|
|
||||||||
Departments of Immunology and Molecular and Medical Genetics, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 and µ4
4,
and the subunit distribution was unaltered by J chain. However, J chain
was found only in the µ2
2 species, suggesting that some
arrangement of inter-µ bonds directs incorporation of J chain.
IgM-S337 hexamer also dissociated to µ2
2 and µ4
4, but also
yielded several species migrating much more slowly in SDS-PAGE than
wild-type µ12
12. To account for these forms, we propose that each
µ-chain can interact with three other µ-chains and that some
hexameric molecules contain two catenated µ6
6 circles. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Two functions have been described for Ig-associated J chain. J chain is necessary for binding of IgM and IgA to the poly-Ig receptor, which functions in epithelial transcytosis of Igs (11, 12, 13). Also, J chain modifies polymeric assembly of IgM, in that relatively more pentamer and less hexamer are produced in the presence of J chain. The fraction of IgM that was seen as pentamer in the absence of J chain has varied among different studies, ranging from none up to 50% (14, 15, 16). Pentameric IgM differs from hexameric IgM in several ways. First, J chain is found in pentameric, but not hexameric, IgM. Second, pentameric IgM is less cytolytic than hexameric IgM (17, 18). Third, analysis of mutant IgM has suggested that more inter-µ-chain C414-C414 bonds are formed in hexameric IgM than in pentameric IgM (19, 20). These correlations could have multiple explanations. For example, incorporation of J chain into pentamer might affect the disulfide bonding of IgM and in this indirect way depress its cytolytic activity. Alternatively, the hexameric C1q complement component might interact better with hexameric than with pentameric IgM. As well, IgM-bound J chain might sterically hinder the binding of C1q and thereby decrease the cytolytic activity of pentameric IgM.
To extend our understanding of the relationships among disulfide bonding, cytolytic activity, and incorporation of J chain, we have examined the structure and function of wild-type IgM produced in cells expressing or not expressing J chain. We have similarly examined IgM in which one or more µ-chain cysteine residues have been replaced by serine. Our results indicate that pentameric IgM is produced in the absence of J chain and that this J-IgM, like J+IgM, is much less cytolytic than hexameric IgM. We have not detected any difference in the inter-µ-chain disulfide bonding when comparing J+ and J- pentameric IgM, but incorporation of J chain appears to be restricted in some way by the C414-C414 bond. Our analysis also suggests that each µ-chain in hexameric IgM might be bonded to three other µ-chains rather than to only two µ-chains as is conventionally depicted.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell lines are based on the Sp6 hybridoma cell line, which
secretes IgM specific for DNP and
TNP3 (21). All
J+ cell lines producing mutant IgM, except T/µ-S414(0),
were obtained by transfecting µ gene constructs into the X10 cell
line, which expresses the
-chain but not the µ-chain (22). The
transfectoma, T/µ-S414(0), which produces IgM-S414 in the absence of
J chain, has been previously described (20). We have used two
Sp6-derived mutant cell lines, igm482 and igm43, for size markers and
other controls. The cell line igm482 secretes IgM monomer lacking the
Cµ4 domain (23), and igm43 secretes polymer lacking the Cµ1 domain
from which the
light chain dissociates in SDS (21). IgME10 is
derived from the myeloma MOPC-315 and produces IgM bearing
-chain (24).
Protein analysis
Biosynthetic labeling of cells was performed as described previously (4), except that [35S]methionine (SJ.204, Amersham, Arlington Heights, IL) was used at a concentration of 50 to 100 µCi/ml for labeling.
35S-labeled or unlabeled IgM was prepared from supernatants either by affinity purification using DNP-Sepharose (17) or by immunoprecipitation using anti-IgM Abs and protein G-agarose (4).
IgM was fractionated by sucrose density gradient centrifugation at 23,000 rpm for 16.75 h in an SW41 rotor as previously described (17).
Nonreduced IgM was fractionated by SDS-PAGE using a modification of Laemmlis method (4, 25). To obtain optimal resolution of various IgM species, the concentrations of acrylamide and agarose were varied, as indicated in the figure legends. The sample buffer for SDS-PAGE sometimes contained 25 mM iodoacetic acid to prevent spontaneous reduction, but its inclusion was found not to affect the result. Prestained molecular mass markers (Life Technologies, Grand Island, NY; 14228 kDa) were included in most experiments. Separated proteins were visualized either by autoradiography and PhosphorImager analysis (Molecular Dynamics, Sunnyvale, CA) or using a Western blot procedure (see below).
Radiolabeled J chain was assayed by AU-PAGE (26). To assess individual IgM species, bands were excised from the SDS-PAGE gel, extracted, and then analyzed by AU-PAGE (27). After extraction, IgM was reduced by 50 mM DTT in 0.1 M Tris (pH 8.0), alkylated with an equal volume of 0.5 M iodoacetic acid in 1.5 M Tris-HCl (pH 8.8), and precipitated with 10 vol of acetone at -20°C. Acetone-precipitated samples were dissolved in AU-PAGE sample buffer (0.2 M Tris (pH 8.0), 8.0 M urea, and bromophenol blue) and loaded onto the gel.
J chain was also detected by Western blot analysis (20). Thus, after SDS-PAGE, the nitrocellulose filter was incubated with rabbit anti-human J chain Abs (1/100 dilution; Biogenex, San Ramon, CA), followed by alkaline phosphatase-conjugated mouse anti-rabbit IgG (1/2000 dilution; Jackson ImmunoResearch, West Grove, PA). Buffer for blocking and Ab incubation contained PBS, 0.2% I-Block (Tropix, Bedford, MA), and 0.1% Tween-20. The wash buffer was 0.1% Tween-20 in PBS. The substrate buffer for enhanced chemiluminescence detection was 0.1 M diethanolamine, 1 mM MgCl2 (pH 10.0), 1% CSPD (Tropix), and 5% N-Block (Tropix).
Complement-mediated hemolysis
Complement-mediated hemolysis of IgM was tested in V-shaped 96-well plates. Samples were diluted in balanced salt solution containing 1% calf serum. Serial dilutions of IgM samples (either from SDG fractions or standard supernatant, from the J+ parental hybridoma Sp6/HL) were incubated with SRBC-TNP at a final concentration of 0.12% for 1 h at 37°C. To remove sucrose, this mixture was centrifuged, and the pelleted IgM-SRBC were resuspended in buffer and recentrifuged. The washed IgM-SRBC were then resuspended at 0.12% in the presence of guinea pig complement at a dilution of 1/250 and incubated at 37°C. After 1-h incubation, unlysed SRBC-TNP were pelleted by centrifugation. Supernatants were transferred to flat-welled microtiter plates, and lysis was measured as adsorbance at 405 nm. In some experiments, hemolysis was also tested by the method of Davis et al. (17).
Northern blot analysis
Isolation of cytoplasmic RNA and Northern blot analysis were
performed as described previously. Transferred, immobilized RNA was
hybridized to end-labeled oligonucleotides specific for the Cµ4 exon
of the µ gene (4), the V-region of the TNP-specific
-chain (22),
or the J chain (20).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We have previously described an expression system based on the
hybridoma Sp6, which produces IgM-
specific for the hapten TNP.
Several mutant cell lines lacking the µ gene but retaining the
functional
gene have been derived from Sp6 (22, 28). These
µ-,
+ cell lines serve as recipients
for transfected normal and mutant µ genes, which are present as a
genomic expression unit in the pSV2neo vector. The mutant µ genes,
resulting transfectants, and corresponding IgM are denoted according to
the substituted amino acid, e.g., µ-S414, T/µ-S414, and IgM-S414,
respectively.
To produce IgM bearing normal and mutant µ-chains in the absence as
well as the presence of J chain, we sought to isolate a hybridoma
mutant cell line that had ceased to produce J chain but which would
nevertheless express the transfected µ genes. In earlier work we
fortuitously isolated a transfectoma, T/µ-S414(0), expressing the
mutant protein IgM-S414, but not J chain (19, 20). This cell line
produces no detectable J chain protein or mRNA. The cause of this J
chain deficiency is not known. To obtain a cell line that had lost the
µ-S414 pSV2neo vector, the T/µ-S414(0) cell line was subjected to
300 to 400 rad from a 137Cs source and subcloned.
Approximately 800 single precursor colonies were tested by ELISA for
IgM production. One negative colony was obtained; it was G418 sensitive
and lacked both µ mRNA (Fig. 1
) and µ
DNA (not shown). We then confirmed that this colony produced the
-chain and lacked J chain mRNA (Fig. 1
). This cell line, denoted
G10, was used to express normal and mutant µ genes.
|
To study the role of J chain in IgM structure and function, we transfected the G10 cell line with plasmids encoding either wild-type µ-chain or µ-S337. From each transfection, two independent transformants were chosen for further study. Their IgM, denoted J-IgM-wt and J-IgM-S337, was compared with IgM produced by previously established (J+) transformants expressing J+IgM-wt or J+IgM-S337 (4). Each transformant produced a level of IgM expression corresponding to 10 to 60% of that of the parental Sp6/HL hybridoma, with overlapping ranges for each pair.
We initially investigated how secreted J-IgM-wt was
assembled using sucrose density gradient (SDG) centrifugation in
combination with nonreducing SDS-PAGE to assess the state of
polymerization, as hexamer is expected to sediment more rapidly than
pentamer in SDG centrifugation and to migrate more slowly than pentamer
in SDS-PAGE. For this analysis, J+IgM-wt and
J-IgM-wt were metabolically labeled with
[35S]methionine, and secreted IgM was purified by its
affinity to DNP-Sepharose. This IgM was then separated by
(nondenaturing) SDG centrifugation into various polymeric and monomeric
species. As shown in Figure 2
A,
J-IgM-wt had a more prominent monomer peak than
J+IgM-wt. To obtain a more complete separation of the
polymeric species, the faster and slower polymeric fractions of the
gradient were separately pooled and resedimented (Fig. 2
A). Analysis of selected fractions from the
secondary gradients indicated that for both J+IgM-wt and
J-IgM-wt, the faster sedimenting material was greatly
enriched for species that have lower mobility in SDS-PAGE, and that,
conversely, the slowly sedimenting material had a higher mobility in
SDS-PAGE (Fig. 2
B). Moreover, the slowly sedimenting
J-IgM polymers have the same mobility in SDS-PAGE as the
slowly sedimenting J+IgM polymers, which have been
previously identified as pentamer (17, 18). We conclude from these
results that both J+IgM-wt and J-IgM-wt
include both pentameric and hexameric species. The sequential gradients
yielded pentameric material that contained no detectable hexamer band
on SDS-PAGE. The hexameric material usually contained detectable
pentamer (see below).
|
|
4% of the total
secreted J-IgM-wt protein. J chain-deficient IgM pentamer activates complement poorly
Previous reports have shown that pentameric J+IgM
is much less cytolytic than hexameric J-IgM, but it has
been unclear whether this difference is due to the presence of J chain
in pentamer or to some other structural difference between the two
types of polymer. To distinguish these possibilities we compared the
cytolytic activity of the pentameric and hexameric species of
J+IgM and J-IgM prepared by sequential SDG
centrifugations. To gauge whether cytolytic activity was derived from a
single species, we assayed three fractions from different positions in
the pentamer and hexamer peaks. As described in Materials and
Methods, IgM from the indicated SDG fractions was serially diluted
and adsorbed to TNP-coupled erythrocytes. The IgM-TNP-erythrocytes were
then incubated in the presence of guinea pig serum as a complement
source, and lysis was assessed spectrophotometrically (Fig. 4
). As a measure of cytolytic activity we
have calculated the amount of IgM that lysed 50% of the erythrocytes
(Table I
). Pentamer from both
J+IgM-wt and J-IgM had lower lytic activity
than unfractionated IgM-wt, and this activity was nearly the same for
each of the three fractions assayed from each gradient, thus arguing
that this activity was not due to contaminating hexamer. Hexamer from
both J+IgM and J-IgM had higher lytic activity
than unfractionated IgM-wt, and this activity increased for the faster
sedimenting fractions. SDS-PAGE analysis of these fractions indicates
that the fractions denoted hexamer contained some pentameric IgM (Fig. 2
B). The level of contaminating pentamer was less in
faster migrating fractions, which had greater hemolytic activity. To
estimate the activity of pure hexamer, we assumed that contaminating
pentamer did not significantly contribute to the total lytic activity.
Pentamer contamination was calculated from the intensity of the
SDS-PAGE bands, and the measured lytic activity was divided by the
fraction of hexamer to give the activity of pure hexamer.
|
|
Data for three independent SDG experiments are summarized in Table I
.
For both J+IgM-wt and J-IgM-wt, we found that
pentamer was much less active than hexamer, indicating that its J chain
content was not the only reason that pentamer was less lytic than the
hexamer. As noted above, our finding that the activity of pentameric
J-IgM did not differ much between the faster and slower
fractions argues that this activity was not due to contamination by a
small amount of hexameric IgM. We are unsure whether the two- to
threefold differences seen between J+ and J-
pentamers and between J+ and J- hexamers are
significant (see Discussion).
A puzzling feature was that the activity of J+ pentamer
compared with that of hexamer (
0.8%) was much lower than the 5%
value seen in earlier studies from this and another laboratory (17, 18). We have tested whether this difference reflects changes in the
method of assay, with variable results. That is, in repeated testing
using the method of Davis et al. (17) we found that J+
pentamer ranged from 1.4 to 12% of the cytolytic activity of hexamer.
We have not identified the source of this variation.
Analysis of disulfide bonding pattern in J chain-deficient IgM-S337 polymers
Inter-µ-chain disulfide bonding in polymeric IgM-wt is mediated
by three cysteines, C337, C414, and C575, which are believed to form
homo-pairs, e.g., C337-C337 (Fig. 5
A). However, the
connectivity of the µ-chains, i.e., the series and parallel
arrangement of disulfide bonds (see Fig. 5
for definitions), is not
known. To gain information about the connectivity and to ascertain
whether it is affected by J chain, we examined IgM-S337. Several
observations argue that IgM-S337 closely resembles IgM-wt, except for
the absence of the C337-C337 disulfide bond. Thus, IgM-S337 efficiently
assembles into pentamer and hexamer that have normal sedimentation
rates in SDG. IgM-S337 pentamer and hexamer are comparable to the
corresponding wild-type proteins in their cytolytic activities.
Pentameric IgM-S337 contains a normal amount of J chain (19). IgM-S337
polymers are assembled from noncovalent subunits, whose size and
composition are determined by the extent to which C414-C414 and
C575-C575 join µ-chains in series. In the model presented in Figure 5
B, an IgM-S337 pentamer is represented as a structure that
would dissociate in SDS to yield one µ4
4 subunit and three
µ2
2 subunits. In the µ4
4 subunit, two C414-C414 bonds join
the µ-chains in series with one C575-C575 bond. As illustrated, the
µ2
2 subunits are of three types: a subunit bonded by only
C414-C414, a subunit bonded by only C575-C575, and a subunit bonded by
C414-C414 and C575-C575 in parallel. These examples illustrate how the
size of the subunits (here µ2
2 and µ4
4) indicates whether
C414-C414 and C575-C575 are in series, but not whether they are
parallel.
|
|
2) and dimer (µ4
4)
species were the predominant subunits for all polymeric fractions
tested, each accounting for 30 to 50% of the total IgM, as quantified
by PhosphorImager. Extended exposure of the SDS-PAGE gel revealed many
bands. Nevertheless, we discerned no major differences in band pattern
between J+IgM-S337 and J-IgM-S337 pentamers.
As will be considered in Discussion, these results suggest
that J chain does not greatly alter the extent to which C414-C414 and
C575-C575 link µ-chains in series.
Like hexameric IgM-wt, hexameric IgM-S337 was highly heterogeneous, and
here also the J+IgM-S337 and J-IgM-S337 gave
comparable patterns (Fig. 6
B). As in the case of
pentameric IgM-S337, the predominant species were µ2
2 and
µ4
4. Hexamer lacked several of the minor species that were present
in pentameric IgM-S337 (designated P1 and P2) and that migrated slower
than µ4
4. Moreover, unlike pentameric IgM-S337, hexameric IgM-S337
included several bands (H1H4) that migrated more slowly than either
pentameric or hexameric IgM-wt. The identities of these very slowly
migrating species are considered further in Discussion.
We were concerned that some of the subunits present in both the
pentamer- and hexamer-enriched fractions might truly be associated with
only one polymeric species or the other, but may exist in all fractions
because SDG centrifugation had yielded incomplete separation. It was
not possible to assess the purity of the noncovalent pentamer and
hexamer in the same direct manner as we did for IgM-wt. Nevertheless,
our data suggest that cross-contamination was not a serious problem.
Thus, the fact that pentamer-enriched fractions from IgM-S337 were much
less cytolytic than hexamer-enriched fractions indicates that pentamer
fractions were not severely contaminated. Also, very pure pentamer was
obtained under the same separation conditions used for IgM-wt. IgM-S337
hexamer fractions might have been contaminated to some extent with
pentamer, but this also was probably not severe. Thus, IgM-S337
pentamer fractions contained two species with unique SDS-PAGE mobility
(P1 and P2 in Fig. 6
B). These species could not be
detected in the slowly sedimenting hexamer fractions, although other
bands that are common to pentamer and hexamer fractions had similar
intensities. These observations indicate that hexamer obtained from the
faster shoulder of the peak included very little pentamer
contamination.
Disposition of J chain within IgM subunits
As shown above, IgM-S337 yielded predominantly species with the
composition µ2
2 and µ4
4. The double mutant, IgM-S(337, 414),
also assembles efficiently into polymers, but the polymers dissociate
in SDS into µ2
2 subunits held together by the C575-C575 disulfide
bond (4) (Fig. 5
C). As indicated in Figure 7
, the overall J chain content of
secreted IgM-S337 and IgM-S(337, 414) was similar to that of IgM-wt,
consistent with earlier findings that C575, but not C414 or C337, is
necessary for J chain incorporation (20). To examine how J chain was
distributed among the various substructures present in IgM-S337 and
IgM-S(337, 414), 35S-labeled polymeric IgM was purified by
SDG centrifugation (not shown). IgM from the polymer-containing
fractions was immunoprecipitated and then analyzed by SDS-PAGE (Fig. 8
A). Some of the minor
bands shown in Figure 6B
were not detected here, probably because of
the shorter exposure time. The various bands were extracted from the
gel and analyzed by AU-PAGE (Fig. 8
B). For IgM-S337,
J chain was detected only in species B, not in species A or C. The
relative mobility of these species thus indicates that J chain was in
µ2
2 subunits, but not in µ4
4. The same result was also
obtained in separate experiments in which polymeric subunits, separated
by SDS-PAGE, were probed for J chain by Western blot (not shown). The
significance of the restricted distribution of J chain is considered
further in Discussion.
|
|
2 (species D, 21% of the total polymer; species E, 69% of the
total polymer) as well as various minor bands of faster mobility. J
chain was detected in species D and to a much lesser extent in species
E, but not in species F, G, or H. Considering that only C575 was
available for intermolecular disulfide bonding in IgM-S(337, 414), the
presence of J chain in this µ2
2 unit indicates that J chain
bridged the µ-chains via a C575-J-C575 linkage.
IgM-S337 and IgM-S(337, 414) polymers yielded µ2
2 subunits
(species B, D, and E) that had slightly different mobilities.
Nevertheless, under reducing conditions, µ-chains from these three
species had the same SDS-PAGE mobility, identical with that of
µ-chain from wild-type polymers (not shown). This suggests that the
mobility difference between species D and E seen under nonreducing
conditions reflects the presence of J chain, and that differences in
intrasubunit disulfide bonding might be responsible for the different
mobilities of species B and E.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Previous analyses of IgM produced in the absence of J chain have led to different conclusions. Cattaneo et al. (16) concluded from their electron microscopic analysis of IgM produced by transfected glial cells that 50% of the IgM made in the absence of J chain was pentameric. This might be an overestimate, as this study did not distinguish hexamer in which one arm was obscured from genuine pentamer. Randall et al. (15) found that the B cell lines WEHI-231 and BCL1 produced some J-deficient pentameric IgM. Niles et al. (14) used transfectants of a pituitary cell line to produce IgM and found that polymeric IgM secreted in the absence of J chain was exclusively hexameric. In stark contrast, we have found that pentameric IgM is efficiently produced in a J chain-deficient hybridoma cell line. We do not know the reason for these differences, but it is possible that the various cell lines express different intracellular accessory proteins. In fact, Roth and Koshland described a B cell-specific disulfide interchange enzyme (29). Further work, such as the analysis of J chain-deficient mice (12), will be needed to establish which of these systems best mimics the in vivo situation.
To simplify the analysis of inter-µ chain disulfide connectivity, we
have used the C337S substitution to eliminate the C337-C337 bond. This
approach raises the question of whether the C414-C414 and C575-C575
bonds are formed in IgM-S337 as they are formed in IgM-wt. As presented
above, this seems to be a valid assumption, as all measurements that we
have made, namely the relative distributions of monomer, pentamer, and
hexamer; the cytolytic activity; and the J chain content, were similar
in IgM-S337 and IgM-wt. What, then, does the subunit composition of
IgM-S337, as visualized in SDS-PAGE analysis, tell us about the
connectivity of C414-C414 and C575-C575 bonds? In gross terms, IgM-S337
pentamer was heterogeneous and composed predominantly of µ2
2 and
µ4
4 subunits; still larger subunits were present in lesser
amounts. In µ4
4 and larger subunits, C414-C414 bonds must have
joined µ-chains in series with C575-C575 bonds. The existence of
several subunits migrating approximately as µ2
2 (Fig. 6
B) might reflect different bonding arrangements
within the µ2
2 units, such as those illustrated in Figure 5
A. Our data also indicate that at least some pentameric
molecules contained subunits of different sizes. That is, a pentamer
that contained µ4
4 must also have contained a different type of
subunit, e.g., such a pentamer could have assembled as
(µ4
4)2(µ2
2) or (µ4
4)(µ2
2)3.
Moreover, not all pentameric molecules were identical, since, if they
were, no subunit with a size of µ2
2 or larger could have
constituted <20% of the total subunits, and contrary to this
prediction, some larger subunits were detected in small amounts.
As mentioned in the introduction, J chain is incorporated into intracellular pentamer before inter-µ-chain disulfide bond formation is complete. In principle, this provides the opportunity for J chain to affect inter-µ-chain bond formation. For this reason we compared the subunit species derived from J+ and J-IgM-S337. The fact that we did not see an effect of J chain on the SDS-PAGE band pattern indicates that J chain did not alter inter-µ-chain bonding, that J chain affected only parallel connecting disulfide bonds, or that J chain content was much less than one per pentamer.
Hexameric IgM-S337 was assembled differently from pentameric IgM-S337.
Although, hexameric IgM-S337, like pentameric IgM-S337, had µ2
2
and µ4
4 as major components, hexamer also contained a series of
unique subunits with very low mobility in SDS-PAGE. Therefore, at least
some pentamer and hexamer must differ in their connectivity. Of the
slowly migrating hexameric subunits, H4 migrated approximately with
hexameric IgM-wt in SDS-PAGE, and H3, H2, and H1 migrated successively
slower. These bands were not heptamer, octamer, and nonamer, because
they comigrated with wild-type hexamer in SDG under native conditions.
Figure 9
illustrates models for hexameric
IgM-S337 that might account for many of the observed subunits. These
models make two assumptions: 1) that in hexameric IgM all µ-chains
are joined by C414-C414 in series with C337-C337 (or, in the case of
IgM-S337, C414-C414 in series with noncovalently interacting
Cµ2-Cµ2 domains), and 2) that C575-C575 bonds can occur in multiple
ways. The first assumption is supported by the observation that
IgM-S575 can assemble as covalent hexamer, and in this case the
C414-C414 bonds must all be in series with C337-C337 (17). This
arrangement might be a hallmark of all hexameric IgM. Figure 9
illustrates the second assumption that there are different modes of
C575-C575 bonding. Models A and B are those originally proposed for
human IgM by Feinstein and colleagues in which each µ-chain interacts
with only two other µ-chains (30, 31). In the case of IgM-S337, these
structures would denature in SDS to yield µ12
12 and µ2
2
species, respectively. In models C through E, each µ-chain interacts
with three other µ-chains; structure C would denature to yield three
µ4
4 subunits, structure D would yield µ12
12, and structures E
and F would yield two µ6
6 subunits. Structures such as E can occur
as four distinct isomers that differ in their degrees of catenation. In
this figure we have illustrated the two extreme cases with zero (E) and
three (F) links. By analogy with catenated DNA we would expect that
singly, twofold, and threefold catenated µ6
6 circles would migrate
progressively faster in electrophoresis. Thus, the catenated structures
might account for the three slowest bands (H1H3). Species H4 might
correspond to model A or D or to a more complex molecule with topologic
knots. We suppose that uncatenated µ6
6 circles would migrate like
a trimer, a species that was conspicuous by its absence, but the loose
structure of such a molecule might have rendered its mobility
anomalous. We suppose that hexameric IgM-wt might also assemble with
these different arrangements of C414-C414 and C575-C575 bonds. However,
in this case the C337-C337 bonds would be expected even in SDS to
maintain the hexameric IgM-wt as a compact structure, which then
migrated as a single band regardless of catenation.
|
2 subunits
contained covalently bonded J chain indicates that the C575 residues
were used to link both µ-chains as well as the J chain, i.e., that J
chain bridged two µ-chains via C575. Moreover, our results indicate
that J chain was present mainly or exclusively in this cross-linked
mode. That is, if a significant proportion of J chain were incorporated
by a single µ-J disulfide bond, the J chain would also have been
present in the less abundant species F through H (Fig. 8
For IgM-S337 polymers, we found that µ2
2 subunits, but not
µ4
4 subunits, contained J chain. The failure of µ4
4 subunits
to incorporate J chain is intriguing, as these units contained both
C575-C575 and C414-C414 bonds. This implies that J-chain incorporation
was affected by structural features besides the availability of C575,
namely the presence of C414-C414 bonds. Figure 10
illustrates one of many possible
models, namely a model in which stereochemical effects prevent J chain
from bonding either to µ-chains linked by C414-C414 (µ chains 8 and
9) or to their neighboring µ-chains (µ-chains 7 and 10). That is,
the C414-C414 bond might cause tight packing and exclude J chain from
both µ4
4 and the adjoining two µ2
2 subunits but allow
incorporation into the more distant µ2
2 (µ-chains 2 and 5). This
hypothesis might also explain why a pentamer does not incorporate more
than one J chain, as the typical pentamer might contain either a
µ4
4 subunit (bearing C414-C414 in series with C575-C575) or a
µ2
2 subunit (in which C414-C414 is parallel with C575-C575).
Similarly, the absence of J chain in hexamer might be explained by its
numerous C414-C414 bonds. However, many other models are possible,
including structures in which J chain links nonneighboring
µ-chains (20).
|
In this study we have found substantially less activity for pentameric IgM, particularly for J+IgM, than was reported in earlier studies (17, 18). This difference might reflect differences in the degree of hexamer contamination in the pentamer-enriched preparations. We have also not completely ruled out the effects of different assay conditions. It is important to test the generality of our findings. In particular, our cytolytic assays used mouse IgM to activate guinea pig complement, and it will be interesting to assess the different IgM structures using components derived from single species. These reservations notwithstanding, our results are consistent with the hypothesis that J+ pentamer is completely noncytolytic. That is, J- pentamer appeared to be more active than J+ pentamer, raising the possibility that the low activity of the nominally J+ pentamer IgM derived wholly from a subpopulation of J chain-deficient molecules. Our results thus suggest that the most important role for J chain is in the binding of IgM to the poly-Ig receptor for transepithelial transport of IgM. That this J chain-containing IgM has little or no cytolytic activity invites the speculation that there is some physiologic advantage to a system in which only inactive IgM is transcytosed. A related point has been made with regard to IgA, which also contains J chain and is noncytolytic (13). Perhaps it is important to avoid inflammatory reactions in tissues that are heavily exposed to foreign materials, and perhaps simple aggregation of invading microorganisms within an excretory organ such as the gut provides an efficient and effective method of neutralizing infection.
Normal IgM is a highly heterogeneous collection of molecules in which heterogeneity is generated by variations in disulfide bonding. In gross terms, IgM appears predominantly as pentamer and hexamer; smaller molecules, monomer, dimer, trimer, and tetramer, are also found (36, 37). There is an additional heterogeneity among the pentameric and hexameric species in which the inter-µ-chain disulfide bonds are formed in multiple ways. There are other proteins that are also assembled into polymers of different sizes, and in which all or most polymer subunits are held together by disulfide bonds: IgA, serum pulmonary surfactant protein (SP-D), and human von Willebrandt factor (38, 39, 40). Similar to IgM, the intersubunit disulfide bonds of IgA and SP-D have alternative arrangements. By contrast, some proteins assemble into a single polymeric species with a well-defined conformation: human serum amyloid P component, earthworm hemoglobin, yeast proteasome, protective antigen from Bacillus anthracis and bacteriophage fr capsid proteins (41, 42, 43, 44, 45). The subunits of such polymers are held together solely or primarily by noncovalent forces. It is intriguing that in these examples noncovalently assembled molecules occur as unique structures, while those using disulfide bonds occur in multiple arrangements. The reason for these differences might be that intersubunit disulfide bonds can trap polymers in configurations that would not be stable if maintained solely by noncovalent interactions. By contrast, in the absence of disulfide bonding, assembly can reach equilibrium in which the structure of lowest free energy predominates.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Address correspondence to Dr. Marc J. Shulman, Department of Immunology, University of Toronto, Medical Sciences Building, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5S 1A8. E-mail: ![]()
3 Abbreviations used in this paper: TNP, 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl; AU-PAGE, alkaline urea-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; SDG, sucrose density gradient; wt, wild type. ![]()
Received for publication November 3, 1997. Accepted for publication February 19, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Noisakran and G. C. Perng Alternate Hypothesis on the Pathogenesis of Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever (DHF)/Dengue Shock Syndrome (DSS) in Dengue Virus Infection Experimental Biology and Medicine, April 1, 2008; 233(4): 401 - 408. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Azuma, Y. Ishikawa, S. Kawai, T. Tsunenari, H. Tsunoda, T. Igawa, S.-i. Iida, M. Nanami, M. Suzuki, R. F. Irie, et al. Recombinant Human Hexamer-Dominant IgM Monoclonal Antibody to Ganglioside GM3 for Treatment of Melanoma Clin. Cancer Res., May 1, 2007; 13(9): 2745 - 2750. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. S. Hohman, S. E. Stewart, L. L. Rumfelt, A. S. Greenberg, D. W. Avila, M. F. Flajnik, and L. A. Steiner J Chain in the Nurse Shark: Implications for Function in a Lower Vertebrate J. Immunol., June 15, 2003; 170(12): 6016 - 6023. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Braathen, V. Sorensen, P. Brandtzaeg, I. Sandlie, and F.-E. Johansen The Carboxyl-terminal Domains of IgA and IgM Direct Isotype-specific Polymerization and Interaction with the Polymeric Immunoglobulin Receptor J. Biol. Chem., November 1, 2002; 277(45): 42755 - 42762. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. M. Phillips-Quagliata, S. Patel, J.-K. Han, S. Arakelov, T. D. Rao, M. J. Shulman, S. Fazel, R. B. Corley, M. Everett, M. H. Klein, et al. The IgA/IgM Receptor Expressed on a Murine B Cell Lymphoma Is Poly-Ig Receptor J. Immunol., September 1, 2000; 165(5): 2544 - 2555. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. Sorensen, I. B. Rasmussen, V. Sundvold, T. E. Michaelsen, and I. Sandlie Structural requirements for incorporation of J chain into human IgM and IgA Int. Immunol., January 1, 2000; 12(1): 19 - 27. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Lycke, L. Erlandsson, L. Ekman, K. Schon, and T. Leanderson Lack of J Chain Inhibits the Transport of Gut IgA and Abrogates the Development of Intestinal Antitoxic Protection J. Immunol., July 15, 1999; 163(2): 913 - 919. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |