|
|
||||||||

,
,
,§
,
,||
*
Department of Pediatrics, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA 22908; and
Departments of Microbiology and Immunology,
Division of Digestive Diseases of the Department of Medicine,
§
Department of Gastroenterology, West Los Angeles Veterans Administration Medical Center;
¶
Department of Radiation Oncology and
||
Molecular Biology Institute, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Eß7
integrin (6, 7), and they lack expression of molecules such as CD2,
which characterize most other T cell populations (4, 8). Unlike T cells
derived from spleen or lymph node, SI-IEL proliferate poorly in
response to mitogenic stimuli (9, 10), but ex vivo they demonstrate
brisk cytolytic activity in redirected lysis assays (10, 11, 12), and they
have a constitutively activated MAP-2 kinase (10). In addition, SI-IEL
are enriched for TCR 
+ cells (13), and subpopulations
of IEL express coreceptors that are almost never found in other sites,
including lymphocytes that are single positive for the homodimeric form
of CD8 (CD4-, CD8
+) and double positive
(CD4+, CD8
+) lymphocytes (3, 14). T
lymphocytes found in other locations in the intestine, including those
in the large intestinal epithelium (4, 15, 16, 17) and lamina propria
lymphocytes (LPL) of the small and large intestines (18, 19) (our
unpublished observations), share some of the unique features of SI-IEL,
although there clearly are regional differences within the intestinal
mucosal immune system. The phenotypic and functional specialization of
intestinal mucosal T lymphocytes probably reflects their close
association with both the external environment and epithelial cells,
but the precise role of these lymphocytes in host defense and immune
regulation remains to be determined. Results from a number of studies suggest that intestinal mucosal T lymphocytes, particularly SI-IEL, constitute a separate lineage of T lymphocytes. First, there is evidence that many or most IEL are derived from a thymus-independent developmental pathway (20, 21), although the degree of thymus influence and the subpopulations that are thymus independent remain controversial issues (22, 23). It is widely believed that the thymus-independent T cells arise from bone marrow precursors that migrate directly to the intestine for selection (14, 20), although direct proof for intraintestinal T cell selection is lacking. Second, studies of parabiotic mice indicate that there is relatively little recirculation of SI-IEL (24). Third, in a transfer model in which IEL suspensions are transferred to SCID recipients, we found that IEL preferentially populated intestinal as opposed to peripheral lymphoid tissue (25). Collectively, these data suggest that IEL are a distinct population of T lymphocytes, some of which arise from precursors in the intestine, and the majority of which tend to remain at that site. In addition, the data from parabiotic mice suggest that mature thymus-derived T cells from the recirculating pool rarely enter the intestinal compartments.
Despite data suggesting that IEL are a distinct and separate lineage from other T cells, results from previous studies indicate that IEL can be derived from mucosal T cell populations found in either mesenteric lymph node or Peyers patches (26, 27). By contrast, the ability of typical, thymus-derived T cells found in peripheral lymph node and spleen to home to intestinal tissues is controversial, but recent studies have shown that adoptively transferred T cells from such peripheral lymphoid tissues can home to the intestinal epithelium of SCID mice (28, 29, 30, 31). The data from this transfer model therefore suggest that nonmucosal, thymus-derived T cells are capable of establishing populations of intestinal T cells. The majority of studies on spleen or peripheral lymph node have involved transfer of the CD4+, CD45RBhigh subpopulation of T lymphocytes, a condition that leads to colitis in the SCID host (28, 30, 31). It remains possible, therefore, that the homing of lymph node T cells to the intestine is an aberrant process that could be associated with the induction of inflammatory disease.
In this report we have characterized the phenotypic and functional properties of the lymph node-derived T cells that home to the SCID intestine in the absence of colitis. We found that the cells resident in the intestine of the SCID host are markedly different from the donor population. These T cells are not typical of lymph node T lymphocytes, but instead, they are more similar to normal IEL and LPL with regard to the expression of a variety of cell surface molecules, cytolytic and proliferative activities, and their propensity to home to the intestine upon retransfer. The data, therefore, demonstrate that the process of intestinal homing in the SCID host does not lead to the presence of phenotypically abnormal T lymphocyte populations in the intestine. This suggests that a qualitatively similar process could take place in immune-competent hosts, thereby providing a potential source of mature, thymus-derived T cells in IEL and LPL populations. Furthermore, we demonstrate that a normal bacterial flora is required for the intestinal homing and/or expansion of the donor lymph node T cells in this model, suggesting that bacteria or bacterial products may play a critical role in the in vivo expansion and/or homing of mucosal T lymphocytes to the intestine.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
C.B-17(H-2d) SCID mice homozygous for the scid mutation were bred from stocks obtained from the SCID Mouse Core Facility at University of California-Los Angeles. These specific pathogen-free (SPF) SCID mice were housed in cages held in enclosed racks with filtered air and were given autoclaved bedding and food and acidified water ad libitum. SPF SCID mice are negative for a variety of bacterial, viral, and fungal pathogens for which they have been screened, but they have a normal extent of aerobic and anaerobic flora (W. McBride, unpublished observations). By contrast, reduced flora (RF) C.B-17 SCID mice were derived by cesarean section delivery of SPF fetal mice, with transfer to RF foster mothers in a separate facility maintained by the Department of Radiation Oncology, University of California-Los Angeles. Mice in this colony, including the rederived C.B-17 SCID mice, are devoid of intestinal aerobes. They have been reassociated with two nonpathogenic, anaerobic (clostridial) bacterial species (W. McBride, unpublished). This was performed to optimize the health and fecundity of these otherwise germfree mice. We, therefore, do not call these mice germfree, but refer to them as having RF. They are maintained as described above for SPF SCID mice in enclosed cage racks with filtered air and autoclaved food, bedding, and water. Donor lymphocyte populations were prepared from the external inguinal lymph nodes, although in some cases a mixture of axial, inguinal, and popliteal lymph nodes of 6- to 8-wk-old SPF male or female mice. BALB/c x C57BL/6 F1 (CB6F1) mice, which have the H-2d/H-2b haplotype, were used for transfer into C.B-17 SCID mice. When possible, donor mice were matched by sex with recipients. Unless stated in Results, SCID mice no older than 8 to 10 wk were used in all cell transfer experiments.
Preparation of donor lymphocyte populations
Cell suspensions in RPMI with 5% FCS (Life Technology, Grand
Island, NY) were prepared from the peripheral lymph node or spleen from
6- to 8-wk-old mice. Cell suspensions were cleared of debris, counted,
and resuspended in PBS. Cells (25 x 105) in
0.2 ml of PBS were injected into the peritoneum of recipient SCID mice.
In some cases, before transfer the cells were sorted on a FACStar
instrument (Becton Dickinson, Mountain View, CA) located in the
University of California-Los Angeles Flow Cytometry Core Facility
(Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center) for CD4+ cells with
FITC-conjugated anti-CD4 clone GK1.5 or for CD8+ cells
with anti CD8
clone 53-6.7. Resultant T cell populations were >98%
enriched for either CD4+ or CD8+ T cells, were
>99% viable, and represented a 50 to 70% recovery from the presorted
population. For secondary transfers, 5 to 8 x 105
SI-IEL prepared from SCID mice transplanted with lymph node cells 8 wk
earlier were transferred to a group of secondary SCID recipients by
i.p. injection. SI-IEL from individual recipient mice were not pooled,
but were transferred separately.
Preparation of IEL and LPL
Intestinal mucosal lymphocytes were prepared from individual or pools of control CB6F1 mice or from individual SCID mice 6 to 10 wk after transfer of donor cells, using a modification of a previously described procedure (32). Cells isolated from engrafted SCID mice were never pooled for experimental analysis. Briefly, the small and large intestines were removed from their mesentery, and the Peyers patches or lymphoid aggregates were excised. The intestines were then cut longitudinally, the contents were removed, and the segments were washed before cutting them into 0.5-cm-long pieces. IEL were prepared using mechanical and chemical disruption of the epithelial layer in Ca2+- and Mg2+-free HBSS (Life Technology) supplemented with 1 mM DTT (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO). Intestinal pieces were shaken at 37°C three times for 20 min each time at 250 rpm. Cells were collected after each shake, pooled, and isolated on a discontinuous 40/70% Percoll (Pharmacia Biotechnology, Inc., Piscataway, NJ) gradient at 900 x g for 20 min. Following removal of the epithelial layer, LPL were released from finely chopped intestinal segments by incubation in 1.5 mg/ml of dispase (Sigma) in RPMI with 5% FCS for 60 min at 37°C. LPL cell suspensions were filtered through nylon mesh, and mononuclear cells were isolated by discontinuous Percoll gradient centrifugation as described above. Purified cells were >98% viable by exclusion of trypan blue. Cells prepared in this way are predominantly lymphocytes, although IEL preparations contain significant numbers of intestinal epithelial cells, as judged by light microscopy, light scatter properties in the flow cytometer, and staining with specific mAb. Final T lymphocyte cell numbers were determined from the total cell yield, which was corrected for the percentage of CD3+, donor haplotype cells as determined by flow cytometry.
Flow cytometric analysis of lymphocyte populations
Following purification of T cells from engrafted SCID mice or
from donor mice, cells were resuspended at a concentration of at least
1 x 105 cells/ml in PBS staining buffer
containing 2% BSA (w/v) and 0.02% NaN3 (w/v). Pretitrated
mAb, either unconjugated or directly conjugated to FITC, phycoerythrin
(PE), or biotin, were added to cell suspensions at 4°C and incubated
for 20 to 30 min. All directly conjugated mAb to various surface Ags
were purchased from PharMingen (San Diego, CA), while streptavidin
Tricolor was purchased from CalTag (South San Francisco, CA). The mAb
used for these studies included FITC-labeled or biotinylated
anti-CD3
(145-2C11) (33), FITC- or PE-labeled anti-CD4
(GK1.5) (34), FITC- or PE-labeled or biotinylated anti-CD8
(53-6.7) (35), PE-labeled anti-CD8ß (53-5.8) (35), PE-labeled
CD45R/B220 (RA3-6.32) (36), biotinylated anti-L-selectin (CD62L;
MEL-14) (37), biotinylated anti-CD-69 (H1.2F3) (38), FITC-labeled
anti-TCR
ß (H57-597) (39), PE-labeled anti-mouse integrin
IEL (M290) (40), and biotinylated
anti-Kb (AF6-88.5) or anti-Kd
(SF1-1.1). Cells were incubated in Ab staining buffer at 4°C for 20
min with the primary mAb, washed twice, and then incubated with the
secondary reagent for an additional 20 min at 4°C. At the completion
of the staining reaction, cells were washed as described above and
resuspended in fixative (PBS buffer with 0.02% NaN3 (w/v)
and 1% (w/v) paraformaldehyde) until analysis by flow cytometry. The
samples were run on a FACScan flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson
Immunocytometry Systems, San Jose, CA) in the University of
California-Los Angeles Flow Cytometry Core Facility. IEL were
distinguished from epithelial cells based on their size and granularity
as they appeared in the forward angle and side angle light scatter
setting. Between 1500 and 5000 events in the lymphocyte gate were
acquired.
Histologic and immunocytochemical studies
Segments of large and small intestines were excised and cleaned
as described in the previous section. One- to two-centimeter sections
of intestine were either fixed in 10% formalin (Sigma Chemical Co.) or
immersed in Optimal Cutting Temperature Compound (Miles, Inc., Elkhart,
IN) and snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen. Formalin-fixed tissue was
embedded in paraffin, and 5-µm sections were prepared and stained
with hematoxylin and eosin by the Core Pathology Laboratory at
University of California-Los Angeles or by the Pathology Associates
Laboratory (Los Angeles, CA). Frozen sections were cut at 5-µm
thickness on a cryostat microtome and placed on glass slides. These
sections were air-dried and fixed in acetone. Before mAb staining,
frozen tissue sections were rehydrated with PBS and then blocked with
20% normal rabbit serum (Vector Laboratories, Inc., Burlingame, CA) in
PBS at 4°C for 20 min before incubation with pretitrated CD8
mAb 53-6.7 in PBS supplemented with 2% normal rabbit serum for 60 min
at 4°C. The sections were rinsed twice in PBS at 4°C and incubated
with pretitrated biotinylated rabbit anti-rat IgG (Vector
Laboratories) for 30 min at 4°C. Following incubation, samples were
washed and incubated with avidin-horseradish peroxidase and then
substrate as described by the manufacturer (Vectastain Elite, ABC Kit,
Vector Laboratories). Before analysis, frozen sections were
counterstained with Coomassie blue (Sigma Chemical Co.). Stained tissue
sections were photographed through a Nikon Labophot microscope with
attached camera (Nikon, Melville, NY).
Proliferation assays
Microtiter plates were precoated with a solution of protein G
column-purified CD3
mAb (145-2C11; a gift from Dr. H. Holcombe, Yale
University, New Haven, CT) in PBS. The plates were incubated at 37°C
for 2 h. The wells were subsequently washed three times with RPMI
1640 (Tissue Culture Media Center, University of California-Los
Angeles). To measure proliferation, freshly isolated IEL, lymph node,
or spleen cells from normal mice or engrafted SCID mice were plated at
a density of 2.0 x 105 cells/well in flat-bottom
microtiter plates (Corning, Corning, NY). The cultures, with or without
CD3 mAb precoating, were conducted in 200 µl of complete RPMI with
10% FCS and gentamicin (20 µg/ml; Sigma Chemical Co.). Cells were
incubated at 37°C with 5% (v/v) CO2 for 48 h, and
then pulsed for 20 h, with the addition of 1 µCi/well of
[3H]TdR (New England Nuclear-DuPont, Wilmington, DE). The
cultures were harvested with an automated cell harvester, and
[3H]TdR incorporation measured by liquid scintillation
counting.
Redirected lysis assays
Fc receptor-positive P815 target cells (DBA/2, H-2d) were prepared for use by incubating 1 x 106 cells with 200 µCi of Na51Cr2O3 (New England Nuclear-DuPont) for 4 h at 37°C with 5% (v/v) CO2. Labeled target cells were washed four times and plated at 1 x 104 cells/well in U-bottom 96-well microtiter plates (Costar, Cambridge, MA). SI-IEL prepared from lymph node-transplanted mice or normal lymph node spleen cells prepared from (C57BL/6 x BALB/c) F1 mice were titrated in separate wells to give E:T cell ratios ranging from 0.6:1 to 46:1, depending on the experiment, in a total volume of 200 µl. Where indicated, CD3 mAb was added at the same time as effector cells to give a final concentration of 10 µg/ml. The assays were incubated at 37°C with 5% (v/v) CO2. After 6 h, 100 µl of supernatant was collected and counted in a gamma counter. The percent specific killing was calculated as the sample release (in counts per minute) minus the spontaneous release (in counts per minute) divided by the total release (in counts per minute) minus the spontaneous release (in counts per minute). Spontaneous release was measured in supernatants collected from labeled target cells incubated with medium alone, while total release was measured in supernatants collected from labeled target cells after treatment with 2% (v/v) Triton X-100 (Sigma Chemical Co.). Spontaneous release was <10% of maximal release in all experiments.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We and others have developed a model system to study mucosal
T cell engraftment following injection of lymph node or spleen cells
into SCID mice (27, 28, 29, 30, 31). This model permits the introduction of
exogenous lymphocytes without the need for irradiation or surgery, and
the use of semisyngeneic, F1 donors permits the
quantitation of donor-derived cells without the risk of a graft-vs-host
reaction. By injecting as few as 2 to 5 x 105 T cells
from semisyngeneic CB6F1 mice obtained from either the
inguinal lymph nodes or a mixture of peripheral lymph nodes excluding
the mesenteric lymph nodes into the peritoneum of C.B-17 SCID mice, we
were able to detect donor T cell engraftment in the SCID intestine.
This engraftment plateaus at 6 to 8 wk postinjection and lasts for at
least 20 wk, which was the longest time elapsed before the analysis of
a SCID recipient. A representative two-color immunofluorescence
analysis of cells from IEL and LPL of the small and large intestines
from an individual mouse (Fig. 1
)
demonstrated that nearly all the CD3+ lymphocytes in the
intestinal mucosa of the SCID recipient expressed the donor parental
MHC haplotype (Kb), and that nearly all the donor-derived
cells in the intestine were CD3+ T cells. The preparations
also contained CD3-, Kb- cells that were host
derived; some of these may have been immature T cell precursors that
may arise in the intestine and cannot differentiate further in the SCID
host (41). In some hosts we observed an increase in the number of such
SCID host, CD3- cells following lymphocyte transfer (data
not shown). This may occur as a result of T cell-derived cytokines.
|
|
|
All intestinal mucosal compartments were highly populated with T
lymphocytes in transplanted SCID mice, and the transferred lymph
node-derived T cells were capable of expanding in vivo. A quantitative
analysis of IEL prepared from the small intestines of individual, lymph
node- or spleen cell-engrafted mice is presented in Figure 3
. The recipient SCID mice achieved at
least normal IEL cellularity by 6 to 8 wk post-transfer and were in
fact, on the average, slightly hypercellular. While nearly 1 x
106 T cells were purified, on the average, from the
small intestinal epithelium of CB6F1 control mice,
individual lymph node-engrafted SCID mice gave rise to an average of
2.8 x 106 SI-IEL (Fig. 3
). This increase was
statistically significant, but despite the increased numbers of cells,
the recipients did not show any signs of intestinal inflammation. The
large intestinal epithelium of the SCID recipients contained
approximately 2-fold more T cells than were recovered from
CB6F1 control mice (Fig. 3
), also indicative of a
significant repopulation, although this increase was not statistically
significant. These data clearly show that nonmucosal T cells
efficiently engraft and expand to normal levels, or greater than normal
levels, in the host. Including the lamina propria and the intestinal
epithelium, the total number of T cells purified from all intestinal
mucosal compartments in SCID mice was approximately 7- to 10-fold
greater than that in the injected population, demonstrating that the
donor cells expand in vivo. This expansion may occur primarily in the
intestine or elsewhere. In contrast, the spleen was relatively
hypocellular, containing nearly 10-fold fewer T cells than were
recovered from control CB6F1 mice (Fig. 3
). It is not known
why repopulation of the intestine is more efficient than repopulation
of the spleen. CD3-, B220- cells in the
spleen of SCID recipients could be either immature T or B lymphocytes,
which are known to be present in SCID mice (42). Peyers patches and
lymph nodes were macroscopically not detectable in the recipient SCID
mice at any time point, including points earlier than the 6 wk required
for maximal colonization of the host intestine.
|
The efficiency with which peripheral lymph node T cells
established intestinal lymphocyte compartments in engrafted SCID mice
prompted us to ask whether engrafted populations displayed surface Ags
characteristic of the T cells in this location. We found that engrafted
SI-IEL, like normal SI-IEL, expressed the mucosa-specific integrin,
IEL (also known as
E), and the
activation Ag, CD69, and showed concurrent loss of L-selectin (CD62L),
the lymph node-homing receptor. Data from a representative experiment
are shown in Figure 4
. Nearly all splenic
and lymph node lymphocytes from donor CB6F1 mice expressed
CD62L, while only 2% had
IEL and 12% expressed the
activation Ag CD69 (Fig. 4
, top row). By contrast, in
this representative experiment depicted in the middle row of
Figure 4
, the progeny of the donor population that localized in the
small intestinal epithelium were 89%
IEL positive and
78% CD69 positive, with only 5% expressing CD62L. This profile is
very similar to that of normal IEL (Fig. 4
, bottom
row). In addition, similar to normal IEL, CD2 levels were
decreased or absent in the engrafted SI-IEL, and the engrafted
CD8+ IEL were CD28 negative. The donor-derived IEL were
nearly all Thy-1+ (data not shown), which is consistent
with their being thymus derived or activated (4, 8). Spleen cells in
the engrafted SCID mice had a phenotype intermediate between those of
normal spleen and engrafted SI-IEL. They expressed high levels of CD2
and Thy-1, up to 30% were CD69 and
IEL positive, but
they were mostly CD62L negative (data not shown). As CD69 and
IEL can be acquired by activated T cells (43), while
CD62L is down-regulated, this suggests that donor T cells in the spleen
of SCID recipients are comprised partially of activated or memory
cells, and perhaps that only those T cells are capable of long term
survival in the SCID hosts.
|

+ lymphocytes are very infrequent, and TCR
ß+ and CD8
+ single-positive cells
are essentially undetectable (data not shown). The low frequency of TCR

+ and the absence of TCR
ß+,
CD8
single-positive cells in the SCID host intestine probably
reflect the absence of these T cell subsets in lymph nodes, as these
subpopulations are well represented in the SCID intestine following
transfer of unfractionated SI-IEL populations (B. Sydora et al.,
manuscript in preparation). Regional specialization of lymphocytes engrafted in the SCID host intestine
A degree of regional specificity of T cell homing and expansion in
SCID mice is suggested by the CD4+ and
CD8+ composition of the T cell populations isolated from
the intestinal epithelium, lamina propria, and spleen. The data are
summarized in Table I
. In this analysis, any contaminating
TCR-CD8+ host-derived T cells were excluded by gating on
the Kb+ donor-derived population. The average ratio of CD4
to CD8 T cells in the donor lymph node population was 1.8:1. Engrafted
LPL display, on the average, equal proportions of CD4+ and
CD8+ T cells in both small and large intestines (ratios of
0.88 and 1.03, respectively; Table I
). Donor T cells purified from the
SCID spleen favored CD4+ lymphocytes with an average ratio
of 2.9 (Table I
). In contrast to these results, CD8+ T
cells were selectively enriched in SI-IEL, with an average CD4:CD8
ratio of 0.32 (Table I
). The LI-IEL showed a more equal ratio of CD4
and CD8 cells (ratio = 0.84), similar to the LPL populations. In
addition, as in the intestine of normal mice (3, 14), a distinct
population of CD4+/CD8+ double-positive T cells
was evident among the IEL of engrafted SCID mice. These cells were
infrequent among engrafted SCID LPL, and they were largely absent from
the engrafted spleen and the original donor population (Table I
). In
summary, these results demonstrate that in the engrafted SCID mice,
homing and expansion of lymphocytes favor those T cells with the CD8
phenotype in mucosal tissues compared with spleen, with the greatest
selection for CD8+ lymphocytes in SI-IEL. These results are
qualitatively similar to the distribution of CD4 and CD8+
cells observed in normal mice (4, 15, 16, 17).
Lymphocytes engrafted in the intestine re-home specifically to the intestine
We have reported previously that IEL re-home preferentially to the
intestine when transferred into SCID mice (25). To determine whether
the T lymphocytes engrafted in the intestine of SCID mice behave like
normal intestinal mucosal lymphocytes with regard to intestine-specific
homing, we performed secondary transfers. SI-IEL were isolated from
SCID mice that were given lymph node cell suspensions 8 to 10 wk
earlier and were transferred to secondary SCID recipients. Individual
primary and secondary recipient SCID mice were analyzed, and the
results obtained are summarized in Figure 5
. As noted above, a primary transfer of
lymph node T cells led to the establishment of T lymphocytes in both
the epithelium of the small intestine and the spleen of the SCID
recipient (Figs. 3
and 5
). The epithelium in these primary SCID
recipients was relatively hypercellular with respect to lymphocytes,
yielding an average of 3.9 x 106 T cells (Fig. 5
), which is approximately 3.5 times as many SI-IEL as were found in a
normal, CB6 F1 control, immune-competent mouse in this
series of experiments. The spleen, however, was relatively hypocellular
with respect to T lymphocytes, with an average of only 1.8 x
106 donor T cells present. This is about 1/10th the number
of T cells found in normal mice. When transfer of SI-IEL from two
primary SCID recipients to a set of secondary SCID recipients was
conducted, there was only a small reduction in the donor-derived SI-IEL
cell number in these secondary recipients, to an average of 1.6 x
106 T cells. The difference in the average number of IEL in
these secondary recipients is not statistically significant compared
with the average numbers in the control mice or in the primary
recipients. By contrast, nearly 10-fold fewer donor-derived T cells
were present in the spleen of the secondary recipients compared with
those in the primary recipients, with an average of only 2 x
105 cells (Fig. 5
). This decrease in average cell number in
the secondary recipients was highly statistically significant. It
therefore appears that T cells purified from nonmucosal sites undergo a
functional differentiation, and that they are subsequently limited in
their ability to re-establish nonmucosal populations in the spleen. The
relatively intestine-specific homing pattern of these lymph
node-derived T cells in SCID mice is similar to the pattern obtained
following transfer of intestinal mucosal T cells from normal mice to
SCID recipients (25) (B. Sydora et al., manuscript in preparation).
|
It has been demonstrated in a number of studies that mucosal
lymphocytes proliferate poorly in response to mitogenic stimuli or
stimulation with polyvalent anti-CD3 mAbs (9, 10, 44). Some
subpopulations of mouse SI-IEL, such as those that express CD2 or those
that express Thy-1, retain a somewhat greater proliferative capacity
than the bulk of the population of IEL (8, 45). Like IEL from control
mice, IEL populations isolated from SCID mice engrafted with lymph node
T cells proliferated poorly in response to TCR stimulation with CD3 mAb
compared either with the donor population or with donor-derived T cells
located in the spleen (Fig. 6
). The
donor-derived cells that located to the SCID recipient spleen produced
twofold fewer counts per minute than normal splenocytes, but this
difference was not statistically significant.
|
The presence of cytoplasmic granules in populations of SI-IEL (12, 46) and their de novo cytolytic activity when these cells were freshly
isolated (10, 45, 47) suggest that SI-IEL are cytolytic effector cells
in vivo. This cytotoxic activity could be measured in a redirected
lysis assay, in which polyclonal stimulation of cytotoxic effectors was
achieved by binding anti-TCR mAbs to the Fc receptor of
51Cr-labeled targets (48). Unlike SI-IEL,
CD8+ T cells isolated from the lymph node and spleen did
not exhibit cytotoxic activity in a redirected lysis assay, unless they
had undergone a prior Ag stimulation. To determine whether peripheral
lymph node T cells that had populated the small intestine of a SCID
host were functionally similar to resident SI-IEL, these engrafted
lymphocytes were tested in a redirected lysis assay. Killing of CD3
mAb-coated P815 targets by lymph node donor-derived SI-IEL was obtained
at E:T cell ratios as low as 5.5:1 (Fig. 7
). In contrast, spleen or lymph node
from control CB6 F1 mice or IEL prepared from the large
intestine or spleen cells from engrafted SCID mice showed no chromium
release, with or without CD3 mAb, at all E:T cell ratios tested (data
not shown).
|
To define factors that may be responsible for the migration of
lymph node-derived T lymphocytes to intestinal tissue, we have examined
the role of bacterial colonization in the engraftment of intestinal T
cells in SCID mice. Lymph node cells were transferred to SPF SCID mice,
which had not been infected with any of a set of known mouse pathogens
but had normal intestinal flora, and to RF SCID mice, which are close
to being germfree (see Materials and Methods). The
recipients were analyzed 6 to 10 wk later for the presence of
CD3+, Kb+ T lymphocytes in the intestine. The
results from a representative flow cytometric analysis of individual
SCID recipients are presented in Figure 8
A. The two RF SCID mice shown
had only 23 and 32% of CD3+, H-2Kb+ cells
within the SI-IEL preparation compared with 86 and 82% from two
individual SPF SCID recipients. This representation understates the
true difference, as the total cell yields were greatly reduced when the
preparations were obtained from RF SCID mice. Quantitative analysis of
cell yields of IEL and LPL purified from the large and small intestines
of the two types of engrafted SCID mice showed that the average cell
numbers were reduced 45-fold among SI-IEL in RF compared with those in
SPF recipients, while LI-IEL were, on the average, 3-fold lower, SI-LPL
were 20-fold lower, and LI-LPL were 10-fold lower than those in SPF
controls (Fig. 8
B). The overall difference in cell
number between RF and SPF SCID mice was statistically significant
(p = 0.0001). In summary, these results show
that optimal engraftment of T cells into intestinal mucosal
compartments is influenced by bacterial flora. The primary residence of
diverse, anaerobic flora within the small intestine (49) and their
absence in the RF colony suggest that this class of bacterial flora
plays a major role in the establishment of SI-IEL following lymphocyte
transfer to SCID mice, although other mucosal T cell populations also
were greatly reduced in the RF SCID recipients.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We show here that lymphocytes derived from the peripheral lymph node
can home to the intestinal epithelium and lamina propria in SCID mice,
where they provide a long term reconstitution of mucosal T cells.
Although the data reported resulted from transfer of peripheral lymph
node cells, transfer of spleen cells gave essentially similar results.
T lymphocytes are capable of populating the SCID host intestine, but,
in the doses used, B cells are not. The selective reconstitution of the
lymphoid system together with the results from phenotypic analysis of
the donor-derived T cells in the SCID intestine indicate that the
ability to populate the intestine is a function of mature, CD4
single-positive and CD8
ß single-positive T cells. This is
supported by the results obtained following transfer of either sorted
CD4 or sorted CD8 single-positive T cells in our studies and those of
others (28, 29, 30, 31).
The population of the SCID host with donor-derived T cells is more efficient in the intestine than in the spleen. The intestine shows increased numbers of T cells compared with those in normal, control mice, while the spleens of the SCID recipients have approximately 10-fold fewer T cells than those found in control spleens. We speculate that the population of long term surviving cells in the SCID host may be enriched for memory cells, and that some of these cells may localize preferentially to the intestine on account of exposure to intestinal flora.
Results from previous experiments have shown clearly that cells activated in the Peyers patch of normal mice home to the intestinal epithelium (46, 51). In addition, we have found that transfer of Peyers patch lymphocytes to SCID mice does lead to the generation of IEL and LPL populations in the recipients, although this process was not particularly efficient (data not shown). The absence of detectable Peyers patches and lymph nodes in the SCID recipients suggests that this Peyers patch to intestine migration pathway is not obligatory for the long term reconstitution of IEL and LPL. The presence of intestinal lymphocytes in aly mutant mice lacking Peyers patches (52) also is consistent with the possibility that IEL need not be derived from activated Peyers patch lymphocytes. Although we could not detect visible Peyers patches at any time point, we cannot exclude the possibility that small numbers of lymphocytes reside there transiently before going on to the lamina propria and epithelium. This is consistent with results from short term assays showing binding of peripheral T cells to Peyers patch high endothelial venules (53).
The factors that prevent IEL from efficiently re-entering the
peripheral T cell pool following secondary SCID transfer (25) (Fig. 5
)
are not known. It is unlikely that SI-IEL are restricted due to their
lack of L-selectin, as we found L-selectin-negative T cells in the
spleen of engrafted mice, and residence within the spleen was enhanced
in L-selectin knockout mice (54) and in mice treated with the
anti-L-selectin mAb MEL-14 (55). The marked reduction of SI-IEL and
LPL in ß7-deficient mice (56) suggests that integrins
containing ß7, paired with either
4 or
IEL, facilitate entry of T cells into the epithelial
layer (57) or may function to tether cells in this location (58). This
is in agreement with the enrichment of ß7-positive T
cells in the SCID host intestine following lymph node cell transfer.
Additional integrins may be involved in intestinal localization, as
suggested by recent studies of ß2 integrin and
intercellular adhesion molecule-1-deficient mice (59).
Several experimental results support an important role for T cell
activation in mucosal colonization of the SCID host. First, we found
that the majority of lymph node-derived T cells in the intestinal
mucosa constitutively express the activation Ag CD69. Second, we
demonstrated that bacterial flora were required for the efficient
colonization of the SCID host intestine. It remains possible that a
decrease in mucus or other factors in the intestine of RF mice could
have effected the cell yields obtained following mucosal T cell
preparation rather than the actual cell number present. This is not
likely, however, to explain the >10-fold decrease in cells colonizing
most compartments of the intestine in the RF recipients, particularly
LPL, which are separated from the mucus. Bacterial flora might provide
a source of Ag for the activation and expansion of T lymphocytes. The
requirement for diverse bacterial flora for the establishment of cells
within the intestine of engrafted SCID mice is similar to what has been
observed in normal, intact mice, particularly for TCR
ß+ SI-IEL (60, 61).
It is not known whether the T cell expansion observed in the SCID host occurs systemically or primarily in the intestine. Several earlier observations are consistent with a systemic expansion. First, intestinal inflammation is a major complication of graft-vs-host disease (46, 62), and recirculating T cell blasts activated by MHC-encoded alloantigen have been shown to traffic to the intestine (63). Second, systemic infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus leads to the presence of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus-specific CTL in SI-IEL, although viral Ag could not be detected in the intestinal epithelium (64). On the other hand, studies comparing oral and systemic administrations of intestinal viral pathogens, reovirus, and rotavirus showed that oral administration of either virus was more efficient in the development of virus-specific CTL among Peyers patches or IEL (51, 65) and in the inflammation model in which SCID recipients develop colitis, most T cell proliferation occurred in the intestine (66).
By a variety of criteria, the T lymphocytes that populate the SCID
intestine are similar to the T cells normally found there. These
criteria include the pattern of expression of cell surface proteins,
the preferential re-homing of the donor-derived T cells to the
intestine, and the functional consequences of TCR cross-linking,
notably the acquisition of cytolytic activity. There are two possible
explanations for the differences between the donor population and the T
cells that ultimately populate the SCID intestine. First, factors in
the SCID host might lead to marked phenotypic and functional changes in
the donor T lymphocytes found in the intestine. Second, a very few T
cells with a mucosal phenotype, i.e., CD69+,
IEL+, and CD62L-, might already
be present in the lymph node, and they might be selectively expanded in
the intestine following transfer. Because some of the populations found
in the intestine, such as CD4, CD8
double-positive IEL, are not
detectable among lymph node cells, we consider expansion of a
pre-existing, infrequent T cell subset to be a less likely possibility.
Consistent with a possible phenotypic change in vivo, it has been
demonstrated that CD3 cross-linking in vitro in the presence of TGF-ß
leads to the strong induction of
IEL expression
(43).
Because the lymph node T cells that home to the SCID intestine are
similar to the resident mucosal lymphocytes in normal mice, we believe
that a similar homing process may occur continuously following T cell
activation in immune-competent organisms. This would provide a source
of thymus-selected T cells in the intestinal mucosa. It remains
possible, however, that even those IEL and LPL with a phenotype similar
to that of thymus-derived T cells, such as TCR
ß+
CD4+ and CD8
ß+ T lymphocytes, may be
derived from an extrathymic lineage. Even if a fraction of activated T
cells normally homed to the intestine, the increase in T cell numbers
in the lymphocyte-engrafted SCID intestine suggests that the homing of
thymus-derived T cells to the intestine may be regulated differently in
immune-deficient hosts. For example, resident T cells within the
epithelium (such as TCR 
+ IEL) or lamina propria
could exert feedback mechanisms limiting the expansion of
thymus-derived T cells in the intestine (67).
In contrast to the results we have obtained following transfer of lymph node T cells, data from parabiotic mice analyzed over a period of several weeks indicated that SI-IEL rarely contained T cells derived from the other parabiont, unlike those of the peripheral T cell pool (24). These data imply that the migration of thymus-derived, peripheral T cells to the intestinal epithelium can account quantitatively for only a small percentage of IEL in immune-competent mice. It remains possible, however, that the conditions used in these experiments, such as the state of the bacterial flora, did not promote intestinal homing and/or T cell expansion. Given the data from graft vs host disease and virus-infected mice, we hypothesize that the presence of thymus-derived, peripheral T cells in the intestine could be most significant in cases of infection or acute intestinal inflammation.
The factors, other than activation, that regulate the homing and/or expansion of peripheral T lymphocytes to the intestine remain to be defined. These considerations are likely to be critical for a general understanding of host defense against mucosal infection. They also may be critical for understanding the pathogenesis of inflammatory bowel diseases, as an excess of activated, CD4+, T lymphocytes in the intestine is characteristic of conditions such as Crohns disease (68). Recently, a number of mouse models of inflammatory bowel diseases have been described, and in nearly every model, where tested, pathogenesis is greatly attenuated when the bacterial flora are reduced, such as when either RF or gnotobiotic animals are compared with SPF animals (Refs. 31, 69, and 70, and references cited therein). This suggests that the bacterial flora may be important in the homing and activation of pathogenic lymphocytes to the intestine, similar to the important role it plays in the homing of nonpathogenic T cells in the SCID transfer model described here.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 These authors contributed equally to this work. ![]()
3 Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Beate Sydora, Room 1529, MacDonald Medical Research Laboratory, Division of Digestive Diseases, Department of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095-7019. ![]()
4 Current address: University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA 19104. ![]()
5 Current address: La Jolla Institute for Allergy and Immunology, 10355 Science Center Dr., San Diego, CA 92121. ![]()
6 Abbreviations used in this paper: GALT, gut-associated lymphoid tissue; SI-IEL, small intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes; IEL, intraepithelial lymphocytes; LPL, lamina propria lymphocytes; high, high level; SPF, specific pathogen free; RF, reduced flora; PE, phycoerythrin; LI-IEL, large intestine intraepithelial lymphocytes. ![]()
Received for publication May 13, 1997. Accepted for publication November 18, 1997.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
IELß7 integrin on T cell receptor 
and T cell receptor
ß T cells. Eur. J. Immunol. 24:635.[Medline]

+ intraepithelial lymphocytes. Science 243:1716.
-
T-cell receptor on intestinal CD8+ intraepithelial lymphocytes. Nature 333:855.[Medline]
/ß repertoire of mucosal CD8+ cells from murine large intestine: implications for functional state. J. Exp. Med. 180:433.
/ß in the intestinal epithelium: evidence for distinct circulation patterns of gut- and thymus-derived T lymphocytes. J. Exp. Med. 176:187.
in CD4+ T cell receptor
ß+ T cells migrating into the murine small intestine epithelial layer. Eur. J. Immunol. 25:1580.[Medline]
ß T cell receptors. J. Immunol. 142:2736.[Abstract]