|
|
||||||||
Departments of Immunology and Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ß (6). The
premature death of naive peripheral T cells in the BB/W rat precludes
their continued development in the periphery, as evidenced by the
absence of peripheral T cells expressing RT6 and CD45RC (7). The mechanisms through which the BB/W rat lyp allele contributes to the development of antipancreatic autoimmunity remain obscure. A potential pathogenic mechanism is the induction of an excessive production of nitric oxide by macrophages, which are the first mononuclear cells to infiltrate the pancreatic islets of BB/W rats (8, 9). It has been shown that nitric oxide is toxic for ß-cells in vitro. Further, the incidence of diabetes is decreased in BB/W rats that are treated with inhibitors of nitric oxide synthase (10). We have demonstrated that the excessive production of nitric oxide by BB/W rat macrophages is secondary to the T lymphopenic state of these animals (11). Specifically, we have shown that the levels of nitric oxide produced by BB/W macrophages are restored to those produced by macrophages derived from nondiabetes-prone animals when they develop in the context of a normal-sized pool of recirculating T cells.
Two lines of evidence suggest that the T lymphopenic process of the
BB/W rat could also compromise the development of T cells that would
normally regulate potentially diabetogenic T cells. Adoptive transfer
of normal histocompatible T cells to diabetes-prone BB/W rats results
in the partial correction of the peripheral T lymphopenia and the
prevention of both insulitis and diabetes (12, 13). This protection has
been attributed to a subset of donor-derived CD4+,
TCR
ß+ T cells expressing RT6 on their surface (12).
Furthermore, administration of depleting anti-RT6 mAb to
diabetes-resistant rats, which are genetically related to BB/W rats,
results in peripheral T lymphopenia phenotypically similar to that
observed in unmanipulated BB/W rats and in the development of type I
diabetes when the recipients are simultaneously treated with inducers
of IFN-
(14).
In unmanipulated BB/W rats, infiltration of pancreatic islets by mononuclear cells becomes detectable at 4 wk, and the peak incidence of diabetes is observed around 3 mo (15). The protection of BB/W rats from diabetes afforded by adoptive transfer of histocompatible T cells is time dependent (16). The administration of normal T cells to BB/W recipients at 45 wk of age, around the time of initiation of insulitis, prevents the development of diabetes. In marked contrast, the diabetogenic process remains unaltered when normal T cells are adoptively transferred to 2-mo-old diabetes-prone BB/W recipients, in which insulitis is already apparent (16). The analysis of this differential effect of T cell reconstitution on antipancreatic autoimmunity has been hampered by the lack of suitable congenic strains of diabetes-resistant and diabetes-prone rats. In particular, the lack of genetic markers distinguishing donor- and recipient-derived T cells has precluded the recovery of donor-derived T cells that had been used for the reconstitution of 1- and 2-mo-old diabetes-prone recipients. Consequently, it has been impossible to directly analyze the differential capacity of donor-derived T cells to regulate the diabetogenic process in vivo.
We have developed a CD45 congenic strain of diabetes-prone BB/W rats, BB/W.7b. At different stages of the diabetogenic process, these animals were reconstituted with T cells isolated from diabetes-resistant BB rats (DR-BB/W) that differed from recipients at the CD45 and lyp loci. As expected, all BB/W.7b animals that were reconstituted with normal T cells at 2 mo of age developed diabetes. Surprisingly, however, the kinetics of onset of diabetes was enhanced compared with those of unreconstituted BB/W.7b animals. We demonstrate that the acceleration of the diabetogenic process resulted from the priming of diabetogenic T cells among donor-derived T cells. Thus, unfractionated T cells from normal donors were unable to regulate primed diabetogenic T cells of recipient origin or to prevent priming and expansion of the diabetogenic T cell precursors present in the donor inoculum. T cell reconstitution of 1-mo-old BB/W.7b rats prevented diabetes. However, the protective donor-derived T cells were unable to regulate primed diabetogenic T cells of BB/W origin in a cotransfer system, even in circumstances where protective T cells outnumbered diabetogenic T cell by >50-fold. Further, the T cells that were protective in a first recipient became diabetogenic when subsequently transferred to a second recipient. Thus, reconstitution of 1-mo-old diabetes-prone recipients with normal T cells was protective, but when donor T cells were rescued 3 mo later and used to reconstitute a 2-mo-old diabetes-prone recipient, the kinetics of onset of diabetes were enhanced. This observation demonstrates that early T cell reconstitution of BB/W rats does not result in a long term physical or functional depletion of islet cell-specific T cell precursors among the protective donor cells. Taken together, the results support the conclusion that normal T cells can prevent the initiation of an antipancreatic autoimmune process in BB/W rats; however, they are unable to regulate an autoimmune response once it has been initiated.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Isocongenic diabetes-prone (BB/W) and diabetes-resistant (DR-BB/W) BB rats that differ at the lyp locus were obtained from the University of Massachusetts (Worcester, MA). Wistar Furth (WF) rats were purchased from Charles River (Frederick, MD). BB and WF rats share the same MHC haplotype (RT1u) and are congenic for the two allelic forms of CD45, RT7a for BB rats and RT7b for WF animals. To be able to distinguish mononuclear cells (MNC) of BB/W origin from those of DR-BB/W origin we introduced the RT7b allele of WF rats into the genetic BB/W background. Lymphopenic and diabetic RT7a/b males resulting from the first backcross were used for further backcrosses with BB/W animals. RT7b congenic BB/W rats used in these studies originated from the fourth to sixth backcrosses. Animals were housed in specific pathogen-free conditions, and all the sentinels were negative for circulating Abs specific for the diabetogenic Kilhams virus. Diabetes-prone rats were tested three times a week for the presence of glycosuria and ketonuria. Once animals became glycosuric, the diagnosis of diabetes was established on the basis of hyperglycemia (blood glucose, >16.7 mM) for 2 consecutive days. Some diabetic rats were treated with s.c. implants of insulin (Linplant, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada).
mAbs, three-color immunofluorescence, and FACS analysis
The mAbs used in this study were affinity purified from
hybridoma culture supernatants on rat anti-mouse Ig-Sepharose or
mouse anti-rat Ig-Sepharose, and then conjugated with FITC, biotin,
or PE using standard procedures. These mAbs included anti-rat Ig
(MARK1) (17), anti-CD8 (MRC-OX8) (18), anti-CD4 (W3/25)
(18), anti-CD45RC (MRC-OX22) (19), anti-OX41 (a molecule
expressed on macrophages and granulocytes in rats; MRC-OX41) (20),
anti-CD11b/c (MRC-OX42) (20), and anti-CD5 (MRC-OX19) (21),
which were provided by Dr. A. A. Like (Worcester, MA) with the
permission of Dr. D. Mason (Oxford, U.K.). R73, a hybridoma secreting
an mAb specific for a nonpolymorphic determinant of rat TCR
ß (22)
was a gift from Dr. T. Hünig (Martinsried, Germany). The rat
hybridomas DS4.23 (anti-RT6a), 6A5
(anti-RT6b), NDS-58 (anti-RT7a), and
8G6.1 (anti-RT7b) (23) were provided by Dr. D.
Greiner (Worcester, MA) and Dr. M. Newton (Oxford, U.K.),
respectively. G4.18, a mouse hybridoma secreting an mAb specific for
rat CD3
(24), was obtained from Dr. G. W. Butcher (Cambridge,
U.K.) with the permission of Dr. B. M. Hall (University of New
South Wales, Liverpool, Australia). Streptavidin-PE/Texas Red
Tandem was purchased from Southern Biotechnology Associates
(Birmingham, AL). Affinity-purified normal rat and mouse Ig as well as
rat antiserum specific for mouse Ig were purchased from Biocan
(Ontario, Canada). Affinity-purified goat anti-rat Ig
anti-serum was purchased from Sigma (St. Louis, MO).
Suspensions of MNC were incubated with biotinylated mAb, followed by streptavidin-PE/Texas Red Tandem. PE-labeled and FITC-conjugated mAbs were then added simultaneously. Viable cells were gated using forward and side angle scatter and were analyzed flow cytometrically with a FACScan (Becton Dickinson, San Jose, CA).
Purification of T cells
T cells were enriched by negative selection using a rosetting procedure as previously described (25, 26). Briefly, donor T cells (DR-BB/W and WF) used in reconstitution experiments were purified from pooled splenic and lymph node MNC through the depletion of macrophages, B lymphocytes, and NK cells. The cell suspension was incubated with a mixture of mouse mAbs consisting of MARK-1, OX41, OX42, and 3.2.3. mAb-coated cells were mixed with SRBC (Cederlane, Hornby, Canada) coated with rat anti-mouse Ig. The cell suspension was rotated for 30 min at 4°C to allow rosette formation. To maximize aggregate formation and hence the degree of purification, the cell suspension was then mixed with normal mouse Ig-coated SRBC for 30 min at 4°C. Rosettes were separated by centrifugation at 200 x g for 1 min. The supernatant containing the T cells was recovered and analyzed. The degree of enrichment was assessed by FACS analysis. The purity of T cells from nonlymphopenic animals was routinely >98%.
Following reconstitution of diabetes-prone BB/W.RT7b and
BB/W rats with T cells from DR-BB/W and WF donors, respectively, cells
of donor origin were purified from splenic MNC as described above with
some modifications due to the fact that the anti-RT7 mAbs used for
the depletion of host T cells are of rat origin. The depleting Ab
mixture included anti-RT7 mAb in addition to the mouse mAbs. This
was followed by an incubation of the MNC with rat anti-mouse Ig
mAb 187 (27) to coat all the cells that had to be depleted with rat
Abs. mAb-coated splenocytes were mixed with SRBC coated with goat
anti-rat Ig. The cell suspension was rotated for 30 min at 4°C to
allow rosette formation. The rosettes were separated by centrifugation
at 200 x g for 1 min. The supernatant was collected
and centrifuged at 600 x g for 10 min. The pellet was
resuspended, mixed again with goat anti-rat Ig-coated SRBC, and
rotated for 30 min at 4°C. The cell suspension was then mixed with
normal rat Ig-coated SRBC for 30 min at 4°C. Rosettes were separated
by centrifugation at 200 x g for 1 min. The
supernatant containing donor-derived T cells was recovered and
analyzed. More than 98% of the cells in the resulting cell suspension
were donor derived.
RT6+ T cells of DR-BB/W origin were sorted from splenic and lymph node MNC using a FACStar (Becton Dickinson). Splenic T cells from acutely diabetic rats were isolated by three-step rosetting as described above.
T cell reconstitution of diabetes-prone BB rats and adoptive transfer of diabetes
T cell reconstitution of 1- and 2-mo-old diabetes-prone BB/W rats was achieved through one i.v. injection of T cells derived from 2-mo-old normal donors.
Thymectomized and sublethally irradiated (TX) rats were used as T cell recipients in adoptive transfer experiments. Three-week-old rats were thymectomized (28), rested for a week, and then exposed to gamma radiation immediately before T cell transfer. The sublethal doses of gamma radiation for 3- to 4-wk-old BB/W and WF rats were 5 and 7 Gy, respectively. Donor T cells were transferred immediately after purification or after in vitro activation. T cell activation was performed in bacteriological petri dishes at a concentration of 106 cells/ml in Iscoves modified Dulbeccos medium supplemented with 10% FCS. Cells were incubated with PMA (20 ng/ml; Sigma), ionomycin (25 µM; Calbiochem, San Diego, CA), and 20 U/ml of rIL-2 at 37°C for 72 h. At the end of the culture, an aliquot of the cells was kept for phenotypic analysis, and the remaining cells were injected i.v. into the recipients. In cotransfer experiments, cells were mixed following activation in the indicated ratios. Thereafter, recipients were checked three times per week for the development of diabetes. Diabetic animals were killed after 3 consecutive days of stable hyperglycemia. Nondiabetic recipients were sacrificed at various intervals after transfer. The pancreas was fixed in 1% formalin and paraffin embedded, and sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin. MNC from lymph nodes and spleen were analyzed to determine the degree of engraftment of donor T cells.
Statistics
Statistical analysis of significance was performed using unpaired Students t test.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It has been previously demonstrated that T cell reconstitution of
BB/W rats early in life (
1 mo old) prevents the development of
diabetes, whereas reconstitution later in life (
2 mo old) is not
protective (16). To gain insight into the mechanisms underlying this
protection, or lack thereof, we developed a CD45 congenic strain of
diabetes-prone BB/W rats, named BB/W.7b, which provided the
opportunity to distinguish T cells of the isocongenic,
diabetes-resistant strain DR-BB/W from those of BB/W origin. As
illustrated in Table I
, the prevalence
and peak incidence of diabetes in BB/W.7b animals resulting
from the fourth to sixth backcrosses, were similar to those observed in
inbred, RT7a homozygous BB/W rats. The genetic
heterogeneity of BB/W.7b used in this study, although
limited, could have influenced their diabetogenic phenotype and
resulted in minor histocompatibility differences with the DR-BB/W
strain. These concerns can be ruled out for the following reasons.
BB/W.7b animals resulting from the ninth backcross
(BC) have now been generated in our laboratory. These animals
exhibit a peak incidence of diabetes and a cumulative incidence of the
disease similar to those in animals resulting from the fourth to sixth
BC. Further, the kinetics and magnitude of T cell reconstitution of
BB/W.7b rats from the ninth BC following injection of
DR-BB/W T cells are superimposable on those observed in animals
resulting from the fourth to sixth BC (data not shown). We therefore
analyzed the differential effects of i.v. injection of 2530 x
106 DR-BB/W T cells into BB/W.7b rats either
early or late in life on the development of diabetes.
|
Late T cell reconstitution of diabetes-prone BB/W rats results in the activation of donor-derived diabetogenic T cells
It has been demonstrated that T cells from acutely diabetic BB/W
rats can adoptively transfer diabetes to young syngeneic recipients as
long as donor T cells are preactivated in vitro (29). T cells of
DR-BB/W origin that were used for reconstitution of BB/W.7b
rats were purified from recipient splenocytes and subsequently tested
for their capacity to adoptively transfer diabetes. Four-week-old
thymectomized and sublethally irradiated (TX) BB/W rats were used as
recipients of DR-BB/W T cells to rule out a possible contribution of
recipient-derived T cells in the adoptive transfer system. In the
absence of T cell transfer, TCR
ß+ T cells accounted
for about 3% of the lymph node MNC, and <1% of splenic MNC in TX
BB/W rats 1 mo after irradiation. One month after T cell transfer,
secondary lymphoid organs of TX recipients contained 5- to 10-fold more
T cells than those of nontransferred recipients (Fig. 1
, A and B).
Importantly, the nontransferred TX animals uniformly fail to develop
diabetes or insulitis (Tables II and III).
|
|
|
|
DR-BB/W and BB/W rats are isocongenic animals differing at the lyp locus (30), and the former strain can develop type 1 diabetes after various manipulations. For example, diabetes can be induced in DR-BB/W rats by cyclophosphamide treatment (31), sublethal irradiation (32), or the combined administration of anti-RT6 mAb and poly(I:C) (33). In the same circumstances, other strains of animals, including those sharing the MHC haplotype of BB/W rats, fail to develop diabetes (31). It could therefore be argued that the presence and activation of islet cell-specific cells among DR-BB/W T cells used to reconstitute 2-mo-old BB/W.7b rats are related to the isocongenic nature of donor and recipient strains. To determine whether this is the case, we substituted DR-BB/W T cells with WF T cells for the reconstitution of diabetes-prone BB/W animals.
We and others have previously demonstrated that the life span of naive T cells in BB/W rats does not exceed 6 days as a consequence of the lyp mutation (4, 5). Rescue of BB/W recent thymic emigrants from premature apoptotic death can occur through activation by their specific Ag (5). Therefore, the capacity of BB/W rat peripheral T cells to respond to a given Ag requires the persistence of a continuous thymic output of T cells and/or previous exposure to this Ag. When BB/W rats are thymectomized, their pool of recirculating T cells is only comprised of T cells that have been exposed to their specific Ag before thymectomy. We have previously illustrated this point using the minor histocompatibility differences that exist between the BB/W and WF strains. Thus, injection of WF T cells in euthymic BB/W rats is followed by the rapid rejection of donor cells. In contrast, injection of WF T cells in thymectomized BB/W rats is followed by an expansion of donor cells (5). However, if BB/W rats are thymectomized after the injection and subsequent rejection of WF T cells, the recipients can mount a secondary immune response against another injection of WF T cells (5).
Similarly, thymectomy of BB/W rats before the initiation of insulitis
prevents diabetes, possibly because naive precursors of diabetogenic T
cells disappear rapidly from the pool of recirculating T cells after
thymectomy (Table IV
). In contrast,
thymectomy at 2 mo has little effect on the diabetogenic process (Table IV
), possibly because activation of diabetogenic T cells occurred
before thymectomy.
|
T cells of WF origin were isolated 1 mo after reconstitution from the
spleen of BB/W recipients that had developed diabetes and/or insulitis
and were adoptively transferred with or without preactivation to
syngeneic or BB/W TX recipients (Table V
). All TX recipients developed type 1
diabetes rapidly, independent of the activation state of WF T cells
(Table V
). In contrast, none of the TX recipients of WF T cells
isolated from BB/W rats thymectomized and reconstituted at 1 mo
developed diabetes or insulitis (Table V
).
|
Previous studies had indicated that T cell reconstitution of 2-mo-old BB/W rats had no effect on the ongoing diabetogenic process of recipients (16). In contrast, we demonstrate the pathogenicity of late T cell reconstitution in BB/W rats that results from the priming and expansion of islet cell-specific T cells of donor origin. Further, our results show that within the limits of our experimental conditions, the recruitment of ß-cell-specific T cells, present among unfractionated, donor-derived T cells, to the diabetogenic process cannot be regulated.
Lack of evidence for the existence of T cells that can regulate primed diabetogenic T cells
DR-BB/W T cells that were used for the reconstitution of
1-mo-old BB/W.7b rats were isolated from recipient
splenocytes 2 mo after reconstitution. At that time, donor-derived
cells accounted for 5560% of splenic T cells (not shown). Adoptive
transfer of 2 x 106 of these protective DR-BB/W T
cells to TX BB/W recipients failed to induce either diabetes or
insulitis among recipients (Table II
) in the following 3 mo. This
innocuity of DR-BB/W T cells was independent of their state of
activation at the time of transfer (Table II
). Similar results were
obtained when DR-BB/W T cells were substituted with WF T cells (Table V
). BB/W rats that were thymectomized at 1 mo did not develop diabetes
regardless of whether they were reconstituted with WF T cells or left
unmanipulated. When WF T cells were recovered 3 mo after reconstitution
of 1-mo-old thymectomized BB/W rats and adoptively transferred to
syngeneic or BB/W TX rats, none of the recipients developed diabetes or
insulitis, independent of the activation state of WF T cells (Table V
).
Increased levels of MHC class I expression and transcription of IFN-
are the first abnormalities that can be detected in the islet cells of
unmanipulated 1-mo-old BB/W rats (35, 36). It is unclear how T cell
reconstitution at this initial stage of the inflammatory process of
pancreatic islets results in complete protection of the recipients from
both diabetes and insulitis. T cell reconstitution could prevent
activation of diabetogenic T cells and/or regulate the effector
function of a limited number of primed, self-specific T cells. Using an
adoptive cotransfer system, we sought to determine whether DR-BB/W T
cells lost their diabetogenic potential and/or acquired the capacity to
modulate diabetogenic T cells during their expansion in 1-mo-old
BB/W.7b rats.
DR-BB/W T cells used for the reconstitution of 1- and 2-mo-old
BB/W.7b rats were recovered from 4-mo-old recipients, mixed
in a ratio of four protective T cells to one diabetogenic T cell, and
transferred, without preactivation, to TX BB/W rats. As illustrated in
Table II
, DR-BB/W T cells derived from BB/W.7b recipients
that had been reconstituted at 1 mo and protected from diabetes were
unable to prevent the adoptive transfer of diabetes induced by DR-BB/W
T cells recovered from diabetic BB/W.7b rats that had been
reconstituted at 2 mo. This lack of protection was reproduced in two
other experiments, one of which involved the transfer of T cell
populations that were mixed in a similar 4:1 ratio after in vitro
activation (data not shown). It is therefore unlikely that the
DR-BB/W T cells that expanded in 1-mo-old BB/W.7b
rats protected these animals from pancreatic inflammation through
regulation of the effector functions of diabetogenic T cells. However,
the limited numbers of DR-BB/W T cells recovered from reconstituted
BB/W.7b rats did not allow us to test higher ratios of
protective to diabetogenic T cells in our cotransfer system. It could
be argued, therefore, that the clonal expansion of diabetogenic T cells
among DR-BB/W T cells recovered from diabetic BB/W.7b
donors far exceeded the regulatory capacity of DR-BB/W T cells
recovered from protected BB/W.7b donors. We reasoned that
the optimal ratio of regulatory to potentially diabetogenic T cells
would be found in the protective DR-BB/W T cell population that was
used for the reconstitution of 1-mo-old BB/W.7b rats. We
determined whether this T cell population would remain nondiabetogenic
after transfer into animals whose pancreatic islets are the target of
an ongoing autoimmune response mediated by endogenous T cells.
Protective DR-BB/W T cells can become diabetogenic
We reconstituted 2-mo-old BB/W.7b rats with 5 x
106 DR-BB/W T cells that had been previously used for the
reconstitution of 1-mo-old BB/W.7b rats and had persisted
in these initial recipients for 3 mo. The subsequent 2-mo-old
BB/W.7b recipients of these DR-BB/W T cells became diabetic
3 wk after reconstitution (Table I
). The relatively low level of T cell
reconstitution observed in these animals was probably due to the low
number of DR-BB/W T cells injected at 2 mo (Table I
). DR-BB/W T cells
used in two successive reconstitutions were purified from the second
BB/W.7b recipients, activated, and then injected into TX
BB/W recipients. All the TX BB/W recipients became diabetic 21 days
after transfer (Table II
). These results demonstrate that T cell
reconstitution of 1-mo-old BB/W.7b rats does not result in
a long term physical or functional depletion of islet cell-specific T
cell precursors among donor cells or in the expansion of T cells that
can regulate the activation and expansion of diabetogenic T cells.
T cell subsets, including RT6+ T cells, from unmanipulated DR-BB/W donors become diabetogenic when cotransferred with low numbers of T cells from diabetic BB/W donors
The recruitment of adoptively transferred DR-BB/W T cells to the diabetogenic process of BB/W recipients occurs when T cell reconstitution is performed after the initiation of insulitis. This observation suggests that an established inflammatory process in the recipient islets is a prerequisite for the priming and expansion of diabetogenic cells among donor-derived T cells. We determined whether T cells from DR-BB/W rats would become diabetogenic when adoptively transferred to insulitis-free TX recipients containing primed diabetogenic T cells in numbers too low to induce insulitis by themselves.
Decreasing numbers of activated T cells isolated from acutely diabetic
and unmanipulated BB/W donors were injected alone or together with a
fixed number of activated DR-BB/W T cells into TX recipients (Table III
and V). Importantly, the DR-BB/W T cells used in the initial
series of cotransfers were isolated from the spleens of 3-mo-old
BB/W.7b animals that had been T cell reconstituted at 1 mo.
Therefore, induction of diabetes or insulitis could only originate from
BB/W T cells. A minimum of 106 T cells from acutely
diabetic BB/W donors were required to transfer diabetes or insulitis
when injected alone, and these cells had to be activated in vitro
before transfer (Table III
). However, diabetes could be induced by
adoptive transfer of as few as 103 activated BB/W T cells
when these cells were coinjected with DR-BB/W T cells (Table VI
). This induction of diabetes by the
cotransfer of BB/W and DR-BB/W T cells was observed even in the absence
of activation in vitro (not shown). Neither diabetes nor insulitis
could be induced when T cells from 1-mo-old prediabetic BB/W rats were
substituted for T cells from diabetic BB/W donors in our cotransfer
system (not shown), suggesting the need for in vivo priming and
expansion of diabetogenic T cells in our cotransfer model. Three
conclusions can be drawn from these results. Advanced insulitis does
not seem necessary for the priming and clonal expansion of diabetogenic
cells among DR-BB/W T cells. The frequency of diabetogenic cells among
splenic T cells from diabetic BB/W rats is at least 10-3.
DR-BB/W T cells recovered from BB/W.7b rats that had been T
cell reconstituted at 1 mo failed to regulate diabetogenic BB/W T cells
even when DR-BB/W T cells exceeded BB/W T cells by a factor of 700.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our results demonstrate that T cell reconstitution of BB/W rats after the initiation of insulitis is not neutral vis-a-vis the ongoing autoimmune process of the recipients. Rather, it is deleterious due to the recruitment of donor-derived T cells to the diabetogenic process. This precipitation of diabetes after late T cell reconstitution demonstrates that unfractionated T cells originating from diabetes-resistant donors are unable to regulate primed diabetogenic BB/W T cells even in circumstances where normal T cells outnumber pathogenic T cells by almost 1000-fold. Furthermore, the reconstituting T cells fail to regulate their own autoreactive potential.
This is the first demonstration of the exacerbation of an ongoing autoimmune process through adoptive transfer of unfractionated T cells derived from normal donors. This observation probably results from the effects of the BB/W lyp allele on the life span of T cells. In most cases where regulation of an ongoing autoimmune process by adoptively transferred T cells was attempted, the recipients were not lymphopenic, and/or the life spans of donor and recipient T cells were similar. If activation of donor-derived, autoreactive T cells occurred in these circumstances, their clonal expansion was probably limited compared with that of recipient-derived T cells and hence unlikely to profoundly alter the course of the ongoing autoimmune process (40, 41). This is not the case in the model of BB/W rats reconstituted with T cells, in which both resting and activated T cells of recipient origin are short lived (5), while donor T cells have a normal life span. Consequently, the clonal expansion of donor-derived, islet-specific T cells following their adoptive transfer in lymphopenic BB/W rats and the subsequent contribution of these donor T cells to the ongoing antipancreatic autoimmune process are likely to overcome those of recipient T cells. Our results also show that the lyp allele of the BB/W rat, which is known to contribute to the development of diabetes, is at least partly responsible for the slow progression of T cell-mediated ß-cell destruction in unmanipulated animals.
It has been suggested that one potential mechanism through which the BB/W lyp allele contributes to the development of antipancreatic autoimmunity is the impaired development of T cells that express RT6 and can regulate self-specific T cells (16, 33, 42, 43, 44, 45). This hypothesis is based on three observations. BB/W rats lack peripheral T cells expressing RT6 on their surface (43). Diabetes can be induced in nonlymphopenic rats that are normally diabetes resistant, through Ab-mediated depletion of RT6+ T cells (33, 44, 45). Early T cell reconstitution of diabetes-prone BB/W rats with cells expressing RT6 prevents diabetes (42). Our cotransfer experiments demonstrate that RT6+ T cells derived from diabetes-resistant donors are potentially diabetogenic and fail to regulate pathogenic T cells even in circumstances where RT6+ T cells outnumber diabetogenic T cells by almost 100-fold. These results argue against a regulatory role for a subset of RT6+ T cells against antipancreatic autoimmunity, at least when this subset is part of unfractionated T cells, or a T cell population enriched in RT6+ cells.
While our results confirm that early T cell reconstitution of BB/W rats protects these animals from diabetes (16), they provide indirect evidence that this protection does not result from the development of an islet cell-specific regulatory T cell subset. As previously reported, we could not detect an infiltration of pancreatic islets by mononuclear cells in protected animals (16). The protective T cells that were allowed to expand in BB/W recipients for 3 mo were unable to regulate very low numbers of diabetogenic T cells in our cotransfer experiments. More importantly, the diabetogenic potential of these protective T cells, as shown by our "double-parking" experiments and our cotransfer experiments, is indistinguishable from that of T cells derived from unmanipulated, diabetes-resistant donors.
How, then, does T cell reconstitution of 1-mo-old recipients mediate protection? BB/W rat T cells can mount an immune response against alloantigens and nominal Ags, including self Ags (5). Although these T cell responses are relatively slow compared with those observed in animals carrying a different lyp allele, they are vigorous enough to reject an allograft and destroy pancreatic islets (1, 5). It is therefore tempting to propose that the protective effect of normal T cells early in life does not result from the response of these protective T cells to a specific Ag, but, rather, from their capacity to restore a pattern of recirculation and/or cytokine secretion critical to preventing pancreatic ß-cells from becoming immunogenic. This protection from diabetes afforded by T cells would require a functional lyp gene.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Philippe Poussier, Arthritis and Immune Disorder Research Center, 620 University Avenue, Suite 700, c/o Ontario Cancer Institute, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G 2M9. E-mail address: ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: BB/W, diabetes-prone Biobreeding/Worcester rats; DR-BB/W, diabetes-resistant BB/W rats; WF, Wistar Furth; MNC, mononuclear cells; PE, phycoerythrin; TX, thymectomized and sublethally irradiated; BC, backcross; IDDM, insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. ![]()
Received for publication December 3, 1998. Accepted for publication February 8, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
chains. Hybridoma 1:125.[Medline]
/ß in the intestinal epithelium. J. Exp. Med. 178:1947.
precedes diabetes in both the BB rat and streptozotocin-treated mice. Immunity 1:469.[Medline]
/ß T cells in secondary lymphoid organs. J. Exp. Med. 177:891.
-chains (CD25). J. Immunol. 155:1151.[Abstract]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. Lundsgaard, T. L. Holm, L. Hornum, and H. Markholst In Vivo Control of Diabetogenic T-Cells by Regulatory CD4+CD25+ T-Cells Expressing Foxp3 Diabetes, April 1, 2005; 54(4): 1040 - 1047. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Ramanathan, M.-T. Bihoreau, A. D. Paterson, L. Marandi, D. Gauguier, and P. Poussier Thymectomy and Radiation-Induced Type 1 Diabetes in Nonlymphopenic BB Rats Diabetes, October 1, 2002; 51(10): 2975 - 2981. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Ramanathan, L. Marandi, and P. Poussier Evidence for the Extrathymic Origin of Intestinal TCR{gamma}{delta}+ T Cells in Normal Rats and for an Impairment of This Differentiation Pathway in BB Rats J. Immunol., March 1, 2002; 168(5): 2182 - 2187. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. P.L. Chiu, D. V. Serreze, and J. S. Danska Development and Function of Diabetogenic T-cells in B-cell-Deficient Nonobese Diabetic Mice Diabetes, April 1, 2001; 50(4): 763 - 770. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||