|
|
||||||||
Department of Biochemistry, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA 02111
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Crystallographic analysis has provided important insights into heavy (H)3 and light (L) chain contributions to Ag binding and has revealed that all six complementarity determining region (CDR) residues of both H and L chains provide contacts for Ag binding by most Abs (10). The third CDR of the H chain (CDR3H) domain provides contact sites in all Abs and, in most cases, it provides more contacts than the other CDR loops (10). That is true for an anti-DNA autoantibody that has been crystallized with bound oligonucleotide (dT)3 (11), and is predicted to be true for other anti-nucleic acid Abs that have been crystallized in the unliganded form (12).
Crystal structures are not available for most Abs, but information about their important binding site amino acids can be inferred, with caution, from experiments involving directed mutagenesis. Many anti-DNA autoantibodies contain Arg residues at relatively high frequency in CDR sequences (13, 14) and mutagenesis studies have shown that these residues are often important for DNA binding (15). In many anti-DNA autoantibodies, the V region H chain (VH) plays a dominant role, determining nucleic acid binding even when combined with various V region L chains (VL) domains (16). One strong anti-dsDNA Ab was affinity labeled only in the H chain by oligonucleotide (17); and, in the cases of several anti-DNA Abs, the VH domain alone can bind to nucleic acid Ags (18, 19, 20, 21). Recently we found that VH domains coded by cDNA from PBLs of healthy human adults (and therefore not known to be derived from anti-DNA Abs) could bind ssDNA and poly(dT) (22).
One of the DNA-binding VH domains is that of mAb Z22, obtained from a C57BL/6 mouse immunized with Z-DNA-MBSA complexes (20). mAb Z22 is an IgG mAb highly selective for Z-DNA. It binds to Z-DNA of varying base sequence, probably interacting in part with the phosphate backbone of the helix (23). Recombinant single chain variable fragment (scFv), containing both VH and VL domains of Z22, has the same affinity, selectivity, and Id as the parent Ab (20). Swapping of domains of rZ22 scFv with those of other Igs revealed that a correct VH-VL combination is required for Ag binding within the context of Z22 variable fragment (Fv) (24) and that CDR3H residues play a critical role in that binding. Substitution of just one or a few CDR3H residues either eliminates Ag-binding by the Fv or modifies its selectivity to yield autoantibody-like polyreactivity with ssDNA and dsDNA as well as Z-DNA (25). Moreover, the rZ22 VH domain alone can bind the Z-DNA form of poly(dG-dC) with approximately the same affinity as the scFv or Fab. Like the parent Ab, the VH domain does not bind the B form of poly(dG-dC) (20).
These findings raise the question of whether Z-DNA binding by the VH domain of Z22 is the same as or differs fundamentally from binding by the Fv domain. We first compared Ag-binding selectivity of VH and Fv domains. Then, to test whether Z22 CDR3H is a critical region for DNA binding in VH as it is in Fv, and whether the same amino acids are involved in DNA binding by both VH alone and VH within Fv, we compared the effects of several amino acid substitutions on binding by both VH and Fv domains. We discuss implications of natural autoantibody-like activity of the isolated VH domain.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Bacterial plasmid vectors pIg16 and pIg20, designed for
expression of scFv containing original or substituted VH and VL Z22
domains, and pIg16VH and pIg20VH (with only the VH domain), were
reported previously (20, 24, 26). DNA fragments coding for VH domains
with one to four substitutions (25) were cut out of the scFv constructs
by digestion with restriction enzymes XmaI and
XbaI (New England Biolabs, Beverly, MA). The excised DNA
fragments were gel purified and ligated into similarly digested and
purified pIg16VH or pIg20VH vectors for expression of each VH
domain fused to a B domain of Staphylococcal protein A (SPA) (Table I
and Fig. 1
).
|
|
Transformation of Escherichia coli BL21(DE3)pLysE (27) with pIg16- or pIg20-based constructs of VH, mutant VH, scFv, and mutant scFv, identification of isopropylthiogalactoside-sensitive colonies, induction of recombinant protein synthesis, and purification of the products were performed as described previously (21, 24). Samples of 1.5 µg of purified recombinant proteins were subjected to SDS-PAGE with 2-ME for analysis of the size and purity of products (21). Gels were stained with Coomassie blue.
Ags for binding assays
Poly(dA), poly(dT), poly(dU), and poly(dG-dC) were purchased from Pharmacia (Piscataway, NJ). (dC)80 was synthesized by the Protein Resource Laboratory at Tufts University School of Medicine (Boston, MA). The Z-DNA form of poly(dG-dC) was prepared and stabilized by bromination as described (28) and dialyzed against PBS at 4°C overnight. Calf thymus dsDNA from Sigma (St. Louis, MO) was used as dsDNA and was boiled for 10 min and chilled on ice for preparation of ssDNA.
Polynucleotide binding by recombinant scFv, modified scFv, VH, and modified VH proteins
Binding of recombinant proteins to various polynucleotides was tested by ELISA as described (29). Wells of UV-treated microtiter plates (Immulon I, Dynatech, Alexandria, VA) were coated with polynucleotides at a concentration of 2 µg/ml in PBS. Rabbit IgG, 1 µg/ml in PBS, was used to detect the SPA domain of recombinant protein. Alkaline phosphatase-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG (Boehringer Mannheim, Indianapolis, IN), diluted 1:6000, was used to detect bound rabbit IgG. All reaction volumes were 100 µl. A410 was read after 1 h of color development after addition of substrate. Relative binding activity, a measure of binding per unit protein concentration, was calculated based on the concentration required to reach an A410 of 0.5. The value of 0.5 was chosen because it was near the end-point but still in the linear portion of parallel titration curves. In competitive ELISA, Z22 VH was incubated with polynucleotides in solution for 30 min and the mixture was added to wells coated with Z-DNA or ssDNA. In all ELISA experiments, Ab fragments were incubated in Ag-coated wells for 1 h. Each Ab fragment concentration was tested in duplicate, and experiments were repeated two or three times, as indicated in figure legends.
Thrombin cleavage of pIg20 VH-SPA fusion protein
A total of 200 µg of rVH-SPA fusion protein in 500 µl of PBS with 2.5 mM CaCl2 was digested with 3.5 µg of thrombin (17.5% W/W; Hematologic Technologies, Essex Junction, VT) at 25°C for 2 h. EDTA was added to a final concentration of 5 mM to stop the reaction. The mixture of cleaved SPA and VH was mixed with 200 µl of IgG-Sepharose beads and rocked overnight at 4°C. On centrifugation, the VH was in the supernatant; the SPA fragment was bound to sedimented beads and was eluted from them with 0.1 M acetic acid, pH 3.4.
Gel filtration of VH- and VH-Z-DNA complexes
In a test of the VH-SPA domain size under nondenaturing conditions, 10 µg of recombinant protein in 1 ml of PBS was passed through a polyacrylamide P100 (Pharmacia) size-exclusion column (1.4 x 48 cm) equilibrated with PBS, pH 7.2. Protein was washed through the column with 80 ml of PBS, and fractions of 1 ml were collected. For detection of recombinant protein, 50-µl samples of each fraction were coated on wells of a microtiter plate, and the immobilized protein was detected through its SPA domain with rabbit IgG and alkaline phophatase as in the ELISA (21). The column had been calibrated with samples of 500 µg of each of albumin (Mr 66,000; Sigma), carbonic anhydrase (Mr 29,000; Sigma) and cytochrome c (Mr 12,400; Sigma).
To measure soluble complexes, we incubated an excess (100 µg) of Z-DNA with 25 µg of rVH-SPA in 1 ml of PBS for 1 h at room temperature and passed the mixture through the Sephacryl S100 size-exclusion column (1.4 x 48 cm). Fractions of 1 ml were collected, and recombinant protein was detected by ELISA with rabbit IgG and enzyme-conjugated anti-rabbit IgG as described above. The fraction of VH that bound to Z-DNA was calculated as the ratio of A410 readings at the void volume peak (VH complexed to Z-DNA) to the sum of the A410 readings for the void volume and the included peak (free VH).
In vitro association of VH and VL
A total of 400 µg of rVH-SPA and rVL-SPA fusion proteins were mixed and incubated at room temperature for 1 h. The mixture was dialyzed in PBS at 4°C overnight and applied to a Sephacryl S100 (3.5 x 56 cm) size-exclusion column. Then, 240 ml of PBS was collected in 5 ml fractions for the first 80 ml and 2-ml fractions for the following 160 ml. The A280 reading for each fraction provided the size distribution of protein in the VH plus VL mixture. Samples of 10 µl from several fractions were analyzed for VH and VL content by Western blotting. Rabbit IgG and alkaline phosphatase-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG were used for detection of recombinant protein on the blots.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In previous studies, soluble recombinant scFv and VH fragments of
anti-Z-DNA Ab Z22 retained the affinity of the parental Fab (20).
The Fab, scFv, and VH fragments all bound the Z-form but not the B-form
of poly(dG-dC) (20). In the present study, DNA fragments coding for VH
domains with directed substitutions (Table I
) were cloned into pIg16H-
or pIg20H-based vectors for the expression of VH-SPA domains alone. The
pIg20 and pIg16 products differ only by the presence of a thrombin
cleavage site between the Ig and SPA domains in the pIg20 form. DNA
sequencing of scFv and VH mutants confirmed that expected mutations
were present and the correct reading frame was intact.
All scFv, scFv mutants, VH, and VH mutants were produced by transformed E. coli BL21(DE)pLysE cells as soluble fusion proteins, each linked to one B domain of SPA. The SPA served as a tag for purification of recombinant proteins by IgG-Sepharose and detection of recombinant proteins by Western blot and ELISA assays. It was shown previously that the SPA in the fusion protein does not interfere with VH-VL association or Ag binding (20). In a further test in this study, SPA was cleaved from fusion protein. Isolated SPA did not bind to any of the polynucleotides tested (data not shown).
Yields of purified scFv or VH proteins varied from 0.3 to 2.2 mg/L of
bacterial culture supernatant. SDS-PAGE and Coomassie blue staining
confirmed that the recombinant fragments had the predicted sizes: 34
kDa for the scFv-SPA and 20 kDa for the VH-SPA (Fig. 2
B). The N99K, H3M18, and
H3M34 VH proteins are slightly larger than the others because a larger
PCR primer (including several bases of the C region) was used in the
original cloning of this domain into the scFv (25).
|
Binding of Z22 VH to soluble Z-DNA
The ability of VH protein to bind to Z-DNA in solution was tested
by incubation of a mixture of 100 µg of Z-DNA (determined in
preliminary experiments to be an excess) and 25 µg VH in 1 ml of PBS
at room temperature for 1 h, followed by analysis with a Sephacryl
S-100 column. Free VH-SPA protein was entirely in the included volume.
Approximately 19% of the Z22 VH protein formed a stable complex with
polynucleotide by this measurement, emerging at the void volume with
Z-DNA (Fig. 3
, A and
B). The amount of protein in the complex was increased to
32% by incubation of the VH and DNA mixture at 37°C for 3 h
before it was loaded onto the column. When VH protein with a S98A
mutation was incubated with 50 µg of Z-DNA, 23% of the protein
emerged with the Z-DNA.
|
Fab or scFv of Ab Z22 bind selectively to Z-DNA, but not to
dsDNA or ssDNA (20). In the present study, a high concentration of scFv
did show weak binding to poly(dT) but not to several other synthetic
polynucleotides. In contrast, Z22VH alone was much less selective. It
showed strong binding to Z-DNA, poly(dT), poly(dC), and poly(dU),
moderate binding to ssDNA, and weak binding to dsDNA. It did not bind
to poly(dA) or the B-form poly(dG-dC) (Table II
). In competitive ELISA, testing
interactions in solution, Z-DNA was the most effective competitor among
the soluble polynucleotides tested, whether Z-DNA or ssDNA was the
immobilized Ag (Fig. 4
). VH domains from
both pIg16 and pIg20 were expressed and tested for Ag binding. The
thrombin site residues in pIg20 did not affect selectivity of
polynucleotide binding (not shown). In a previous study, the VL-SPA
domain alone did not bind to Z-DNA (20). A newly prepared sample used
in the current experiments did bind the DNA when used at concentrations
six times higher than those required with the VH-SPA domain. Even at
the higher concentrations, the Z22 VL-SPA domain with F94L and F96W
substitutions did not bind any of the polynucleotides tested; nor did
the VL domain of a closely related anti-Z-DNA mAb, Z44, or that of
an anti-guanylate mAb.
|
|
Extensive modification of the CDR3H segment, replacing four
residues by Ala and two residues by Asp, eliminated polynucleotide
binding activity of both the scFv and the VH domains (Table III
), indicating that CDR3H contributes
to binding by both proteins. Previous studies showed that a single N99K
substitution in the scFv context totally eliminated Z-DNA binding,
indicating the importance of N99 for Z22 activity. However, more than
that Asn residue is required, as neither the scFv nor the VH with the
mutant DAAANAAAMDY sequence bound to any of the polynucleotides.
Substitution of three or four amino acids (H3M18 and H3M34), including
N99, caused a marked loss of binding by Fv but no reduction in binding
by VH (Table III
).
|
Direct tests for modulation of polynucleotide binding by Z22 VL
When equal amounts of VH-SPA and VL-SPA were mixed in vitro and
applied to a Sephacryl S-100 size-exclusion column, most of the protein
emerged as one major peak corresponding in size to a VH-VL heterodimer
(Fig. 5
A). Western blotting
showed that the major peak had equimolar amounts of VH and VL,
indicating that the soluble recombinant V domains are able to assemble
in solution into a stable 1:1 complex (Fig. 5
B). The same
experiments were also performed with the modified VH domains S98A and
N99K. S98A VH associated with Z22 VL as effectively as did wild-type
Z22 VH. However, N99KVH associated poorly with Z22 VL; only a small
percentage of the protein mixture was in the heterodimer peak.
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our experiments identified two major differences in nucleic acid Ag binding by the VH alone and the Fv domain of anti-Z-DNA mAb Z22. First, although the VH retains the ability to distinguish between Z-DNA and B-DNA forms of poly(dG-dC), it is much less selective than the scFv when assayed with other polynucleotides. Unlike the scFv, VH alone binds to immobilized or soluble polypyrimidines and ssDNA as well as Z-DNA. Second, introduction of single and combined mutations revealed that the contacts with Z-DNA are not precisely the same for the scFv and the VH alone. The experiments also demonstrated that association of VL with VH is able to modulate or veto the DNA binding potential of the VH domain.
These results extend previous work in this laboratory with mAb Z22
domains (20, 25). The earlier work had not measured reactions of VH
alone with polynucleotides other than Z-DNA or B-DNA forms of
poly(dG-dC) (20) and had measured the effects of CDR mutations only in
the context of the scFv (25). Consistent with the previous studies
(20), higher concentrations of VH than scFv were required for an
equivalent ELISA measurement of binding to Z-DNA immobilized on the
solid phase (Tables I and II), even though affinities measured by
surface plasmon resonance were similar for the two domains (20).
Competitive immunoassays were more concordant with the affinities, as
similar concentrations of soluble Z-DNA (
0.1 µg/ml) were required
for 50% inhibition of VH or scFv binding to immobilized Z-DNA (20);
the same soluble Z-DNA concentration was inhibitory in the present
study (Fig. 4
). As discussed previously, the differences in
noncompetitive and competitive ELISA may reflect concentrations of
properly folded protein or Fv dimerization.
A different combination of CDR3H residues is required for Z-DNA binding by the VH domain alone and the scFv. Substitution of four CDR3H residues by alanine and one by aspartate completely eliminated binding by the VH alone, indicating that CDR3H is important for the VH alone, as it is for the scFv (20). However, although N99 is critically important in the Fv binding, it is not critical in the VH domain alone. Contributions from CDR1 and CDR2 to Ag binding by the VH domains are possible, as they were for isolated anti-oxazolone and anti-lysozyme VH domains (30). B cell superantigen-like interaction with framework residues (31) may also contribute. Substitutions in the CDR3H can also affect VH-VL interaction, as evidenced by the poor association of the N99K-containing VH with wild-type Z22VL.
A question arises whether the VH resembles a native V domain. The presence of a B domain of SPA in the fusion protein may favor correct folding (32). Other examples of isolated VH domains have features of native structure, identified by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (33) or x-ray crystallography (34). The Z22VH-SPA fusion protein had little or no aggregated material. About 75% of the VH and VL protein associated to form a functional 1:1 heterodimer with the same binding selectivity as the parent Fab, indicating that most of the VH was at least able to assume a native conformation. However, only part of a Z22VH sample formed a stable complex when mixed with an excess of Z-DNA. An increase in the active fraction following incubation of the VH protein at 37°C indicates that some VH conformations may be interchangeable between active and inactive forms. Another portion of the protein may not be activable, perhaps as a result of exposure to low pH during elution from the affinity column.
The role of VH in Ag binding
The Ag-binding activities of separated H and L chains of various Abs were assessed soon after the separation of Ab chains was first achieved (35). In most of these early experiments, the separate chains retained little activity, but Ag binding was partially restored on recombination of the chains (36, 37, 38, 39). The most complete recovery of activity occurred when homologous H and L chains were recombined, indicating that both chains contribute to forming an Ag-binding site. This conclusion was substantiated when it was recognized that both H and L chains could be affinity labeled by hapten (40), and it has been amply confirmed in many crystal structures of Ag-Ab complexes (10). However, in most complexes there are more H chain contacts than L chain contacts with Ag (10), and the CDR3H makes more contacts than other CDRs. This distribution of contact residues is consistent with the early experiments with separate chains, noted above, in which the H chain alone had more Ag binding activity than the isolated L chain, even if both were very much less active than intact IgG. A particularly high level of activity of a single chain occurred in the case of a polyclonal purified Ab to p-aminophenyl-ß-lactoside, in which the H chain affinity for hapten was 87% of that measured with mildly reduced but still intact Ig (41). The high Ag binding potential of H chains is evident in camel serum Ab, a large fraction of which is comprised of H chain dimers (42). In recent years, several examples of Ag binding VH domains other than those of anti-DNA Abs have been identified, including lysozyme- or hemocyanin-binding VH domains isolated from immunized animals (43).
The H chain often plays a dominant role in Abs to DNA. The prominence of VH in determining DNA binding activity is a property of disease-related autoantibodies (16, 19, 21) as well as Abs induced by immunization with nucleic acids (20). In mice transgenic for the H chain of a disease-related anti-dsDNA autoantibody, the ability of that H chain to direct dsDNA binding, i.e., potentially harmful autoreactivity, led to either elimination of large numbers of B cells (44) or B cell anergy (45). Some B cells did escape this negative regulation through a mechanism of receptor editing (46), in which that H chain became associated with an L chain that vetoed DNA binding. Both the modulating activity of the L chain and its contribution to the binding of different Ags may determine the fate of developing B cells (47). In a lupus-prone mouse, B cells develop even if they express a DNA-binding Ab (48). Thus normal regulatory mechanisms monitor the autoreactive dsDNA binding activity of B cell products, and the H chain properties are particularly prominent in that autoreactivity. A breakdown of normal regulation permits expansion, class switching, mutation, and affinity maturation of anti-DNA Abs in lupus subjects.
A possible role for VH ligand binding activity in preimmunization B cell selection
Perhaps this close monitoring of DNA binding follows from the relatively frequent occurrence of anti-ssDNA reactivity in "natural autoantibodies" or products of quiescent but potentially autoreactive B cells in normal subjects (49, 50). The binding properties of these natural autoantibodies resemble those of the isolated VH domain of mAb Z22. For example, IgM anti-DNA autoantibodies are not as selective as immunization-induced Abs; they often bind poly(dT), and some of them bind Z-DNA (51). It is not known whether B cells making natural autoantibodies are direct precursors of cells that make disease-related autoantibodies or immunization-induced Abs, but poly(dT) binding is common not only among nonpathogenic IgM natural autoantibodies; it is also common among class-switched mutated IgG Abs in humans or mice with active disease (52, 53, 54). Representation of Z-DNA binding in the background of "natural autoantibody" may account for the fact that Z22 and another highly selective IgG mAb, Z44, have been formed with very few VH mutations from germline sequences (55, 56).
Polypyrimidine binding is a form of autoreactivity that was also noted with normal VH domains, such as those coded in clones of cDNA libraries made from normal circulating B cells (19, 22). In these cases, it could not be known whether the VH domains were derived from natural anti-DNA Abs, but the frequency of poly(dT) binding was high (5 of 11) in a small sample of cDNA clones from a healthy young adult (22). We are now exploring the occurrence of such binding activity with VH domains cloned from cDNA libraries and single human neonatal (cord blood) B cells. A high frequency of polypyrimidine binding could reflect a functionally important role for this property in B cell development and selection before exposure to exogenous Ags. Structural features of polypyrimidines or Z-DNA may be, or may mimic, self-ligands that are important in positive as well as negative selection of B cells.
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Department of Biochemistry, Tufts University School of Medicine, 136 Harrison Avenue, Boston, MA 02111. E-mail address: ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: H, heavy; L, light; CDR, complementarity determining region; CDR3H, third complementarity determining region of the heavy chain; Fv, variable fragment; scFv, single chain variable fragment, comprising both VH and VL; SPA, Staphylococcal protein A; VH, variable domain of the heavy chain; comprising VH, DH, and JH segments; VL, variable domain of the light chain, comprising VL and IL segments. ![]()
Received for publication November 16, 1998. Accepted for publication January 14, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
Y.-R. Kim, J.-S. Kim, S.-H. Lee, W.-R. Lee, J.-N. Sohn, Y.-C. Chung, H.-K. Shim, S.-C. Lee, M.-H. Kwon, and Y.-S. Kim Heavy and Light Chain Variable Single Domains of an Anti-DNA Binding Antibody Hydrolyze Both Double- and Single-stranded DNAs without Sequence Specificity J. Biol. Chem., June 2, 2006; 281(22): 15287 - 15295. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Li, L. Fernandez, K. C. O'Connor, T. Imanishi-Kari, and B. D. Stollar The Rearranged VH Domain of a Physiologically Selected Anti-Single-Stranded DNA Antibody as a Precursor for Formation of IgM and IgG Antibodies to Diverse Antigens J. Immunol., October 1, 2001; 167(7): 3746 - 3755. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H.-L. Wun, D. T.-M. Leung, K.-C. Wong, Y.-L. Chui, and P.-L. Lim Molecular mimicry: anti-DNA antibodies may arise inadvertently as a response to antibodies generated to microorganisms Int. Immunol., September 1, 2001; 13(9): 1099 - 1107. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. M. A. Hoet, M. Pieffers, M. H. W. Stassen, J. Raats, R. de Wildt, G. J. M. Pruijn, F. van den Hoogen, and W. J. van Venrooij The Importance of the Light Chain for the Epitope Specificity of Human Anti-U1 Small Nuclear RNA Autoantibodies Present in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Patients J. Immunol., September 15, 1999; 163(6): 3304 - 3312. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |