|
|
||||||||



*
Department of Pharmacology and Cell Biophysics, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, OH 45267; and
GenPharm International, San Jose, CA 95131
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
light chain Ig genes are inactivated and which carry human Ig gene
segments, with a digoxin-protein conjugate has enabled us to generate
and isolate eight hybridoma cell lines secreting human sequence
anti-digoxin mAbs. Six of the mAbs have been partially
characterized and shown to have high specificity and low nanomolar
affinities for digoxin. In addition, detailed competition binding
studies performed with three of these mAbs have shown them to have
distinct differences in their digoxin binding, and that all three
structural moieties of the drug, the primary digitoxose sugar, steroid,
and five-member unsaturated lactone ring, contribute to Ab
recognition. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
4)-D
glycoside-linked digitoxoses, are the active compounds in digitalis
preparations derived from the foxglove plant and are commonly
prescribed to treat chronic heart failure and some supraventricular
arrhythmias (1, 2, 3). However, these compounds exhibit a
very narrow therapeutic index, and digitalis toxicity is among the most
prevalent of adverse drug reactions encountered by clinicians (2, 4, 5). Fortunately, the use of digitalis has been facilitated by
the generation of Abs that can be used to monitor patients serum drug
concentrations in order to maintain safe levels (6, 7).
Also, the i.v. administration of affinity-purified Fab of sheep
polyclonal anti-digoxin Abs can quickly reverse digoxin
cardiotoxicity by binding to free drug in plasma and effecting the
redistribution of the drug from a patients tissues back to the
vascular circulation (8, 9). Further, because Fabs are
relatively rapidly excreted in urine, high affinity Fabs that retain
bound drug can provide a route of drug elimination as well as a means
of its neutralization (10). Because both the clinical usefulness of anti-digoxin polyclonal Fab treatment (11, 12, 13) and the feasibility of generating drug-specific mouse mAbs have been well established, this immunological treatment strategy is potentially applicable to additional drug overdose situations. Indeed, in addition to sheep polyclonal anti-digoxin Fabs, goat Fabs directed against colchicine (14) have been used to treat life-threatening overdoses of this toxic alkaloid. Additionally, therapeutic mouse mAbs directed against the tricyclic anti-depressant, desipramine (15), and the abused psychosis-inducing drug, phencyclidine (16), are under development. Unfortunately, in general, sheep and goat polyclonal Fabs can present problems with respect to the ability to reproducibly generate high affinity Abs, which then must be purified from collections of animal sera. Further, the use of these foreign proteins in patients leads to an immunological response that can cause hypersensitivity reactions and acute anaphylaxis. Mouse mAbs, while providing a single well-characterized product, have very short half-lives in humans and are especially prone to generate anti-idiotypic, inactivating Abs as well as anti-constant region responses. Therefore, drug-targeted immunological intervention has been restricted by the lack of reliable methods to produce drug-specific human Abs that would reduce the risk of sensitizing patients and allow for more than a one time only intervention during life-threatening crises. To address this general problem, in recent years, considerable efforts have been made to generate mouse-human chimeric, humanized, and primatized mAbs (17, 18, 19, 20) that are more suitable for human use.
As an alternative and potentially more useful approach, recently we
(21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26) and others (27, 28, 29, 30) have adopted the
strategy of humanizing the mouse humoral immune system. We have been
able to develop several unique strains of genetically altered mice with
inactivated endogenous µ heavy and
light chain loci and inserted
human heavy (constant regions, Cµ and C
) and
light chain
transgenes (21, 22, 23, 24). This allows the generation of mouse B
cells that are capable of responding to immunization and undergo heavy
chain class switching and somatic mutation to generate human IgG1
Abs. Our initial results indicate that these animals are capable of
generating human Abs against a variety of human and nonhuman proteins
and that standard hybridoma technology can be used to obtain human mAbs
with affinities and quantities that compare favorably with those of
murine mAbs (24, 25, 26).
We now report the first use of one of these transgenic mouse strains, HC2/KCo5 (24), to generate hybridoma-secreted human mAbs directed against the low m.w., nonpeptidic hapten, digoxin. In this paper we describe the partial characterization of six of the eight human anti-digoxin mAbs we have obtained to date. Three of these mAbs have been studied more thoroughly, and determination of the ability of eight digoxin-related cardiotonic steroids and 10 steroid hormones to compete with digoxin for mAb binding has shown them to have a fine specificity of binding comparable to that of normal mouse mAbs. Further, radioligand binding studies have shown them to have low nanomolar binding affinities for digoxin that may prove sufficient for them to be clinically useful.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The mice [(C57BL/6J x CBA/J)F2]
used in this study have undergone four distinct genetic modifications,
resulting in double-transgenic/double-deletion mice that have been
described previously (25). The disruption of the
endogenous mouse µ heavy chain production (designated the CµD
strain) results from the insertion of a neomycin resistance gene into
the µ coding region (N. Lonberg, D. Fishwild, and L. D. Taylor,
manuscript in preparation). The
light chain disruption (JC
D
strain) results from recombinant deletion of J
and C
gene
segments (24). The constructed human sequence heavy chain
minilocus, transgene, designated HC2, that rescues B cell development
in the mutant background animals, includes four
VH, 16 D, six JH gene
segments, and Cµ and C
1. The KCo5 light
chain transgene contains the KCo4 transgene of four V
, with all five
J
gene segments and C
as well as a 450-kb yeast artificial
chromosome (YAC)3 that
contains most of the remaining distal portion of the human V
region
(25).
Synthesis of hapten-carrier conjugates
Digoxin was conjugated to BSA, chicken OVA, and keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) using the method described by Butler and Chen (6). The approximate extent of digoxin covalent coupling per mole (or milligram) of protein was determined spectrophotometrically in 83% H2SO4, with the absorption of the hapten-protein conjugate at 388 and 465 nm compared with that of protein and digoxin (6). The extent of hapten coupling was 8 and 2 mol of digoxin/mol of BSA and OVA, respectively, and 0.1 mmol/mg KLH.
Immunizations and cell fusion
Fifteen transgenic mice were immunized initially with either 100 µg of a digoxin-KLH conjugate suspended in CFA via i.p. injection or 50 µg of digoxin-KLH suspended in TiterMax (TM) via s.c. injection. The mice receiving immunogen in CFA were then immunized i.p. twice with 20 µg of digoxin-KLH in IFA followed by weekly or biweekly injections of 20 µg of digoxin-OVA in IFA. The mice receiving immunogen in TM were subsequently immunized s.c. approximately monthly with 50 µg of digoxin-OVA in TM. All mice received a final i.v. boost of 20 µg of digoxin-OVA in PBS 3 days before fusion. Splenic lymphocyte suspensions were fused to P3 x 63-Ag8.653 nonsecreting mouse myeloma cells (American Type Culture Collection, Manassas, VA; CRL 1480), and hybridomas selected as previously described (25).
Hybridoma cell screening and cloning
An ELISA was used to screen for hybridoma-secreted human anti-digoxin Abs. Microtiter plate wells were coated overnight at 4°C with 100-µl aliquots of 10 µg/ml of digoxin-BSA in 10 mM PBS, pH 7.2. Thereafter, the ELISA was completed as previously described (24). The hybridomas from positive-testing plate wells were then subcloned by limiting dilution plating.
Purification of human mAbs
The stability of cloned hybridoma cell lines was established by
several weeks of in vitro culturing and repeated testing of spent
culture medium for the presence of secreted mAb. Samples containing
110 x 106 cells in log phase growth
were injected i.p. into pristane-treated SCID mice for growth as
ascites cells. The ascites fluids were then removed from animals,
centrifuged, and sterile membrane filtered, and non-Ig proteins were
removed by 0.8 M
(NH4)2SO4
precipitation. The Ig fraction was equilibrated with 1 M
(NH4)2SO4
and 0.1 M glycine, pH 8.0, and loaded onto a protein A-Sepharose column
(Pharmacia, San Diego, CA). The mAbs were eluted with 0.1 M glycine and
0.1 M NaCl, pH 3.0, neutralized with 1 M Tris base, and dialyzed
against PBS. The OD at 280 nm was determined, and an absorptivity
coefficient of 1.4 was used to calculate the protein concentration
(31). Lowry protein determinations (32) of
mAb concentrations performed using BSA as standard matched well with
the OD-calculated values.
Characterization of the mouse sera
The relative levels of serum human IgM and IgG anti-digoxin Abs were determined at weekly intervals during immunization using the ELISA described by Fishwild et al. (25). In addition, mouse serum samples obtained at the time of cell fusion were monitored for relative levels of both human and mouse IgG and IgM anti-digoxin Abs. Serum samples were exposed to plate-adsorbed digoxin-BSA, and biotinylated goat anti-mouse and anti-human heavy chain-specific secondary Abs were used to detect the hapten-bound Ab. A streptavidin-alkaline phosphatase conjugate was used to quantitate anti-digoxin Abs through its hydrolysis of the substrate p-nitrophenylphosphate. Total serum concentrations of mouse and human Abs were determined by adsorbing to the microtiter plates either goat anti-mouse Ig Fc specific or anti-human Igs Fc specific Abs to capture any mouse or human Ig chains present in the serum solutions. The captured Abs were probed using a collection of biotinylated goat anti-mouse and anti-human heavy and light chain-specific Abs.
Isotype analysis of hybridoma secreted Abs
Each cloned hybridoma cell line was tested for its production of
a human anti-digoxin IgG
Ab and the absence of any mouse chain
Igs. Spent medium from hybridoma cultures was exposed to
digoxin-BSA-coated ELISA plate wells, and bound Ab was probed with
isotype- and species-specific, biotinylated Abs, including goat
anti-human G, M,
, and
chains and goat anti-mouse G, M,
A,
, and
chain-specific Abs. Next, the media were tested for any
Ab binding to the carrier proteins coupled with digoxin, including BSA,
chicken OVA, and KLH or to turkey OVA, chicken serum albumin, and
casein. Finally, as described above for the serum samples, goat
anti-mouse IgG Fc-specific and anti-human IgG Fc-specific Abs
were adsorbed to the microtiter plates to capture for detection and
quantitation any mouse or human Ig chains present in the hybridoma
supernatant solutions.
ELISA analyses of human mAb avidities and binding specificities
Avidity determinations. The avidities of the six mAbs isolated for digoxin were determined using an ELISA in which the digoxin-BSA conjugate (5 µg/ml) was adsorbed to microtiter plates, which were then blocked using a 5% BSA/PBS solution followed by varying concentrations of culture medium or purified mAb. Then, biotinylated goat anti-human IgG Ab was added, followed by a streptavidin-alkaline phosphatase conjugate and then substrate to detect bound human Ab.
Competitive binding ELISAs. Determination of the relative binding specificities of the six mAbs, their binding to digoxin, additional derivatives, and a variety of steroids was accomplished through use of a competitive binding ELISA. Anti-human IgG Fc region-specific Ab was adsorbed to the microtiter plates, and then the human mAbs were captured to the plates. Subsequently, a fixed concentration of a digoxin-alkaline phosphatase conjugate was mixed with varying concentrations of digoxin, serving as the standard, or other competitors, and binding of the digoxin-AP conjugate was determined. Briefly, goat anti-human IgG Fc-specific IgG (5 µg/ml) was adsorbed onto polystyrene (Corning, Corning, NY) plates in 0.1 M NaHCO3, pH 9.6, followed by a blocking step with 0.5% casein in 10 mM PBS buffer, pH 7.6, and 0.02% sodium azide and then the addition of 100 µl of mAb (2 µg/ml). The captured mAbs were incubated for 1 h at 37°C with 100 µl of a mixture of a 1/50 dilution of a digoxin-alkaline phosphatase conjugate (O.E.M. Concepts, Toms River, NJ) and varying competitor concentrations in 10 mM PBS, pH 7.2, and 0.5% casein. Following washing of the plate, 50 µl/well of the substrate solution (1 mg/ml p-nitrophenylphosphate, 50 mM NaHCO3, pH 9.8, and 1 mM MgCl2), was added to the plates and incubated at room temperature for 10 min. Ab-bound digoxin-AP was quantitated colorimetrically (405 nm) after adding 50 µl/well of 0.1 N NaOH. Data were analyzed using a nonlinear regression curve-fitting program Inplot (GraphPad, San Diego, CA).
Ligand binding assays
First, radioligand binding assays using varying concentrations of [3H]digoxin were performed with the three purified anti-digoxin mAbs to obtain the dissociation constants (Kd). Next, competition binding studies were performed to obtain the IC50 or inhibition constants of digitoxin, digoxigenin, and progesterone relative to that of digoxin. These assays used a double Ab precipitation technique, previously described (33), to recover the [3H]ligand-mAb complexes on glass-fiber filters. For Kd determinations, 0.060.3 µg/0.5 ml assay of purified mAb was incubated at room temperature for 1 h with varying concentrations of [G-3H]digoxin (sp. act. = 15 Ci/mmol; DuPont-NEN, Boston, MA) in 0.5 ml of PBS, pH 7.4, containing 0.05% BSA. Then excess affinity-purified goat anti-human IgG Fc specific (ICN Biomedicals, Costa Mesa, CA) and rabbit anti-goat IgG Abs were added to each assay tube, and the binding reactions were allowed to go to completion (33). To determine nonspecific binding, a Na+,K+-ATPase-directed mAb (M7-PB-E9) (34) was substituted for the anti-digoxin mAbs. The Kd values for digoxin were obtained by analyzing the data using PRIZM (GraphPad, San Diego, CA), a nonlinear regression curve-fitting program. The competition curves were obtained by performing binding studies with a fixed 60-nM concentration of [3H]digoxin and varying concentrations of cold competitor. The IC50 values were obtained by fitting the radioligand binding data using Inplot (GraphPad). These IC50 values were converted to inhibitory dissociation constants (Ki values), using the Cheng and Prusoff (35) equation: Ki = IC50/(1 + [L]/Kd), where [L] is the concentration of [3H]digoxin, and Kd is the dissociation constant for digoxin.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this work, HC2/KCo5 mice were immunized with the digoxin-carrier conjugates as described in Materials and Methods. All 15 animals generated a hapten-directed response, with eight being designated high responders by having serum titer values of >1/1250 when tested for human IgG Ab binding to digoxin-BSA by ELISA.
As illustrative of the animals responses, serum samples from two mice
that were considered good producers of anti-digoxin Abs were
characterized with respect to the timing and level of their responses.
Mouse IgG as well as the human Ab responses were expected due to
trans-switching from the recombined human VDJ sequence to
the murine endogenous
heavy chain and because the endogenous
locus was not disrupted (24). As shown in Fig. 1
, both initial human IgM and IgG
anti-digoxin responses occurred within the first week after
immunization, with the IgG levels peaking at about 2 wk and severalfold
higher than the IgM response. In addition, the mouse IgG
anti-digoxin response was monitored and was found to be about
one-third to one-half that of the human IgG response. Further, serum
samples obtained from these two transgenic animals at the time of cell
fusions as well as that for two normal CB6F1/J
mice (one immunized with digoxin-KLH and one control) were analyzed and
compared. These results indicated that the sera from the transgenic
mice 14739 and 14747 contained about 190 and 42 µg/ml, respectively,
of total mouse IgG with essentially no mouse IgM. In comparison, the
two normal mice had mouse IgG levels of 7.2 and 2.3 mg/ml and IgM
levels of 0.89 and 0.39 mg/ml. The serum levels of human IgG for both
transgenic mice were
11 µg/ml, while human IgM levels were 244 and
400 µg/ml, respectively. Thus, while the production of mouse IgG in
the transgenic animals appeared to be reduced to only 23% that in
normal mice, these levels still surpassed those of the human IgG.
Endogenous IgM production was well below that of the human IgM.
Interestingly, despite the fact that total endogenous mouse IgG levels
surpassed those of the human IgG, the transgenic animals
immunological response to immunization with the digoxin-carrier
conjugate was predominately a human IgG response.
|
The spleens from six of the 15 immunized animals were used for
cell fusions. Hybridomas from two of the six animals generated
detectable human IgG k anti-digoxin Abs in the culture medium.
Altogether, nine anti-digoxin Ab-producing hybridoma cell
populations were detected in parental wells, while all eight of the
hybridomas chosen for further growth and subcloning were successfully
isolated. Six of these hybridoma cell lines were then conditioned to
grow as T-flask cultures, and late growth phase samples of the culture
medium were tested for human mAb binding to the digoxin-BSA, -KLH, and
-OVA conjugates. The human mAbs secreted by these cell lines bound
equally well to all three hapten-protein conjugates. Further all six
anti-digoxin mAbs were fully human IgG
Igs, with no detection
of mouse or human-mouse mixed chain Abs. In addition, no mAb binding
was detected to bovine, chicken, or human serum albumin; KLH; chicken
or turkey OVA; or casein. Ab binding dilution curves obtained using
culture medium samples showed that the mAbs were secreted at
concentrations that gave titer values, or half-maximal binding to
carrier-linked digoxin at dilutions of
1/200 to 1/400. Ab
concentrations were determined by capturing the mAbs from solution with
plate-adsorbed Ab and comparing these levels to those obtained using
purified human IgG as a standard. Human mAb concentrations in the
medium were
525 µg/ml of human mAb. Dilution curves of mAb
binding to digoxin-BSA showed all of them to have an estimated apparent
binding affinity or avidity of about 0.51 nM (data not shown). These
avidity values were in agreement with the values obtained for several
high affinity mouse mAbs (obtained from Michael Margolies,
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA) monitored using the same
ELISA procedure (our unpublished observations).
Characterization of binding avidities and specificities of three purified human anti-digoxin mAbs
Three mAbs, designated 5C2-4, 7F2-31, and 11E6-7 were obtained from mouse ascites samples and purified, and their binding avidities and specificities for digoxin were determined. As found previously for mAbs in cell culture supernatants, the ELISA procedure using digoxin-BSA as Ag gave essentially identical titer values of about 1 nM for all three mAbs (data not shown).
Next, a competitive ELISA protocol was used to determine the mAbs
apparent affinities for digoxin. In this procedure, adsorbed
anti-human IgG Fc region-specific Igs captured a fixed amount of
mAb to the plates, and the IC50 values for
digoxin were obtained by having digoxin compete in solution with
digoxin-alkaline phosphatase for mAb binding. The
IC50 values of mAbs 5C2-4, 7F2-31, and 11E6-7 for
digoxin were
0.28, 0.15, and 0.15 µM, respectively (see
representative Fig. 2
A). These
results suggested that mAbs 7F2-31 and 11E6-7 were similar to each
other but distinct from 5C2-4.
|
|
|
|
1 nM titer values for binding to the digoxin-BSA conjugate and
IC50 ELISA values of 0.17, 0.12, and 0.18 µM,
respectively, for digoxin. In the competition ELISA they had similar
digoxin relative IC50 ratios for digitoxin and
digoxigenin of
3.3 and 1.7, respectively, with no binding to
ouabain. For the steroids, determination of their relative
IC50 values showed testosterone to have an
150-fold lower affinity than digoxin, with cortisone being weakly
inhibitory. In addition, cholesterol, ß-estradiol, and androsterone
showed essentially no competition with digoxin. Thus, pending a more
complete repetition of these ELISAs with purified Ab and determination
of their Kd values and amino acid
sequences, these three mAbs, while not identical, were more similar to
7F2-31 and 11E6-7 than to 5C2-4. Determination of human mAb binding affinities for digoxin
To obtain true Kd or affinity
values of the purified mAbs for digoxin, we used a radioligand binding
assay, which employed a double Ab aggregation step to generate a
[3H]ligand-three Ab complex that was recovered
on glass-fiber filters. As shown, in Table III
(and illustrated in Fig. 4
), the affinities of mAbs 7F2-31,
11E6-7, and 5C2-4 for digoxin were 2.5, 4.5, and 22 nM, respectively.
Determination of their Ki values for
digoxin, digoxigenin, digitoxin, and progesterone showed the three mAbs
to have nanomolar affinities for digoxin, digoxigenin, and digitoxin
and micromolar values for progesterone. mAb 5C2-4 was clearly
distinguished from the other two mAbs by having the poorest affinity
for all four compounds tested, while 7F2-31 showed nearly identical
affinities for digoxin and digitoxin. Further, there were sufficient
differences between the Ki values
obtained for 7F2-31 and 11E5-7 to suggest that, while similar, they are
distinct mAbs. Interestingly, all three mAbs have considerably less
cross-reactivity with the steroid progesterone than was apparent from
the competitive ELISA. These results suggest that in any in vivo usage
these mAbs would not alter endogenous steroid hormone levels.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this work we report the production of eight mouse hybridomas, which secrete human sequence anti-digoxin mAbs, and initial avidity and fine binding specificity determinations for six of these mAbs. ELISA competition binding studies using digoxin and related cardioactive steroids as well as steroid hormones demonstrated the importance of all three structural components of digoxin, the digitoxose sugars, steroid moiety, and lactone ring for mAb recognition. In addition, radioligand binding studies showed three of the mAbs, those designated 5C2-4, 7F2-31, and 11E6-7, to have affinities for digoxin from about 220 nM with relatively good recognition of digoxigenin and digitoxin but greatly reduced affinities for progesterone, the steroid hormone that showed the highest degree of mAb binding.
Analysis of the ELISA competition binding data obtained for the three
more fully characterized mAbs enables us to make some initial
conclusions about their binding specificities. These results show that
the sugar moiety (at least the primary sugar) contributes to binding of
the mAbs, because the aglycones, digoxigenin and digitoxigenin, had
5- and 8-fold lower binding affinities than digoxin and digitoxin,
respectively. As for the contributions of substituents on the steroid
moiety of digoxin, the removal of the C-12 hydroxyl group (digitoxin)
results in an
3-fold reduction in the binding affinity for all three
mAbs. In contrast, with acetylstrophanthidin, the presence of an
acetyl and hydroxyl group at the aglycones C-3 and C-5 groups (ring
A) and the conversion of the C-19 methyl to a keto group had
surprisingly little additional effect on mAb binding. The results
obtained with ouabain and oleandrin, however, show that the presence of
additional hydroxyl groups (C-1, C-3, and C-11, ouabain) or an acetate
group at the steroid C-16 (oleandrin) essentially abolishes recognition
by these Abs. The data obtained with the steroids then showed that the
addition of a hydroxyl group (corticosterone vs hydrocortisone) at C-17
or the oxidation of the C-18 methyl to a keto group (corticosterone vs
aldosterone) results in a 4- to 10-fold drop in mAb affinities from
that for corticosterone. In addition, removal of the C-19 methyl group
and conversion of the steroid ring A from a keto-hexyl (testosterone)
to an aromatic phenol (ß-estradiol) essentially abolished the binding
for all three mAbs. Therefore, these human mAbs seem to have extensive
complementary shape interactions with much of what, as conventionally
presented in Fig. 3
, would be the upper side or face of the steroid
moiety of digoxin.
It is also evident that the unsaturated five-member lactone ring is an
important binding determinant as reduction of the C20-C22 double bond
(dihydrodigitoxin) reduces digitoxins affinity for 5C2-4, 7F2-31, and
11E6-7, 16-, 170-, and 100-fold, respectively. Also, substitution with
a six- rather than a five-member unsaturated lactone as occurs in
bufalin (a digitoxigenin, congener) results in an
18-fold decrease
in affinity for all three mAbs. A further indication that these mAbs
may have defined binding pockets for the lactone within their
Ag-combining sites analogous to those determined, for mouse mAbs 26-10
(44) and 40-50 (45), is the fact that
cholesterol has essentially no ability to compete with digoxin, but
replacement of its eight-carbon alkyl chain on ring D (C-17) with
either a ketomethyl (progesterone) or a hydroxyl group (testosterone)
enables the steroid moiety to inhibit digoxin binding, albeit with a
100-fold lower affinity than digoxin.
In the absence of confirmatory sequence information we do not know the extent to which the six mAbs reported here differ or are closely related, because they originate from one animal. However, 5C2-4 appears distinct from 7F2-31 and 11E6-7 as its IC50 and Kd values for digoxin were about 2- and 10-fold higher than those for the other two mAbs. Moreover, 7F2-31 and 11E6-7 appear distinct based on their Ki values for digoxigenin, digitoxin, and progesterone. Further testing of all six mAbs will allow us to determine whether this mouse yielded only three or up to six distinct mAbs, a possible testament to the repertoire diversity of the transgenic animal.
We can, however, make some general comparisons between these mAbs and
the mouse anti-digoxin mAbs characterized by others. First, the low
nanomolar affinities of these human mAbs for digoxin compare very well
with mAbs obtained from the BALB/c mouse strain (46, 47).
These values are, however, at least 10-fold poorer than the majority of
mAbs obtained by Margolies and colleagues (40, 41) from
the A/J strain of mice, which they report to be unique with respect to
its high affinity anti-digoxin responses. Next, we can compare the
competition binding data for the human mAbs with the results obtained
by Margolies et al. (40) with 14 mouse mAbs. First, with
respect to the ability of the human mAbs to distinguish between digoxin
and digitoxin we found that the 3-fold loss in the affinity of the
human mAbs for digitoxin more than matches the average 1.4-fold
difference in affinity observed for nine of the mouse mAbs. Then, with
respect to the recognition of the sugar moiety by the human mAbs we
found that the 5- and 8-fold reductions in their binding to the digoxin
and digitoxin aglycones, respectively, are comparable with those of a
group of six mouse mAbs, which averaged
2.6- and 9-fold decreases in
their affinities for the aglycones. Further, the decreased affinities
of the three human mAbs for acetylstrophanthidin with essentially no
binding to ouabain, oleandrin, and most steroids are also consistent
with the range of specificities observed for the A/J mouse-derived Abs.
Interestingly, a chimpanzee-derived anti-digoxin mAb
(48) has also been characterized and found to have a
4-fold affinity differential between digoxin and digitoxin but no
recognition of the digitoxose sugars.
Finally, we would like to consider the likelihood of mAb 7F2-31 having the potential to be clinically useful for digoxin detoxification. Although most animal detoxification studies have used mouse mAbs (42, 43) with about a 10-fold higher affinity than mAb 7F2-31, one study has directly compared the in vivo effects of three mouse mAbs with differing digoxin affinities. Cano et al. (46) tested the abilities of these mAbs to raise total plasma digoxin and reduce free digoxin levels by reversing the drugs normal tissue distribution in rats. Interestingly, they report that at a stoichiometric mAb/drug ratio, mAb 6C9 with a digoxin affinity of 3.2 nM was able to reduce free plasma levels by 90% compared with the 99% achieved by mAb 1C10, which has an affinity of 0.17 nM. Furthermore, by raising the concentration of mAb 6C9 to a 5:1 ratio vs drug, it was found to be equally as effective as 1C10. In contrast, the third mAb, with a Kd value of 40 nM, was essentially ineffective.
Comparison of the affinity of mAb 7F2-31 with clinically used Fab preparations provides encouraging information. Sheep Fabs with affinities ranging from 10.01 nM (49, 50) have all been effective when administered at stoichiometric concentrations relative to patients plasma drug levels. In addition, Fab preparations that may have had Kd values above 1 nM have proven effective (37). Therefore, mAb 7F2-31 may prove adequate for initial treatment of the massive drug overdose levels of digoxin (or digitoxin), for which anti-digoxin Fab intervention is currently recommended (50). Clearly, both mAbs 7F2-31 and 11E6-7 have affinities that are at least 10- to 30-fold greater than the Kd values of the Na+ pump for digoxin under in vivo ligand conditions (51, 52), and they should compete effectively with the Na+ pump for digoxin.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. William Ball, Department of Pharmacology and Cell Biophysics, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, OH 45267. E-mail address: ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: YAC, yeast artificial chromosome; KLH, keyhole limpet hemocyanin; TM, Titer-Max. ![]()
Received for publication February 9, 1999. Accepted for publication June 4, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
transcripts. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90:3720.
monoclonal antibodies from a novel strain of minilocus transgenic mice. Nat. Biotechnol. 14:845.[Medline]
- and ß-isoforms and kinetic properties in mammalian liver. Am. J. Physiol. 262:C1491.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. B. Norman, M. K. Norman, W. R. Buesing, M. R. Tabet, V. L. Tsibulsky, and W. J. Ball The Effect of a Chimeric Human/Murine Anti-Cocaine Monoclonal Antibody on Cocaine Self-Administration in Rats J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther., March 1, 2009; 328(3): 873 - 881. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. B. Norman, M. R. Tabet, M. K. Norman, W. R. Buesing, A. J. Pesce, and W. J. Ball A Chimeric Human/Murine Anticocaine Monoclonal Antibody Inhibits the Distribution of Cocaine to the Brain in Mice J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther., January 1, 2007; 320(1): 145 - 153. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |