25–34), suggesting that IFN-{gamma} suppresses acute CIA; however, administration of IL-2 in the presence of Abs to IFN-{gamma} exacerbated disease more than anti-IFN-{gamma} alone, suggesting that IL-2 has an IFN-{gamma}-independent stimulatory effect on disease development.



View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 9. IFN-{gamma} produced in response to rhIL-2 mediates the observed inhibition of CIA. Mice were given anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab, XMG.6, or an isotype-matched control Ab, GL113, at days 13 and 20 after primary CII immunization. rhIL-2 (60,000 U/day) was administered from day 14 to 21. Mice were scored for arthritis on days indicated, as described. The median arthritic score (A) and the percentage of mice exhibiting arthritis (B) are shown. Each group consisted of at least eight mice. *, p <= 0.05 comparing GL113, IL-2 vs XMG.6, IL-2 groups; {dagger}, p <= 0.05 comparing XMG.6, HBSS vs XMG.6, IL-2 groups.

 
We also examined whether the IFN-{gamma} produced in response to rhIL-2 administration during chronic disease was responsible for the observed exacerbation of established CIA. Anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab was administered at days 27 and 34 after primary CII immunization. rhIL-2 was administered from day 28 to 35. Administration of anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab had no significant effect on the exacerbation of established disease by rhIL-2 administration (Fig. 10Go). Median arthritic scores from both IL-2-treated groups were significantly higher than from the PBS/HBSS group (day 35; p < 0.05).



View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIGURE 10. IFN-{gamma} produced in response to rhIL-2 treatment does not mediate the observed exacerbation of CIA. Mice were given anti-IFN-{gamma} Ab, XMG.6, or an isotype-matched control Ab, GL113, at days 27 and 34 after primary CII immunization. rhIL-2 (60,000 U/day) was administered from day 27 to 35. Mice were scored for arthritis on days indicated, as described. Each group consisted of at least eight mice.

 

    Discussion
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 
The balance of Th1 and Th2 cytokines is thought to influence the autoimmune arthritis process, in that Th1-type cytokines are associated with disease (13). Therefore, our finding that IL-2, a Th1-derived cytokine, can suppress CIA, was unexpected. Our studies demonstrate that the effects of IL-2 on CIA depend on the timing of administration. Because cytokine mRNA levels and cellular populations within affected CIA joints change over the course of CIA (18), the response of this joint environment to administration of IL-2 may be different during the acute and chronic stages of CIA and, therefore, might be observed as differences in disease manifestation.

Although recent studies using recombination-activating gene-1-deficient mice raise questions regarding the requirement for mature T and B cells in the induction of CIA (33), there is much evidence that T cells are normally involved in disease induction. CIA can be prevented by administration of Abs to CD4 (28, 30) or CD3 (22). Administration of anti-CD40 ligand prevents joint inflammation, infiltration of inflammatory cells into the subsynovial tissue, joint erosion, and anti-CII Ab production (29). Both cellular and humoral immunity against CII are dependent on the T cell costimulatory molecule CD28, because mice lacking CD28 show a minimal T cell response to CII and produce very low levels of anti-CII IgG or IgM Abs (26).

Because IL-2 administration results in a general suppression of T cell responses to either CII or anti-TCR (2C11), the data presented here support the hypothesis that T cells are necessary to induce CIA but that they may not play a major role in established CIA. Lymph node cells from CIA mice have been defined as more Th1-like during the early response to CII, with IFN-{gamma}-secreting cells maximal around day 15 after primary immunization (34), whereas IL-4-producing cells are predominant at day 30 right before disease onset. Therefore, the observed suppressive effects that administration of IL-2 has on T cell responses in CIA may be more critical early in disease when Th1-type cells are dominant. The failure of IL-2 to suppress established disease suggests that these T cell responses are not critical in established CIA. Once the T cell response has been established or after the second CII injection, IL-2 may stimulate the production of IL-2R-bearing inflammatory cells in the synovium, such as macrophages that may increase the inflammatory response to CII and result in the observed exacerbation of disease.

The ability of IL-2 to suppress immune cell functions has also been observed in other settings. For example, IL-2-deficient mice have increased T and B cell proliferation and develop autoimmune disorders such as ulcerative colitis-like disease and autoimmune hemolytic anemia (20, 21, 35), which can be prevented by treatment with rhIL-2 before postnatal day 10 (36). IL-2 has also been shown to suppress the immune response to corneal implants by prolonging allograft survival in mice (37).

A number of recent studies suggest potential mechanisms for the observed inhibitory effects of IL-2 on CIA. For example, in vitro culture with IL-2 leads to apoptosis of activated T cells (38, 39). Other studies have implicated IFN-{gamma}, which enhances Fas and Fas ligand expression, in lymphocyte apoptosis (40, 41, 42). Because the inhibitory effect of IL-2 on CIA development is IFN-{gamma}-dependent and IL-2 treatment induces a large increase in IFN-{gamma} production, it seems likely that IL-2 indirectly inhibits CIA by inducing production of IFN-{gamma}, which enhances apoptosis of lymphoid cells that would otherwise contribute to CIA development. Although IL-2 might also suppress CIA by activating a subpopulation of CD4+ IL-2R+ T cells that can induce peripheral T cell tolerance to autoantigens (43, 44), this mechanism is not known to be IFN-{gamma} dependent. Consequently, it is less likely to be mediating suppression of CIA in our system. Additional experiments to investigate the mechanisms of IL-2 suppression of T and B cell responses are in progress.

Analysis of the role of IFN-{gamma} in animal models of arthritis have suggested both protective and exacerbating effects of IFN-{gamma} on disease (14, 15, 45, 46, 47, 48). Interestingly, administration of IFN-{gamma} has been shown to protect or exacerbate disease in rat adjuvant arthritis, depending on the time of administration (49). These results are similar to our observations with rhIL-2 administration. However, even though the inhibition of onset of disease was mediated by IFN-{gamma} in response to IL-2 administration, IL-2 itself mediated a pro-inflammatory effect on CIA, as evidenced by the increase in arthritic scores in mice treated with both IL-2 and anti-IFN-{gamma} Abs. Additionally, the observed exacerbation of disease by IL-2 administration was not mediated by IFN-{gamma}. Other studies have demonstrated that treatment of mice with IL-2 can induce IFN-{gamma} production and subsequent in vitro killer cell activity (50, 51). Studies are currently underway to further characterize this in vivo IFN-{gamma} response to rhIL-2 treatment.

The observation that IL-2 mRNA levels paralleled the up-regulation of IL-2R{alpha} expression is consistent with the dependence of IL-2R{alpha} expression on the presence of IL-2 protein (24, 25). The observed increase in IL-2 mRNA contrasts with results from previous studies that were unable to detect IL-2 protein in RA synovial fluid or CIA joints (17, 52). However, failure to detect IL-2 in the RA synovium may reflect the tendency of investigators to biopsy later in the disease course. Recently, IL-2 mRNA has been detected in RA synovial cells (53), and IL-2 protein has been found to be significantly increased in PBMCs from RA patients with early onset, but not late onset, synovitis (19).

Results from other recent studies also support a possible role for IL-2 in the autoimmune disease process. Weak linkage of certain cytokine genes, including IL-2, to RA (54) suggests that IL-2 may play a role in the disease process but that it is probably one of several factors involved in disease manifestation. Additionally, mouse models of diabetes and experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis have linked a region of mouse chromosome 3, including the IL-2 gene locus, to the manifestation of these autoimmune diseases in mice (55).

In summary, the results presented here demonstrate a role for IL-2 during the early stages of CIA. IL-2 can inhibit disease through effects that are mediated by IFN-{gamma}, and IL-2 can exacerbate disease, possibly by direct effects on IL-2R-bearing cells. IL-2 may be integral to many autoimmune processes. Further investigation of the mechanisms of action of IL-2 in autoimmunity and the IFN-{gamma} dependence of these mechanisms may lead to a better understanding of the pathogenesis of autoimmune arthritis and other autoimmune disorders.


    Acknowledgments
 
We thank Dr. Ed Giannini and Monica DeLay for helpful discussions and critical review of the manuscript. We would like to acknowledge Chiron for supplying the recombinant human IL-2 used in these studies.


    Footnotes
 
1 This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grants AI34958, AR44059, and AR42632, by the Schmidlapp Foundation, and by the Children’s Hospital Research Foundation of Cincinnati. Back

2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Raphael Hirsch, Division of Rheumatology, Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Pavilion Building 2-129, 3333 Burnet Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45229. Back

3 Abbreviations used in this paper: RA, rheumatoid arthritis; CIA, collagen-induced arthritis; rhIL-2, recombinant human IL-2; CII, type II collagen. Back

Received for publication March 8, 2000. Accepted for publication May 17, 2000.


    References
 Top
 Abstract
 Introduction
 Materials and Methods
 Results
 Discussion
 References
 

  1. Feldmann, M., F. M. Brennan, R. N. Maini. 1996. Role of cytokines in rheumatoid arthritis. Annu. Rev. Immunol. 14:397.[Medline]
  2. Bessis, N., M. C. Boissier, P. Ferrara, T. Blankenstein, D. Fradelizi, C. Fournier. 1996. Attenuation of collagen-induced arthritis in mice by treatment with vector cells engineered to secrete interleukin-13. J. Immunol. 26:2399.
  3. Hesse, M., S. Bayrak, A. Mitchison. 1996. Protective major histocompatibility complex genes and the role of interleukin-4 in collagen-induced arthritis. Eur. J. Immunol. 26:3234.[Medline]
  4. Horsfall, A. C., D. M. Butler, L. Marinova, P. J. Warden, R. O. Williams, R. N. Maini, M. Feldmann. 1997. Suppression of collagen-induced arthritis by continuous administration of IL-4. J. Immunol. 159:5687.[Abstract]
  5. Joosten, L. A. B., E. Lubberts, P. Durez, M. M. A. Helsen, M. J. M. Jacobs, M. Goldman, W. B. van den Berg. 1997. Role of interleukin-4 and interleukin-10 in murine collagen-induced arthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 40:249.[Medline]
  6. Tanaka, Y., T. Otsuka, T. Hotokebuchi, H. Miyahara, H. Nakashima, S. Kuga, Y. Nemoto, H. Niiro, Y. Niho. 1996. Effect of IL-10 on collagen-induced arthritis in mice. Inflamm. Res. 45:283.[Medline]
  7. Walmsley, M., P. D. Katsikis, E. Abney, S. Parry, R. O. Williams, R. N. Maini, M. Feldmann. 1996. Interleukin-10 inhibition of the progression of established collagen-induced arthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 39:495.[Medline]
  8. Allen, J. B., H. L. Wong, G. L. Costa, M. J. Bienkowski, S. M. Wahl. 1993. Suppression of monocyte function and differential regulation of IL-1 and IL-1ra by IL-4 contribute to resolution of experimental arthritis. J. Immunol. 151:4344.[Abstract]
  9. Chomarat, P., J. Banchereau, P. Miossec. 1995. Differential effects of interleukins 10 and 4 on the production of interleukin-6 by blood and synovium monocytes in rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 38:1046.[Medline]
  10. Isomaki, P., R. Lukkainen, R. Saario, P. Toivanen, J. Punnonen. 1996. Interleukin-10 functions as an antiinflammatory cytokine in rheumatiod synovium. Arthritis Rheum. 39:386.[Medline]
  11. Katsikas, P. D., C.-Q. Chu, F. M. Brennan, R. N. Maini, M. Feldmann. 1994. Immunoregulatory role of interleukin 10 in rheumatoid arthritis. J. Exp. Med. 179:1517.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  12. van Roon, J. A., J. L. van Roy, F. H. Gmelig-Meyling, F. P. Lafeber, J. W. Bijlsma. 1996. Prevention and reversal of cartilage degradation in rheumatoid arthritis by interleukin-10 and interleukin-4. Arthritis Rheum. 39:829.[Medline]
  13. Dolhain, R. J., A. N. van der Heiden, N. T. ter Haar, F. C. Breedveld, A. M. Miltenburg. 1996. Shift toward T lymphocytes with a T helper 1 cytokine-secretion profile in the joints of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 39:1961.[Medline]
  14. Cooper, S. M., S. Sriram, G. E. Ranges. 1988. Suppression of murine collagen-induced arthritis with monoclonal anti-Ia antibodies and augmentation with IFN-{gamma}. J. Immunol. 141:1958.[Abstract]
  15. Mauritz, N. J., R. Holmdahl, R. Jonsson, P. H. Van der Meide, A. Scheynius, L. Klareskog. 1988. Treatment with {gamma}-interferon triggers the onset of collagen arthritis in mice. Arthritis Rheum. 31:1297.[Medline]
  16. Banerjee, S., B. Wei, K. Hillman, H. S. Luthra, C. S. David. 1988. Immunosuppression of collagen-induced arthritis in mice with an anti-IL-2 receptor antibody. J. Immunol. 141:1150.[Abstract]
  17. Firestein, G. S., W. D. Xu, K. Townsend, D. Broide, J. Alvaro-Gracia, A. Glasebrook, N. J. Zvaifler. 1988. Cytokines in chronic inflammatory arthritis. J. Exp. Med. 168:1573.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  18. Thornton, S., G. P. Boivin, Y. Ma, R. Hirsch. 1999. Association of the course of collagen-induced arthritis with distinct patterns of cytokine and chemokine messenger RNA expression. Arthritis Rheum. 42:1109.[Medline]
  19. Kanik, K. S., E. Hagiwara, C. H. Yarboro, H. R. Schumacher, R. L. Wilder, D. M. Klinman. 1998. Distinct patterns of cytokine secretion characterize new onset synovitis versus chronic rheumatoid arthritis. J. Rheumatol. 25:16.[Medline]
  20. Sadlack, B., H. Merz, H. Schorle, A. Schimpl, A. C. Feller, I. Horak. 1993. Ulcerative colitis-like disease in mice with a disrupted interleukin-2 gene. Cell 75:253.[Medline]
  21. Horak, I.. 1995. Immunodeficiency in IL-2-knockout mice. Clin. Immunol. Immunopathol. 76:S172.[Medline]
  22. Hughes, C., J. A. Wolos, E. H. Giannini, R. Hirsch. 1994. Induction of T helper cell hyporesponsiveness in an experimental model of autoimmunity by using nonmitogenic anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody. J. Immunol. 153:3319.[Abstract]
  23. Finkelman, F. D., S. C. Morris. 1999. Development of an assay to measure in vivo cytokine production in the mouse. Int. Immunol. 11:1811.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  24. Chastagner, P., J. L. Moreau, Y. Jacques, T. Tanaka, M. Miyasaka, M. Kondo, K. Sugamura, J. Theze. 1996. Lack of intermediate-affinity interleukin-2 receptor in mice leads to dependence on interleukin-2 receptor {alpha}, ß and {gamma} chain expression for T cell growth. Eur. J. Immunol. 26:201.[Medline]
  25. Froussard, P., D. L. Jankovic, P. Chastagner, J. Theze. 1991. Induction of mouse p55 interleukin-2 receptor gene expression by IL-2 and IL-4 and characterization of its transcription initiation sites. Mol. Immunol. 28:87.[Medline]
  26. Tada, Y., K. Nagasawa, A. Ho, F. Morito, O. Ushiyama, N. Suzuki, H. Ohta, T. W. Mak. 1999. CD28-deficient mice are highly resistant to collagen-induced arthritis. J. Immunol. 162:203.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  27. Wooley, P. H., H. S. Luthra, M. M. Griffiths, J. M. Stuart, A. Huse, C. S. David. 1985. Type II collagen-induced arthritis in mice. IV. Variations in immunogenetic regulation provide evidence for multiple arthritogenic epitopes on the collagen molecule. J. Immunol. 135:2443.[Abstract]
  28. Goldschmidt, T. J., M. Andersson, V. Malmstrom, R. Holmdahl. 1992. Activated type II collagen reactive T cells are not eliminated by in vivo anti-CD4 treatment: implications for therapeutic approaches on autoimmune arthritis. Immunobiology 184:359.[Medline]
  29. Durie, F. H., R. A. Fava, T. M. Foy, A. Aruffo, J. A. Ledbetter, R. J. Noelle. 1993. Prevention of collagen-induced arthritis with an antibody to gp39, the ligand for CD40. Science 261:1328.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  30. Chu, E. B., M. V. Hobbs, C. B. Wilson, C. G. Romball, P. S. Linsley, W. O. Weigle. 1996. Intervention of CD4+ cell subset shifts and autoimmunity in the BXSB mouse by murine CT4LA4Ig. J. Immunol. 156:1262.[Abstract]
  31. Stuart, J. M., A. S. Townes, A. H. Kang. 1982. Nature and specificity of the immune response to collagen in type II collagen-induced arthritis in mice. J. Clin. Invest. 69:673.
  32. Theze, J., P. M. Alzari, J. Bertoglio. 1996. Interleukin 2 and its receptors: recent advances and new immunological functions. Immunol. Today 17:481.[Medline]
  33. Plows, D., G. Kontogeorgos, G. Kollias. 1999. Mice lacking mature T and B lymphocytes develop arthritic lesions after immunization with type II collagen. J. Immunol. 162:1018.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  34. Doncarli, A., L. M. Stasiuk, C. Fournier, O. Abehsira-Amar. 1997. Conversion in vivo from an early dominant Th0/Th1 response to a Th2 phenotype during the development of collagen-induced arthritis. Eur. J. Immunol. 27:1451.[Medline]
  35. Contractor, N. V., H. Bassiri, T. Reya, A. Y. Park, D. C. Baumgart, M. A. Wasik, S. G. Emerson, S. R. Carding. 1998. Lymphoid hyperplasia, autoimmunity, and compromised intestinal intraepithelial lymphocyte development in colitis-free gnotobiotic IL-2-deficient mice. J. Immunol. 160:385.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  36. Klebb, G., I. B. Autenrieth, H. Haber, E. Gillert, B. Sadlack, K. A. Smith, I. Horak. 1996. Interleukin-2 is indispensable for development of immunological self-tolerance. Clin. Immunol. Immunopathol. 81:282.[Medline]
  37. Zhang, E., T. Poul, S. Bulfone-Paus, J. Wachtlin, U. Kunzendorf, F. Hoffmann. 1998. Prolongation of corneal allograft survival by an interleukin-2 immunoglobulin fusion protein in mice. Graefe’s Arch. Clin. Exp. Ophthalmol. 236:486.[Medline]
  38. Zheng, L., C. L. Trageser, D. M. Willerford, M. J. Lenardo. 1998. T cell growth cytokines cause the superinduction of molecules mediating antigen-induced T lymphocyte death. J. Immunol. 160:763.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  39. Critchfield, J. M., M. K. Racke, J. C. Zuniga-Pflucker, B. Cannella, C. S. Raine, J. Goverman, M. J. Lenardo. 1994. T cell deletion in high antigen dose therapy of autoimmune encephalomyelitis. Science 263:1139.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  40. Oyaizu, N., T. W. McCloskey, S. Than, R. Hu, V. S. Kalyanaraman, S. Pahwa. 1994. Cross-linking of CD4 molecules upregulates Fas antigen expression in lymphocytes by inducing interferon-{gamma} and tumor necrosis factor-{alpha} secretion. Blood 84:2622.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  41. Shustov, A., P. Nguyen, F. Finkelman, K. B. Elkon, C. S. Via. 1998. Differential expression of Fas and Fas ligand in acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease: up-regulation of Fas and Fas ligand requires CD8+ T cell activation and IFN-{gamma} production. J. Immunol. 161:2848.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  42. Maciejewski, J., C. Selleri, S. Anderson, N. S. Young. 1995. Fas antigen expression on CD34+ human marrow cells is induced by interferon {gamma} and tumor necrosis factor {alpha} and potentiates cytokine-mediated hematopoietic suppression in vitro. Blood 85:3183.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  43. Thornton, A. M., E. M. Shevach. 1998. CD4+CD25+ immunoregulatory T cells suppress polyclonal T cell activation in vitro by inhibiting interleukin 2 production. J. Exp. Med. 188:287.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  44. Sakaguchi, S., N. Sakaguchi, M. Asano, M. Itoh, M. Toda. 1995. Immunologic self-tolerance maintained by activated T cells expressing IL-2 receptor {alpha}-chains (CD25): breakdown of a single mechanism of self-tolerance causes various autoimmune diseases. J. Immunol. 155:1151.[Abstract]
  45. Boissier, M. C., G. Chiocchia, N. Bessis, J. Hajnal, G. Garotta, F. Nicoletti, C. Fournier. 1995. Biphasic effect of interferon-{gamma} in murine collagen-induced arthritis. Eur. J. Immunol. 25:1184.[Medline]
  46. Manoury-Schwartz, B., G. Chiocchia, N. Bessis, O. Abehsira-Amar, F. Batteux, S. Muller, S. Huang, M. C. Boissier, C. Fournier. 1997. High susceptibility to collagen-induced arthritis in mice lacking IFN-{gamma} receptors. J. Immunol. 158:5501.[Abstract]
  47. Kageyama, Y., Y. Koide, A. Yoshida, M. Uchijima, T. Arai, S. Miyamoto, T. Ozeki, M. Hiyoshi, K. Kushida, T. Inoue. 1998. Reduced susceptibility to collagen-induced arthritis in mice deficient in IFN-{gamma} receptor. J. Immunol. 161:1542.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  48. Vermeire, K., H. Heremans, M. Vandeputte, S. Huang, A. Billiau, P. Matthys. 1997. Accelerated collagen-induced arthritis in IFN-{gamma} receptor-deficient mice. J. Immunol. 158:5507.[Abstract]
  49. Jacob, C. O., J. Holoshitz, P. Van der Meide, S. Strober, H. O. McDevitt. 1989. Heterogeneous effects of IFN-{gamma} in adjuvant arthritis. J. Immunol. 142:1500.[Abstract]
  50. Weigent, D. A., G. J. Stanton, H. M. Johnson. 1983. Interleukin 2 enhances natural killer cell activity through induction of {gamma} interferon. Infect. Immun. 41:992.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  51. Sayers, T., H. Rossiter, J. Chung, A. Hren, D. Armerding. 1985. In vivo activation of murine natural killer cell functions by human recombinant DNA interleukin 2. Immunobiology 169:303.[Medline]
  52. Mussener, A., M. J. Litton, E. Lindroos, L. Klareskog. 1997. Cytokine production in synovial tissue of mice with collagen-induced arthritis (CIA). Clin. Exp. Immunol. 107:485.[Medline]
  53. Buchan, G., K. Barrett, T. Fujita, T. Taniguchi, R. Maini, M. Feldmann. 1988. Detection of activated T cell products in the rheumatoid joint using cDNA probes to interleukin 2 (IL-2) IL-2 receptor and IFN-{gamma}. Clin. Exp. Immunol. 71:295.[Medline]
  54. John, S., A. Myerscough, A. Marlow, A. Hajeer, A. Silman, W. Ollier, J. Worthington. 1998. Linkage of cytokine genes to rheumatoid arthritis: evidence of genetic heterogeneity. Ann. Rheum. Dis. 57:361.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  55. Encinas, J. A., L. S. Wicker, L. B. Peterson, A. Mukasa, C. Teuscher, R. Sobel, H. L. Weiner, C. E. Seidman, J. G. Seidman, V. K. Kuchroo. 1999. QTL influencing autoimmune diabetes and encephalomyelitis map to a 0.15-cM region containing Il2. Nat. Genet. 21:158.[Medline]



This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
S. D. Clutter, D. C. Wilson, A. D. Marinov, and R. Hirsch
Follistatin-Like Protein 1 Promotes Arthritis by Up-Regulating IFN-{gamma}
J. Immunol., January 1, 2009; 182(1): 234 - 239.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
I. M. Irmler, M. Gajda, and R. Brauer
Exacerbation of Antigen-Induced Arthritis in IFN-{gamma}-Deficient Mice As a Result of Unrestricted IL-17 Response
J. Immunol., November 1, 2007; 179(9): 6228 - 6236.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
JEMHome page
H.-J. Wu, H. Sawaya, B. Binstadt, M. Brickelmaier, A. Blasius, L. Gorelik, U. Mahmood, R. Weissleder, J. Carulli, C. Benoist, et al.
Inflammatory arthritis can be reined in by CpG-induced DC NK cell cross talk
J. Exp. Med., August 6, 2007; 204(8): 1911 - 1922.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
W. Zhou, F. Zhang, and T. M. Aune
Either IL-2 or IL-12 Is Sufficient to Direct Th1 Differentiation by Nonobese Diabetic T Cells
J. Immunol., January 15, 2003; 170(2): 735 - 740.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.Home page
S. B. Han, S. H. Park, Y. J. Jeon, Y. K. Kim, H. M. Kim, and K. H. Yang
Prodigiosin Blocks T Cell Activation by Inhibiting Interleukin-2Ralpha Expression and Delays Progression of Autoimmune Diabetes and Collagen-Induced Arthritis
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther., November 1, 2001; 299(2): 415 - 425.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
J. Immunol.Home page
G. L. Costa, M. R. Sandora, A. Nakajima, E. V. Nguyen, C. Taylor-Edwards, A. J. Slavin, C. H. Contag, C. G. Fathman, and J. M. Benson
Adoptive Immunotherapy of Experimental Autoimmune Encephalomyelitis Via T Cell Delivery of the IL-12 p40 Subunit
J. Immunol., August 15, 2001; 167(4): 2379 - 2387.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Request Permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Thornton, S.
Right arrow Articles by Hirsch, R.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Thornton, S.
Right arrow Articles by Hirsch, R.


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS