|
|
||||||||
RI Subunits: A New Regulatory Step in the Fc
RI Signaling Cascade Revealed by Studies of Fc
RI Dimer Signaling Activity1





*
Departamento de Inmunologia, Instituto de Investigaciones Biomedicas, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico; and
Department of Pathology and Cancer Research and Treatment Center, University of New Mexico Health Sciences Center, Albuquerque, NM 87131
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ß
2) IgE receptor,
Fc
RI, of mast cells activates two tyrosine kinases: Lyn, which
phosphorylates ß and
subunit immunoreceptor tyrosine-based
activation motifs, and Syk, which binds
-phospho-immunoreceptor
tyrosine-based activation motifs and initiates cellular responses. We
studied three Fc
RI-dimerizing mAbs that maintain similar dispersed
distributions over the surface of RBL-2H3 mast cells but elicit very
different signaling responses. Specifically, mAb H10 receptor dimers
induce very little inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate synthesis,
Ca2+ mobilization, secretion, spreading, ruffling, and
actin plaque assembly, whereas dimers generated with the other
anti-Fc
RI mAbs induce responses that are only modestly lower
than that to multivalent Ag. H10 receptor dimers activate Lyn and
support Fc
RI ß and
subunit phosphorylation but are poor Syk
activators compared with Ag and the other anti-Fc
RI mAbs. H10
receptor dimers have two other distinguishing features. First, they
induce stable complexes between activated Lyn and receptor subunits.
Second, the predominant Lyn-binding phospho-ß isoform found in mAb
H10-treated cells is a less tyrosine phosphorylated, more
electrophoretically mobile species than the predominant isoform in
Ag-treated cells that does not coprecipitate with Lyn. These studies
implicate Lyn dissociation from highly phosphorylated receptor subunits
as a new regulatory step in the Fc
RI signaling cascade required for
Syk activation and signal progression. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
RI,3 activates a
signaling sequence that leads within minutes to degranulation and
membrane/cytoskeletal responses, including actin polymerization,
ruffling, spreading, integrin activation, and actin plaque assembly,
and within hours to increased cytokine synthesis (reviewed in 1 .
Recent studies have provided insight into the sequence of early events
by which cross-linking this multichain (
ß
2) immune system
receptor leads to functional responses. RBL-2H3 rat tumor mast cells
contain two Fc
RI-associated protein tyrosine kinases, the
Src-related enzyme, Lyn (2), whose principal substrates are the
receptors ß and
subunits (3), and PTK72/Syk (4), which
phosphorylates a wide range of downstream signaling molecules,
including phospholipase C
isoforms, the p85 subunit of
phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase, Vav, Grb2, and others (5, 6, 7, 8, 9), and is
essential for all known Fc
RI-mediated responses (3). In resting
RBL-2H3 cells, a proportion of Lyn associates with the Fc
RI ß
subunit (10, 11) in an SH4 domain-dependent fashion (12). Fc
RI
cross-linking permits Lyn associated with one receptor to phosphorylate
tyrosines located within immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation
motifs (ITAMs) in the ß and
subunits of the adjacent receptor.
Some of the resulting ß subunit phosphotyrosines serve as binding
sites for the recruitment and activation of more Lyn molecules that, in
turn, support more subunit phosphorylation (10). Other phosphotyrosines
bind other signaling molecules containing SH2 domain motifs.
Analyses of subunit cytoplasmic domain sequences have shown that the
Fc
RI
subunit contains a typical ITAM, with 10 amino acids,
including three threonines, between the two critical tyrosine residues
(reviewed in 13 . It has been established that both
-ITAM
tyrosines are phosphorylated to approximately similar levels in
activated cells (14) and that the doubly phosphorylated Fc
RI
-ITAMs serve as binding sites for the tandem SH2 domains of Syk,
resulting in its autophosphorylation and activation (15). These and
other data identify Syk as the principal
-ITAM ligand. In contrast,
the Fc
RI ß-ITAM has only nine amino acids, including two serines
and a tyrosine between the typical ITAM tyrosines, and its three
tyrosines are phosphorylated to different extents (membrane distal
> membrane proximal > internal) (14). Ligands for the
phosphorylated ß subunit ITAM include Lyn and the negative signaling
molecule, inositol polyphosphate 5-phosphatase (16). As well as
stimulating tyrosine phosphorylation, Fc
RI cross-linking stimulates
ß-ITAM serine and
-ITAM threonine phosphorylation (7, 14, 17). The
identities of the kinases and the contributions of these ITAM
phosphorylation events to signal transduction are not yet established
(discussed in 17 .
ITAM motifs are found in the cytoplasmic tails of other members of the
multichain immune recognition receptor family that includes, in
addition to the Fc
RI, the TCR, the B cell receptor, and several
Fc
receptors. Engagement of all these receptors results in ITAM
tyrosine phosphorylation mediated by receptor-associated Src kinases,
creating sites for the binding and activation of Syk kinases that, in
turn, phosphorylate and activate enzymes that initiate a variety of
response pathways (reviewed in Refs. 13, 18, and 19). Thus, the model
of signal initiation by sequential kinase activation described above is
not limited to the Fc
RI signaling cascade, but applies to a family
of related receptors.
In 1988, Ortega and colleagues reported the development of a series of
mAbs, designated F4, J17, and H10, specific for the
subunit of the
Fc
RI expressed on RBL-2H3 cells (20). All three of these
anti-Fc
RI mAbs induced secretion, supporting previous evidence
(reviewed in 21 that the Fc
RI dimer is the minimal unit
capable of activating Fc
RI-coupled responses. Importantly,
comparison of the secretory dose-response curves with the extent of
Fc
RI dimerization demonstrated that not all dimers have equivalent
signaling activities. In particular, anti-Fc
RI mAb H10-induced
dimers elicited substantially less secretion than anti-Fc
RI mAbs
F4 and J17. The differences discovered between these anti-Fc
RI
mAbs in studies of the kinetics of Fc
RI dimerization induced by each
Ab and in biophysical studies of dimerized receptor properties,
including rotational mobility and dimer lifetime, could not
unambiguously explain the low signaling activity of mAb H10 (20, 21, 22, 23).
Thus, it was proposed that configurational differences between dimers
induced by mAb H10, compared with mAbs F4 or J17, might contribute to
their different signaling activities.
We have used this battery of anti-Fc
RI mAbs to explore the
initial events in the Fc
RI signaling cascade. The experiments
reported here support previous evidence that all three mAbs generate
Fc
RI dimers but not higher oligomers and substantially extend
previous evidence for the limited signaling activity of H10-induced
dimers in comparison with dimers induced with mAbs F4 and J17.
Importantly, they link the weak signaling activity of H10-induced
dimers to the formation of stable complexes between Lyn and
incompletely phosphorylated Fc
RI.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The preparation and characterization of three anti-Fc
RI
mAbs, H10 (IgG2b), F4 (IgG1), and J17 (IgG1) were described previously
(20). Polyclonal anti-phosphotyrosine Ab was produced by G. Deanin
and J. Potter, University of New Mexico, and purified as described
previously (24). DNP-specific anti-IgE mAb (anti-DNP-IgE) (25)
was purified from ascites as previously described (26). Rabbit
anti-IgE Ab was prepared as described previously (27). mAb to the
Fc
RI ß subunit was a gift from Dr. J. Rivera, National Institute
of Health (28). Rabbit anti-Syk Ab raised against a Syk-specific
peptide was a gift from R. Geahlen (Purdue University). Mouse
anti-phosphotyrosine mAb, PY20, was from Transduction Laboratories
(Lexington, KY), and rabbit anti-Lyn Ab was obtained from Santa
Cruz Laboratories (Santa Cruz, CA). Biotinyl anti-mouse IgG was
purchased from Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories (West Grove, PA),
and protein A and protein A/G-conjugated Sepharose were obtained from
Oncogene (Cambridge, MA). Fifteen-nanometer protein A-gold- and
streptavidin-conjugated colloidal gold particles and Abs and solutions
for ECL were purchased from Amersham (Arlington Heights, IL).
DNP24-BSA (DNP-BSA), fura-2, and fura-2/AM were obtained
from Molecular Probes (Eugene, OR). [3H]serotonin and
[3H]Ins(1, 4, 5)P3 were obtained from
DuPont-New England Nuclear (Boston, MA).
Cell activation
Conditions for RBL-2H3 cell culture were previously described
(26). For studies of the signaling activity of Fc
RI oligomers, cells
were incubated overnight with 1 µg/ml anti-DNP-IgE, then washed
with modified Hanks buffer (29) containing 0.1% BSA and activated at
37°C by the addition of either 0.1 or 1.0 µg/ml of DNP-BSA or 1
µg/ml rabbit anti-IgE. For studies of the signaling activities of
anti-Fc
RI mAbs, cells were simply activated by the addition of
mAb (0.1 µg/ml unless otherwise stated).
Secretion
Secretion was measured from the Ag- or anti-Fc
RI
mAb-induced release of preloaded [3H]serotonin from cells
grown as monolayers on 24-well tissue culture dishes as previously
described (26). All measurements were performed in duplicate and
corrected for spontaneous release of [3H]serotonin during
the standard 20-min assay period. To determine the percent
degranulation, total cell-associated [3H]serotonin was
measured by Triton X-100 lysis of nonincubated cells.
Cells (8 x 106/assay) were activated in
suspension with Ag or anti-Fc
RI mAbs. Ins(1, 4, 5)P3
levels were determined in the supernatant fractions of neutralized TCA
extracts using the isomer-specific radioreceptor assay of Challis and
colleagues (30) as modified previously (31). Data were expressed as
picomoles of Ins(1, 4, 5)P3 per milligrams of TCA-insoluble
protein.
Ca2+ mobilization
Ag- and anti-Fc
RI mAb-induced changes in intracellular
Ca2+ were measured in individual, fura-2/AM-loaded RBL-2H3
cells using fluorescence ratio imaging microscopy as previously
described (32).
Microscopy
To observe Ag- or anti-Fc
RI mAb-induced membrane ruffling
and spreading, cell monolayers on glass coverslips were activated, then
fixed either with 2% glutaraldehyde for scanning electron microscopy
or with 2% paraformaldehyde/0.5% saponin followed by
rhodamine-phalloidin for fluorescence microscopy (27, 33). Cells were
examined using a Hitachi S800 scanning electron microscope or a Zeiss
Photomicroscope III equipped for epifluorescence microscopy.
Receptor mapping
For receptor mapping studies, cells were activated with 1
µg/ml anti-IgE Ab or 0.1 µg/ml anti-Fc
RI mAb on glass
coverslips. The cells were then fixed for 10 min at room temperature in
10% paraformaldehyde, 0.075% glutaraldehyde, and 0.2% picric acid in
0.1 M phosphate buffer, pH 7.2, as previously described (27). After
fixation, IgE-primed, anti-IgE-activated cells were rinsed and
incubated for 30 min in PBS-1% BSA containing a 1/17 dilution of 15-nm
protein A-gold particles (27). After further rinsing, the cells were
postfixed with 2% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer, pH
7.4, and processed for scanning electron microscopy. For these samples,
inherent receptor distributions were determined by conducting the first
fixation before the addition of anti-IgE, and nonspecific gold
labeling was observed by anti-IgE labeling without prior IgE
priming. Anti-Fc
RI mAb-labeled cells were incubated after the
initial fixation with biotinyl anti-mouse IgG followed by 15-nm
streptavidin-gold particles. For these samples, inherent receptor
distributions were determined by anti-Fc
RI mAb incubation at
4°C, and nonspecific gold labeling was observed by biotinyl
anti-mouse IgG-streptavidin gold labeling without prior incubation
with anti-Fc
RI mAb.
Immune complex kinase assays
Cell suspensions (6 x 106 cells/ml; 0.5
ml/assay) were activated with Ag or anti-Fc
RI mAb, then lysed in
ice-cold 50 mM HEPES (pH 7.2), 150 mM NaCl, 1% Brij-96, and 1 µg/ml
each of leupeptin, antipain, and pepstatin. In most experiments the
lysis supernatants were cleared of any protein A- or A/G-reactive
proteins by incubation for 2 h at 4°C with protein A- or protein
A/G-Sepharose beads. After preclearing (omitted when
immunoprecipitation was with directly bead-coupled Abs), they were
incubated for 2 h at 4°C with specific Abs prebound to protein
A-Sepharose (polyclonal anti-Lyn and anti-Syk), protein
A/G-Sepharose (monoclonal anti-phosphotyrosine), or
anti-phosphotyrosine-agarose or anti-Lyn agarose beads. After
washing four times, kinase activity was determined from the
incorporation of ATP into specific proteins during a 2-min incubation
at 30°C with 10 µCi of [
-32P]ATP as previously
described (26).
Immunoblotting
Cells were activated, lysed, and precleared (if appropriate), and specific proteins were immunoprecipitated with Abs as described above. Ab-protein complexes were released from the washed beads by boiling, separated by 10% SDS-PAGE, and transferred to nitrocellulose. After overnight incubation at 4°C in 3% BSA to block nonspecific binding, blots were probed with specific Ab for 1 h at room temperature and washed again. For autoradiography, blots were incubated for an additional hour with 125I-labeled anti-mouse IgG, and dried membranes were exposed to x-ray film. For chemiluminescence detection, blots were incubated with horseradish peroxidase-conjugated anti-mouse Abs, washed, immersed in enhanced chemiluminescence solution, and exposed to x-ray film.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The anti-Fc
RI mAbs used here were originally selected for
their ability to induce secretion from RBL-2H3 cells. Further
characterization showed that they compete with each other and with IgE
for binding to the Fc
RI
subunit, that they bind in a
stoichiometry of 1 Fab:1Fc
RI, and that they elicit quantitatively
different secretory responses (20). Originally, 220 nM (
330
ng/ml) anti-Fc
RI mAb elicited optimal secretion, and the order
of activity in degranulation assays was Ag = F4 > J17 >>
H10. With current anti-Fc
RI mAb preparations and RBL-2H3 cells,
70-nM (0.1 µg/ml) concentrations of all three mAbs are necessary to
induce optimal secretion, and the order of activity has changed
somewhat. mAb H10 remains a poor secretagogue, consistently inducing
the release of 1520% of the total [3H]serotonin under
conditions where optimal Ag (0.1 or 1.0 µg/ml DNP-BSA) causes the
release of 4070% of the total mediator, depending on cell culture
density and passage number. Current preparations of mAb J17 are strong
secretagogues, inducing only 510% less secretion than Ag in a 20-min
assay. mAb F4 receptor dimers have been less consistent, originally
inducing more secretion than mAb J17 (20) but recently inducing
responses that are usually smaller than J17-induced responses but
consistently greater than the responses induced by mAb H10. Based on
all degranulation assays performed during the course of this work, the
relative activities as secretagogues of current anti-Fc
RI mAb
preparations are: multivalent Ag > or = J17 > or
= F4 >> H10.
The activation of phospholipase C
isoforms, leading to the
synthesis of Ins(1, 4, 5)P3, is one of the earliest responses
of RBL-2H3 cells to Fc
RI cross-linking. The results in Fig. 1
A show that multivalent Ag
and anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 and J17 induce an increase in cytoplasmic
Ins(1, 4, 5)P3 levels that is detectable after 1 min and
persists for about 10 min before returning toward baseline. In
contrast, mAb H10 induces very little Ins(1, 4, 5)P3
synthesis in RBL-2H3 cells.
|
Secretion depends on Ca2+ mobilization that is
initiated by the Ins(1, 4, 5)P3-mediated release of
intracellular stores and maintained by Ca2+ influx. Ratio
imaging microscopy was used to compare the Ca2+
mobilization responses of RBL-2H3 cells to anti-Fc
RI mAb-induced
receptor dimers and to DNP-BSA-induced receptor oligomers. Typical
results are shown in Fig. 1
, BD. In duplicate experiments,
100% of cells mobilized Ca2+ in response to 0.1 µg/ml
concentrations of DNP-BSA and of anti-Fc
RI mAbs J17 and H10.
However, there were characteristic differences in the lag time to the
initial Ca2+ spike response, previously attributed to the
release of Ca2+ from intracellular stores (32): 42 ±
15 s (n = 7 cells) for DNP-BSA-stimulated cells,
70 ± 12 s (n = 7 cells) for J17-stimulated
cells, and 170 ± 109 s (n = 8 cells) for
H10-stimulated cells. Additionally, Ag and anti-Fc
RI mAb J17
induced a persistent increase in cytoplasmic Ca2+ levels,
attributable to Ca2+ influx (32). In contrast,
anti-Fc
RI mAb H10 induced a series of Ca2+ spikes,
presumably resulting from the periodic release and reuptake of
Ca2+ stores, but failed to support a sustained elevation in
cytoplasmic Ca2+ levels. The supply of anti-Fc
RI mAb
F4 was too limited for extensive studies of Ca2+
mobilization. However, in a single experiment, anti-Fc
RI mAb F4
receptor complexes induced responses similar to those to J17 (not
shown).
Membrane and cytoskeletal responses
Cross-linking IgE-Fc
RI complexes with multivalent Ag induces
striking membrane and cytoskeletal responses, including filamentous
actin polymerization, membrane ruffling, spreading, integrin
up-regulation, and the assembly of specialized adhesion structures
called actin plaques (1, 33, 34). We used fluorescence and scanning
electron microscopy to examine a subset of these responses, including
spreading, actin plaque assembly, and membrane ruffling. Resting cells
adhere loosely to glass coverslips, and filamentous actin, localized
with rhodamine-phalloidin, is distributed as a cortical meshwork that
outlines pseudopodia as well as in amorphous cytoplasmic aggregates
(Fig. 2
A). These cells
maintain a microvillous surface morphology (Fig. 3
A, inset). Cross-linking with
DNP-BSA for 10 min induces a strong spreading response, accompanied by
the assembly of actin plaques at sites of cell-substrate interaction
(Fig. 2
B) and by a transformation of the upper cell surface
to a lamellar topography (Figs. 2
C and 3B,
inset). Cross-linking with anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 (not shown) and J17
(Fig. 2
, E and F, and Fig. 3
C, inset)
induces spreading, actin plaque assembly, and ruffling responses that
are essentially the same as those induced by Ag. In contrast,
H10-activated cells show a modest spreading response, with little or no
actin plaque assembly (Fig. 2D
) or membrane ruffling (Fig. 3
D, inset).
|
|
RI dimers
Ortega et al. (20) showed previously that the binding
stoichiometry of anti-Fc
RI mAb Fab fragments was one Fab to one
Fc
RI, implying that all three mAbs can cross-link receptors only
into dimers. Independently, Baird and colleagues demonstrated that
small receptor oligomers induced with chemically cross-linked IgE
molecules can induce large scale receptor clustering by a process that
is independent of interoligomer cross-linking (35). Further studies by
the Baird group suggested that the underlying mechanism may involve the
segregation of membrane lipids to create local environments that are
especially favorable for receptor clustering (36). Extending this
concept, Stauffer and Meyer (37) suggested recently that IgE receptor
signaling requires the transient association of cross-linked receptors
with punctate plasma membrane microdomains where they induce the
spatially restricted activation of SH2 domain-containing proteins such
as Syk and phospholipase C
1. Based on these results, it seemed
possible that the stronger signaling activity of anti-Fc
RI mAb
F4- and J17-induced dimers could reflect their ability to be drawn into
clusters or membrane domains that might engage kinases and other
signaling molecules more effectively than mAb H10 receptor dimers. To
test this, we localized anti-Fc
RI mAb-Fc
RI complexes on the
surfaces of resting and activated cells by immunogold labeling and
backscattered electron imaging in the scanning electron microscope. For
comparison, we looked at the effects of cross-linking IgE-receptor
complexes on the same cell population with polyclonal anti-IgE Ab
that elicits strong signaling activity (27). Fc
RI oligomers induced
on IgE-primed cells by polyclonal anti-IgE were detected by
postfixation labeling with 15-nm protein A-gold particles as previously
described (27). Anti-Fc
RI mAb-receptor complexes were detected by
postfixation labeling with biotinylated anti-mouse IgG followed by
streptavidin-conjugated 15-nm gold particles.
No gold particles bound to cells that were incubated with secondary
reagents without prior exposure to cross-linking Abs (Fig. 3
A). Typical receptor aggregates induced on IgE-primed cells
by 5-min cross-linking with polyvalent anti-IgE at 37°C are
illustrated in Fig. 3
B. In contrast, gold particles
localizing anti-Fc
RI mAb-receptor complexes remained dispersed,
mostly as singlets and doublets, over the entire membrane of cells that
were incubated for 10 min at 4°C (not shown), for 10 min at 37°C
(illustrated for mAbs J17 and H10 in Fig. 3
, C and
D), or for 20 min or longer (not shown) with all three
anti-Fc
RI mAbs. To detect patterns of receptor redistribution
that might not be apparent by eye, photographic negatives from cells
labeled at 4 or 37°C and on cells that were fixed before labeling
were digitized, and gold particle distributions were determined by an
image analysis system developed by C. Wofsy, M. Sanders, and G. Donohoe
at the University of New Mexico (38). Image analysis also failed to
reveal consistent differences in aggregate size or distribution between
the different mAbs or labeling conditions. Transmission electron
microscopic analyses of similar samples showed no internalization of
receptor-mAb-colloidal gold complexes during incubation for up to 20
min at 37°C (not shown).
Different anti-Fc
RI mAbs induce different phosphoprotein
profiles in anti-phosphotyrosine kinase assays
The abilities of the different anti-Fc
RI mAbs to activate
protein tyrosine phosphorylation was tested by anti-phosphotyrosine
immune complex kinase assays. Typical results are shown in Fig. 4
. Anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes
from resting cells support relatively little incorporation of
[
-32P]ATP into proteins. Anti-phosphotyrosine immune
complexes from cells that were activated for 2 min with 0.1 µg/ml
multivalent Ag phosphorylate a series of proteins, including a
53/56-kDa doublet known from previous studies (4, 26) to represent
phosphorylated Lyn and bands at around 33 and 1012 kDa shown
previously (7) to correspond to the phosphorylated Fc
RI ß and
subunits. The signal from phosphorylated Lyn was stronger when
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes were from cells treated with
any of the three anti-Fc
RI mAbs than when they were from
Ag-treated cells. These data suggest that all anti-Fc
RI mAb
receptor dimers are fully competent to initiate Lyn-mediated ß and
subunit ITAM phosphorylation, the event that launchs the Fc
RI
signaling sequence. Importantly, the signals from bands corresponding
to the phosphorylated ß and
subunits were strikingly stronger
when anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes were generated from
H10-activated cells than when they were from cells activated with Ag or
the signaling-competent anti-Fc
RI mAbs, F4 and J17. Results were
the same regardless of whether lysates were cleared with protein
A/G-Sepharose beads before the addition of
anti-phosphotyrosine-coated beads. Thus, the excess ß
signal
in lysates of H10-treated cells could not be explained by the
nonspecific interaction of detergent-solubilized mAb receptor complexes
with protein A/G beads.
|
RI receptor subunits
The results of anti-Lyn immune complex kinase assays are given
in Figs. 5
A and 6. In Fig. 5
A, cells were incubated for 5 min with either 0.1 µg/ml
DNP-BSA or 0.1 µg/ml of all three anti-Fc
RI mAbs. In Fig. 6
, incubation was for 2, 5, or 10 min
with the same concentrations of DNP-BSA and of two anti-Fc
RI
mAbs, H10 and J17 (Fig. 6
A), or for 5 min with a 100- to
500-fold range of Ag, H10, and J17 concentrations (Fig. 6
B).
In all cases, cells were lysed, and the lysis supernatants were
clarified by incubation with protein A-Sepharose beads. Lyn and
Lyn-associated proteins were then precipitated from the clarified lysis
supernatants using anti-Lyn-protein A-Sepharose beads. Kinase
activity was again determined from the incorporation of
[
-32P]ATP into proteins.
|
|
RI mAbs than in resting
cells (the low signal from Ag-treated cells in this experiment is
unusual). With more recent lots of polyclonal anti-Lyn Ab (as in
Fig. 6
In cells activated with Ag or anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 and J17, the
autophosphorylated doublet of Lyn is the only strong band seen in
anti-Lyn immune complex kinase assays over a range of incubation
times (Figs. 5
A and 6A) and concentrations of
stimulus (Fig. 6
B). In contrast, anti-Lyn immune
complexes from H10-treated cells, when assessed in in vitro kinase
assays, always showed substantial incorporation of
[
-32P]ATP into the Fc
RI ß and
subunits
regardless of the incubation time (Figs. 5
A and
6A) or concentration of stimulus (Fig. 6
B). These
results provided the first evidence that Fc
RI cross-linking with mAb
H10 induces the formation of stable complexes between Lyn and its
principal endogenous substrates, the receptors ß and
subunits.
This Lyn-bound receptor is a likely source of some or all of the strong
phospho-ß and phospho-
signals detected by
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complex kinase assays shown in Fig. 4
.
H10 receptor complexes are poor Syk activators
In Fig. 5
B, anti-Syk immune complexes were
incubated with [
-32P]ATP to measure
cross-linker-induced Syk autophosphorylation, an index of Syk activity.
As previously reported (26), there is little or no Syk activity in
resting cells. Syk is strongly activated by Ag and anti-Fc
RI mAb
J17. There is an intermediate level of Syk activation in
anti-Fc
RI mAb F4-treated cells. Consistent with their impaired
signaling activity, anti-Fc
RI mAb H10 receptor complexes induce
the least Syk activation in kinase-specific assays.
Different cross-linking agents induce different phospho-ß isoforms in RBL-2H3 cells
In Fig. 7
, A andB, anti-phosphotyrosine-reactive proteins were
immunoprecipitated from variously activated cells, separated by
SDS-PAGE, and probed with either anti-ß subunit mAbs (Fig. 7
A) or anti-phosphotyrosine mAbs (Fig. 7
B).
The results of anti-ß blotting showed that
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes from resting cells
(left lane) are essentially free of ß subunits. It
thus appears that there is little intrinsic tyrosine phosphorylation of
receptor subunits and of proteins that bind and coprecipitate these
subunits in RBL-2H3 cells. Anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes from
cells activated for 5 min with Ag or anti-Fc
RI mAbs contained
three anti-ß-reactive bands, designated ß1, ß2, and ß3.
ß3 (
33 kDa) was readily detected in cells treated with Ag and
anti-Fc
RI mAb J17, was less abundant in cells treated with
anti-Fc
RI mAb F4, and was virtually undetectable in cells
treated with anti-Fc
RI mAb H10. ß2 (
30 kDa) was the
predominant band in cells treated with anti-Fc
RI mAbs H10 and
F4. There was also a substantial signal from ß2 in cells treated with
Ag and with anti-Fc
RI mAb F4. ß1 (
27 kDa) was readily
detected in mAb H10-treated cells, but contributed very little signal
in cells treated with Ag or with anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 and J17 (see
Fig. 7
).
|
Lyn does not associate with the Fc
RI ß3 isoform
In Fig. 7
, C and D, anti-Lyn immune
complexes were precipitated from lysates of Ag- or anti-Fc
RI
mAb-activated cells and separated by SDS-PAGE, and Western blots of
replicate gels were probed as described above with either anti-ß
or anti-phosphotyrosine mAbs. The two less phosphorylated ß
subunit isoforms, ß1 and ß2, discovered in highest amounts in
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes from H10-activated cells,
were also prominent in anti-ß blots of anti-Lyn immune
complexes from H10-activated cells (Fig. 7
C). These results
support evidence from anti-Lyn immune complex kinase assays (Figs. 5
A and 6) that a substantial amount of Lyn exists in a
stable complex with Fc
RI subunits in H10-treated cells. They
identify H10-induced ß1 and ß2 as Lyn-binding isoforms. In
contrast, the highly phosphorylated ß3 isoform, found particularly in
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes from Ag- and J17-treated
cells, is completely absent from anti-Lyn immune complexes and is
thus identified as having very little binding activity for Lyn. Ag- and
anti-Fc
RI mAb J17-induced ß2 also showed very little
association with Lyn. The simplest explanation is that the ß2 band
may consist of proteins that are phosphorylated on different tyrosines
or on a different combination of tyrosine and serines, resulting in
their similar electrophoretic mobilities but different Lyn-binding
activities and potential for further phosphorylation to the ß3
isoform.
In many replicate experiments, the ß2 and ß3 isoforms were
consistently resolved by immunoblotting antiphosphotyrosine immune
complexes from activated cells (as in Fig. 7
), while immune complex
kinase assays usually revealed a single band (as in
Figs. 46![]()
![]()
). We
speculate that this difference reflects the release of constraints to
reaching the most phosphorylated state under the conditions of our in
vitro assays. In contrast, a band resembling ß1 was detected in
lysates of anti-Fc
RI mAb H10-treated cells both by anti-ß
immunoblotting (Fig. 7
) and by anti-phosphotyrosine and
anti-Lyn immune complex kinase assays (Figs. 4
and 6
). The small
amounts of ß1 even in cells treated with anti-Fc
RI mAb H10
raises uncertainty about its identity. ß1 may be a third phospho-ß
subunit isoform that cannot be phosphorylated to completion by Lyn in
vitro. Alternatively, it may be a product of limited proteolysis of the
ß2 or ß3 isoform.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
RI cross-linking
to secretory responses (21). The work of Ortega and colleagues with two
signaling-competent anti-Fc
RI mAbs, F4 and J17, provided
definitive support for this proposal. A third mAb to the Fc
RI
subunit, H10, was found to induce very limited secretory activity. The
differences in secretory activity of Fc
RI dimers induced by
different mAbs have been postulated to arise from different
configurational constraints of the dimers (20, 22, 23). Here, we have
extended the characterization of signaling differences among the three
anti-Fc
RI mAbs to include not only secretion, but also
Ins(1, 4, 5)P3 synthesis, Ca2+ mobilization,
ruffling, spreading, and actin plaque assembly. The effectiveness of
cross-linker-induced cell activation in these studies was Ag >
or = J17 > or = F4 >> H10, somewhat different from
that originally reported (20).
We considered the possibility that the different anti-Fc
RI
mAb-induced receptor dimers may redistribute by a process that is
independent of interdimer cross-linking into differently sized
aggregates with correspondingly different signaling activities. In
particular, recent evidence that cross-linked IgE receptors may
redistribute to punctate plasma membrane domains visible at the
resolution of the fluorescence microscope (37) led to the hypothesis
that Fc
RI dimers induced by anti-Fc
RI mAb J17 might
redistribute into larger clusters than Fc
RI dimers induced by
anti-Fc
RI mAb H10. Fluorescence microscopy (not shown) resolved
receptor clusters in cells treated with anti-IgE but not with
anti-Fc
RI mAbs. The dispersed distributions of receptor
complexes induced by all three anti-Fc
RI mAbs were confirmed at
the higher resolution of the scanning electron microscope. Based on
these results, it is clear that formation of large receptor clusters is
not required for signaling. It remains possible that the
signaling-competent mAbs induce very small clusters of Fc
RI dimers
that cannot be distinguished from fully dispersed H10-induced dimers by
our gold-labeling procedures, which tag only a small proportion of
total receptors.
Contemporary models suggest that the Fc
RI signaling cascade is
initiated by the Lyn-mediated transphosphorylation of tyrosines in the
receptor subunit cytoplasmic tails, creating ß subunit
phosphotyrosine binding sites for the SH2 domains of additional Lyn
molecules that, in turn, catalyze further Fc
RI ß and
subunit
phosphorylation (10, 12, 39). The results of anti-phosphotyrosine
immune complex kinase assays revealed strong signals from
phosphorylated Lyn in H10-activated cells. The signals from
phosphorylated receptor subunits were substantially greater when
anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes were prepared from
H10-activated cells than when they were from Ag-activated cells. These
data indicate that H10 receptor dimers are fully competent to support
the initial events of Lyn-mediated subunit transphosphorylation that
launch the Fc
RI signaling sequence.
Importantly, we detected strong signals from phosphorylated Fc
RI ß
and
subunits when lysates of H10-treated cells were used as a
source of Lyn (and Lyn-associated proteins) for anti-Lyn immune
complex kinase assays. In contrast, signals from phosphorylated
receptor subunits were weak or absent when Lyn was immunoprecipitated
from lysates of cells that were activated with Ag or with
anti-Fc
RI mAbs J17 or F4. These experiments established that mAb
H10, but not Ag or the more signaling-competent anti-Fc
RI mAbs,
induces stable complexes between activated Lyn and receptor subunits.
There was less Syk phosphorylation in anti-Syk immune complex
kinase assays when lysates were from H10-activated cells than when they
were from cells activated with Ag or with anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 and
J17. It thus appeared that the presence of stable Lyn-receptor
complexes may be incompatible with strong Syk activation and signal
propagation in intact cells.
We discovered that anti-phosphotyrosine immune complexes from
activated cells contain two principal phosphorylated Fc
RI ß
subunit isoforms, designated ß2 and ß3, each with its own
characteristic electrophoretic mobility, resulting at least in part
from differences in the extent of ß subunit tyrosine phosphorylation.
(Differences in serine phosphorylation might also contribute to these
distinct mobilities). A third phospho-ß band, ß1, detected in mAb
H10-treated cells may represent an additional phospho-ß isoform but
could also be a degradation production from the principal isoforms.
Importantly, different cross-linking agents induced different
distributions of total Fc
RIß between these phospho-ß isoforms.
Specifically, the most phosphorylated, least mobile phospho-ß form,
ß3, was most prominent in Ag- and J17-stimulated cells, occurred in
modest levels in F4-stimulated cells, and was barely detectable in
H10-treated cells. The moderately phosphorylated, moderately mobile
phospho-ß form, ß2, was found at highest levels in H10-treated
cells and in substantial amounts in cells stimulated with Ag and
anti-Fc
RI mAbs F4 and J17. Finally, the least
tyrosine-phosphorylated, most mobile phospho-ß species, here called
ß1, was found almost exclusively in H10-treated cells. These
phospho-ß isoforms can be distinguished not only by their
phosphorylation levels, but also by their ability to bind Lyn. Thus,
the incompletely phosphorylated ß1 and ß2 bands that predominate in
mAb H10-treated cells coprecipitate with Lyn in anti-Lyn immune
complexes. In contrast, ß3, the highly phosphorylated phospho-ß
isoform found in cells treated with Ag and the signaling-competent
anti-Fc
RI mAbs, does not coprecipitate with Lyn.
These results are consistent with previous evidence that Lyn binding to
partially phosphorylated Fc
RIß promotes further ß and
subunit phosphorylation (10, 40). They suggest for the first time that
Lyn dissociation is a prerequisite for Syk recruitment to
subunit
phospho-ITAMs and for signal propagation. They indicate that Lyn
dissociation depends on the successful progression of a Lyn-mediated
Fc
RI ß subunit phosphorylation sequence. We cannot as yet propose
a definitive mechanism for the blockade of ß subunit phosphorylation
and Lyn dissociation in H10-treated cells. However, Ortega et al. (20)
concluded that configurational differences between Fc
RI dimers
induced by H10 and other mAbs might explain their different signaling
properties. Our data raise the possibility that these configurational
constraints make a phosphorylation site(s) on the ß subunit
inaccessible to activated Lyn in H10-treated cells.
Recent work by Pribluda et al. (14) established that Fc
RI
cross-linking with multivalent Ag causes the phosphorylation of three
tyrosines, all located within the ß subunit ITAM region. Two are
typical ITAM tyrosines, and the third is an atypical internal tyrosine.
The extent of phosphorylation of these tyrosines is variable. Two
serines located within the ß-ITAM sequence are also variably
phosphorylated following Fc
RI cross-linking. In the simplest case,
it is conceivable that the three phospho-ß isoforms represent mono-,
di-, and trityrosine-phosphorylated species and that one of the three
ß-ITAM tyrosines remains inaccessible to Lyn in H10-treated cells,
preventing complete subunit phosphorylation and Lyn dissociation.
However H10-induced ß2 binds Lyn, whereas Ag-induced ß2 has little
Lyn-binding activity. Thus, it is perhaps more likely that the ß2
band includes several species that are phosphorylated on different
tyrosines or on a different combination of tyrosines and serines,
resulting in their similar electrophoretic mobilities but distinct
Lyn-binding activities and potential for further phosphorylation to the
ß3 isoform in intact cells. Further work is also needed to decide
whether ß1 participates in the normal phosphorylation sequence.
The occurrence of multiple phospho-ß subunit isoforms in intact,
Ag-stimulated cells is not a new observation. In 1992, we demonstrated
that Fc
RI cross-linking causes a time- and Ag
concentration-dependent shift in the electrophoretic mobility of
anti-phosphotyrosine-reactive Fc
RI ß in
[
-32P]orthophosphate-labeled Ag-treated RBL-2H3,
resembling the ß2 to ß3 transition (7). Paolini et al. (41) also
demonstrated a mobility shift in response to 1 min of receptor
cross-linking in RBL-2H3 cells and showed that the less mobile form of
phosphorylated ß induced by Ag could be returned to its original
higher mobility form by the addition of monovalent hapten for 30
s. Other work by Kinet and colleagues has demonstrated a cross-linker-
and Lyn-dependent ß subunit mobility shift, resembling the ß2 to
ß3 transition, in both P815 and NIH-3T3 cells induced to express
wild-type and mutant Fc
RI subunits (11, 42). The ß1 isoform has
not been reported previously in Ag-stimulated RBL-2H3 cells. However,
Jouvin et al. (11) showed in transfected P815 cells that mutagenized
Fc
RI ß lacking all three ß-ITAM tyrosine phosphorylation sites
but still capable of serine phosphorylation had a distinctive faster
mobility than the wild-type ß isoform. The similar behaviors of
H10-induced ß1 in RBL-2H3 cells and mutated ß in P815 transfectants
encourage phosphopeptide sequence analyses to determine whether ß1 in
RBL-2H3 cells is a third phospho-ß subunit isoform with a low level
of tyrosine phosphorylation, possibly supplemented by serine
phosphorylation. As noted, we cannot exclude the alternative
possibility that ß1 is simply a product of limited proteolysis of the
ß2 or ß3 isoforms.
Previous investigators have had difficulty in demonstrating
Lyn-receptor complexes in Ag-stimulated cells (10). Our data predict
this result. For signaling-competent cross-linking agents, the speed at
which Lyn is recruited to Ag-receptor complexes, mediates the Fc
RI
subunit phosphorylation sequence, and then dissociates from the
receptor implies that only a small proportion of Lyn is likely to be in
the receptor-bound form during active signaling. It is clear from
recent studies that Lyn is limiting for signaling (39). Thus, the
transient interaction of Lyn with subunits has at least two advantages.
First, it permits Syks access to
-phospho-ITAMs, as required for
signal propagation. Second, it maintains a supply of Lyn for signal
initiation through new receptor cross-linking events.
In summary, we suggest Lyn dissociation from highly phosphorylated
Fc
RI subunits as a new regulatory step in the Fc
RI signaling
cascade that is required for Syk activation and signal propagation. We
predict that a similar regulatory step will be discovered by analyses
of other multichain immune recognition receptor signaling pathways.
Consistent with this, two groups studying the induction of T cell
anergy by altered peptide ligands found that occupying the TCR by
altered peptides can in some cases induce TCR
-chain phosphorylation
with very little ZAP70 recruitment or activation (43, 44). In both
studies an unusual highly mobile, less phosphorylated
subunit
isoform dominated over the less mobile, highly phosphorylated
isoform induced by immunogenic peptide. Cells exposed to the altered
peptide ligands were only weakly activated by these ligands and were
resistant to subsequent challenge with immunogenic peptides. Smith et
al. (45) found that a nonmitogenic anti-CD3 mAb similarly induced a
less phosphorylated phospho-
isoform than the one found in cells
treated with mitogenic anti-CD3 and was also unable to induce
substantial ZAP70 activation. By analogy with our studies in mast
cells, it is likely that ZAP70 activation may have been impaired in all
these studies due to the formation of stable complexes between
incompletely phosphorylated
subunits and Src family members that
block the ZAP70-
interaction.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Janet M. Oliver, Cell Pathology Laboratory, Cancer Research Facility, Suite 201, 2325 Camino de Salud, University of New Mexico School of Medicine, Albuquerque, NM 87131. E-mail address: ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: Fc
RI, the high affinity IgE receptor; ITAM, immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif; Ins(1,4,5)P3, inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate. ![]()
Received for publication January 29, 1998. Accepted for publication September 10, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
RI crosslinking. M. M. Hamawy, ed. IgE Receptor (Fc
RI) Function in Mast Cells and Basophils 139. R. G. Landes Co., Austin.
RI-mediated signaling and effector function by the Syk-selective inhibitor, piceatannol. J. Biol. Chem. 269:29697.
RI-mediated tyrosine phosphorylation and activation of the 72-kDa protein-tyrosine kinase, PTK2, in RBL-2H3 rat tumor mast cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89:9107.
1 in rat basophilic leukemia cells. J. Biol. Chem. 266:24237.
RI-mediated tyrosine phosphorylation of multiple proteins, including phospholipase C
1 and the receptor ß
2 complex, in RBL-2H3 rat basophilic leukemia cells. Mol. Cell. Biol. 12:3176.
RI cross-linking. Mol. Biol. Cell 6:1145.[Abstract]
1, but not PLC
2, in antigen-stimulated RBL-2H3 mast cells. Mol. Biol. Cell 9:483.
RI-mediated responses in mast cells. M. M. Hamawy, ed. IgE Receptor (Fc
RI) Function in Mast Cells and Basophils 107. R. G. Landes Co., Austin.
receptor on mast cells monitored by specific monoclonal antibodies and IgE. Biochemistry 30:3450.[Medline]
RI dimer formation by specific monoclonal antibodies on mast cells. Biochemistry 33:8813.[Medline]
RI
and ß subunits in the control of Fc
RI-mediated tyrosine kinase activation and signaling responses in RBL-2H3 mast cells. J. Biol. Chem. 270:4013.